International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
ipmi BUSINESS STUDIES
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF
e-ISSN: 2622-4585 | p-ISSN: 2580-0132
Vol. 4 | No. 2 (June 2020)
Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking
Purbawati Setyaningsih¹*, Acep R. Jayaprawira²
¹Perbanas Banking Finance and Informatics Asia Institute (IKPIA), Bekasi 17114, Indonesia
²Trisakti University (Usakti), DKI Jakarta 11440, Indonesia
ABSTRACT
ARTICLE INFO
This study analyzes how agricultural investments may strengthen
the Islamic banking industry that is sustainable in the short and long
term. Qualitative data sources are secondary data from BPS, Baznas,
ACT Global Waqf and research on BWI in the form of secondary data
from March 2007 to December 2018. Data were analyzed using the
Error Correction Model (ECM) Methodology. Ziswaf have a signi icnt
effect on GDP both of the long term and the short term, with the ECT
coef icient was - 1.81E-07 meaning that there are increasing GDP will
be adjusted within one (1) year with the residual speed of the balance
value of - 181 percent. In the long term, the GDP have in luented
simultaneously by all independent variables with affected positively
by Exports-Agi, PMDN and Ziswaf signi icantly; and it have
in luenced negatively by Export signi icantly at the R-square level of
0.98 meaning that the variables are tested to provide almost all the
information needed to predict the GDP. Export-Agi was the most
in luence with a value of coef icient variable 44.875570. While in the
short term, GDP was signi icantly in luenced by Ziswaf on R-square
0.26 which means that there have 74 per cent of other variables
outside the model that affect GDP.
Article History:
The selection of competitive plants in the zakat distribution program
and the use of idle waqaf land is very important to be considered by
institutions / individuals who are interested in PMDN investment in
the agricultural sector and ziswaf management institutions. Every
land and sea have the blessing and the competitive power of its own
and its utilization as well as possible considering the state of the
local community as a major source of labor, without neglecting the
environment as part of sustainable development goals. A smart-smallmicro inanc can be synergized with ziswaf as a step to strengthen
the technical and managerial mustahik. Cash waqf can also be used
as an instrument for the development of further capital. Economic
growth is accompanied by sustainability is the best choice, the chance
- 82 -
Received : 22-02-2020
Revised
: 12-06-2020
Accepted : 17-06-2020
Published : 30-06-2020
Keywords:
Islamic Financing
Sustainable Islamic Banking
Agricultural Investment
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
alignment of a sustainable Islamic inancial investment can be
expanded globally in scope and impact. Islamic inancial transactions
can be retained should provide investment categories permitted by
religion (halal) and did well to supply logistics either through A-PLS
or sukuk using the inancing agreements like salam, muzara'ah, and
mugharasah; irrigation infrastructure for areas prone to lack of water
with Musaqa or Istishna inancing. Careful handling prior to harvest,
post - harvest handling of agricultural products and halal food
processing industry is part of the growing Islamic Bankings
sustainable advantage.
*Corresponding Author E-mail:
purbawati.s@perbanas.id
Copyright © 2020 Authors. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which
permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
INTRODUCTION
The Background
The inancial sector is a means that bridges the
interests of those who have excess funds (deposit
funds or creditors) and those who need funds
(borrowers of funds or debtors) with banks as
intermediaries. The Islamic inance sector is
booming, from a market of just $200bn in 2003,
the sector is expected to grow to over $4trn in
assets by 2030. Islamic contracts fall into three
broad categories: trade-oriented transactions
(debt-like instruments), equity (pro it-and-losssharing) and support contracts. Each of these
categories creates an opportunity for new
sustainability
oriented
products.
The
characteristic of products have four main
features: 1) Asset backed, 2) Ethical, 3) Share
risks equitably and
4) Subject to good
governance (Usher and Ndiaye, 2020). The
sustainability and viability of Islamic inance
come from fundamental requirements set by
principles of the Sharia Law. Islamic transactions
should strictly adhere to the permissible (halal)
and abstain from the prohibited (haram). As will
be reviewed below, these requirements are
implied by divine rules that include prohibition
of riba (interest), gharar (ambiguity), maisir
(gambling) and commodities such as intoxicants
and pork (Myers and Hassazadeh, 2013).
The inancial sector has a very important function
in international trade, as well as providing
convenience services for transactions between
countries. In the macroeconomic context the
inancial sector has a role as a means of
transmitting monetary policy so that the shock
that occurs in the inancial sector can affect the
effectiveness of monetary policy. The inancial
sector plays an important role in economic
growth and development (Miller, 1998). The
employment effect appears to be correlated with
the level of sustainability of agricultural practices,
with an estimated 30 percent increase in
employment for sustainable agriculture, compared
to unsustainable practices. The International
Institute for Sustainable Development (2014)
states that the welfare of the country is so
important, so that agricultural trade has always
been, and continues, a major issue of controversy
multilateral trade negotiations. Many developing
countries have the advantage in agricultural
production compared with their developed
country trading partners, but are not able to
exploit the growth potential of this machine.
In many developing countries (even in countries
where the agricultural sector is not a large
component of national GDP) agriculture is an
important work base for most of the population.
The employment effect appears to be correlated
with the level of sustainability of agricultural
practices, with an estimated 30 percent increase
in employment for sustainable agriculture,
compared to unsustainable practices. Basically,
economic growth measures a country's ability to
expand output levels faster than population
- 83 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
growth rates. Increased economic growth rate is
affected by such an increase in exports and
increased investment. The concept of green
growth is a concept that is based on sustainable
and
environmentally
friendly
economic
development, facing the problem of global
warming. In an open economic system, exports
will generate revenues that would be used to
inance imports, particularly imports of capital
goods and raw materials required in the
production process that will create added value.
Investment or capital investment is also a
component of value added to national building,
which is the purchase of capital goods and
production equipment to improve the ability to
produce
goods
needed in the economy
(Sutawijaya, 2010). Trade must be used as a
positive catalyst for economic, social and
environmental change, rather than encouraging
environmental degradation.
Green-economy
presents a model for reversing this trend, with
changing economic policies and incentives by
supporting social growth, justice and prosperity
through
conservation,
using
nature
by
preserving resources and alerting pollution
control. Economic growth have characterized by
the growth of output per capita and rised living
standards, the value of economic growth have
measured by the level of growth in gross
domestic product (GDP) in constant prices. The
main driver of economic
growth (an
environmental point) at the moment is expancing
and liberalizating global trade that does not
harm the natural environment. While trade
growth in 2050 have expected to be driven by
tripled of global population and kuartered of
the increased current GDP.
The agricultural sector was in luenting economic
growth on the second most in luential after the
processing industry and still above the trade and
construction sector. More than half of the GDP of
the manufacturing industry have agriculturebased. In a holistic agricultural sector from
upstream (or on farm) to downstream (or down
stream industries) on a value chain, it was
contribution to GDP in a ggregate reaches around
55 percent. If the types and value chains of
agricultural commodities which numerous and
numerous in Indonesia, was using developed
technology and have supported by modern
logistics systems, so Indonesia's GDP will increase
potentially and also the welfare of farmers and
other rural economic actors will increase too.
The agricultural sector also the biggest absorber
of labor, which was about 35 percent of the
total workforce (Hadad, 2016). According to BPS
(2017) the total population over the age of 15
years working in Agriculture, Plantation, Forestry,
Hunting and Fisheries was 31.9 percent.
The function of agriculture in development is to
improve the agricultural sector, increase economic
growth, reduce poverty, increase income, provide
food security, and provide environmental services.
However, the government and donors have
stopped this agricultural function, leaving behind
agricultural growth which has now declined.
Currently 75 percent of world poverty occurs in
rural areas, sectoral income disparities have been
destroyed, food insecurity has returned, and
widespread
environmental
degradation,
sustainability sustainable. Mobilizing these
functions request the transfer of political
economy to overcome the bias of anti agricultural
policies, manage governance for agriculture, and
adjust the priority with the requirements of the
State (Sukirno, 2006).
Nigeria, the western part of Africa has large
agricultural work, in addition to storing various
minerals including petroleum, natural gas, lead,
iron ore, and coal; also has a growing fast foreign
trade, a lmost 95 percent of foreign exchange is
the result of oil exports. The state of Kano is an
important agricultural, forestry and ishery place
in Nigeria with
population
density and
productivity. About 70 percent of the population
works in agriculture, that’s includes cocoa, palm
oil, cotton and rubber farming. Agricultural
products are the main export after crude oil;
many cotton commodities are planted in the north
which have sandy soil and temperate; coconut
plantations are mostly cultivated in the south and
produce coconut oil to make soap, cooking oil and
- 84 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
lubricants. In Kano, Nigeria state agricultural
inancing available through the conventional
banking system is less desirable due to high
interest rates, and the majority of Muslim farmers
in the country are very reluctant and aware of
disobedience to religion. Then there was a decline
in agricultural output. They was proposing an
alternative agricultural activities that will bene it
through one Islamic inancial product called
salam inancing (Mohammed, Ogunbado & Bashir,
2016).
