Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sergej Hloch
Dagmar Klichová
Grzegorz M. Krolczyk
Somnath Chattopadhyaya
Lucie Ruppenthalová Editors
Advances in
Manufacturing
Engineering and Materials
Proceedings of the International
Conference on Manufacturing
Engineering and Materials
(ICMEM 2018), 18–22 June, 2018,
Nový Smokovec, Slovakia
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering (LNME) publishes the latest develop-
ments in Mechanical Engineering—quickly, informally and with high quality.
Original research reported in proceedings and post-proceedings represents the core
of LNME. Also considered for publication are monographs, contributed volumes
and lecture notes of exceptionally high quality and interest. Volumes published in
LNME embrace all aspects, subfields and new challenges of mechanical
engineering. Topics in the series include:
• Engineering Design
• Machinery and Machine Elements
• Mechanical Structures and Stress Analysis
• Automotive Engineering
• Engine Technology
• Aerospace Technology and Astronautics
• Nanotechnology and Microengineering
• Control, Robotics, Mechatronics
• MEMS
• Theoretical and Applied Mechanics
• Dynamical Systems, Control
• Fluid Mechanics
• Engineering Thermodynamics, Heat and Mass Transfer
• Manufacturing
• Precision Engineering, Instrumentation, Measurement
• Materials Engineering
• Tribology and Surface Technology
Lucie Ruppenthalová
Editors
Advances in Manufacturing
Engineering and Materials
Proceedings of the International Conference
on Manufacturing Engineering and Materials
(ICMEM 2018), 18–22 June, 2018, Nový
Smokovec, Slovakia
123
Editors
Sergej Hloch Somnath Chattopadhyaya
Faculty of Manufacturing Technologies Indian School of Mines (ISM)
Technical University of Košice with a seat in Indian Institute of Technology
Prešov Dhanbad, Jharkhand, India
Prešov, Slovakia
Lucie Ruppenthalová
Dagmar Klichová Institute of Geonics of the CAS
Institute of Geonics of the CAS Ostrava-Poruba, Czech Republic
Ostrava-Poruba, Czech Republic
Grzegorz M. Krolczyk
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
Opole University of Technology
Opole, Poland
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Preface
It is very delightful for us to write the introduction to this volume of Lecture Notes of
Mechanical Engineering with subtitle “Advances in Manufacturing Engineering and
Materials”. This volume comprises the papers presented during the International
Conference on Manufacturing Engineering and Materials, held from 18 to 22 June
2018, in Nový Smokovec and organised by the Faculty of Manufacturing
Technologies TUKE in Prešov, under the auspices of the Dean of the Faculty
Dr. h. c. Prof. Ing. Jozef Zajac, PhD., in collaboration with the Institute of Geonics
of the CAS in Ostrava-Poruba, under the auspices of its Director Ing. Josef Foldyna,
CSc., Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad,
India, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering at Opole University of Technology,
Mechanical Engineering Faculty in Slavonski Brod under auspices of dean
Prof. Dr. Sc. Ivan Samardzić the TEAM International Society, under the auspices
of the President Prof. dr. sc. Dražan Kozak with the further cooperation of
Baden-Wuerttemberg Cooperative State University and Istanbul Medipol
University.
The conference captures various aspects of progress in the (un)conventional
manufacturing technologies contributing to the increase of competitiveness of
industry with regard to the sustainable development, preservation of the environ-
ment and natural resources. The main spirit of the conference is Your Science=Our
Future. The conference aims at creating synergies of “practice and research”
increasing the potential and commercial viability of research and development in
the field of advanced technologies and materials in industries. The conference was
attended by delegates from 18 countries around the world (Austria, Croatia, Czech
Republic, France, Germany, Great Britain, Greece, India, Italy, Iran, Korea, Poland,
Russia, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain and Turkey). For the motivation of the
researchers, a competition for the best scientific research work in two areas, i.e.
water jet technology and conventional technologies, endowed with €300, €200 and
€100, has been organised during the conference. The competition was financially
supported by two companies from Germany: ANT—Applied New Technologies
and Company Klenk in Balzheim (toolmaker). In addition to the accepted papers,
the following prominent researches from renowned research institutions have been
v
vi Preface
Smooth running of the ICMEM 2018 can be hardly imagined without the
proactive work of Management of Atrium Hotel especially. A big thanks go to
director of the hotel and event manager Mgr. Miška Žembová, the stuff of the hotel.
Big thanks go to Mgr. Ľubica Ferencová, MSc. Daniela Hatalová and MSc. Alena
Mihaľovová from Faculty of Manufacturing Technologies, for their administration
backup and to Dr. Svetlana Radchenko for arranging of Faculty brochures for
participants.
Moreover, I would like to thank, namely to two persons, MSc. Beáta Puobišová
(Scientific Toy) and MSc. Michal Figura (Magical Physics). Many of us understood
how important is science popularisation not only for children. Everybody knows
that currently words such as Mathematics and Physics have become the worst
words ever. If you remember words from keynote address of Prof. Dražan Kozak,
there is direct correlation between economic growth and education within STEM
(science, technology, engineering and mathematics). I think MSc. Beáta Puobišová
and MSc. Michal Figura remind us how curiosity in the students can be awakened
and how important it is. This part was finacially supported by Technická diag-
nostika, s.r.o in Prešov. Thanks also belong to Ing. Eugen Knotek, PhD., from
Vysoke Tatry town for his opening speech.
Sergej Hloch
Contents
Invited Papers
Study Programs in STEM Field in Eastern European
Countries vs. Brain Drain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Dražan Kozak
Manufacturing in Times of Digital Business and Industry 4.0 -
The Industrial Internet of Things Not Only Changes the World
of Manufacturing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
Jan M. Olaf and Eckhart Hanser
A New Method for Gear Chamfering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Manfred Schlatter and Niklas Müller
ix
x Contents
Materials
Increasing Compressor Wheel Fatigue Life Through Residual
Stress Generation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375
Simon M. Barrans, Andrew Thompson, and John Allport
Contents xiii
Dražan Kozak(&)
1 Introduction
1.1 Why Is STEM Important?
STEM stands for Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics and refers to any
subject that refers to these four disciplines. Sometimes, this abbreviation is extended by
A, standing for Arts and design, to form STEAM, which refers to the following
characteristics: creativity, collaboration, critical thinking, and communication. Nowa-
days, governments and universities around the world prioritize enrollment of students
to STEM studies, in order to address this shortfall. In some cases, it is also easier for
STEM graduates to immigrate to another country and to look for a job in that field [1].
Over the last decade, this situation has become usual in the Eastern European countries,
as they are less developed than Western Europe countries. Special attention has been
paid to encourage more female students to choose a STEM degree. This is why
decision makers introduced policies aimed at increasing the proportion of women
choosing to study in these areas. Out of 12% of women in bachelor programs who get a
STEM degree each year, only 3% of them find job in the STEM field [1].
There is constant increase in numbers of STEM graduates in the EU countries.
Nowadays, their share is about 23%, with the largest records in Austria, Sweden,
Germany and Finland. Similar situation is in the United States and Japan (22%).
According to the PISA tests (Program for International Student Assessment), almost
every fifth scholar in the EU still has no adequate knowledge from these basic fields
(18%), while this is less present in Korea (7%) or in Japan (8%). In the period from
2003 to 2013, total growth of employees who graduated in some STEM subject
increased for even 12% in the EU (1.8 million of people), while the total growth of
employees was bigger for only 4%. However, there is the issue of relatively small
number of jobs (only 7% of total amount). The percentage of unemployed STEM
graduates is less than 5%. There is continuous lack of engineers on the labor market, so
80% of companies indicate that hiring the right engineers will be either highly or very
crucial for the future success of their business [2] (Fig. 1).
It is evident that there is a great demand at the labor market for graduates in STEM
field. Therefore, it makes sense to increase the number of students who enroll the
STEM study programs. However, if tuition fees are covered by government, as it is the
case in Croatia, and if the graduates have no obligations towards the home country after
graduation, this approach becomes questionable. If so, unconditional studying for free
enables the graduates to search for a job position in another more developed country
without any obligation to the government. By losing the best engineers, mathemati-
cians, physicists and other qualified graduates, these already less developed countries
become poorer and this causes further economic inequality between countries. This is
even more emphasized if a country is not ensuring sufficient funds for the research and
development (R&D), and if there is not enough researchers.
Fig. 3. Researchers per million inhabitants vs. R&D expenditure as % of GDP [4].
6 D. Kozak
In 2016, the gross domestic product (GDP) of the European Union (EU) amounted
to € 14.800 billion (bn) at current prices. Over half of it was generated by three EU
member states: Germany, the United Kingdom and France [5]. With a GDP worth €
3.100 bn in 2016, Germany was the leading EU economy, accounting for over a fifth
(21.1%) of EU GDP. It was followed by the United Kingdom (16.0%), France (15.0%),
Italy (11.3%), Spain (7.5%) and the Netherlands (4.7%).
At the opposite end of the scale, eleven EU member states had a GDP of less than
1% of the EU total. These countries were Malta, Cyprus, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania,
Slovenia, Croatia, Bulgaria, Luxembourg, Slovakia and Hungary (Fig. 4).
As presented in the Fig. 4, Croatia and Slovenia have practically similar portion in
GDP of EU28, but Slovenia has only about half of the population of Croatia. With
almost 3 times higher relative number of researchers and investment to R&D than
Croatia, Slovenian government sets the goals to promote high-tech industry and to
become a modern society. It sounds attractive also for the graduates from other
countries to find a job in Slovenia. There is a clear dependence of the present GDP
growth and R&D investment in the previous period, as presented in the Fig. 5. One can
expect direct correlation of the economic recovery and investment to R&D.
Study Programs in STEM Field in Eastern European Countries vs. Brain Drain 7
Fig. 6. Doctors of science (PhDs) by county of permanent residency that graduated in 2000–
2012 at Croatian universities [6].
Fig. 7. Gross domestic product per capita in Croatian counties in 2015 [7].
many students than in the technical sciences (20%), and six times more than the
percentage of students in biomedicine and health (8%). The percentages of students in
natural and biotechnical sciences are similar (4% and 5%, respectively), but the total
number of students in these two scientific areas does not exceed 10%.
Study Programs in STEM Field in Eastern European Countries vs. Brain Drain 9
Fig. 8. Percentage of students in different scientific areas in Croatia in the academic year
2015/2016 [8].
3 Conclusions
The paper presents some correlations between the investments into R&D and the
number of researchers/doctors of science/graduates, especially in STEM field, and their
influence on the GDP growth. These correlations have been elaborated on the example
of Croatia as an Eastern European country. There is a constant increase in number of
young STEM graduates who seek employment abroad, still the Croatian government is
not offering solution to such occurrences. This presents the threat to the economic
stability of the country, as its competitiveness decreases. As the industry lacks the work
force, it needs to attract workers from countries that are less developed than Croatia.
There is a crucial question of tuition-free studying in Croatia and of increasing of quota
in STEM field, thus increasing the number of STEM graduates without any obligation
to the government after their studies. Another issue is referring to what kind of
10 D. Kozak
measures should be undertaken by the Croatian government to make the job positions
more attractive not just for domestic graduates, but also for foreigners.
References
1. https://www.topuniversities.com/courses/engineering/what-stem. Accessed 24 May 2018
2. Close the Engineering Skills Gap, © Tech-Clarity, Inc. (2017)
3. Blog of The State University of New York. https://blog.suny.edu/2014/04/new-york-
schoolkids-urged-to-focus-on-high-growth-career-tracks/. Accessed 23 May 2018
4. http://uis.unesco.org/apps/visualisations/research-and-development-spending. Accessed 23
May 2018
5. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/documents. Accessed 23 May 2018
6. Croatian Bureau of Statistics. www.dzs.hr. Accessed 21 May 2018
7. Croatian Bureau of Statistics. https://www.dzs.hr/Hrv_Eng/publication/2018/12-01-03_01_
2018.htm. Accessed 18 May 2018
8. https://www.azvo.hr/images/stories/publikacije/Analysis_of_the_five-year_cycle_of_re-accre
ditation_of_HEIs.pdf. Accessed 26 May 2018
Manufacturing in Times of Digital Business
and Industry 4.0 - The Industrial Internet
of Things Not Only Changes the World
of Manufacturing
Abstract. Digital business and Industry 4.0 have already significantly changed
the world of manufacturing. Data related to the machines as well as process data
from the manufacturing lines serve to install powerful applications and services
within the entire manufacturing ecosystem. The article provides an overview on
several methods used in the manufacturing with respect to process efficiency and
reliability as well as quality management. Methods used today often have been
designed many years ago but due to increasing computer power and IT capa-
bilities at reasonable costs they evolve as success factor in digital business.
1 Introduction
Since its first appearance less than ten years ago the digital transformation has evolved
into a driver regarding both, business and private life. It has become a major buzzword
and a hype which itself was driven by technology and technical improvements in
computerization, increasing processor capabilities and network capacities at decreasing
prices at the same time. Thus, methods even well-known from the past have experi-
enced a revival on the base of these new technical capabilities. They are coming along
with new methods being developed in the context of digital business.