Formal inancial institutions that exist today tend
to prioritize non-agricultural services that have
high returns but the risk is low. Observations such
as maturity, the potential for, and constraints in
developing social funds in Indonesia in his role in
the agricultural sector needed to boost national
economic development, although development
was not fully supported by adequate capital.
Islamic Bankings (IBs) in Indonesia is not
dominating the economy (Sunarmo, 2018).
Financial literacy on community’s understanding
of banking as a inancial intermediary institution
just only 21,80 percent that was lower compared
to Philippines (27 percent), Malaysia (66 percent),
Thailand (73 percent) and Singapore with the
highest level of understanding of the banking
sector i.e. 98 percent. The low level of banking
literacy indicates that many people do not know
condition of Ibs. In the long run, does not show
equilibrium means IBs in a developing condition.
There for the collaboration between goverment,
Indonesia FSA and BI, banking and the community
is needed to increase the growth its in the future.
IBs operates on monopolistic market and perfect
competitions, means Ibs has not been consistent
in developing its products so requires t he
development of exellent products with spesi ic
characteristics and market share.
For investment funding, that the social sector of
Islamic inance has the potential to push further
the commercial sector and reciprocally shake in
terms of social welfare bene its for the community
(Ismal, et.al., 2015). This reciprocal relationship
can be a potential catalyst for sustainable
economic development and efforts to deepen
Islamic inance. For this reason, the project-based
sukuk in the spirit of developing the real sector
through the social sector can be innovated.
Speci ically, sukuk is related to waqf with waqf
assets as part of the basic assets arranged in a
combination of commercial (tijari) and noncommercial (tabbaru) schemes. Mulyawan (2017)
describes the role of Islamic Social Finance
scheme (ISF) in accelerating the growth of the
national economy and can take a high growth rate
and consistently to avoid the middle income trap.
Factors that affect the economic growth were the
industrial structure, disparity, ef iciency, human
resources, investment and macro-policy.
Contributions ISF to accelerate growth in National
Economy 2016-2025, a phase strengthening the
economic structure, is predicted with an average
growth target of 6 percent per year and 6.7
percent at the end. To optimizing Development of
ISF to the front should be supported by information
systems, standards and international accounting
standards in luence on the achievement of a high
governance standards with the development of
1) Monitoring ef icient, 2) An effective regulatory
framework and compatible with other sectors, 3)
The quality of human resources, 4) An effective
educational program.
Research purposes
The purpose of this research are:
1. To determine the effects of domestic capital
investment,
Islamic
social
funds and
international trade of agricultural sector to
sustainable economic growth.
2. To explore the potential of islamic banking
and the sukuk structure to assist agricultural
development towards food security, increase
state income and equitable sustainable
economic growth.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Effect Agriculture to Food Security and
Sustainable Economic Growth
In a hadith, the Prophet sallallaahu 'alaihi wa
sallam said, ‘The Muslims unit (in ownership) on
three things: grasses (which grow in no man's
land), water (rain water, springs, and river water),
- 85 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
and irewood (collected by humans from trees).’
(Narrated by Abu Daud no. 3477 and Ahmad 5:
346. Shaykh Syu'aib Al Arnauth and Al Ha izh
Abu Thohir said that the hadith authentic. See the
explanation of Al Baydhowi quoted by Al Munawi
in Faidhul Qodir 6: 271) (rumaysho.com/3353).
‘Grasses’ can be interpreted as plants food, both
for livestock and humans, while ‘ ire’ can now be
interpreted as energy. All three must not be owned
by individuals. Ibnul Qayyim rahimahullah said,
‘The person who put water in his container
(packaging) did not include in the hadith. The
water that we had put in our containers like
goods that are originally public property but we
had moved into our power and want us to sell,
such as irewood taken from the forest, a bunch
of grass we collect, and salt we take from the sea’.
The hadith above can be understood also that
food, water and energy we have is not ours
absolute 100%. Because the substance is the
common property of mankind. This means that
human association is due to the position of water,
grassland and ire as public facilities needed
jointly by a community or socienty. Therefore we
need to be careful to use it so it does not use other
people's rights by means of redundant and
super luous. Because the nexus of the universe
or the network for the water-energy-food is
interrelated to the survival of human life. This
hadith is also in harmony with constitution UUD
1945 Article 33 paragraph 3 which was formulated
by the founding scholars of this country that 'The
Earth, water and natural resources contained
therein are controlled by the State and used for the
greatest prosperity of the people' (MUI-LPLHSDA,
2017).
The preparation of a framework for sustainable
development, must bring further economic
interests and environmental sustainability,
provide a process of economic transformation,
and expand access to society out of poverty and
justice. This is a consideration that social and
environmental problems that have not been
included in economic calculations are important
elements that need to be considered. Balance
between the interests of pro it does not mean
giving legitimacy to lose attention and commitment
to protect the environment and better social life
(OJK, 2017). Existing formal inancial institutions
tend to prioritize non-agricultural services that
have high returns but low risks. Related to the
national
economic
development,
social
development fund for the agricultural sector in
Indonesia needs to be examined because the
sight of their development is often not fully
supported by adequate capital, and the necessary
exploration maturity, potential, and their barriers.
Islamic scholars in the use of waqf marked as
protecting resources and the supply of public
goods for the bene it of the Muslims in general. In
the tradition of Waqf has contributed signi icantly
such as schools, hospitals and universities.
Agricultural business (in a broad sense) is related
to the organism and its environmental ecosystem.
In Indonesia, according to Law No. 32 of 2009 on
the Protection and Environmental Management,
sustainable development has a conscious and
planned effort that integrates environmental,
social and economic development strategies to
ensure the integrity and safety of the environment,
ability, well-being and quality of life for the
current generation and the future in order to
establish integrated ecosystem. This includes the
planning, utilization, control,
maintenance,
monitoring and enforcement (Samad, 2016).
Small-scale farmers represent 90 percent of the
rural poor and make up the majority of the
world's starving population. FAO seeks to protect
livelihoods from shocks, make food production
systems more resilient and more able to absorb
impacts, and recover from disturbing events;
with Food and Nutrition Safety through the FAO
Interdisciplinary Framework Program: Resilient
Livelihoods. The program contains strategic
directions to FAO member countries and partners
for implementing disaster risk reduction
measures in agriculture, forestry and isheries at
the local, national, regional and global levels.
This Framework Program re lects t he Hyogo
Framework for Action and seeks to help member
countries implement the ive Priorities for
Action for the agricultural sector. The Framework
- 86 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
Program supports national government partners,
the direct bene iciaries are small farmers in
developing countries, including small scale
farmers, ishermen, herders, foresters and urban
poor-especially
women-whose
lives
and
livelihoods are threatened. It also responds to the
latest recommendations made on disaster risk
reduction by the Agriculture Committee, Program
and Finance Committee, the World Food Security
Committee and the Fisheries Committee.
Investment or capital investment is also an
added value component for the national building,
the purchase of capital goods and production
equipment to improve the ability to produce the
goods needed in the economy (Sutawijaya,
2010). Environmental sustainability within the
framework of Islamic Economics goal is maslahah.
Command to preserve the environment stated in
Surah Al-Baqarah [2]: 60 which means: ‘And
(remember) when Moses prayed for water for his
people; We said: ’Strike the rock with your staff’.
Then gushed from it twelve springs. Indeed each
tribe knew their drinking place (respectively). Eat
and drink the sustenance (given) Allah, and do not
roam the earth with mischief’.
Trade must be used as a positive catalyst for
economic, social and environmental change,
rather
than
encouraging
environmental
degradation. Green economy presents a model
to reverse this trend, by changing economic
policies and incentives by supporting social
growth,
justice
and
prosperity
through
conservation and use of nature by conserving
resources and reminding pollution control. Green
investment is an option to achieve sustainable
green growth. Green investment has the
potential to grow income and jobs that are more
environmentally friendly, increase access to clean
water and energy, increase the transfer of green
goods and services, reduce carbon emissions and
waste, and preserve biodiversity, ecosystems and
forests.
Protecting the environment is associated with a
doubling of crop enterprises (multicrops) to
improve the quality of the climate, and waste
management with production ef iciency and
management ef iciency in the area of processing
industry, as well as promoting the halal industry.
Green industrial estates also makes it easy to
estimate speci ic consumption, production and
trade between countries, easily reduces the
impact on biodiversity loss, and can provide
useful insights for designing demand-side
mitigation strategies and interventions. In trade,
an increase in the price of environmental bene its
provided by production companies, will be charged
to consumers. It is a challenge for development
economists.
Increasing agricultural productivity in appropriate
and needed places, has the potential to reduce
poverty in the future. A study has been carried
out on a comparison of the characteristics of
twenty- ive developing countries that have had
extraordinary success in reducing extreme
poverty over the past twenty to twenty- ive years,
covering some of the poorest countries and some
of the richest developing countries in the world,
representing almost all geographical regions,
these countries are also very different in their
economic management and management systems,
using indicators
of
their macroeconomic
characteristics and especially, their agricultural
economic characteristics. Retrieved effectiveness
of poverty reduction through increased farm
income growth than other sectors because: 1) The
high incidence of poverty in rural and agricultural
population as compared to other places, and 2)
most of the poor people in rural areas and their
livelihood
largely
depends on agriculture
(Cervantes-Godoy & Dewbre, 2010).
South Korea was the irst country in the world
to establish the concept of national policy since
2008 in an effort to increase the country's
independence and reduce the impact of climate
change. South Korea has now changed from a
poor agrarian country into a developed industrial
countries (Putra, 2014). Now, Indonesian’s
important agendas for food security are improving
the competitiveness of agricultural commodities.
According to BPS data for 2017, the Indonesian
agriculture sector contributes to GDP at least
- 87 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
percent. A total of seven types of commodities
contributed to the agricultural sector. These
commodities include Plantation (3.47 percent),
Food Crops (3.22 percent), Fisheries (2.57
percent), Livestock (1.57 percent), Horticulture
(1.44 percent), Forestry (0.67 percent), and
Agriculture and Plantation Services (0.19 percent).
Investment Agricultural Trade trough ISF,
Islamic Banking and Sukuk
Raumah wells in Medina was originally owned
by Jews, who at the time of prolonged droughtstricken, the wells are no longer left only one clean
water from the well. Muslims of Medina lock to
queue up and buy water from those wells to meet
the requirements, then the Rasulullaah salallahu
'alaihi wassalam respectfully said, ‘O my friend,
anyone among you who donate their property
to be able to free up the well and donate it to the
people, it will memdapat His heaven Allah Ta'ala’
(Narrated by Muslim). In practice, according to
the management of waqf as-Sunnah wells belonging
to Ustman bin Affan radialahu anhu still available
now, actively used by the people of Madina and
bordered by a fence and can be viewed from
outside the fence. Results management can be felt
by the poor and those who need it, as well as
being a source of water in the surrounding land
to irrigate palm plantations. Palm trees are
managed for generations of caliph until the Saudi
government under the Ministry of Agriculture.
Then, the Saudi government sells harvested date
from the date palm plantation to the market.
Half of the pro its are distributing to orphans and
the needy and the other half are keeping in the
form of a bank account in the name of Ushman,
held by the Ministry of Awqaf. The account
money that continues to grow have used for the
construction of hotels in the name of Ustman bin
Affan Hotel. The hotel have managed by Sheraton,
the one of the international standard hotels with
15 loors and 24 rooms on each loor, it is equipped
with a large restaurant and shopping places as
well as close to the Ustman bin Affan Mosque which
is also still actively used (https://globalwakaf.com).
In Malaysia, idle land is land that can be used for
cultivation but is now in a non-use status, or
abandoned land, or vacant land for two years in a
row according to the de inition of the Department
of Agriculture in Malaysia (DOA) used as potential
inventory through endowments. Criteria for idle
land are: 1) Rice land that has not been cultivated
or used for grazing purposes for three years in
a row; 2) Rice ields equipped with physical
infrastructure for double planting but only single
crops; 3) Rice land planted with plants other than
rice; 4) Rubber and other tree plantations that are
abandoned or not fully utilized as rarely tapped
(Sha iai, Moi & Ahmad, 2015).
Abdurrahman (2010) said that riba-free bank
need do risk management through diversi ications
of sectors of economy; with the riba-free bank’s
credit policies committee devices an investment
‘pie’ that allocates the investment of its funds in
each sectors; through applying the proper riba-free
inancing model that its grows from cost-plus
(murabaha) to money management (mudaraba),
joint venture (musharaka), leasing (ijara) and
riba-free inancing of future production (ba-i ul
salam/ishtisna); through diversi ication of client
with spread a inancing activity to the community
without a inancing into a small number af
succesful businesspersons to result more clients
on the investment side and bigger pool of reverals,
and also distributed the probability of failure;
through diversi ications bt geogra ic location.
Figure 1 is Riba-free investment tools to developing
the riba-free banking investment product. The
investment pyramid displays the characteristics
and nature of products that it each layer. At the
bottom of the pyramid, the advisor allocates a
certain percentage of the customer’s wealth in the
form of cash equivalens,its include the demand
deposit. The next layer of investment is a longerterm investment that can mature in three months
to three years, such as automobile inancing or a
piece equipment. Riba-free based bond called
sukuk.
Gini ratio, ZISWAF, total exports, and the
Production Index Sharia Stock Index examined
for their effects on GDP. In the long and short term
- 88 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
models, the Gini Ratio, Ziswaf and Production
Index have a signi icant positive effect on GDP,
while total exports and the Sharia Stock Index
both have no signi icant effect on GDP. If the value
of the Gini Ratio, Ziswaf and Production Index
decreases or slows down, the GDP also decreases.
The Gini ratio can be increased through economic
activities based on export-oriented agricultural
resources through government policy support
(Setyaningsih, Azis & Hadiyati, 2019). The increase
in exports can still be done to see the potential
for idle waqf land in Indonesia. Unemployed
agricultural land can become a burden because
they have to pay taxes. Land as an economic
resource if neglected, and in the end will not be
able to generate income either for landowners
or farmers. Unemployed agricultural land in
Indonesia and for the development of exportoriented agriculture, has the potential to be
activated using zakat and waqaf funds. Thus the
structure of Islamic
inance
agricultural
development through combination with other
contracts, namely al-muzara'ah, al-musaqa and almugharasah could be an option.
RF Stock
investing and
Mutual Funds
Cash,
RF Money
Market and
RF CD
Growth
RF Bondas
‘Sukuk’
Income
Investments
Cash and Cash
Equivalents
Figure 1. Riba-free Investment Tools
Source: Abdul-Rahman (2010)
Characteristic of Investment Sukuk are 1)
Investment sukuk are certi icates of equal value
issued in the name of the owner or bearer in order
to establish the claim of the certi icate owner over
the inancial rights and obliglations represented
by the certi icate, 2) Investment sukuk represent
a common share in the ownership of the assets
made available for investment, whether these
are non-monetary assets, usufruct, services or a
mixture of all these plus intangible rights, debts
and monetary assets. These sukuk do not represent
a debt owed to the issuer by the certi icate holder,
3) Investment sukuk are issued on the basis of
Sharia'a- nominated contract in accordance with
the rules of the rules Sharia'a that govern their
issuance and trading, 4) The trading of investment
sukuk is subject to the term that govern trading
of the rights they represent, 5) The owners of
these certi icate share the return as stated in the
subscription prospectus and bear the losses in
proportion to the certi icate owned (held) by
them (AAOIFI, 2004).
Sukuk muzara'ah de inition is found in the number
3/7. This Sukuk de ined as sukuk issued with the
aim of mobilizing funds in the context of the
inancing of agricultural activities under the
contract muzara'ah, so that sukuk holders are
entitled to share of agricultural products in
accordance with the agreement. In part 5/1/5/9,
regulated Sharia provisions on the issuance of
sukuk this type. In this case there are two types of
sukuk namely sukuk issued by land owners or
sukuk issued by land managers (workers). If the
sukuk is issued by the land owner (landowner or
land bene it owner), then the buyer of the sukuk
acts as the manager of agricultural land based
on the muzara'ah contract. The funds from the
issuance of sukuk are funds for agricultural costs.
Meanwhile, if the sukuk is issued by the land
manager, the sukuk buyer acts as the owner of
the land, where the funds from the sukuk issuance
are used to buy agricultural land. So that the
sukuk holders are entitled to a part of the land
production according to the agreement (AAOIFI,
2004).
The de inition of Sukuk Musaqah is in number
3/8. This sukuk de ined as a sukuk issued with the
purpose of using funds from the issuance of sukuk
to carry out irrigation activities for fruiting plants,
paying operational costs and maintaining these
plants based on the musaqah contract, so that the
sukuk holders are entitled to a part of the harvest
according to the agreement. In number 5/1/5/10
the sharia provisions regarding the issuance of
these types of sukuk are regulated. In this case
there are two types of sukuk musaqah that can be
issued, namely sukuk issued by landowners who
- 89 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
Sukuk Mugharasah de inition is found in the
numbers 3/9. This Sukuk is de ined as s ukuk
issued
under
the
contract
mugharasah
(agriculture), in the context of inance planting
and maintenance fund, so that the investor is
entitled to a land and crops.In number 5/1/5/11,
Sharia provisions regarding the issuance of these
types of sukuk are regulated. In this case there
are two types of mugharasah sukuk that can be
issued, namely sukuk issued by land owners or
sukuk issued by land tenants. If the sukuk is issued
by the land owner (landowner or land bene it
owner), then the buyer of the sukuk acts as a
planter based on the Mugharasah contract. The
funds from the issuance of sukuk are funds for
the cost of planting and maintaining plants.