The German term “Industry 4.0” invented some seven years ago characterizes the
fourth industrial revolution [1, 2] and in the meantime it is recognized worldwide as
a synonym of industrial internet of things (IIoT).
Industry 4.0 in a literal sense focuses the industry’s digital transformation, however,
it is widely used outside industry as well. Regarding manufacturing the industrial
internet of things covers the overall manufacturing ecosystem (Fig. 1) including
external partners like suppliers, service providers and customers as well as processes
such as procurement, logistics and intralogistics, industrial engineering, quality man-
agement and assets services and maintenance etc.
Even the product itself becomes part of the manufacturing ecosystem since its
intelligence – either intrinsic by integrated processors or extrinsic e.g. by intelligent
workpiece carriers – enables the product to communicate with the production line thus
upscaling the product to a “smart product”.
2.2 Manufacturing
When investigating IoT solutions in manufacturing the first ideas that come to mind are
those of increasing process efficiency, agility and flexibility. “Lot-size 1 by methods of
mass production” is the embodiment for industry 4.0 [7]. It leads to agility and flex-
ibility in production to be prepared to react promptly to customer’s demands. However,
it induces a highly intelligent and automated manufacturing processes with minimized
manual work and tooling times. Nowadays this can be compared to the crowning of the
smart factory initiatives as described in detail by Soder [8]. Obviously, it cannot be
substitute to it but the prosecution and it will only deliver best output if it is applied to
lean production processes. First of all muda has to be eliminated from the process
before intelligent automation and IoT methods and tools are introduced. Usually, cyber
physical production systems (CPPS) serve to integrate both, physical processes in
combination with computational intelligence and networking capabilities (CPS) on the
one hand side and manufacturing science and technology on the other. Together with
comprehensive process and system data these CPPS set up the digital twin of the
system, production line, or plant. Digital twins serve to simulate processes, systems’
operation, or e.g. the cooperation of humans and machines.
However, setting up of industry 4.0 environments in existing plants may raise
unexpected problems, e.g. when the existing machines are not suitable for integration
and can only be upgraded in the operation context, i.e. the overall control and operating
system including its programming framework has to be upgraded [9]. Larger amounts
of effort and money must be invested in these cases.
Within a smart factory there are many more examples for smart applications
helping to increase plant availability and uptime. When moving parts or goods within
the production line conveyor belts are most widely used with clamps for fixing the parts
safely. A reliable clamp operation therefore is obligatory for process safety as well as
safety at work. The lock and release times of these clamps can be used to predict clamp
failure due to contamination [17]. This example shows, that a single IoT application not
Manufacturing in Times of Digital Business and Industry 4.0 15
As mentioned earlier the product itself will become part of the digital transformation
and its manufacturing ecosystem. It is expected that in future the product will control
the production process autonomously [18]. In addition the product will carry a lot of
digital information regarding manufacturing process and history, quality and certifi-
cation, material and properties, etc. If the product does not have any internal data
storage the information is stored outside the product body, e.g. in the cloud with a
unique identifier (e.g. IP address, QR code, RFID) as a reference.
Many decades before the IIoT has been postulated to be the fourth industrial
revolution, material properties as well as material models have been investigated in
order to simulate manufacturing processes. Kraft et al. simulated the die pressing and
sintering of ceramics to optimize the die by means of finite element (FE) analysis [19].
The author of this article himself used combined experiments and FE simulations to
determine material properties [20, 21]. As in-process methods combined with IoT
sensor signals the FEM analysis will increase the model’s accuracy significantly.
However, even todays commercial computers are not powerful enough, to deliver
results within acceptable response times.
4 Requirements
The industrial internet of things not only changes the world of manufacturing. Tech-
nical prospects on the one hand side and technical contraints on the other are defining
the requirements of the manufacturing ecosystem. Since smart devices and cyber
physical (production) systems are available from multiple suppliers, it becomes obvi-
ous, that a common integration space is required for setting up the communication
within the system. And it needs data: meta data from the machines in the production
line, oftenly already generated when the machine itself is developed and produced
(machine lifecycle data), and data from the production process (field data). This for sure
includes a common semantics of information and data collected from the field. Fur-
thermore the data acquisition has to be absolutely robust and reliable in the industrial
environment. However, solely collecting data must not be the goal of the overall effort.
The data have to be analyzed by appropriate means in order to enable further actions in
the system. This sometimes requires local processing power, e.g. by edge computing,
and decentralized data storage capacities, e.g. in the cloud. When analyzing field data
for process monitoring and predictive maintenance thresholds need to be defined.
These can either be calculated analytically or by model assumtions an iterative solu-
tions or by recording reference values from the field. The latter represents the “expert’s
experience” and is mostly used in the field.
In addition to integrating and interfacing systems and machines the ecosystems is
extended to business partners like suppliers and customers. Therefore several more
16 J. M. Olaf and E. Hanser
interfaces have to be set up, further increasing the complexity of the manufacturing
ecosystem. Inevitably this leads to the demand for a platform approach with interfaces
to business partners, machines and systems, and software and applications (Fig. 3).
Of course, availability and all aspects of cyber security are of utmost importance for
a reliable manufacturing framework in industry 4.0. The progress in this area is
encouraging, however, the security issue will never be solved a full 100%.
The business transformation driven by the internet of things and services already has
a deep impact on the manufacturing processes. Manufacturing like many other
industrial disciplines is continuously growing together with information technology
with many chances and opportunities but with restrictions and consequences as well.
If data collected from both, the machinery and the field level is significant and
reliable it enables analyses and measures to improve process quality and efficiency in
production. Nevertheless, the chances arising have not been completely implemented
up to now. Even in spite of the awesome progress in computer technology some areas
still lack technical capabilities. Here artificial intelligence and quantum computing will
provide future enhancement.
Manufacturing in Times of Digital Business and Industry 4.0 17
References
1. acatech: Umsetzungsempfehlungen für das Zukunftsprojekt Industrie 4.0 – Abschlussbericht
des Arbeitskreises Industrie 4.0, Frankfurt (2013)
2. BITKOM: Industrie 4.0 – Volkswirtschaftliches Potenzial für Deutschland, Berlin (2014)
3. Homrich, R.: Driverless transport service for assembly. In: T-Systems, Best Practice, January
2018, pp. 23–25. Köln (2018)
4. SEW Schaufensterfabrik Homepage. https://www.sew-eurodrive.de/unternehmen/ihr_erfolg/
zukunftsthemen/industrie-40/basics/schaufensterfabrik/schaufensterfabrik.html. Accessed 30
Apr 2018
5. Schlüsselfertige Lernfabrik für Industrie 4.0. In: SPS-MAGAZIN, October 2017, TeDo
Verlag GmbH, Marburg (2017)
6. Across-AR Homepage. http://across-ar.de/home/augemented-reality-service/. Accessed 30
Apr 2018
7. Bauernhansl, T., ten Hompel, M., Vogel-Heuser, B.: Industrie 4.0 in Produktion,
Automatisierung und Logistik. Springer Verlag, Wiesbaden (2014)
8. Soder, J., Vogel-Heuser, B., Bauernhansl, T., ten Hompel, M.: Handbuch Industrie 4.0 Band
1 Produktion, pp. 3–26. Springer Verlag, Wiesbaden (2017)
9. Käuflin, P., Reeb, P.: Programmierung ABB Industrieroboter, Semesterarbeit, DHBW
Lörrach (2017)
10. Foster, I., Kesselman, C.: The Grid 2: Blueprint for a New Computing Infrastructure.
Morgan Kaufmann/Elsevier (2003)
11. Pude, F., Roser, A.: Online-Monitoring für verteilt arbeitende 3D-Drucker, Projektbeschrei-
bung (2016)
12. Eberl, S., Huse, T., Meier, M., Dienert, J., Wellinger, T., Olaf, J.: Verteilte Fertigung 1-3;
Semesterarbeiten, DHBW Lörrach (2017–2018)
13. Roser, A.: Fabb-It UG – 3D Druckservice, personal note, Lörrach (2017)
14. Iwata, K., Moriwaki, T.: An application of acoustic emission measurement to in-process
sensing of tool wear. Ann. CIRP 25, 21–26 (1977)
15. Scheer, C.: Überwachung des Zerspanprozesses mit geometrisch bestimmter Schneide durch
Schallemissionsmessung, Diss. Nr. 13462, ETH Zürich (2000)
16. IFM: From vibration monitoring to Industry 4.0, company/product information, Essen
(2017)
17. Langenecker, S.: Entwicklung eines Systems zur Erfassung von Daten einer S7 Steuerung
und anschließender Einbindung dieser Daten in eine Cloud Applikation, Master thesis,
DHBW CAS, Mosbach (2018)
18. Breyer-Mayländer, T.: Management 4.0 – Den digitalen Wandel erfolgreich meistern. Carl
Hanser Verlag, München (2017)
19. Kraft, T., Riedel, H., Stingl, P., Wittig, F.: Finite element simulation of die pressing and
sintering. Adv. Eng. Mat. 1(2), 107–109 (1999)
20. Olaf, J.M., Sester, M., Hönig, A., L’Huillier, P.: Finite element analysis of indentation
experiments using viscoelastic material models. Comput. Mater. Sci. 3, 218–222 (1994)
21. Olaf, J.M., Sommer, E.: Finite element analysis of indentation experiments in surface coated
materials. Exp. Mech. 33(3), 201–204 (1993)
A New Method for Gear Chamfering
Abstract. In order to chamfer the teeth of a gear wheel there are three
important methods in the market: “Chamfer Cut”, roll chamfering and “Grato-
mat”. All of them have advantages but are not suitable in all situations. For such
difficult chamfering operations and especially for smaller series a new method
for accurate chamfers was created. The process is based on the geometry of the
gear tooth and is simulated by mathematical calculations and therefore a special
milling tool has to be manufactured for each individual gear wheel. With this
tool is it possible to chamfer the teeth with very high quality in a short time and
under economical conditions.
The typical symbol of mechanical engineering for hundreds of years is a gear which is
used for moving machines or vehicles or in general that technical devices work. Gears
are manufactured by casting, forging, fine blanking or by cutting technologies like
hobbing, shaping or broaching. The cutting technologies are mostly used with precision
gears where heavy forces are to be transmitted or in cases where the gearboxes have to
be very silent.
Unfortunately these cutting technologies produce more or less big burrs (see Fig. 1)
or at least sharp edges which can induce that the gear are unusable. When such gears
are forward manufactured by hardening or have to be assembled in a gearbox, they can
produce the following problems:
• Handling can hurt the workers
• Damaging while transporting the gears
• Too much carbonizing at the edges can induce chipping
• The faces of the gears were used as contact surface or as clamping area for fol-
lowing processes like smooth finishing of the hardened gear
• The lifetime of following tools like grinding wheels or honing tools will be
shortened
• Problems while assembling the gear, especially when the assembling is automated
• Higher noise with damaged flanks of the teeth
• Residues of the burr can damage a gearbox because of abrasion.
For this reason all gears which have been made with cutting tools will be deburred
but with most of the deburring operations a sharp edge is left and for a lot of
Fig. 1. Gear made with hobbing and with big burrs at the exit side of the cutting tool (on the
left) and the cross section of a flash from this gear wheel (on the right).
applications this is not a satisfying quality. Sometimes the removal of a big burr with
brushes or with similar technologies seems to be easy but there will be a residue of the
burr on his base and this can lead to problems while the gear wheel is in use.
If the required edge quality is not very high, then one of the more simply methods of
deburring is adequate. Besides of undirected methods like electrochemical machining
or thermal energy machining it exist the methods of deburring or filing wheels (see
Fig. 2). They are able to remove a burr or a flash but they leave more or less sharp
edges of the teeth.
Fig. 2. Deburring wheels on the left and filing wheels on the right [1, 2].
For the good quality of the edges chamfering is the best known technology which
can produce a defined chamfer of about 45°. Chamfering makes sure that all residues of
20 M. Schlatter and N. Müller
a burr are removed and e.g. the assembling of the wheels in a gearbox can be done
without damaging the flanks of the counter wheel.
There are at least three technologies on the market which are able to chamfer gear
wheels. One of them is “Fette Chamfer Cut” (see Fig. 3).
This technology is fast and produces a good chamfer quality but the tools are very
expensive and they cannot work at all possible positions of the burrs of a gear wheel
but only when the flanks of the wheel are easy to reach (see Fig. 4).
Fig. 4. Typical position of chamfering tools (circles marked with “d” and “h”) [3].
A New Method for Gear Chamfering 21
A second technology for gear chamfering is called roll chamfering. With this
forming technology a chamfer can be produced but the material is not removed but
rather pushed from the edge right into the tooth as a kind of strain hardening as result
(see Fig. 5). In the following process of real hardening the edge could break out.
At least a technology called “Gratomat” is also known. This device works with a
milling tool and this follows the outline of the edges of the teeth (see Fig. 6). The
quality of the chamfers depend very highly on the worker and his adjustment of the
device or on the wear of the milling tool.
Fig. 7. Calculation and simulation of the shape of the teeth of the gear wheel (left) and the space
between the teeth with the shape of the chamfer behind the original surfaces (right).
After that the processing can start and the gear wheel is chamfered in a few
seconds. This can be done with very easy to process gear wheels like in Fig. 1 (on the
left), Fig. 7 and below in Fig. 8 on the left as well as very small bevel pinions in Fig. 8
on the right.