Whereas if the sukuk is issued by the land tiller,
the sukuk buyers act as the owner of the land,
where the funds from the issuance of the sukuk
are used for the costs of planting crops. So that
the sukuk holders are titled to part of the plants
and land according to the agreement.
Other innovative inancing is needed both
community participation, cooperation between
government and business entities and Blended
Finance in the form of community participation
so that the primary balance which is a combination
of state revenue and expenditure minus debt
interest payments, can be positive. Mulyawan
(2017) stated that the ISF is a source of
investment that is easily absorbed by the public.
The ISF has the potential to connect and match
untouched segments of society, because inancing
of the SME sector tends to have higher default
rates and higher interest rates than the corporate
and retail segments (Figure 2). ISF has the potential
to do a link-and-match for the segment of society
that is still untapped. The advantage of ISF is that
they have available sources of funds to be absorbed
so that they will not cause systemic risk.
30
Korporat
UMKM
25
Returns (Percent)
have plants on it or sukuk issued by land tenants.
If the sukuk is issued by the land owner who has
plants on it (the land owner or the land bene it
owner), then the sukuk buyer acts as a land tenant
based on the musaqah agreement. The funds from
the issuance of sukuk are funds for irrigation and
crop maintenance costs. Whereas if the sukuk is
issued by the land tiller, the sukuk buyer acts as
the land owner, where the funds from the sukuk
issuance are used for crop irrigation. So that the
sukuk holders are entitled to a part of the crop
production according to the agreement.
BPR
20
15
10
2
6
4
Non Performing Loan
8
Figure 2. Non Performing Loan (NPL) of
Corporate, UMKM and BPR
Source : Mulyawan (2017)
RESEARCH METHODS
This research consists of two parts, combines
qualitative and quantitative analysis. One
analysis is numerous variables that in luence
economic growth, with GDP benchmark using
ECM methodology from secondary data and
quantitative approaches. The second one is the
effects of the research results to increased
international trade through Islamic banking,
using do cumentary methodology of qualitative
approach. This research using Indonesian GDP
data, the data Export-Industry-Agriculture (AGI
EXPORT), Export-Total (EXPORT), Invest-InState (PMDN), and Zakat-Waqf (ZISWAF). Data
sourced from the Central Statistics Agency (BPS),
the Ministry of Trade, Bank Indonesia, the
National Zakat Agency (Baznas) and from the
Global Waqf-Fast Action Response from 20082017.
Data processing ECM
The stationarity test have done by testing the
roots of unit or unit root test. If non-stationary
data have had unit roots, otherwise stationary
data did not have unit roots. This research have
used Augmented Dickey Fuller (ADF) test model,
that show the independent variables studied
- 90 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
were stationary on the 2nd Different. After the
independent variables and the dependent variable
have ful illed the condition of one (1), the next
step is to make the estimated regression equation
(2). Step estimated regression equation (2) is
carried out after the independent variables and
the dependent variable meets the condition (1).
The cointegration test have done by tested its
residu by the Augmented Engle-Granger. If the
residual not stationary at the level, its have a longterm balance. This reseach stationary at the 2nd
Different (Table 1).
The equations for long-run is:
Yt =α0 + α1X1t + α2X2t + α3X7t + α4X8t + et......(1)
GDPt=α0 + α1PMDNst + α2EKSPOR AGIt +
α3EKSPORlt + α4ZISWAFmt + ECT...........................(2)
From DF testing for residual unit root test (Table
1), it was found that the residual stationary at
the degree level that is visible from the value of
t-statistics are signi icant at the 5% critical value
(Prob 0.0000). Data residues are stationary at
level indicates that all cointegrated independent
variables, so as to have a long-term balance.
The equation of short term derivation estimates
with stationerity at 2nd Different are:
LogGDPt =β0 + β1Dt + β2LogPMDNt +
β3LogEKSPOR AGIt + β4LogEKSPORt +
β5DLogZISWAFt + ECT (-1)..................(3)
D(log(GDPt-1)) = β0 + β1Dt + β2D (log (PMDNt1)) + β3D(log(EXPORT AGIt-1)) + β4 D(log
(EXPORTt-1)) + β5D(log(ZISWAFt-1)) + ECT
(-1)..................(4)
ECT (-1) = DlogPMDNt-1 + DlogEKSPOR AGIt-1 +
DlogEKSPORt-1 + DlogZISWAFt-1............................(5)
Where:
LogGDPt
LogPMDNt
: Economic growth in period t
: Investment of Domestic Investment
period t
LogEXPORT-AGIt : Export Value of Agriculture
and Manufacturing Industry
period t
LogEXPORTt : Export Value Total period t
LogZISWAFt : Amount of Zakah and Endowments
in period t
D(LogPDB(t-1)) : Slowdown in Economic Growth
D(LogPMDNI(t-1)) : Inaction
of
Investment
Domestic Investment
D(LogEXPORT AGIt-1) : Inaction of Agricultural
Exports and P rocessing
Industries
(LogEXPORT(t-1)) : Total Export Slowness
D(LogZISWAF(t-1)) : Ziswaf Slowness
D
: Change
T
: Period of time
ECT
: Residual
ECT (-1)
: Residual t-1
α0α1 α2 α3 α4
: Long-term Coe icient
β0 β1β2 β3 β4
: Short-term Coef icient
Stages Analysis Result Data
A second study using documentary methodology
of qualitative analysis, especially in developing
arguments in the development potential of
Islamic banking,
management effectiveness
Awqaf, waqf land use and empowerment of the
State Owned Enterprises, as well as the relevant
legal framework.
ANALYSIS
Result Data Processing ECM
DP test of the residual value obtained from the
Table 1. Unit Root Test Results with the Augmented Dickey Test Fuller (ADF)
LEVEL
VARIABLES
1ST DIFFERENT
2ND DIFFERENT
PROB.
VARIABLES
PROB.
VARIABLES
PROB.
0.9932
D(X7)
0.0000
D(X7,2)
0.0120
EXPORT
0.9666
D(X2)
0.9379
D(X2,2)
0.0009
GDP
0.9214
PMDN
EXPORT AGI
ZISWAF
0.1461
0.6555
D(X1)
0.0000
D(X8)
D(Y)
0.0841
- 91 -
0.0000
D(X1,2)
D(X8,2)
D(Y,2)
0.0000
0.0002
0.0000
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
estimated equation (4) is -1.078809 which is
negative and has a statistical F probability of
0.0035 which is < 0.05. This shows that ECM's
legal requirements have been ful illed (Table 2).
The Export-Agi coef icient variable with a value
of 44.875570 is the biggest most in luential value
in the long-term regression estimation. VariableDomestic Investment, Export-Agi and ZISWAF is
positive, which means three in line with GDP, if
the Export-Agi and ZISWAF grow, GDP will increase
as well; whereas when the three decline or slow
down, GDP will decline or slow down as well.
Negative coef icient value of exports shows that
exports have the opposite relationship with
economic growth in GDP (Table 3).
Long-term economic growth equation model of
ECM be:
PDBt = 8,030520 PMDNt + 44,87557EKSPOR AGIt
– 8,951954EKSPORt + 132.7093ZISWAFt +
895104.3...............................................................(6)
The results of the regression model T-Test shortterm and long-term indicate that ZISWAF variables
VARIABLES
have a signi icant effect on economic growth
variables at a 95 percent con idence level. The
regression R-square value of the short-term
model produces 26 percent of the effect of
variable proportions of PMDN, Export-AGI,
Export, and ZISWAF to GDP, which means that
there have 74 per cent of other variables outside
the model that affect GDP. Rated R-square of
long term result in the proportion of 96 per cent
of the effect of variable Domestic, Export-AGI,
Export, and ZISWAF to GDP, only 4 percent are
in luenced by variables outside the model, meaning
that the independent variables are tested to
provide almost all the information needed to
predict the dependent variable.
The ECM model short-term derivative economic
growth equation is:
D(log (GDPt)) = α0 + α1Dt + α5D (log (ZISWAFmt1)) + ECT (-1)......................(7)
D(log (GDPt)) = 0.023339 + 0.036501D(log
(ZISWAFmt-1)) - 1.81E-07ECT(-1) (8)
The ECT coef icient of the above equation is
Table 2. Log regression results for the 2nd Different
with Augmented Dickey Fuller Test (ADF)
STASIONER 2nd Different
ADF
D(LOG(EKSPORT AGI)
0.002265
0.9597
Not Stationer
0.3051
Not Stationer
D(LOG(EKSPORT)
-0.000508
0.9884
D(LOG(ZISWAF)
0.036501
0.0366
D(LOG(PMDN)
RES(-1)
VARIABLES
Information
Prob
0.039820
-1.81E-07
0.0035
Table 3. T-test results on the Regression model
COEFFICIENT
Prob. (stat)
Not Stationer
Stasioner
Stasioner
HYPOTHESIS TEST
LONG TERM
EXPORT-AGI
44.8756
0.0066
Signi icant
PMDN
8.0305
0.0000
Signi icant
EXPORT
0.0000
-8.9519
ZISWAF
1.3271
D(log(EKSPOR AGI))
0.0023
0.0000
SHORT TERM
Not Signi icant
0.3051
Not Signi icant
-0.0005
0.9884
D(log(ZISWAF))
0.0365
0.0366
0.0398
- 92 -
Signi icant
0.9597
D(log(EKSPOR))
D(log(PMDN))
Signi icant
Not Signi icant
Signi icant
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
-1.81E-07 meaning that there are increasing GDP
will be adjusted within one (1) year with the
residual speed of the balance value of -181 percent.
This research proveds that in the long and short
term ziswaf has a signi icant in luence on economic
growth. In the long run, AGI-Export has the
biggest positive effect compared to the positive
effect of domestic investment and Ziswaf; As for
long-term exports and export- AGI signi icantly
affect economic growth, but otherwise has no
effect on GDP.
Stages Analysis effect of domestic capital
investment, international trade and ISF on
sustainable economic growth in Indonesia
Indonesia is a country undergoing transformation
(Daryanto, 2009) characterized by farmers who
own less than half a hectare of arable land
and traditional harvests that produce little
employment and income. Ziswaf's research
illustrates the religiosity of a community with a
large Muslim population in Indonesia having
a high level of generosity and social care. If well
maintained is a great potential to achieve higher
GDP through ISF contribution, it means the future.
The existence of a negative export to GDP can
occur because the amount of exports is too small
and there is a far greater in luence due to world
demands, trade policies that impose a country at
the time or too many similar imported goods.
Even though his condition seems unfavorable,
but adherents of Islam do not give up and
continue to increase hard efforts because Allah
subhanahu wa taa'ala has guaranteed every
wealth. When farmers / producers have not been
able to produce better quality, the potential for
increased income will also increase by increasing
value-added production, in addition to the
community can increase consumption of domestic
products that are also of higher quality and
reduce consumption of imported products. With
the increased ability of producers, trade can
be increased by expanding markets, including
addressing the needs of domestic interisland
islands and also meeting export standards.
With the enactment of the Halal Product
Guarantee Act (JPH), agricultural products, postharvest handling and supply of agricultural
products to the food or pharmaceutical industry
must meet halal standards to facilitate the halal
industry output process, the halal value chain
becomes important. The food industry can be
developed step by step, conditioned by its
production capacity and industrial capability.
Provision of inancing from Islamic banking can
be done in every step of industrial development.
By increasing the assets and capabilities of
producers, trade can be increased by expanding
markets, including entering international markets.
A country's exports and imports form the basis of
foreign trade. A country must have at least one
industry which produces products / goods more
ef iciently compared to other countries; resulting
from the optimal use of resources. International
trade is a representation of a signi icant part of
the output of many countries. Even though the
risk of international trade is higher than domestic
trade, if it has been identi ied then efforts to
control risk will be the effect of the next task.
Risks that often arise are 1) Exporters who do not
familiar with buyers, 2) Exporters do not know
that importers are a good credit risk, 3) Exporters
do not paid by importers, 4) Political stability
that affects shipping goods abroad in certain
parts in this world (Eun, Resnick & Sabherwal,
2014).
Weakening global demand is the time to introcheck and evaluate the performance of existing
commercial products and improve the quality and
trading system to be more ef icient, both related
to selling prices and commodity volumes. A high
exchange rate will bene it exports, but if demand
is low it will not help improve the trade balance.
When world demand is low, the domestic market
will enjoy goods of better quality (export
standards) and may reduce the tendency of
imports of the same goods. This will improve the
performance of the trade balance. On the process
of collecting research data it is known that the
potential of wakafs land is very large and is still
not fully managed properly. This is supported by
- 93 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
research evidence that domestic investment in
the long term has a real in luence on economic
growth, but in the short term it has no real effect
and ziswaf has a signi icant positive effect on
GDP both in the short and long term.
Enjoying the grace of Allah subhanahu wa ta’alaa
Almighty, so when weakening global demand is
the right time to inspect and evaluate goods /
products, examine and replace
imported
production materials by substituting equivalent
local products, develop product innovations and
better processing technologies, prepare trading
systems to be more ef icient both related to
selling prices, commodity volumes and preparing
agricultural goods / products that meet the World
Trade Organization rules. And the most important
thing is to increase production by increasing the
area of production land and increasing the
capacity of the processing industry and preparing
the formal legal aspects of the contribution of
waqf in the process.
Regarding iscal policy, a high currency exchange
rate will bene it exports, but if the volume of
demand is low it will not help improve the trade
balance. It is precisely in these conditions that
raw-material imports become a trap because
they are a burden on the negative trade balance,
a negative contribution to GDP. When world
demand is low, the domestic market will enjoy
better quality goods (export standards) and can
reduce the tendency of imports of the same
goods, and when world demand rises this will
improve the performance of the trade balance.
Economic growth will change people's demand.
Barokah land-and-oceans Indonesia with a variety
of plants and animal that become commodity
income countries. During 2012-2018 the role of
non-oil and gas exports averaged 86.48 percent
per year. When viewed into commodities, non-oil
and gas exports have always been dominated by
exports of manufactured products from the
period 2012 to 2018. The average contribution of
manufacturing industry exports to non-oil and
gas exports during the period 2012 to 2018 was
80.54 percent. The biggest agricultural commodity
in 2018 is from annual crop commodities (59.45
percent), sorted from the largest value is coffee,
aromatic- medicinal plants and spices, white
pepper, tobacco, and other horticultural crops.
Commodities of capture isheries, aquaculture
and livestock are swallow-nest, crab, seaweed
and other algae, and crabs. Other agricultural
commodities are rubber-gum and the like,
sandalwood (BPS, 2019).
The manufacturing sector is the main sector of
supporting the country's economy. Food industry
commodities contribute 62.73 percent worth
26.27bn US$ supported by palm oil (Unsolid
fractions of re ined palm oil, Crude palm oil-Palm
kernel oil-Rbd, Solid fractions of re ined palm oil,
solid fractions of re ined palm kernel oil, palm
kernel olein-(re ined, bleached & deodorized),
frozen shrimp, coconut oil (fractions of Re ined
coconut oil-Not chemically modi ied, crude oil of
coconut/copra, crude oil of palm kernel), butterfat-cocoa oil, frozen ish, instant coffee and black
tea, bread and cakes, oil-cake and other solid
residues of palm nuts or kernels, cuttle ish and
squid-frozen, hydrogenated & Rbd palm kernel
stearin or olein, frozen illets of tunas, skipjack
or stripe-bellied bonito, tilapias-frozen, cocoa
paste,wholly/partly defatted, coconuts-desiccateddried, cashew nuts-shelled-fresh or dried, oth
pasta-oth instant-noodles, pineapples-othwise
prepared / preserved, oth sugar confectionerynot cont.cocoa-oth soft-cont gelatin (Kemenperin,
2017).
The second biggest value of export performance
is the Chemical Commodity Industry and Chemical
Goods, which includes industries that are
changing organic materials and non- organic raw
with chemical processes and product formation
processes.
Exports of chemical
industry
commodities and goods from chemicals on
analysis. This refers to the 2015 KBLI concept.
The industry share includes basic organic
chemistry sourced from agricultural products
(36.82 percent), Basic organic chemistry sourced
from oil (12.45 percent), soaps and materialscleaners-home-purposes (10.84 percent), arti icialresin/synthetic resins (8.44 percent), and-other
- 94 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
raw materials (fertilizer, essential oils). The third
largest value of export performance is rubber
commodities,
rubber goods and plastics.
Indonesia's rubber production is ranked second
in the world's largest rubber producer after
Thailand, followed by Vietnam in the third position
with the most extensive ownership of Indonesia's
rubber land. Rubber is a commodity that is used in
many products and equipment throughout the
world. The export share consists of Crumb Rubber
which is a raw material for several downstream
rubber products such as tires, conveyor belts,
vehicle spare parts, dock fenders, vulcanizers, and
others, outer-and-inner-tires, and other goods
from other rubber.
Competitiveness and performance of the state
indicates the ability to sell and supply goods and
services in the market is better than the ability
of other countries in the same market. Factors of
comparative advantage can be regarded as natural
factors, while the competitive advantage factor is
a factor that can be developed. RCTA indicator
(Revealed Comparative Trade Advantage) is a
commonly used index to see the development of
export and import growth for the same product.
There are 81 Indonesian agricultural commodities
that have a positive RCTA value, which means they
have competitiveness (comparative advantage) in
the world and domestic markets (FAO, 2011).