Fig. 8. Situation of the chamfering process on two different gear wheels with the steps of the
processing below in red rectangular areas.
A New Method for Gear Chamfering 23
The following figures (Fig. 9) show the situation of processing the two gear wheels
from Fig. 8 with the chamfering tool and the synchronization sensors.
Fig. 9. Processing situation of the two gear wheels shown in a CNC lathe. The chamfering tool
is mounted in the tool holder above the gear wheels and the inductive sensor for the
synchronization is mounted below the gear wheels.
Figure 10 shows the planet wheel bevor and after chamfering and the size of the
chamfer could be adjusted for the different requirements of the later usage.
Fig. 10. The planet gear wheel bevor and after chamfering with the new method.
This processing was done within less than 25 s on a machine which is not opti-
mized for this process because the special machine for this type of chamfering is under
construction.
Also the very small bevel pinions can be chamfered sufficiently (Fig. 11) and the
process produces only a very small secondary burr which wears off during the hard-
ening in a later step.
24 M. Schlatter and N. Müller
Fig. 11. The bevel pinion bevor and after chamfering with the new method. On the right
a enlargement of the face of the bevel pinion can be seen (outer diameter on the top 8 mm).
The advantages of the new chamfering method are not only the short time and the
god chamfer quality but also a lower price for the tools made of toll-steel or of tungsten
carbide and the possibility for including the process in a gear wheel manufacturing
machine or as a stand-alone unit (see Fig. 12) which is very easy to automate.
The machine is planned for an area consumption of 2 m2 with a fast and a strong
power unit and gear wheels with a diameter up to 350 mm or transmission shafts with a
length up to 350 mm can be processed. The gear wheel holders as well as the tool
holders are usual in the market. The machine could be also equipped with an automated
gear wheel feed and with an automated tool change device.
A New Method for Gear Chamfering 25
This method can be used very economically for smaller series of gear wheels up to
1,5 million pieces (see Fig. 13) and for gear wheels in difficult to process situations (see
Fig. 14).
Fig. 13. Relation of costs of the new method “Radial Chamfering” in comparison with “Press
Deburring” and “Chamfer Cut”.
Fig. 14. Difficult to chamfering gear wheels, especially in the space between the single wheel
parts; on the left with an outer diameter of 28 mm and on the right of 23 mm.
4 Conclusions
In the field of mass production of technical parts like gear wheels a new method can be
found in order to finish them with high quality in a very short time and with low costs
by simulating the process and calculate the shape of the tool. The machine to work with
is under construction and will be on the market in 2019.
26 M. Schlatter and N. Müller
Acknowledgments. This research project was supported by the German Ministry of Economics
and Technology with the program ZIM (Zentrales Innovationsprogramm Mittelstand = central
innovation program for medium-sized business).
References
1. NN: EMAG-News 24. Leaflet of the EMAG GmbH & Co. KG, Austraße 24, D-73084 Salach,
August 2015. www.emag.com
2. NN: Leaflet of the Rausch GmbH & Co. KG, Alleestraße 46, D-42781 Haan. www.gratomat-
rausch.de
3. Homepage of the Online-magazine, 10 May 2010. http://www.Zerspanungstechnik.de.
Accessed 22 Feb 2018
4. NN: Leaflet of the Fette GmbH, Grabauer Str. 24, D-21493 Schwarzenbek. www.fette.com
5. http://www.emag.com/de/technologien/drueckentgraten.html. Accessed 26 Feb 2018
Water Jet Technology Session
New Approach of Recycling of Abrasives
for Water Jet Cutting
1 Introduction
Competitive AWJ cutting means low costs per hour or cutting length. In Europe, the
average AWJ cutting cost per hour is relatively high and is in the range from 150 to 200
(€/h), what makes difficulties on achieving competitiveness of the AWJ process.
Challenge for this technology is to reduce the costs remaining the fast speed and
acceptable cut quality. Abrasive used in process is weared in red and yellow zone
(Fig. 1) while in green zone it just flows through. It means that only 30–50% of
abrasive is really used (in one cycle) [1]. It also depends on thickness of cutted
material, thinner cutted material causes lower amount of abrasives wear. In this paper is
described recycling of Barton Garnet because Barton Garnet is mostly used abrasives
for AWJ cutting.
The components of cutting costs in AWJ process include machine tool cost,
abrasive cost, nozzle wear cost, wages including overhead cost and so on. In the AWJ
cutting cost, the abrasive cost (including disposal cost) is usually the largest component
(Fig. 2). This cost share can reach from 20% up to 70% of the total cutting cost,
depending on parameters such as the abrasive mass flow rate, the number of cutting
heads, the abrasive price, the AWJ system’s cost and so on. Since there is a need for
recycling abrasive due to cutting costs in WJ machining, influences of Barton garnet
and recycled abrasive on surface roughness were investigated and compared.
However, the abrasives after cutting can be reused, which can reduce the abrasive
cost and the disposal cost [2].
Conditions of recycling of GMA garnet, the most popular abrasives for blast
cleaning and waterjet cutting, has not been understood satisfactory. It is evident that the
recycling of abrasives can be a good way to reduce the total cutting costs. To find an
effective way for the abrasive recycling, the optimum particle size of recycled and
recharged abrasives for the maximum cutting performance as well as for the minimum
cutting cost should be determined. In addition, the economics of cutting with recycled
and recharged abrasives must be investigated [4].
In practice recycled abrasives can be used for AWJ cutting individually as a new
abrasive or used as addition to new abrasives. The process of addition of the new to the
recycled abrasives is called abrasive recharging. The recharging ensures continuous
addition new abrasives to maintain the maximum cutting performance constantly [2].
New Approach of Recycling of Abrasives for Water Jet Cutting 31
The reduction of abrasive cost as a main cost component in AWJ cutting (Fig. 2)
can be achieved with increasing water pressure (Hashish refers that 33% decreasing of
abrasive costs is possible when water pressure is increased from 4000 to 6000 bar).
Other solution is abrasive recycling. Recycled abrasive can be used for two main
applications: reconditioned - recycled for subsequent use for cutting/blast cleaning or
simple use as a row material for concrete. Therefore, AWJ abrasive recycling has been
the objectives of many studies.
The loss of cutting ability of abrasive particles (because of disintegration of
abrasives by breaking or fragmentation) in the AWJ cutting process occurs in two
stages:
1. during the mixing process (due to interactions between abrasives and the compo-
nents of equipment for focusing and mixing with water and between particles with
each other);
2. during the cutting process (because of the interactions between particles with the
work material and particles and each other). Therefore, understanding of the frag-
mentation of abrasive particles is highly relevant to a study on abrasive recycling.
The fragmentation of abrasive particles have been investigated in many studies,
however, the optimum abrasive size for recycled abrasives and for recharged
abrasives has not been refered.
Ohlsen [6] reported that particles smaller than 60 µm lead to a very small depth of
cut, poor cutting quality and can cause abrasive clogging in the mixing head. More-
over, the author found that the cutting performance and the cutting quality of the
recycled abrasives is acceptable while particle size distribution lies in the range from
125 to 180 µm. This range of the particle size can lead to the maximum depth of cut
and a lower surface roughness.
Kantha and Krishnaiah Chetty [7] found that the reusability of a local garnet from
Southern India (or the recycling capability which is determined by the percentage of
abrasives that can be reused) with the particles larger than 90 µm is 81, 49, 26 and 15%
after the first, second, third and fourth recycling, respectively. The authors [7] inves-
tigated effect of recycled abrasives of three cycles on the depth of cut, on the surface
roughness and on the kerf width. It was observed that the maximum depth of cut of the
first and second recycled abrasives is approximately 82 and 79% of the new abrasives.
Also, cutting with the first and the second recycled abrasives can reduce both the
surface roughness and the kerf cone.
The influence of the recharging on the depth of cut, on the surface roughness, and
on the kerf width for cutting with aluminum was investigated by Kantha and Krish-
naiah Chetty [8]. The authors found that an increase of the added new abrasives up to
40% led to a significant increase of the depth of cut and a slight increase thereafter.
Less than 5% of waterjet users might be at risk of putting hazardous waste down their
drain, it is worthwhile to verify that you are in the 95% group. Waste after AWJ cutting
(sludge) – Fig. 3 is composed of by-products collected at wastewater treatment process.
32 M. Duspara et al.
Fig. 3. (a) Sludge after AWJ cutting, (b) Microscope view of sludge 200X.
Once treated, sludge can be recycled or disposed of using three main routes:
recycling to agriculture (landspreading), incineration or landfilling. Other, less devel-
oped outlets exist, such as silviculture, land reclamation, and other developing com-
bustion technologies including wet oxidation, pyrolysis and gasification. Each
recycling or disposal route has specific inputs, outputs and impacts.
3 Recycling System
The idea of the recycling machine itself came from the final work and was based on the
principle that the used abrasive grain broke, burnt and with that knowledge they are
lighter than grains that were not used in the cutting process. The idea was to twist the
sludge while still in the water in the pot. The centrifugal force will lift all the used
abrasive, since the used abrasive is lighter it will be in the upper rotation zone. They
will spill out and exit from the pot, while remaining unused abrasive will remain on the
bottom (the procedure can be repeated several times) until all impurities are cleaned.
Shown on the Fig. 4.
The impurities are removed by overflowing. The container is tilted at a slight angle,
and the filling with water is poured over the edge. In order to accelerate the process,
a pour is used, which simultaneously involves a greater amount of water and impu-
rities, while the usable abrasive remains deposited at the bottom. The procedure is
repeated until relatively pure water is obtained. After separation used from unused
abrasives particles, the wet abrasives must be dried (Fig. 5).
New Approach of Recycling of Abrasives for Water Jet Cutting 33
After drying the recycled abrasive, a microscopic analysis was performed to see the
effect of this abrasive recycling process. Figure 6a shows a new unused abrasive, while
Fig. 6b is recycled abrasive. The abrasive particles after recycling are smaller in size,
some between MESH 80 and MESH 120. If a comparison of Figs. 3b and 6b is made,
there is no tiny white particle (recycled abrasive) after recycling and we can conclude
that the recycling process is successful. In preliminary testing system was shows
60–70% of success. That means that from 100 kg of sludge was got some between
60–70 kg new abrasives.
Recycling system was continue developed in company STM Stein-Moser GmbH in
Austria, company which produce machine for water jet cutting and accesories for
machine (water filtration, abrasive recycling machine…..) and made patent application,
on this way recycling of abrasive.
34 M. Duspara et al.
Fig. 6. (a) New abrasive Barton garnet MESH 80, (b) Recycled abrasive.
4 Conclusion
In Croatia there are about 20 cutting machines with abrasive water jets. The data of the
Konid process on the average monthly consumption of 1.5 tons of abrasive was used,
with 120 h of machine operation per month and the price of an abrasive of 350 € per
ton. Therefore, the smallest amount of used abrasive in RH is about 360 t, from which
this procedure can be obtained about 270 t of reusable abrasive.
In the Republic of Croatia there is no facility specialized for the recycling of such
types of waste therefore uncontrolled disposal of the abrasive used, and consequently
the remains of the cut material is a serious environmental problem. From the economic
New Approach of Recycling of Abrasives for Water Jet Cutting 35
side, the abrasive represents about 51% of the total cost of cutting, while electricity
consumes about 46% of the cost, and the water is 2–3%. Using recycled abrasives,
electricity would account for about 77% of the cost, while the cost of the abrasive
would equalize with the cost of water of about 11%. A total of 44% savings are made
using of recycled abrasives.
References
1. The fabricator; Reusing Waterjet Cutting Abrasive. https://www.thefabricator.com/article/
waterjetcutting/reusing-waterjet-cutting-abrasive. Accessed 08 May 2018
2. Stoić, A., Palatinuš, T., Duspara, M., Stoić, M., Marić, M.: Application of recycled abrasives
for AWJ cutting. In: CIM Conference, pp. 213–219. Faculty of Mechanical Engineering and
NavalArchitecture, Šibenik (2015)
3. Final thesis Tomislav Palatinuš, Mechanical Engineering Faculty in Slavonski Brod (2014)
4. Hloch, S., Valiček, J., Stoić, A., Kozak, D., Samardžić, I., Novak Marcinčin, J., Modrak, V.:
Rezanje mlazom vode, Strojarski fakultet u Slavonskom Brodu Sveučilišta J.J. Strossmayera
u Osijeku (2011)
5. Stoić, A., Palatinuš, T., Kosec, B., Duspara, M., Stoić, M.: The effects of life cycle
management of abrasives on sustainable WJ cutting. In: Proceedings of 6th International
Scientific and Expert Conference Technique, Education, Agriculture & Management, TEAM
2014, Kecskemet (2014)
6. Ohlsen, J.: Recycling von Feststoffen beim Wasserabrasivestrahlverfahren, VDI Fortschritt-
Berichte, Reihe 15, Nr. 175 (1997)
7. Kantha, B.M., Krishnaiah Chetty, O.V.: A study on recycling of abrasives in abrasive water
jet machining. Wear 254, 763–773 (2003)
8. Kantha, B.M., Krishnaiah Chetty, O.V.: Studies on recharging of abrasives in abrasive water
jet machining. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 19, 697–703 (2002)
The Use of Areal Parameters for the Analysis
of the Surface Machined Using the Abrasive
Waterjet Technology
Abstract. The paper deals with areal evaluation of the surface texture of
AISI 304 material created by the abrasive waterjet. The sample examined was
measured using an optical profilometer and an optical microscope. The surface
topography is most frequently evaluated according to the surface profile
parameters defined in ISO 4287. However, for a more complex analysis of
a studied surface, it is more advantageous to use an areal (three-dimensional)
method which applies the knowledge acquired from the profile (two-
dimensional) method extended by new research findings. The areal parameters
of the surface texture are described in the standard ISO 25178-2.
1 Introduction
gives us insufficient information about the character of the entire surface. In contrast,
the spatial evaluation of the surface texture gives us a number of new parameters that
more accurately quantify the studied surface and characterize the surface’s functional
properties. For this reason, comparisons were made of the profile and surface param-
eters in order to obtain a new view on the subject.
The paper describes the profile method of surface quality evaluation of the cutting
wall of the studied sample. In addition, the article focuses on areal analysis that
represents significant qualitative progress in the surface texture evaluation. Results of
values of profile and areal parameters obtained from the surface of the experimentally
created sample from AISI 304 material are presented.
2 Standardised Parameters
The following section will focus on standardized profile and areal parameters. In the
engineering practice, profile parameters of the profile roughness (so-called 2D
parameters) are used for the evaluation of the surface quality. Selected representatives
of the height parameters Ra, Rq, Rp, Rv and Rz are further defined in the standard ISO
4287 [6]. The development of measurement techniques has brought new possibilities in
the evaluation of surfaces, i.e. 3D parameters. Definitions of individual areal param-
eters are presented in the standard ISO 25178-2 [7]. The so-called S-parameters are the
height parameters Sa, Sq, Sp, Sv and Sz which are determined according to the specified
area.
3 Experimental Setting
The quality and topography of the cutting surface were assessed on a test sample from
the AISI 304 material measuring 50 mm 20 mm 5 mm.
Equipment for abrasive waterjet cutting available at the Institute of Geonics of the
CAS, v.v.i. was used as the testing assembly. It consisted of the PTV 75–60 high
pressure pump (2 multiplicators, max. operating pressure of 415 MPa, max. flow rate
of 7.8 l min−1, power of 67 kW) and the X-Y cutting table PTV WJ2020-1Z-D (op-
erating area of 2000 2000 mm, cutting speed continuously adjustable in the range of
0–20 m min−1) The commercially available Australian garnet with MESH 80 was used
as an abrasive material [8]. The water pressure was set at 400 MPa and the standard
cutting head for the abrasive waterjet generation (PTV 301022-X) with a diamond
water nozzle of the diameter of 0.33 mm was used. The diameter of the focusing tube
was 1.02 mm, length of the focusing tube 76 mm, stand-off distance of the focusing
tube orifice from the surface of the cut sample 4 mm. The traverse speed was set at
30 mm min−1.
Topography of the surface created by the abrasive waterjet technology was pre-
cisely studied by means of an optical profilometer MicroProf FRT and an optical
microscope Alicona InfiniteFocus. The obtained data were further analysed with the
SPIP software according to the standards ISO 4287 [6] and ISO 25178-2 [7].
4 Methodology of Measurement
From the measured lines of the length of 15 mm, roughness profiles were obtained
after filtering irregularities and waviness of the surface. Subsequently, height roughness
parameters were calculated at the cut-off distance of 2.5 mm according to the standard
ISO 4287 [6]. The selected height parameters of the surface texture Ra, Rq, Rp, Rv and
Rz are given in Table 1. The acquired profile roughness parameters quantify the surface
texture of the cutting sample wall.
The evaluation of surface quality using 2D parameters is a commonly used engi-
neering practice. However, 3D surface analysis is currently also available. Areal
measurement of the surface structure provides a more objective presentation of a
surface to be controlled, since the individual spatial parameters of the texture are
determined from a higher quantity of measured data.
Spatial measurement of the surface texture of the sample cutting wall was per-
formed by the Alicona optical profilometer. Three measuring areas (1 - upper section of
the cut, 2 - center of the cut, 3 - lower section of the cut) were selected, see Fig. 2.
Height parameters of the surface texture Sa, Sq, Sp, Sv and Sz, which are presented in
Table 2, were determined from measured areas of 3 mm 3 mm according to the
standard ISO 25178-2 [7].
40 D. Klichová et al.
It is well-known (e.g. Hashish 1984) that the kinetic energy of the jet decreases with the
increasing depth h of the cut, thereby increasing the surface roughnesses, i.e. increasing
their height amplitudes, while reducing their spatial frequencies. This is due to the
change in the material removal mechanism, from the predominant tensile and shear
stress to the compressive stress.
Values of the selected height parameters of a roughness profile are listed in Table 1
Deformation stress (strain) is high at the beginning of the separation cut. However, as
the jet is penetrating into the material, the cutting tool (water and abrasive material)
exceeds the elastic limit of the material, resulting in a loss of energy that causes worse
surface quality at the top edge of the cut. In the next part of the cut, the hydro-
mechanical ratios of the separation cut are stabilized and material removal becomes
uniform, creating smooth surface of the cutting wall.
The experimental sample was prepared to achieve the highest possible surface
quality. Therefore the kinetic energy of the jet is stable in the remaining part of the cut,
which corresponds to the roughness parameters measured in the individual lines along
the entire depth of the cut.
The machined surface is a set of irregularities creating the surface texture. Surface
structure components are separated by filtering. When quantifying the surface
The Use of Areal Parameters 41
topography using the standardised parameters, filter settings for the desired profile have
to be correctly selected. Rules and procedures for the surface structure evaluation are
defined in the standard ISO 4288 [9]. The filter (cut-off) kc = 2.5 mm is used when
evaluating sample surfaces with the average arithmetic deviation of the profile of
2 lm ˃ Ra ˂ 10 lm.
When assessing the surface quality, wider variety of standardised R-parameters
have to be considered. If one parameter is used, we get only a partial view of the
surface quality. This can lead to incorrect conclusions about the overall workpiece
quality. Appropriate selection of monitored parameters should comply with require-
ments for the control of operational aspects of the surface. The most commonly used
roughness parameter Ra has a relatively low reporting ability. The parameter Rq is
more sensitive to possible variations of irregularities on the measured profile. However,
it is still an average profile deviation. Another monitored parameter is the highest
profile peak Rz which provides information about the maximum height of the profile.
The parameters Rp gives information about the highest peak of the profile and Rv about
the deepest valley of the profile, evaluating whether the surface structure has higher
peaks or lower valleys. Individual R-parameters give only limited information on the
structure of the analysed surface. Only the multiparametric assessment provides a more
comprehensive view of surface behaviour.
To get a more reliable analysis of the studied surface, it is more appropriate to use
an areal (3D) method which applies the knowledge acquired from the profile (2D)
method extended by new research findings. The surface parameters were measured in
the upper, middle and lower part of the cutting wall of the experimentally created
sample. The areal parameters were calculated applying Gaussian filter of 2.5 mm in
accordance with the standard ISO 25178-3 [10]. Selected height parameters of the
surface texture Sa, Sq, Sp, Sv and Sz which represent the statistical characteristics of the
height z (x, y) of the studied area are presented in Table 2.
The calculated values of Sa and Sq parameters are the same as the values of Ra and
Rq parameters. However, these parameters cannot be considered as equal. The 3D
parameters are calculated using areal filters, while profile filters are used to calculate the
2D parameters. Selected profile and areal parameters can be compared with each other.
It can be assumed that the areal parameter values will be higher than the values of the
profile parameters. This is due to the fact that it cannot be assured by the profile
analysis of the surface that the measured line captured the deepest and highest points of
the studied surface topography. In contrast, when evaluating the area, the areal texture
parameters are determined from a significantly larger number of measured data that
provide a more objective presentation of the controlled area.
The height parameters Sa and Sq represent the arithmetical and square mean
magnitude of height coordinates of the studied surface texture, similar to the Ra and Rq
parameters. Both parameters are insensitive in differentiating peaks and valleys. Their
different values do not give a definitive idea of the character and properties of the
evaluated surface. The parameter Sq can be considered as statistically more significant,
highlighting extreme values of peaks and valleys (dents).
Parameters Sp and Sv specify the absolute highest and lowest points found on the
texture of the examined surface. The maximum height of the evaluated area Sz is the
distance between the highest peak and the deepest valley. When comparing the values
The Use of Areal Parameters 43
of these parameters (Table 2) with the values of the profile roughness Rp, Rv and Rz
(Table 1), it is obvious that the areal parameters reach approximately double the values
of the profile parameters. This is due to the fact that the areal analysis, unlike the profile
analysis, is able to measure the highest peak and the deepest valley of the surface
texture.
6 Conclusion
The areal analysis of the surface represents a significant qualitative advance in the
evaluation of the studied surface texture. The standard spatial assessment of the surface
texture according to the standard ISO 25178-2 [7] provides a number of new param-
eters which quantify the studied area more precisely and characterise the functional
properties of the surface. The presented measurement results point to a lower reliability
of the roughness parameters calculated from the profile of the surface structure. The
areal parameters are obtained from a significantly higher number of measured data with
much greater reliability, so the determined value of the parameter is more plausible.
ISO 25178-2 describes a wide range of surface parameters that define surface
quality and functional properties. It is necessary to perform further analyzes of the
investigated surfaces using surface parameters to obtain a coherent view on the surface
texture created by the abrasive water jet.
Acknowledgments. This article was written within the scope of a project of the Institute of
Clean Technologies for Mining and Utilisation of Raw Materials for Energy Use – Sustainability
Program, (Reg. No. LO1406). The presented work was also supported by a project for the long-
term conceptual development of research organisations RVO: 68145535 and Czech Ministry of
Industry and Trade project No. FV10446. The authors are very thankful for the support.
References
1. Peng, G., Yang, C., Oguma, Y., et al.: Numerical analysis of cavitation cloud shedding in a
submerged water jet. J. Hydrodyn. 28(6), 986–993 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1001-
6058(16)60700-X
2. Peng, G., Ishizuka, M., Hayama, S.: An improved CIP-CUP method for submerged water jet
flow simulation. JSME Int. J. Ser. B-Fluids Therm. Eng. 44(4), 497–504 (2001). https://doi.
org/10.1016/S1001-6058(16)60700-X
3. Klich, J., Klichová, D., Foldyna, V., Hlaváček, P., Foldyna, J.: Influence of variously modified
surface of aluminium alloy on the effect of pulsating water jet. Stroj. Vestn. -J. Mech. Eng. 63
(10), 577–582 (2017). https://doi.org/10.5545/sv-jme.2017.4356
4. Lehocká, D., Klichová, D., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Hvizdoš, P., Fides, M., Botko, F.:
Comparison of the influence of acoustically enhanced pulsating water jet on selected surface
integrity characteristics of CW004A copper and CW614N brass. Measurement 110, 230–
238 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement.2017.07.005
5. Lehocká, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Hvizdoš, P., Fides, M., Botko, F., Cárach, J.:
Surface integrity evaluation of brass CW614N after impact of acoustically excited pulsating
water jet. Procedia Eng. 149, 236–244 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2016.06.662
44 D. Klichová et al.
6. ISO 4287: Geometrical Product Specifications (GPS) - Surface texture: Profile method -
Terms, definitions and surface texture parameters (1997)
7. ISO 25178-2: Geometrical product specifications (GPS) - Surface texture: Areal - Part 2:
Terms, definitions and surface texture parameters (2012)
8. Martinec, P., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Ščučka, J., Vašek, J.: Abrasives for AWJ cutting. INCO
– COPERNICUS No. IC 15-CT98-0821. Institute of Geonics, Ostrava, (2002)
9. ISO 4288: Geometrical Product Specifications (GPS) - Surface texture: Profile method -
Rules and procedures for the assessment of surface texture (1996)
10. ISO 25178-3: Geometrical product specifications (GPS) - Surface texture: Areal - Part 3:
Specification operators (2012)
Research on Water Jet Cutting of Polymer
Composites Based on Epoxy/Waste Fibres
from Coconut Processing
1 Introduction
materials with natural reinforcing fibres are desirable and their use has been ascending
at the present. Coconut fibres are one of prospective natural materials. The coir is the
most often gained mechanically in a line processing the coconuts when the fibres are
removed from the coconuts (pectin packaging) by means of a set of counter-rotating
rollers [3]. A relatively huge amount of for the food industry waste in a form of fibres
can be reached from one coconut [3]. Ca. 100 g of fibres on average are stated [3].
Brown fibres which are the most often arising commodity are separated from matured
coconuts [3]. These fibres are more used than the white fibres, they are thicker and are
of wide applications. White fibres are extracted from immature coconuts [3].
Nowadays, there is a trend to use the biological filler which provides comparable
and often better mechanical properties for the composite materials that the synthetic
fillers. However, it is necessary to focus also on other operations in the engineering, i.e.
e.g. dividing of the material and subsequent machining [4]. It is also necessary to
search for a suitable way of a production of single parts with different shapes. Different
variants of cutting by means of the water jet technology belong among prospective
methods of the composite materials dividing [4]. It does not come to a rise of a heat due
to this technology which would degrade the polymer composite material.