Factors of comparative advantage can be
considered as a factor,
while its natural
competitive advantage factor can be considered
a factor that can be acquired or developed. The
index commonly used to see the development of
exports and also the development of imports for
the same product is RCTA (Revealed Comparative
Trade Advantage).
The results of the
competitiveness analysis with the RCTA indicator
from FAO, 2011 show that based on the average
value in 2009-2011, as many as 81 Indonesian
agricultural commodities have a positive RCTA
value, which means they have competitiveness
(comparative advantage) in the world and
domestic markets.
The most competitive
commodity is palm kernel oil (20.93) as presented
in TableApendix. Revealed Trade Comparative
Advantage (RTCA) is an index used to measure the
relative gains or losses of certain commodities in a
country which is veri ied from its trading patterns,
such as export market share (Table Appendix).
Policy makers face challenges when designing
government initiatives aimed at encouraging the
development of new green sectors, namely what
green sectors will be promoted. In industrial policy
this selection process often fails. The government
needs to design a policy package to support sectors
that have comparative advantages in agriculture,
so industrial policy is likely to succeed. The natural
and comparative advantages of the region in
recent years have been clear to several developing
countries such as the Technology and Information
services in India and Mauritus, the salmon and
wine industry in Chile, and the cut lower sector in
Kenya (The International Institute for Sustainable
Development, 2014).
Stages Analysis Strengthening IBs with
Partnership Financing and Sukuk
The main driver of economic growth from an
environmental standpoint and today is the
expansion of global trade liberalization that does
not harm the natural environment. Global trade
inance volume reached US $23.4 trillion, or onethird of global GDP.
Studies of the impact of
changes on the economic aspects of climate
change by ADB (Asian Development Bank)
showed in 2010, the in luence on igures of 2.2
percent to 6.7 percent of GDP (Fauzi, 2010).
International trade more dif icult and risky than
domestic trade export activity it showed demand
for products of the country which means that the
labor force is used to the technology. Therefore,
the export-oriented company must have a good
marketer, a competitive product, promotion, price
and delivery capabilities as well as services
rendered to the importer. As important as a
competitive company in providing credit to the
importer, the government exported great support
to domestic exporters competitive in the form of
loans that can be extended to importers (Eun,
Resnick & Sabherwal, 2014).
Financial greetings will solve problems on farm
- 95 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
related to: fertilizers, insecticides, herbicides
and storage facilities, etc. It can also function as
a substitute for conventional agricultural inance
in the state of Kano, Nigeria. Financial Salam is
an Islamic inancial product that is used by the
Islamic banking industry to inance agricultural
products and investments for economic growth
and development. Financial greetings are good
products for increasing agricultural output and
overcoming the problem of agricultural products.
This is the same, providing full advance payment
and future delivery of agricultural produce at the
agreed time.
Salam- inance are Islamic inancial products
used by the Islamic banking industry to inance
agricultural products and investments for
agricultural growth and development. Salaminance I s a good products as agricultural
inancing to increase agricultural output and
overcome the problem of agricultural products.
This is the same, providing full payment in
advance and delivery of agricultural products in
the future at the agreed time. Salam- inancing
has been used for more than 1400 years in
Medina
(Ogonbado & Ahmed, 2015).
Implementation in Indonesia, where agricultural
cultivation has shifted by reducing the use of
chemical fertilizers and developing organic crops,
greetings inancing can be directed to provide
quality seeds, crop maintenance, increase postharvest and increase the added value of farmers'
products by developing agro-industry and also
help access global marketing marketing.
The state of Kano,
Nigeria established
micro inance in 44 states' regional governments
to tackle agriculture, trade, trade and industry
issues. Later, Islamic banks introduced Salaminance to replace the conventional mode of
agricultural inancing in the state. Rural farmers,
traders, investors, branches of the Ja'is bank
(Islamic bank) in the state of Kano will get many
bene its. Expected to overcome the eradication
of problems country such as food insecurity,
poverty, unemployment, falling income of farmers
and government. Micro inance can also be
involved in parallel Parallel-Salam contracts.
Salam inancing has the potential to reduce
poverty, job opportunities, increase marketing
activities, provide education and training. The
availability of agricultural output in the state leads
to the socio-economic stability of poor farmers
and the country's economic growth.
On muslim community, an religiously acceptable
banking services must be banking and fnancial
system based Islamic principles. To run an
agricultural project there is the principle of almuzara'a, al-musaqa and mugharasah need to
understand two main ideas; leasing and pro it
sharing/partnership between property and work.
In contrast to al-mudharabah, which is more
suitable for trade contracts and industrial or
commercial operations. So the understanding of
al-muzara'a, al-musaqa and al-mugharasah can
be de ined in principle as a contract based on the
division of products or results rather than pro it
sharing. Therefore, al-muzara'a and al-musaqa can
be identi ied as 'agricultural products and yields
sharing' (aPLS), as opposed to al-mudharabah and
al-musharaka known as 'Pro it and loss sharing'
(PLS). Land together with labor can be considered
a form of capita l and therefore has similarities
with mudaraba and musharaka contracts.
Therefore, it can be said that these principles
are 'Agricultural Production and Yields Sharing
(aPLS)' because land will naturally produce output
or products. Therefore, Muzara'a and Musaqa can
be said as a contract based on yields sharing and
not pro it sharing (Sha iai, 2012).
Further explained that Finance and Participatory
(PF) those model has haved High Level of Risk.
The risks associated with PF are one of the main
challenges in implementing this inancing model.
Islamic Bankings (IBs) have the following high
levels of inherent risk when involved in PF:
I) Lack of Ibs technical expertise due to
the absence of appropriate monitoring
mechanisms: In the absence of appropriate
mechanisms for project
and company
evaluations, banks cannot measure project
performance and value at various stages the
life cycle of their business;
- 96 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
ii) A high level of risk weight that is set: Capital
adequacy standards do not really accommodate
Musharakah and Mudarabah-based products.
A high risk weight age has been established
for these products, which is 400% as stated in
IFSB Standard No. 15, whereas in BASEL III.2
it is 1000%;
iii) Risk of sharia non-compliance: The risk of
sharia non-compliance can also be a major
concern in Musharakah and Mudarabah-based
products. Because the project will usually be
a long-term project and has a complex / hybrid
structure, the bank may not be able to continue
to monitor the project to ensure that it
complies with sharia rules.
Today the use of participatory modes such as
Mudaraba and Musharaka been absent, especially
in the asset side of bank balance sheets. When
some IBs execute Musharakah inancings, it lacks
true risk sharing as the return its based on
conventional pricing benchmark. These practices
have attracted criticism on the current model of
Ibs. Ibs contrary to conventional banks, are
supposed to achieve greater socioeconomic
objectives such as social justice, economic
growth, ef iciency and stability, and these
objectives can be better served through the use of
these participatory modes of inancing. It is also
viewed that these modes have the potential to
better serve the stakeholders through equitable
and broad-based
distribution of risk and
rewards among the entrepreneur, banker and
depositors and promote stability of the inancial
and economic system. Currently, the development
of global sukuk very quickly, and become an
investment option businessman. Based on the
sukuk issuer may be issued by corporations and
governments.
In short, the mechanisms, waqf and agricultural
idle land is a new innovation in waqf
development in the contemporary era. The
scheme aPLS (agricultural production and loss
sharing) that proposed cannot stand alone in
the traditional iqh to be implemented now.
Therefore, the combinations of aPLS contract
with ujrah principle are really needed. Be
important to ensure the lexibility of the contract
that can offer a fully comprehensive scheme of
Islamic agricultural inancing. Nevertheless, the
applications of these mechanisms are not without
controversies. It’s important to mention that waqf
utilization in the waqf system received a lot of
debates among the iqh scholars and modern
scholars.
Management of waqf land for agriculture can
apply other principles such as al-ijarah muntahiya
bi-tamlik, al-murabahah and bay al-salam. At
present Islamic banking institutions tend to
apply two-tier al-mudarabah, not one-sided almudarabah in classical theory, where banks
accumulate deposits from their customers and
invest in third parties. Islamic inancial experts
are more appropriate in applying the principles
of al-muzara'ah and al-musaqah, which are more
relevant and increase th e practicality
of
transactions in Islamic banking / inancial
institutions. Required steps must be determined
from many parties, including academics and
practitioners to improve this product (Sha iai &
Moi, 2015).
Othe r principles such as al-ijarah muntahiya
bi-tamlik, al-murabaha and bay al-salam can also
be included. IBs institutions currently tend to
apply two-tier al-mudarabah, not one- sided almudarabah in classical theory, where banks
accumulate deposits from their customers and
invest them in third parties. Islamic inances (IFs)
experts more precisely implement the principles
of al-muzara'ah and al-musaqah. This is more
relevant for improving the practicality
of
transactions in Islamic banking and inancial
institutions. The necessary steps must be
determined from many parties,
including
academics and practitioners to improve this
product (Sha iai & Moi, 2015).