The water jet cutting technology is based on a principle of pressing water through
the water nozzle under high pressure and thereby accelerating to high speed water jet.
In the mixing chamber, passing water jet creates an under-pressure and thus carries air
along with it. Due to this negative pressure, the abrasive medium is drawn into the two-
phase flow and creates a three-phase flow. The multi-phase jet is concentrated in the
subsequent focus tube [5]. An increase of the cutting effect is possible by adding
abrasive particles [6] or by means of a pulsating water jet [7].
However, a negative aspect is a fact that a failure of an interaction between a matrix
and the reinforcement can occur at the cutting of composite materials at acting of the
high-speed liquid with the abrasive on a surface of a workpiece [8]. A cutting speed is
another significant limit which does not usually have a significant influence on the
material lopping [9]. The unsuitable cutting speed influences a delamination of single
layers which ultimately decreases application possibilities of these composite materials.
The aim of the study is the research on the influence of the abrasive water jet
(AWJ) and the water jet (WJ) on a kerf width in an inlet and the outlet at various
cutting speeds. The research was performed with composite materials naturally rein-
forced with the waste from coconuts processing.
2 Methodology
Cuts of a length 60 mm (Fig. 1A) of the composite material based on short and long
waste fibres from coconuts processing by means of the water jet (WJ) technology and
the abrasive water jet (AWJ) technology at which the mass flow of the abrasive grains
(garnet MESH 80, mechanical dosing device Bimba Flat-1) was 90.62 ± 1.19 g/min
were tested within the research.
The composite material was cut by CNC cutting machine AWJ CT 0806 (with
a high pressure pump AccuStream model A-6030, a screw compressor Keaser Air-
center SM9 and a pressure container of abrasive grains AW-ADS 160) at different
Research on Water Jet Cutting of Polymer Composites 47
Fig. 1. Machining of composites based on short and long waste fibres from coconut processing
by water jet (WJ) technology and abrasive water jet (AWJ) technology: A: CNC AWJ CT 0806,
B: cut in tested composite sample with short non-oriented fibres - inlet of water jet, C: cut in
tested composite sample with long oriented fibres – inlet of water jet.
cutting speeds 50, 100, 250, 500, 750 and 1000 mm/min (the cutting speed represents a
velocity of the cutting head movement above the material). The working pressure was
380 MPa. A distance of the nozzle above the cut material was 3 mm. The diameter of
the nozzle was 0.8 mm. An angle of the nozzle tilt to the composite material was 90°.
The testing cut was made in the composite board of dimensions 100 130 mm
(Fig. 1A). A two-component epoxy resin with a low viscosity suitable for a laminating
technology including the vacuum infusion was used as the matrix. The resin was
hardened with cycloaliphatic polyamine, the main component isophorone di-amine.
The fibres of Cocos nucifera which are by-products at the coconuts processing were
used for the research (the fibres are from coconut processing line in Philippines). 6%
water solution of NaOH was used for a chemical treatment of the fibres. The acting
time was 6 h at a laboratory temperature 24 ± 2 °C. Then all fibres were washed by
a distilled water (including fibres without the chemical treatment) and dried at a
temperature 105 °C for the time 24 h. The fibres were pressed by a compressive force
5 kN into a shape of the board and subsequently saturated with the resin by means of
the vacuum infusion. One board was made from non-oriented short fibres of a length
5.0 ± 0.4 mm (Fig. 1B) and the second board from long fibres oriented in one
direction (Fig. 1C). The reinforcing fibres were prepared by cutting with a knife from
the firm Moraknife.
A width of a kerf inlet and outlet of the abrasive water jet was evaluated within the
research. It considerably differed. A parameter of the kerf width was evaluated by
means of a stereoscopic microscope Arsenal SZP 11-T ZOOM which is equipped with
a digital camera and an evaluating software Quick Industrial Photo 2.3. The evaluated
kerf was measured in 30 places 10 mm from the beginning and the end of the cut.
A thickness of the cut composite board was 4.50 ± 0.15 mm. A topography of the
machined surface depending on the cutting speed and AWJ or WJ technology was
evaluated within the research by means of a surface analysis by means of a scanning
electron microscopy (SEM - microscope TESCAN MIRA 3 GM). The samples were
dusted with gold by means of the equipment Quorum Q150R ES - Sputtering Depo-
sition Rate using Gold.
48 M. Miroslav et al.
The experiment results proved a quiddity of a combination of the cutting speed and the
use of AWJ or WJ technology at dividing of the composite materials with long lon-
gitudinally oriented fibres (Fig. 2) and short non-oriented fibres (Fig. 3). It is obvious
from the results in Fig. 2 that a significant deformation/delamination occurs on the
bottom side of the cut at the use of WJ technology, i.e. without abrasive grains (see
Fig. 4A, D). This significant deformation did not occur at the use of AWJ technology
(Fig. 4B, E).
Fig. 2. Kerf width of cut by WJ and AWJ technology of polymer composite material with filler
based on long longitudinally oriented fibres from coconut processing.
The kerf width in the inlet did not significantly differ at the cutting of the composite
material with long longitudinally oriented fibres by WJ technology depending on the
cutting speeds in the interval from 50 to 1000 mm/min (Fig. 2). The kerf width differed
in the interval from 4.4 to 13.7%. The high influence of the kerf width was in the outlet
depending on the cutting speed when the significant differences occurred from the
speed 500 mm/min (in the interval 86.5 to 439.9%). A significant destruction of the
outlet side occurred at higher speeds, i.e. from 500 mm/min at cutting by means of the
water jet without the abrasive grains (Fig. 4D, F).
The kerf width in the inlet did not significantly differ at the cutting of the composite
material with long longitudinally oriented fibres by means of AWJ technology
Research on Water Jet Cutting of Polymer Composites 49
Fig. 3. Kerf width of cut by WJ and AWJ technology of polymer composite material with filler
based on short randomly oriented fibres from coconut processing.
depending on the cutting speed in the interval from 50 to 1000 mm/min. The kerf width
differed in the interval 4.3 to 15.4%. Analogous trend was also in the outlet of the
abrasive water jet where more significant change in the interval 5.5 to 29.1% occurred
(Fig. 4E). A chipping of the composite board rarely occurred at higher speed
750 mm/min in the abrasive water jet outlet.
It is obvious in terms of the statistical comparison of the kerf width in the inlet and
the outlet depending on the cutting speeds that they are statistically non-homogeneous
groups (p = 0.0000) in the significance level 0.05, i.e. there is the difference between
the kerf width in the inlet and the outlet at both AWJ and WJ technology.
The kerf width in the inlet did not significantly differed at the cutting of the
composite material with short randomly oriented fibres by WJ technology depending
on the cutting speeds in the interval 50 to 1000 mm/min (the difference in the interval
0.3 to 15.8%) – see Fig. 3. The significant influence of the kerf width was in the outlet
at all tested cutting speeds (in the interval 78.3 to 517.2%).
The kerf width in the inlet did not significantly differed at the cutting of the
composite material with short randomly oriented fibres by AWJ technology depending
on the cutting speeds in the interval 50 to 1000 mm/min (9.0 to 26.2%) – see Fig. 3.
Analogous trend was also in the outlet of the abrasive water jet (0.1 to 34.5%).
The same trend as at the composite material with long longitudinally oriented fibres
was also observed at this composite material, namely higher differences in the kerf
width were diagnosed at higher speeds, i.e. over 750 mm/min. It is evident from
50 M. Miroslav et al.
Fig. 4. SEM images of cut of polymer composite material based on waste fibres from coconut
processing - speed 100 mm/min: A: cut by WJ technology of composites with short fibres (MAG
49x), B: cut by AWJ technology of composites with short fibres (MAG 43x), C: detailed view on
cut by AWJ technology of short fibre composites (MAG 758x), D: cut by WJ technology of
composites with long fibres (MAG 56x), E: cut by AWJ technology of composites with long fibres
(MAG 58x), F: detailed view on cut by WJ technology of long fibre composites (MAG 633x).
Fig. 4C that the deformation of the fibres did not occur and the cut was uniform at the
use of AWJ technology.
It is obvious in terms of the statistical comparison of the kerf width in the inlet and
the outlet depending on the cutting speeds that they are statistically non-homogeneous
groups (p = 0.0000) in the significance level 0.05, i.e. there is the difference between
the kerf width in the inlet and the outlet at both AWJ and WJ technologies.
The cut was not in the whole cross-section at the tested composite materials with
the reinforcing phase in the form of the coconut fibres at the cutting speeds 750 and
1000 mm/min at WJ technology (without abrasive grains in the water jet). The water
jet had not sufficient kinetic and erosive ability to create the cut in the whole cross-
section. In the outlet, a breakout of the composite material occurred in the area of the
cut rather than the cut. Also a scattering of the results presented in Figs. 2 and 3 at the
cutting speeds 750 and 1000 mm/min is huge from that reason. The variation coeffi-
cient was up to 230%.
The cutting zone of the composite materials showed huge differences between WJ
and AWJ as it is evident from Fig. 4. An irregular cutting zone, namely in the outlet of
Research on Water Jet Cutting of Polymer Composites 51
the water jet, is visible from Fig. 4A and D. The breakout area in the end of the cut is
visible in the outlet. This negative state occurred at all speeds at the use of WJ
technology. The water jet was already out of sufficient kinetic energy for the cut and it
came to the deformation leading to a fracture of the material. A regular cut with the use
of AWJ technology is visible from Fig. 4B and E. Figures 4A, B, D, E represent the cut
through the whole material.
Acting of WJ and AWJ on the filler of the composite materials in the form of fibres
from the coconut processing is visible in Fig. 5. A good interaction between the matrix
(the resin) and the reinforcing fibre is obvious from Fig. 5A. The cut after the abrasive
particles is evident on the surface of the fibre. The deformation/delamination of the
composite structure in the outlet of the water jet without the abrasive grains is evident
from Fig. 5B. The breakout of single fibres from the matrix occurred in the bottom part
of the cut at the use of WJ technology rather than the cut. Figure 5B shows the cut by
the water jet without the abrasive grains and it is evident that it comes to breaking out
of partial segments of the filler by acting the kinetic energy on the cut.
Fig. 5. SEM images of cut of polymer composite materials based on fibres from coconut
processing: A: detailed view on cut by AWJ – speed 750 mm/min (MAG 505x), B: detailed view
on cut by WJ – speed 750 mm/min (MAG 232x), C: detailed view on cut by AWJ with
significant trace after abrasive grains – speed 100 mm/min (MAG 1.21kx), D: detailed view on
cut by WJ of long longitudinally oriented fibres in composite structure – speed 100 mm/min
(MAG 136x), E: detailed view on cut by WJ – speed 100 mm/min (MAG 475x), F: detailed view
on cut by WJ of long longitudinally oriented fibres of composite material – speed 750 mm/min
(MAG 444x).
52 M. Miroslav et al.
4 Conclusions
The research dealing with cutting of polymer fibre composite material with the filler
based on the waste from coconut processing by means of the unconventional tech-
nology, i.e. the abrasive water jet (AWJ), and the water jet (WJ) proved the quiddity of
the combination of the cutting speed and the presence of the abrasive grains (the use of
AWJ technology) on the effectivity of the area and the width of the cut. The significant
destruction of the material occurred in the water jet outlet (i.e. in the bottom side of the
cut) under unsuitable cutting conditions and at the absence of the abrasive grains. This
is the undesirable factor for following application of these materials in the practice.
They will be used as a design upper/view element which is applied on a basic material,
e.g. chipboards in the furniture industry. These materials have to be cut precisely
according to requirements of a shape and dimensions of a final product.
Acknowledgement. This paper has been made with the assistance of the grant IGA TF CZU
(Research on mechanical properties of polymeric composite materials cut by water jet).
References
1. Naprstkova, N., Kusmierczak, S.: Analysis of decrease machinability possible causes for
claimed alloy. Adv. Sci. Technol. Res. J. 10(31), 94–101 (2016)
2. Novak, M., Naprstkova, N.: The influence of cutting conditions on surface roughness during
steel X38CrMoV5 grinding. Key Eng. Mater. 581, 247–254 (2014)
Research on Water Jet Cutting of Polymer Composites 53
3. Valášek, P., D’Amato, R., Müller, M., Ruggiero, A.: Mechanical properties and abrasive
wear of white/brown coir epoxy. Compos. Part B Eng. 146, 88–97 (2018)
4. Müller, M., Valášek, P.: Research on aluminium alloy AlCu4 Mg surface machined by
abrasive water jet. Manuf. Technol. 17(6), 925–930 (2017)
5. Kušnerová, M., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Valicek, J., Hloch, S., Harnicarova, M., Kadnar, M.:
Innovative approach to advanced modulated waterjet technology. Technicki Vjesnik-
Technical Gazette 19(3), 475–480 (2012)
6. Wang, J., Guo, D.M.: A predictive depth of penetration model for abrasive waterjet cutting
of polymer matrix composites. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 121, 390–394 (2002)
7. Foldyna, J., Klich, J., Hlaváček, P., Zeleňák, M., Ščučka, J.: Erosion of metals by pulsating
water jet. Tehnicki Vjesnik 19(2), 381–386 (2012)
8. Shanmugam, D.K., Nguyen, T., Wang, J.: A study of delamination on graphite/epoxy
composites in abrasive waterjet machining. Compos. Part A 39, 923–929 (2008)
9. Shanmugam, D.K., Chen, F.L., Siores, E., Brandt, M.: Comparative study of jetting
machining technologies over laser machining technology for cutting composite materials.
Compos. Struct. 57, 289–296 (2002)
10. Lemma, E., Chen, F.L., Siores, E., Wang, J.: Study of cutting fiber reinforced composites by
using abrasive waterjet with cutting head oscillation. Compos. Struct. 57, 297–303 (2002)
11. Müller, M., D’Amato, R., Rudawska, A.: Machining of polymeric composites by means of
abrasive water-jet technology. In 16th International Scientific Conference: Engineering for
Rural Development, pp. 121–127. Latvia University Agriculture, Faculty Engineering,
Latvia (2017)
12. Wang, J.: Abrasive water jet machining of polymer matrix composites-cutting performance,
erosive process and predictive models. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 15, 757–768 (1999)
Recent Developments in Pulsating Water Jets
Josef Foldyna(&)
Abstract. Pulsating water jets represent one of the ways to intensify effects of
water jetting technology on materials. In the first part of the paper, phenomena
occurring during the impact of a drop of a liquid on a solid surface and reasons
for their use leading to the generation of pulsating water jets are briefly
described. In the next part, the concept of hydrodynamic nozzle for generating
of pulsating water jets is briefly mentioned. The final part of the paper deals with
the comparison of the erosive effects of continuous and pulsating jets generated
by the acoustic generator and the hydrodynamic nozzle. Presented results proved
superior performance of the pulsating jet generated by the acoustic generator.
The hydrodynamic nozzle exhibits also great potential for significant
improvement of water jetting performance.
1 Introduction
The effects of high-speed water jets on disintegration of materials are well known to the
public. Pure water pressed by commonly used high pressure pumps up to 415 MPa has
sufficient energy to cut paper, wood, plastic, rubber, and thin metal sheets (up to about
1 mm) after passing through a very small hole (i.e. nozzle with a diameter of tenths up
to units of millimeters). After addition of abrasive particles to the high-velocity water
jet, either downstream the nozzle (so-called abrasive water jet) or upstream the nozzle
(so-called abrasive suspension jet), the range of applicability of the jets is greatly
increased. Abrasive jets are capable of cutting, drilling, turning or milling not only
metals, but also difficult to process materials such as composites, structural ceramics,
high-strength alloys, glass, etc. At present, no material is known that would resist the
action of the abrasive jet.
Despite the undisputed technological advances made in recent years in the field of
high-speed abrasive water jet applications, there is a constant pressure on the devel-
opment of new technologies using only pure water jets. The research teams are trying
to improve them to better adapt to ever more demanding environmental requirements,
further improve their performance, and at the same time make their use more
economical.
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 54–62, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_7
Recent Developments in Pulsating Water Jets 55
One possible route is the use of ultra-high pressures to generate water jets. The
feasibility studies of cutting metals with pure water jets at pressures up to 690 MPa
were performed already in early nineties of the last century [2]. Currently commercially
available high-pressure water jet cutting devices are operated at pressures up to
700 MPa. However, such pressures cause extreme stress on individual parts of high-
pressure pumps, which adversely affects their service life.
An alternative approach can be characterized by the effort to eliminate the need for
extremely high pressures by the utilization of the physical phenomenon created by the
droplet’s impact on a solid surface.
2 Background
In the case of a collision of a fluid moving at high velocity with a rigid body, a short-
term transient phenomenon occurs. The phenomenon is accompanied by a noticeable
increase in pressure at the point of the fluid’s impact on the surface, and can cause
severe damage both on the surface and in the internal structure of the material exposed
to the impacting liquid.
The need to study the phenomena that occurs when a droplet strikes the solid
surface has been stimulated in the past primarily by the need to prevent erosion of
steam turbine blades. Currently, for example, there is extensive research on rain erosion
on aircraft and missiles, especially on window materials. Cavitation erosion is also
closely related to the impact of fluid on the solid surface.
The impact of the fluid on the solid surface takes place in two phases. The Fig. 1
illustrates schematically the fluid with density q1 impacting on the rigid surface at the
velocity v. In the first stage of the impact, the fluid behaves as compressible. A small
central area of the first contact is compressed under a uniform pressure and generates an
impact pressure pi due to the so-called water-hammer effect [3]. The impact pressure is
responsible for a large part of the damage caused by the impact of the fluid on the solid
surface.
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of two phases of the impact of a fluid on a rigid surface.
56 J. Foldyna
The magnitude of the impact pressure pi on the central axis of the impacting fluid
can be expressed as
vq1 c1 q2 c2
pi ¼ ð1Þ
q1 c1 þ q2 c2
where v is the impact velocity of the fluid and q1, q2 and c1, c2 are the densities and the
shock velocities in the fluid and the solid, respectively [4].
The first phase of the fluid impact lasts for several microseconds and corresponds to
the time at which the pressure drop wave propagates from the point of the outer contact
of the fluid and the rigid surface to the center of the impacting fluid.
When the impact pressure subsides, the second phase of the fluid impact begins.
During this phase, the fluid behaves as incompressible and the pressure in the central
axis of the impacting fluid drops to a much lower Bernoulli stagnation pressure ps,
which is given by
1
ps ¼ q1 v2 ð2Þ
2
The stagnation pressure lasts for a relatively long time. As soon as the pressure
deformation limit of the liquid is exceeded, the fluid starts to flow radially perpen-
dicular to the beam axis outwardly along the impact surface. The radial flow velocity
can be much higher than the impact velocity of the fluid, and as a result, the normal
forces from the impact of the fluid, as well as the shear forces, act on the surface of the
mate rial. If the surface is uneven or broken, radial fluid flow can cause such shear
forces that are able to create local shear cracks even on the surface of high-strength
materials [5].
The effects caused by the impact of a spherical drop of water on a solid surface at
the velocity of 200 ms−1 (corresponding to the velocity of water jet generated at
pressure of 20 MPa) were simulated numerically using the ANSYS CFD software. The
moment of maximum increase of the impact pressure is documented in Fig. 2 – the
maximum impact pressure reaches 78.5 MPa, with the radial velocity of the flow of
water on the surface being over 280 ms−1 at this time.
Subsequently, the impact pressure drops and the radial velocity of the flow
increases as the water escapes from the compressed area. Figure 3 illustrates a situation
when the radial velocity reaches a maximum value of 395 ms−1, with the impact
pressure dropping to 44 MPa.
Impact pressure pi is many times higher than the pressure ps –it can be approximately
4 to 20 times higher than the stagnation pressure, depending on the pressure upstream
the nozzle. Since the continuous water jet acts on the material essentially only by
stagnation pressure, it is desirable to divide it into a series of “droplets” capable of
producing an impact pressure upon impact and to use the above-described phenomena
accompanying the drop effect on the material to increase effects of high-speed water jets.
This can be achieved by generating sufficiently high-pressure pulsations of the
pressure liquid upstream the nozzle, resulting in the formation of pulsating liquid jets.
One of approaches to solve the problem of generating pulsating jets is based on the
Recent Developments in Pulsating Water Jets 57
Fig. 2. Numerical simulation of the impact of a spherical drop of water on a solid surface at the
velocity of 200 ms−1 at the moment of maximum impact pressure (top: impact pressure
distribution; bottom: radial velocity of the flow on the surface).
Fig. 3. Numerical simulation of the impact of a spherical drop of water on a solid surface at the
velocity of 200 ms−1 at the moment of maximum of radial velocity of the flow on the surface
(top: impact pressure distribution; bottom: radial velocity of the flow on the surface).
Fig. 4. Visualized high-speed pulsating water jets. Top: Acoustically generated pulsating water
jet (10 MPa, 20 kHz; bottom: Pulsating jet generated by hydrodynamic nozzle (8 MPa,
9.5 kHz).
3 Experimental Procedure
The objective of presented work was to compare erosion effects of water jets generated
by various types of nozzles. Three types of the nozzles were selected for the com-
parison: StoneAge Attack Tip AP4 0.038” (0.965 mm) for generation of continuous jet,
pulsating water jet generator 20 kHz equipped with StoneAge Attack Tip AP4 0.038”
(0.965 mm), and hydrodynamic nozzle HDN-01-11.
Firstly, the actual flow rate at two levels of pressure (10 and 20 MPa) was measured
to define nozzle discharge coefficients for tested nozzles and to be sure that the roughly
Recent Developments in Pulsating Water Jets 59
the same water flow rates will be generated by all tested nozzles at given operating
pressure during tests.
Then, optimum standoff distances at operating pressures of 50 and 100 MPa were
determined for individual nozzles by “ramp test” at the traversing velocity of
10 mms−1. Tests were performed on aluminium Al99.5 sheets.
Finally, erosion tests were performed at operating pressures of 50 and 100 MPa and
at five standoff distances selected around optimum standoff distances determined in the
previous stage. Again, the tests were performed at the traversing velocity of 10 mms−1
on aluminium Al99.5 sheets. Hydrodynamic nozzle was tested in two orientations:
(1) jet oscillates perpendicularly to the traversing direction, and (2) jet oscillates in
parallel to the traversing direction (see Fig. 5).
Fig. 5. Orientation of hydrodynamic nozzle in the experiments: (a) jet oscillates perpendicularly
to the traversing direction, (b) jet oscillates in parallel to the traversing direction.
Results are presented in form of graphs in Fig. 6 and Fig. 7. The graphs compare
material removal rates obtained using tested types of jets at pressures of 50 and
100 MPa, respectively.
As can be seen in Fig. 6, jet generated by hydrodynamic nozzle oriented parallel
was able to remove small amounts of material even at 50 MPa. However, its perfor-
mance at this pressure was at the most about 10% of the performance of the pulsating
jet generated at 20 kHz. Continuous jet and jet generated by hydrodynamic nozzle
oriented perpendicularly did not remove any material at the operating pressure of
50 MPa.
At the testing pressure of 100 MPa, there were quite significant differences in the
performance of individual jets (Fig. 7). Whereas material removal rate of the jet
generated by the hydrodynamic nozzle oriented parallel was about 50% lower com-
pared to the pulsating jet generated at 20 kHz, it was still about 3 times higher
60 J. Foldyna
Fig. 6. Material removal rates obtained using tested types of jets at the pressure of 50 MPa.
Fig. 7. Material removal rates obtained using tested types of jets at the pressure of 100 MPa.
compared to that of continuous jet. In addition, the optimum standoff distance was
about 10 mm for the hydrodynamic nozzle (compare to optimum standoff distance of
350 mm for continuous jet).
Material removal rate of the jet generated by the hydrodynamic nozzle oriented
perpendicularly was about 70% lower compared to the pulsating jet generated at
20 kHz. However, it was almost two times higher compared to continuous jet. Again,
optimum standoff distance was about 10 mm for the jet generated by the hydrodynamic
nozzle.
Visual appearance of grooves created by individual jets under optimal conditions
can be seen in Figs. 8 and 9. Continuous jet creates shallow groove with clear features
of small droplet erosion occurring due to natural break-up of the jet at this relatively
Recent Developments in Pulsating Water Jets 61
large standoff distance (Fig. 8 left). Pulsating jet generated at 20 kHz creates deep
groove by the action of well defined and relatively large pulses of water (Fig. 8 right).
The jet generated by the hydrodynamic nozzle oriented perpendicularly creates wider
but shallower groove due to oscillations of the jet perpendicularly to the traversing
direction. Character of the groove created by the jet generated by the hydrodynamic
nozzle oriented parallel is similar (but shallower) to the groove created by pulsating jet.
Fig. 8. 3D surface scan of the groove created by continuous jet at the standoff distance of
350 mm (left) and by pulsating jet generated at 20 kHz and standoff-distance of 65 mm (right) –
operating pressure 100 MPa.
Fig. 9. 3D surface scan of the groove created by the jet generated by the hydrodynamic nozzle
oriented perpendicularly (left) and parallel (right) at the standoff distance of 10 mm – operating
pressure 100 MPa.
5 Conclusion
The experimental tests oriented at the comparison of material removal rate using
various nozzles under roughly the same hydraulic parameters of generated jets were
performed. The experiments proved superior performance of the pulsating jet generated
at 20 kHz at both testing pressures 50 and 100 MPa. Continuous jet was able to
remove material only at the pressure of 100 MPa at large standoff distances with
62 J. Foldyna
optimum standoff distance about 350 mm. Even the tested hydrodynamic nozzle does
not achieve performance of the pulsating jet nozzle at 20 kHz, the hydrodynamic
nozzle exhibits great potential for significant improvement of water jetting perfor-
mance. There are still some opened questions regarding the manufacturing of the
hydrodynamic nozzles because the quality of their internal surfaces (especially in
nozzle outlet) seems to be crucial for generation of highly effective pulsating water jets.
Acknowledgement. The work presented in the paper was performed under the support of the
project the Institute of Clean Technologies for Mining and the Utilization of Raw Materials for
Energy Use – Sustainability program, reg. no. LO1406 financed by the Ministry of Education,
Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic, and the long-term conceptual development of the
research institution RVO: 68145535. The author is thankful for the support.