Food processing industry development should
prioritize high usage of imported raw materials
and weaken the performance of net trade balance
of Indonesia. Financing agricultural (A- inancing)
by IBs /IFs institutions in the long term, it needs
to be directed to the industrial development of
- 97 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
import substitution of raw materials, the
development of local production into innovative
product export standards, developing innovative
industrial equipment is good and cheap. In terms
of the availability of clean water is also needed to
increase agricultural crop production and quality
of agricultural products processing industry
generated. Related to ISF, waqf-wells are an
alternative for the people of Indonesia, can be
mixed with government funding through the
construction of irrigation infrastructure for areas
in need. This problem can be solved by
implementing Musaqa or Istishna contract.
PT Perkebunan Nusantara (c.q. PTPN) is the
one of a state agency related to tea and palm
plantation products which are spread in several
regions in Indonesia. It's time for the state agency
to be able to contribute in state revenue. The
extent of land has not been maximally produced,
if assisted with Islamic inancial inancing, it is
possible to improve its performance
and
contribute to an increase in state income from the
agricultural sector. Likewise, well-managed forest
land will certainly get the balance of the ecosystem
and improve the welfare of the surrounding poor
communities. In general, plantation company
transaction activities are divided into several
stages, including: nursery stage, land preparation
stage, planting and transplanting stages to the
land area, treatment and fertilization Stage,
harvest and harvest-handling stage, harvest
product processing stage, and marketing endproduct. One way to increase business capital is to
issue agricultural sukuk with a special agricultural
contract.
Explanation cooperation agreement based on alMuzaraah, al-Musaqah and al- Mugharasah are: 1)
Al-Muzara'ah is a contract of agricultural business
cooperation between the land owner and the
manager (cultivators), where the seeds of the
plant come from the land owner and agricultural
products are shared between the owner and the
cultivator according to t he agreed ratio. 2) AlMusaqah is a contract of cooperation between the
land owner and the cultivator in the framework of
maintaining plants to grow and bear fruit well, the
results of which are shared between the owner
and the cultivator according to the agreed ratio 3)
Mugharasah is a contract of cooperation between
the land owner and the cultivator in the context of
securing a hard tree where the harvest is the tree
(not the fruit), the results are shared between the
land owner and the cultivator according to the
agreed ratio.
The multiple impact
of
improved
trade
performance is that welfare at the farm level
(upstream) and downstream will also increase.
A good post harvest must be introduced to farmers
so that they will always get a high bargaining
position. The IBs or Islamic inancing scheme
through the agreements above made it possible,
Insyaa Allah. Proposed sharia bank partnership
scheme in Figure 3.
CONCLUTION AND POLICY ADVICER
Conclusion
1. International trade Exports-AGI and Export,
PMDN investment and I S F - Ziswaf was affecting
national growth of GDP with signi icant. In the
long term, the economic growth of GDP is
affected simultaneously by all independent
variables, and is signi icantly affected positively
by international trade Agi Exports, PMDN
investments and ZISWAF sosio economy fund;
and signi icantly in luenced negatively by the
international trade of Export at the R-square
level of 0.98. In the short term, economic growth
of GDP was signi icantly in luenced by ZISWAF
sosio economy fund on R-square 0.26.
2. Partnership Financing and Sukuk are very
potential to be developed for large-scale
agricultural projects, both for the cultivation of
annual crops, plantations, forestry and other
potentially competitive crops with inancing
agreements like Salam, Muzara'ah,
and
Mugharasah. Irrigation infrastructure for areas
prone to lack of water with Musaqa or Istishna
inancing.
Policy Maker
1. The government through the Ministry of
Religion and the Endowment Board more
encourages the development of unemployed
- 98 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
LANDLORD/PTP/WA QAFLAND/
ISLAMIC BANKING
1. TREE/SEED/SEEDLING
2. ANIMAL
3. INDUSTRIAL TOOLS
4. MARKETING TRADE
LANDLORD/PTP/WA QAFLAND/
ISLAMIC BANKING
1. TREE/SEED/SEEDLING
2. MARKETING TRADE
LANDLORD/WA QAFLAND/
ISLAMIC BANKING
1. INDUSTRIAL TOOLS
2. SEED/ANIMAL
3. MARKETING TRADE
SCHEME 1
PARTNERSHIP
SCHEME 2
PARTNERSHIP
SCHEME 3
PARTNERSHIP
FARMER
WORK
FARMER
1. WORK
2. INDUSTRIAL TOOLS
3. ANIMAL
FARMER
WORK
Figure 3. Financing Partnership Scheme
land through the ownership of manufacturing
industries that produce raw materials that
meet the needs of domestic industries and
then export-oriented to reduce domestic
dependence on imported raw materials,
through coordination between three ministries
namely agriculture, trade and industry.
2. The government and IB must encourage the
part of Islamic inancial institutions namely
the concept of 'smart micro inance', which
provides a variety of products to accompany
vulnerable people in the SDGs, through
economic empowerment, but will also ensure
that these communities are adequately
equipped and empowered by strengthening
capacity technical and managerial, building
partnerships, accessing markets, identifying
and managing climate risks in their activities,
etc.
3. The intermediary function of the IB must
provide inancing products based on ethics
and contracts permitted by the central bank,
the fatwa of the local ulama and the state
inancial authority board.
Issuance of
investment sukuk can be informed by the IB or
the government through the ministry of inance
and related bodies / waqf who are unemployed
landowners.
4. Ecosystems that drive liquidity to the real
sector must be maintained. The Central Bank
together with the inance ministry and the
Indonesian central bank must be able to
maintain macroeconomic stability through
government iscal policies and monetary and
exchange rate stability, low interest rates, and
in lation that are lower than the target, so that
the business climate continues to perform well.
- 99 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
REFERENCES
AAOIFI. (2004) Sharia’a Standars. 2004-5. Accounting & Auditing Organization for Islamic Finance
Institutions. ISBN 99901-23-06-3 P.O.Box 1175. Manama, Bahrain. Email: aaoi i@batelko.com.bh
Website: www.aao i.com
Abdul-Rahman, Y. (2010). The Art of Islamic Banking and Finance – Tools and Techniques for Communitybased Banking. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Hoboken, New Jersey.
Anderson, K. (2010). Review. Globalization’s effects on world agricultural trade, 1960 – 2050. School of
Economics, University of Adelaide, Australia. Philosophycal Transaction of Royal Socciety. B (2010)
365, 3007–3021. doi:10.1098/rstb.2010.0131
Agustianto. (2008). Wakaf Produktif Untuk Kesejahteraan Umat. Niriah, Jakarta. 7
Al- Quranul Karim. (2011). Terjemah Kata Per Kata. CV Insan Kamil. Jl. Babakan Sari I No.71 Kiaracondong,
Bandung 40283.
Ahmad, M. (2015). Role of Waqf in Sustainable Economic Development and Poverty Alleviation: Bangladesh
Perspective. Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization. ISSN 22243240 (Paper) ISSN 2224-3259
(Online) Vol.42, 2015
Ashraf, B. N. (2017). Do Trade and Financial Openness Matter for Financial Development? Bank-level
Evidence From Emerging Market Economies. Research in International Business and Finance.
Volume 44, April 2018, Pages 434-458
Azis, R. M. (2009). Kaffah Thingking on Simlammim Method Through Digital Root. Proceeding. ISOIT
International Seminar on Ismalic Thought, UKM, Bangi, Malaysia.
Badan Wakaf Indonesia. (2016). Himpunan Peraturan Perundang-Undnagan tentnag Wakaf. 260 halaman.
Bank Indonesia. (2007). Peningkatan Peran Bank Indonesia dalam Mendorong Pertumbuhan Ekonomi
Melalui Pemetaan Sektor Ekonomi: Laporan Pemetaan Ekonomi Sektor Pertanian. Biro Neraca
Pembayaran, Direktorat Statistik Ekonomi dan Moneter. Jakarta.
Cervantes, G. D., and Dewbre, J. (2010) “Economic Importance of Agriculture for Poverty Reduction”, OECD
Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Working Papers, No. 23, OECD Publishing. doi: 10.1787/5kmmv
9s20944-en
Dermoredjo et al. 2015. Pemetaan Daya Saing Pertanian Indonesia. Laporan Akhir TA 2015. Pusat Sosial
Ekonomi dan Kebijakan Pertanian. Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Pertanian. Kementerian
Pertanian. Jakarta.
Eun, C. S., Resnick, B. G. And Sabherwal, S. (2013). International Finance, 6 Edition. McGrawHill
Education (Asia). Terjemahan Penerbit Salemba Empat.
http://www.fao.org/fsnforum/zh/topics/resources/household-food-security?page=2
https://globalwakaf.com
https://kemenperin.go.id/statistik/peran.php?ekspor=1
Fauzi, A. (2010).The Economics of Climate Change in South East Asia: A Regional Review. Review ADB’s
Review.