References
1. Ovid: Epistulae ex Ponto, IV, 10, 5 (expanded in the Middle Ages)
2. Raghavan, C., Ting, E.: Hyper pressure water jet cutting of thin sheet metal. In: Labus, T.
J. (ed.). In: Proceedings of 6th American Water Jet Conference, pp. 493–504. Water Jet
Technology Association (1991)
3. Hancox, N.L., Brunton, J.H.: The erosion of solids by the repeated impact of liquid drops.
Philos. Trans. Roy. Soc. Lond. Ser. A. Math. Phys. Sci. 1110(260), 121–139 (1966)
4. de Haller, P.: Untersuchungen über die durch Kavitation hervorgerufenen Korrosionen.
Schweizerische Bauzeitung 21& 22(101), 243–246, 260–264 (1933)
5. Klich, J., Klichová, D., Foldyna, V., Hlaváček, P., Foldyna, J.: Influence of variously
modified surface of aluminium alloy on the effect of pulsating water jet. Strojniski Vestnik-J.
Mech. Eng. 10(63), 577–582 (2017)
6. Foldyna, J., Švehla, B.: Method of generation of pressure pulsations and apparatus for
implementation of this method. US patent No. 7,934,666 (2011)
7. Zeleňák, M., Foldyna, J., Ščučka, J., Hloch, S., Říha, Z.: Visualisation and measurement of
high-speed pulsating and continuous water jets. Measurement 72, 1–8 (2015)
8. Lehocká, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Królczyk, J.B., Cárach, J., Krolczyk, G.:
Copper alloys disintegration using pulsating water jet. Measurement 82, 375–383 (2016)
9. Říha, Z.: Tool and hydrodynamic nozzle for generating high-pressure pulsating jet of liquid
without cavitation and saturated vapors. Czech patent No. 306290 (2016)
10. Klich, J., Říha, Z., Foldyna, V.: Influence of hydrodynamic nozzle wear on erosion effect of
self-excited pulsating water jet. In: Klichová, D., Sitek, L. (eds.) Water Jet 2017 – Research,
Development, Applications, pp. 73–80. Ústav geoniky AV ČR, Ostrava (2017)
Investigation on Pulsating Liquid Jet
with Physiological Saline on Aluminium
Surface
Abstract. The paper deals with an experimental study related to the influence
of technological parameter namely standoff distance and fluid pressure over
disintegration depth created on aluminium surface. The fluid used for disinte-
gration is 0.9% physiological saline. This saline solution with density
1.008 kg/m3 higher than water 0.998 kg/m3, when impacts the surface induces
a larger force leading to deeper disintegration grooves keeping other parameters
constant. Special nozzle having diameter of 0.3 mm and 100 mm length was
used during disintegration process. A minimal pressure ranging from 8 MPa to
16 MPa along with standoff distance of 1 mm to 6 mm is varied to observe its
interactional effect over the depth formed during disintegration process. Groove
depth was measured using FRT device in which 10 readings of each groove
were recorded and their mean were considered for further analysis. The results
concluded that for intermediate values of standoff distance (3–4 mm) and higher
fluid pressure (13–16 MPa), deeper grooves were observed. Deepest mean
groove observed within the experimental domain was of 183 µm deep at 2 mm
standoff distance and 16 MPa fluid pressure. The experiments concluded that
saline jet can be used for disintegration of material effectively.
1 Introduction
The disintegration of materials by using water jet process started decades ago. They
were initially used for disintegrating rocks for coal mining [1] and for cleaning and
removal of layers or coatings from materials surface [2]. This technology was then
further used in food processing [3] and stone craving industries [4]. The efficiency of
the method reduced while being used to machine hard to cut material having high
strength, toughness and hardness. The existing technology had to use high-pressure
pumps, which generated high water pressure (upto 620 MPa) resulting into a high-
velocity (200–800 m/s) water jet at the outlet of the nozzle which could create crack
and propagate it into the material for the further failure of material being disintegrated
[5]. Some modification to the technology was done by suspending small abrasive
grains which enhanced its machinability to a large extent. It is used to disintegrate hard
to cut materials [6], super alloys [7] and composite materials [8]. In this technique, the
water carries the abrasive grains suspended in it, at a higher velocity to strike the
material surface to erode it. Induction of abrasive grains in the water stream improves
the usage of this technique even at a lower pressure as compared to pure water jet
machining. This technology is also being used for the turning operation on hard to
machine materials [9]. Shortcomings with both the variants are that it uses high
pressure fluid which requires high pressure generating pumps, large consumption of
water and abrasives [10]. With intervention of water jet in biomedical applications [11],
it requires low pressure fluid compatible with biological environment to be used. To
crater these shortcomings, a new technique namely pulsating liquid jet (PLJ) was
invented. Pulsating water jet (PWJ) was created by inducing pulsations in the form of
shock waves by a piezoelectric transducer, which propagates along the water jet. These
pulsations in the water jet create a hammering effect when interacting with the material
surface. Due to this cyclic hammering, much lower water pressure can disintegrate the
material considering all other parameters same as compared to an abrasive water jet.
Nebekar et al. [12] made a device to produce and utilize the series of liquid clusters
from the continuous water stream, generated by an internal stream modulator to dis-
integrate rocks and other materials. Drawback faced by this setup was a small lifetime
of rotating parts of the modulator. Generation of pulsation using a helmotz oscillator
was done by Shen and Wang [13]. Irregularities in the flow were created by a change in
flow cross section which led to creation of pulsation. This technique of generation of
pulsation lacked the required level of modulations needed for disintegration. Vijay [14]
proposed another method for generating pulsation by using a vibrating transformer
near the nozzle tip, thus creating an ultrasonic field which would help in controlling the
high velocity water flow. This method created cavitation at the nozzle leading to its
high rate of wear. A new method of generation of pulsation was developed by Foldyna
and Svehla [15] which used acoustic waves created by the acoustic transducer, to travel
in a pressurized liquid up till the nozzle tip. These waves travel along with the water
causing it to form bunches, which then successively impact the machined surface to
generate a cyclic loading phenomenon to cause deformation or crack on the impacted
surface. The interaction of jet with surface consists of primarily 2 stages. In the initial
stage a “water hammer” phenomenon is generated which consist of impact of high
pressure liquid on the surface which causes majority damage to the surface. Second
stage comprises fluid flowing outwards from the impacted point. The tangential
velocity with which the fluid travels over the surface is considered approximately to be
5 times the velocity with which it impacted the surface. This velocity creates an added
shear forces on the surface along with the normal forces.
Several researchers have recorded better machining results regarding material
removal and surface finish while performing experiments using PLJ. Hloch et al. [16]
used both continuous water jet and PWJ to disintegrate bone cement. The research
showed the influence of water pressure in case of continuous water jet and pressure
Investigation on Pulsating Liquid Jet 65
along with nozzle geometry in the case of pulsating water jet on penetration depth of
grooves created while disintegrating Palacos R+J bone cement. Foldyna et al. [17]
observed the effect of machining parameters of pulsating water jet such as pressure,
standoff distance and amplitude on the volume removed, surface roughness and surface
topography using aluminium material. Lehocka et al. [18] disintegrated copper alloys
namely brass and bronze, using PWJ. The study primarily focused on the surface
topography, morphology and anisotropy of the material surface after being disinte-
grated by pulsating water jet. Effect of the number of passes and traverse speed on both
the material was analysed. Foldyna et al. [19] studied the influence of the number of
impacts and its velocity upon erosion of stainless steel when impinged by PWJ. Vari-
ation in operating pressure and stand-off distance was studied during experimentation.
A stand-off distance of 40 mm was kept while operating at 10 MPa while 50 mm for
20 and 30 MPa. Exposure time on the material surface was varied from 0.05 s to 5 s.
Bodnarova et al. [20] studied the use of different water jet methods for restoring
concrete structures. Water jet methods included use of continuous and PWJ with both
flat and rotating nozzles. Spray angle of 150 was used in case of flat nozzle. Lehocka
et al. [21] compared the effect of pulsating jet disintegration process on surface
integrity of copper and brass. Surface integrity study included the study of change in
surface layer and strengthening in the subsurface layer. Optical profilometry images
concluded that no definite boundaries were visible after disintegration. Hloch et al. [22]
used different commercially available bone cement to disintegrate using PWJ and study
the effect of water pressure over the material removal and depth of traces created.
Circular nozzle with an orifice diameter 0.7 mm was used during the experiment
keeping stand-off distance of 2 mm and traverse speed 1 mm/s. Water pressure was
varied from 8 to 20 MPa during the experimental runs.
The literature available showed that PLJ can be used effectively in various areas.
Moreover, very limited amount of research considering the influence of the density of
liquid used during the disintegration process has been conducted so far. This research
work is carried out to perceive the effectiveness of 0.9% NaCl solution in terms of
disintegration depth when used in PLJ. It involves a study to observe the influence of
stand-off distance and liquid pressure on the disintegration pattern of aluminium
material being disintegrated at low pressure i.e. under 16 MPa, using 0.9% physio-
logical saline fluid and also to determine the optimal distance of the nozzle from the
work material to achieve deeper disintegration depth.
The PLJ setup available in Institute of Geonics of the CAS in Ostrava was used for
conducting the experiments. The setup comprises a Karcher pump (delivering up to
67 l. min−1 at maximum operating pressure of 160 MPa) and ABB IRB 6640-180
robot for controlling the movement of the cutting head. ECOSON WJ-UG_630-40
generator was used to generate the acoustic wave for PLJ with a working frequency of
20 kHz. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1(a, b). Special nozzles for obtaining
deeper grooves were used for this experiment whose technical specifications are
66 A. Nag et al.
Fig. 1. (a) ABB robot, with special designed nozzle long 10 mm with diameter 0, 3 mm,
(b) Measurement of disintegrated Aluminium surface by Micro Prof FRT device with the
measurement head SEN 000 03.
Pure aluminium plate was used as a work material for conducting all the experi-
ments. Aluminium is a non-magnetic and is highly electrical conductive material. It is
widely used in commercial application due to its high ductility, good corrosion
resistance property, low density and cheaper price. It is currently being used in aircraft
structural frames and automobile parts for its high strength to weight ratio and in
construction industry for its corrosion resistive properties. Aluminium is used for this
experiment for better visualization and understanding the effect of the process
parameter in form of distinguishable grooves formed over the surface of the material
after being disintegrated by PLJ due to its inherent properties of the material.
The liquid used for the disintegration of the work material was 0.9% NaCl solution
in water commonly known as physiological saline. This sterile solution is isotonic to
body fluid and is utilized to keep living tissue temporarily and is additionally used as a
solvent for parenterally administered drugs. Physiological saline as the working fluid
Investigation on Pulsating Liquid Jet 67
was used to observe the effect of change in density of the fluid over the disintegration
depth. The technological advantage of saline water is primarily in term of impact force
induced on the material during the disintegration process. Impact force exerted by a
liquid jet on a stationary object kept perpendicular to the axis of the jet is given by
Eq. 1. Density of 0.9% physiological saline is 1.0046 kg/m3 as compared to density of
water which is 0.998 kg/m3 at 20 °C. This increment in density of fluid keeping other
parameters constant, leads to increase in the impact force during the disintegration
process.
F ¼ qAv2 ð1Þ
Where q = Density of fluid, A is cross section of the impacted area and v is the
velocity of the jet.
The grooves formed by the jet were scanned by MicroProf FRT device for mea-
surement of the depth. 10 depth readings at an interval of 2 mm for each groove were
recorded and there means were calculated for obtaining the optimum depth achieved at
each combination of technological parameters. This optimized value would indicate the
optimal parameter that can be used for effective disintegration of the aluminium
workpiece within the given experimental domain.
Experimental runs at each combination of pressure and stand – off distance were
carried out according to the experimental Table 1. Pictorial view of material after being
disintegrated is shown Fig. 2.
The depth values of the grooves varied according to the technological parameter of
the system and characteristic of the material. In some experimental runs no visible
traces of disintegration was observed in the material. The mean values of each trace
with visible groove depth along with the standard deviation of the depth values are
plotted against the stand-off distance. Figure 3 shows variation in the depth at pressure
values 16 and 15 MPa whereas depth variation occurred for pressure values 14–8 MPa
is shown in Fig. 4.
The trend of groove depth is similar for higher pressure i.e. 16 and 15 MPa while
the depth profile shows uniformity in the trend for the working pressure below 15 MPa
up to 8 MPa. The depth of the grooves increases with an increase in the stand-off
distance until an optimum point and then decreases with further increase in the stand-
off distance [17]. The reason for such trend can be stated as the non-formation of fully
developed pulsations during the initial stage of the flow at a lower stand-off distance. In
absence of these pulsations, it acts as a continuous liquid jet leading to ineffective and
shallower disintegration groove. However, with an increase in the stand-off distance,
the liquid jet enters a transition zone in which fully developed liquid wave fronts are
produced having significant amount of energy which when impacts the material surface
causes considerable plastic deformation. These plastic deformation leads to compres-
sion of nearby surrounding material, inducing stress in the surface and sub-surface. Due
to this phenomenon deeper grooves are formed at a higher stand-off distance. Upon
68 A. Nag et al.
Fig. 2. Traces on sample created at pressures levels from 16 to 8 MPa, using physiological
saline.