Gujarati, D.N. (2004). Basic Econometrics, (4th ed.). The McGraw-Hill Co.
Hadad, S. M. (2016). Pidato Ketua Umum Ikatan Sarjana Ekonomi Indonesia. Inovasi Rantai Nilai Sektor Agro
dalam Mendukung Implementasi Financial Inclusion Untuk Petani. KADIN, ISEI, PISAgro – Balai
Kartini, Jakarta, 23 Mei 2016.
https://www.bps.go.id/publication/2019/08/02/8790fedf90b47c11b009a5ca/analisis- komoditasekspor--2012-2018--sektor-pertanian--industri--dan-pertambangan.html
https://mui-lplhsda.org/pandangan-islam-terhadap-ketahanan-air-pangan-dan-energi-bangsa/
International Institute for Sustainable Development. ( 2014). Trade and Green Economy. A Handbook. Third
Edition. The United Nations Environment Programme Division of Technology, Industry and
Economics Economics and Trade Branch and The International Institute for Sustainable
- 100 -
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
Development. Published by the International Institute for Sustainable Development. Printed in
Geneva, Switzerland.
Josling, T., Anderson, K., Schmitz, A., & Tangermann, S. (2010). Understanding International Trade in
Agricultural Products. Amer Journal. Agr. Econ. 92(2): 424– 446; doi: 10.1093/ajae/aaq011.
Received December 2009; accepted January 2010; April 2010
Miller, H. M. (1998) Financial Markets and Economic Growth, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance
September 1998, Vol. 11 No. 3 (Fall 1998), pages 8 – 14
Mulyawan, D. (2017). Kontribusi Islamic Social Finance Dalam Percepatan Pertumbuhan Ekonomi Nasional.
Materi Seminar Nasional: Islamic Capital Market and Economic Development. 1 Maret 2018.
Kementrian Keuangan-Universitas Gunadarma, Depok.
Myers, T. A., and Hassazadeh, E. ( 2013). The Interconection Between Islamic Finance and Sustainable
Financing. IISD Report. Publised by The International Institute for Sustainable Development. 161
Portage Avenue East, 6 Floor, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada R3B 0Y4. www.iisd.org
Mohammed, A. I., Ogunbado, A. F., & Bashir, A. (2016). The Viability of Salam Finance in the Growth of
Agricultural Production in Kano State, Nigeria. Asian Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, 4(12),
87–92.
Naufal, A. (2010). Peranan Sektor Pertanian dalam Pertumbuhan Ekonomi dan Mengurangi Ketimpangan
Pendapatan di Pemerintah Aceh.
OJK. (2017). Roadmap Map Ekonomi Berkelanjutan 2015-2018
Putra, A. (2014). Implementasi Kebijakan Green Growth di Korea Selatan. Jom Fisip Volume I No.2 Oktober
2014. Riau-Pekanbaru.
Samad, M. (2016). Fiqih Lingkungan, Solusi Pemanasan Global dan Masalah Lingkungan dari Sisi Agama
Islam. Lembaga Adat Melayu Riau, Pekanbaru.
Setyaningsih, P., Aziz, R., & Hadiyati, P. (2019). Analysis of Ziswaf, Production Index and Sharia Stock Index on
Economic Growth. Jurnal Pasar Modal Dan Bisnis, 1 (2), 221- 242.
https://doi.org/10.37194/jpmb.v1i2.32
Sha iai, M. H. M., Moi, M. R., & Ahmad, R. (2015). The Potential of Waqf in Activating Idle Agricultural
Land. Jurnal Pengurusan 44 (2015) 141 - 147
Sha iai, M. H., & Moi, M. R. (2015). Fitting Islamic inancial contracts in developing agricultural land.
Global Journal Al-Thaqafah, 5(1), 43–49. https://doi.org/10.7187/GJAT772015.05.01
Sutawijaya, A. (2010). Pengaruh Ekspor Dan Investasi Terhadap Pertumbuhan Ekonomi Indonesia Tahun
1980-2006. Jurnal Organisasi Dan Manajemen, 6(1), 14–27.
Usher, E. and Ndiaye, D. (2020). 2020: The Year Sustainable Islamic Finance Scales?
https://www.responsible-investor.com/articles Mar 2nd, 2020
- 101 -
International Journal of Business Studies Vol. 4 No. 2 ( June 2020)
APENDIX
Komoditas
Table 1. Positive RCTA Value of indonesia Agricultural commodities (2000 - 2011)
Oil, palm kernel
Rataan 2000-02
Rataan 2003-05
31,4525
27,23601
23,46205
20,92518
1
19,05038
19,41593
18,1185
15,25921
3
Oil, palm
20,86654
Rubber natural dry
21,65471
Cake, palm kernel
Oil, coconut (copra)
Cake, copra
Coconuts
Cinnamon (canella)
Copra
Nutmeg, mace and cardamoms
Fatty acids
Waxes vegetable
19,07756
25,23266
17,84315
11,33397
Margarine, short
7,57106
12,14205
8,55835
6,88426
5,46531
8,29141
8,5454
7,34397
4,83646
4,81333
5,16972
-3,56537
-7,73311
8,14884
10,10293
6,44339
10,12441
5,24315
7,10282
-0,12689
4,3329
7,32542
4,38048
-0,1517
2,12669
2,78269
2,16323
-1,37628
-0,06846
Cigarettes
1,00932
0,7379
0,70618
Cassava dried
2,72764
1,87125
1,28502
Oilseeds nes
1,13598
0
2,8229
1,96928
0,32488
0,42133
2,3039
1,72019
1,66906
Coffee, extracts
0,63567
-0,16313
Mushrooms, canned
3,22989
1,48627
0,25341
0,28842
Wool, hair waste
Cocoa, paste
Spices, nes
Oil, olive residues
Cabbages and other brassicas
Oil, essential nes
0,05653
0,97359
4,39275
1,23016
2,24311
2,14755
4,60719
4,487
3,566
3,36036
3,26412
3,2386
- 102 -
1,69175
1,58973
1,37991
1,34983
1,3049
0,83296
0,66626
0,60014
0,59922
0,5559
0,82774
0,35654
0,10768
1,0865
1,79031
0,49394
0,19872
0,99137
2,23569
-0,61
-0,05001
1,98817
3,00064
0,74595
0,0203
0,23409
0,17221
0,49828
0,96502
6
7
8
9
12
5,0154
1,18219
0,80425
5
5,07304
0,87541
0,44729
4
10
5,45044
0
0,51188
2
5,45392
2,11373
2,2774
3,6942
Molasses
Cocoa, powder & cake
5,55218
2,70575
2,98559
Cigars, cheroots
5,58154
6,88593
-0,01461
7,39582
Tea
9,04703
2,37186
2,83187
Wafers
9,47079
3,14121
2,92568
0
9,54687
3,63192
Coffee, green
4,67224
12,45144
3,16012
44,87243
2,11599
5,07041
15,82169
4,3819
Juice, pineapple, concentrated
Vanilla
5,67585
1,61138
4,42295
Sweet potatoes
5,1156
11,49705
Cocoa, butter
Cotton waste
7,07683
5,04896
10,05308
Fat, nes, prepared
9,85252
-0,98307
Bran, wheat
Meat, nes
13,092
15,22671
-1,26124
9,96799
Cashew nuts, with shell
13,19484
21,11713
5,27797
Pineapples canned
Cocoa, beans
15,8569
12,99636
5,23178
11,65576
17,1123
13,65663
13,97122
14,99865
Flour, roots and tubers nes
18,70652
12,77681
Pepper (piper spp.)
Coconuts, desiccated
20,30643
Rataan 2006-08 Rataan 2009-11 Rataan 2009-11
0,42091
0,34065
0,27996
0,25462
0,24717
0,18778
11
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
Purbawati Setyaningsih, Acep R. Jayaprawira / Strengthening Agricultural Investment Through
Sustainable Islamic Banking / 82 - 103
Cashew nuts, shelled
Pastry
Sugar confectionery
0,55206
0,29305
0,72504
0,46
0,29
0,18148
0,50835
0,17276
45
0,09308
0,13979
47
0,1433
Cereals, breakfast
-0,23583
-0,21089
-0,21823
Bran, rice
-3,42969
-0,43605
0,03445
Cotton linter
-0,00241
Oil, vegetable origin nes
Lard
Bread
Cake, cottonseed
Flour, pulses
Waters,ice etc
Eggplants (aubergines)
Source: FAO (2011), processed
0,25725
0,22342
0,09715
-0,18466
0,03941
-0,00382
0,04761
0,05118
0,14366
0,0497
-0,07847
-0,32534
-1,94676
-5,21936
0,8579
0,5777
0,04485
0,52641
0,21907
0,32708
0,09188
- 103 -
0,74274
-0,01589
0,15721
0,12217
0,11996
0,08739
0,08078
0,07898
0,06953
0,06454
0,06432
0,06273
0,05955
46
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57