Fig. 3. Variation of depth at 16 MPa and 15 MPa pressure with variable standoff distance.
further increase in the stand-off distance, the influence of external atmosphere becomes
dominant causing the high velocity jet to break down into clusters of droplets of liquid.
This phenomenon makes the pulsations lose its disintegrating ability and leads to a
lower depth of the grooves. The working pressure also influences the erosion capability
of the jet [16]. With an increase in pressure, the kinetic energy with which the jet exit
the nozzle increases which in turn increases the impact energy. This jet when strikes the
Investigation on Pulsating Liquid Jet 69
Fig. 4. Variation of depth at 14–8 MPa pressure with variable standoff distance.
surface of the material induces stresses higher than the ultimate strength of the material,
causing it to deform. Due to this deformation, larger material erosion takes place and
deeper grooves are formed. For a working pressure of 16 MPa and 15 MPa, the pro-
cess shows larger disintegrating property in form of grooves which starts to be visible
for stand-off distance as small as 1 mm and increases with the increase in distance.
After a certain increase in depth, it decreases with further increase in the stand-off
distance due to breaking up of jet in clusters of liquid droplets. The erosion depth
obtained at 16 MPa pressure was higher than compared to 15 MPa due to higher
momentum exchange between the jet and the material. For grooves formed by working
pressure lower than 13 MPa does not show any traces of erosion for a 1 mm stand-off
distance. However, for higher stand-off distance distinguishable groves were formed.
The maximum depth value of the grooves obtained for each working pressure,
decreases with the decrease in the pressure. Grooves created while disintegrating the
material at 8 MPa were noticeable only for 3 mm and 4 mm stand-off distance due to
low pressure values. The results of the experiments showed that a deeper removal of
material can be achieved by proper selection of values of input parameters.
4 Conclusion
Disintegration of material using saline jet was carried out effectively. Distinguishable
grooves caused due to erosion of aluminium were observed over material surface. The
results showed that at a lower value of nozzle distance from the surface (1–2 mm),
shallow groove depth were obtained. However, with an increase in the nozzle distance
(3–4 mm), the depth of the grooves increased steadily and maximum depth was
obtained at this range of standoff distance. With a larger increase in the standoff
distance (5–6 mm), the pulsation loses its effectiveness and again a low depth grooves
70 A. Nag et al.
are obtained. Fluid pressure also influenced the depth proportionally i.e. with increase
in fluid pressure the depth of the grooves increased. Maximum mean depth of
182.69 µm was observed at 16 MPa pressure and 2 mm Standoff distance.
The experimentation with saline fluid opens a new direction for research involving
disintegration of biomaterials such as bone cement, whose bio-physical properties gets
disturb while being disintegrated by non-bio compatible methods. Using 0.9% physi-
ological saline jet at low pressure values in PLJ can overcome the demerit faced by
other techniques and can be effectively used for medical purposes.
References
1. Barham, D.K., Buchanan, D.J.: A review of water jet assisted cutting techniques for rock and
coal cutting machines. Min. Eng. 6–14 (1987)
2. Folkes, J.: Waterjet—An innovative tool for manufacturing. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 209,
6181–6189 (2009)
3. Van den Berg, R.W., Hoogland, H., Lelieveld, H.L.M., Van Schepdael, L.: High pressure
equipment designs for food processing applications. In: Ultra High Pressure Treatments of
Foods, pp. 297–313. Springer (2001)
4. Ozcelik, Y., Tercan, A.E., Yilmazkaya, E., Ciccu, R., Costa, G.: A Study of nozzle angle in
stone surface treatment with water jets. Constr. Build. Mater. 25, 4271–4278 (2011)
5. Kong, C.: Water-Jet Cutting BT - CIRP Encyclopedia of Production Engineering. Presented
at the (2014)
6. Hloch, S., Hlaváček, J., Vasilko, K., Cárach, J., Samardžić, I., Kozak, D., Hlavatý, I.,
Ščučka, J.J., Klich, J., Klichová, D.: Abrasive waterjet (AWJ) titanium tangential turning
evaluation. Metalurgija 53, 537–540 (2014)
7. Cárach, J., Hloch, S., Petrů, J., Nag, A., Gombár, M., Hromasová, M.: Hydroabrasive
disintegration of rotating Monel K-500 workpiece. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 96, 981–
1001 (2018)
8. Nag, A., Srivastava, A.K., Dixit, A.R., Chattopadhyaya, S., Mandal, A., Klichová, D.,
Hlaváček, P., Zeleňák, M., Hloch, S.: Influence of abrasive water jet turning parameters on
variation of diameter of hybrid metal matrix composite. In: Applications of Fluid Dynamics,
pp. 495–504. Springer (2018)
9. Nag, A., Ščučka, J., Hlavacek, P., Klichová, D., Srivastava, A.K., Hloch, S., Dixit, A.R.,
Foldyna, J., Zelenak, M.: Hybrid aluminium matrix composite AWJ turning using olivine
and Barton garnet. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 94, 2293–2300 (2018)
10. Azmir, M.A., Ahsan, A.K.: Investigation on glass/epoxy composite surfaces machined by
abrasive water jet machining. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 198, 122–128 (2008)
11. Honl, M., Rentzsch, R., Müller, G., Brandt, C., Bluhm, A., Hille, E., Louis, H., Morlock, M.:
The use of water-jetting technology in prostheses revision surgery—first results of parameter
studies on bone and bone cement. J. Biomed. Mater. Res., Part A 53, 781–790 (2000)
12. Nebeker, E.B., Rodriguez, S.E.: Percussive water jets for rock cutting. In: Proceedings of the
Third International Symposium on Jet Cutting Technology, pp. 11–13 (1976)
13. Shen, Z.H., Wang, Z.M.: Theoretical analysis of a jetdriven Helmholtz resonator and effect
of its configuration on the water jet cutting property. In: Proceedings of the 9th Int.
Symposium of Jet Cutting Technology/Cranfield, pp. D4–189 (1988)
14. Vijay, M.M.: Ultrasonically generated cavitating or interrupted jet (1992)
15. Foldyna, J., Svehla, B.: Method of generation of pressure pulsations and apparatus for
implementation of this method (2010)
Investigation on Pulsating Liquid Jet 71
16. Hloch, S., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Zeleňák, M., Hlaváček, P., Hvizdoš, P., Kľoc, J., Monka,
P., Monková, K., Kozak, D., Magurová, D.: Disintegration of bone cement by continuous
and pulsating water jet. Tech. Gaz. 20, 593–598 (2013)
17. Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Ščučka, J., Martinec, P., Valíček, J., Páleníková, K.: Effects of
pulsating water jet impact on aluminium surface. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 209, 6174–
6180 (2009)
18. Lehocka, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Krolczyk, J.B., Carach, J., Krolczyk, G.M.:
Copper alloys disintegration using pulsating water jet. Meas. J. Int. Meas. Confed. 82, 375–
383 (2016)
19. Foldyna, J., Klich, J., Hlavacek, P., Zelenak, M., Scucka, J.: Erosion of Metals by Pulsating
Water Jet. Teh. Vjesn. Gaz. 19, 381–386 (2012)
20. Bodnárová, L., Sitek, L., Hela, R., Foldyna, J.: New potentional of high-speed water jet
technology for renovating concrete structures. Slovak J. Civ. Eng. 19, 1–7 (2011)
21. Lehocká, D., Klichová, D., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Hvizdoš, P., Fides, M., Botko, F.:
Comparison of the influence of acoustically enhanced pulsating water jet on selected surface
integrity characteristics of CW004A copper and CW614 N brass. Measurement 110, 230–
238 (2017)
22. Hloch, S., Foldyna, J., Pude, F., Kľoc, J., Zeleňák, M., Hvizdoš, P., Monka, P., Smolko, I.,
Ščučka, J., Kozak, D.: Experimental in-vitro bone cements disintegration with ultrasonic
pulsating water jet for revision arthroplasty. Teh. Vjesn. Znan. časopis Teh. Fak. Sveučilišta
u Osijeku. 22, 1609–1615 (2015)
Parametric Study During Abrasive Water Jet
Turning of Hybrid Metal Matrix Composite
1 Introduction
In the present scenario of manufacturing industries, the demand for a new class
of engineering materials is escalating continuously. Such materials must possess
exceptional properties like high strength to weight ratio, better wear and corrosion
resistance, high thermal and electrical conductivity, etc. The combination of these
properties in a particular material accelerates the manufacturing of advanced materials
like composites [1]. Among all types of composites, metal matrix composites (MMCs)
are one of the superior materials for engineering applications. MMCs are the homo-
geneous phase of two distinct materials. One is a metallic phase of matrix and other is a
non-metallic phase of reinforcement which is dispersed in the matrix of metallic phase
[2]. In the automobile industry, aluminium based MMCs (AMMCs) are used at a larger
scale due to its favourable properties like lightweight, upgraded mechanical and
thermal properties, better corrosive and wear resistance [3]. MMCs have favorable
mechanical and physical properties, but the machinability of these materials is still a
challenging task. MMCs have high hardness, and the presence of the hard ceramic
particle, which is abrasive in nature leads to the reduced machining results low tool life
[4]. Conventional machining, particularly turning is widely used for most of the
MMCs, but due to high tool wear, it proves expensive [5]. From past few years, the
development of non-conventional turning is introduced as a substitute of conventional
turning which provides better machining results [6]. The newly developed turning
methods in the non-conventional field is abrasive waterjet turning (AWJT). The turning
mechanisms of these methods are different to conventional methods like it does not
involve the physical contact of tools to the workpiece material [7]. Abrasive waterjet
machining (AWJM) removes the workpiece material by plastic deformation caused due
to the impact force of high-velocity abrasive particle entrained in the high-pressure
water jet [8]. This technique was initially used for cutting of rocks and mining purposes
[9]. Abrasive waterjet turning (AWJT) is a variant of AWJM in which a rotary axis
added to the traditional AWJ setup to machine the cylindrical workpiece. In this
process, the machining starts at the circumference of the workpiece and is slowly fed
along workpiece axis [10]. In AWJT, the jet strikes the workpiece surface at a par-
ticular angle and moves in the axial direction to lengthen the cutting operation [11].
Many researchers have done many experiments using AWJT. Some of the sig-
nificant works are mentioned here. Hashish [12] first investigated the turning operation
via abrasive waterjet process. The first operation was done on MMC of magnesium
boron carbide, glass and aluminium to make specimens for tensile testing. Effect
of traverse speed, rotation speed, jet angle, and lateral feed increment has been dis-
cussed to express the surface quality and texture. Hloch et al. [9] performed tangential
turning on titanium grade 3 using abrasive waterjet at varying traverse speed
(1.5 to 7.5 mm/min). The workpiece diameter was taken 55 mm and abrasive used was
garnet (60 mesh size). Hlavacek et al. [10] investigated the effect of traverse speed,
rotational speed and direction of rotation on surface quality of sandstone workpiece
with AWJ turning. The diameter of workpiece was taken 50 mm. The traverse speed
and rotational speed were considered as a variable process and made in the range of 10
to 60 mm/min and 17 to 34 rpm respectively. Sitek and Hlavacek [13] discussed
the positive and negative aspects of the AWJ turning process and also examine
the behaviour of various materials like rocks, woods, graphite and several metals.
Carach et al. [14] studied the influence of traverse speed on machined surface while
turning Incoloy alloy 925. The drilling of hybrid MMC A356/Sic/Mica was reported by
Rajmohan and Palanikumar [15]. They studied the effect of machining parameters on
thrust force, surface roughness and burr height. RSM techniques has been applied to
get the set of optimized process parameters. Srivastava et al. [16] provided the com-
prehensive development in the field of non-conventional machining on composite
materials. They also discussed the merits and demerits of AWJ process over other
conventional and non-conventional methods regarding machining performance. Sri-
vastava et al. [17] has discussed the AWJ turning of hybrid MMC to evaluate
the surface integrity by varying the traverse speed. They reported the elements
of surface integrity such as roughness parameters, 3D surface visualization, surface
74 A. K. Srivastava et al.
topography and surface morphology. Lehocka et al. [18] has compared the surface
integrity of copper (CW004A) and brass (CW614 N) after acoustically enhanced
pulsed waterjet cutting. They discuss the strengthening of surface and subsurface
layers. Optical profilometry was used to discuss the topographical descriptions. Ravi
Kumar et al. [19] has worked on abrasive waterjet machining of aluminium/tungsten
carbide composites. They discuss the effect of process parameters on machining out-
comes as well as microstructural changes. Srivastava [20] investigated the effect of
peening on austenitic stainless steel by ultrasonically assisted pulsating waterjet. Sur-
face residual stresses, microhardness and topographical studies were determined at
varying traverse speed ranges from 0.25 mm/sec to 2 mm/sec. By the literature above,
it can be concluded that the AWJ turning process still needs a detailed study for precise
solutions like improved surface integrity and better output responses. The aim of the
present study is to examine the effect of process parameters of AWJ turning on
machining outcomes such as surface roughness and MRR.
2 Experimental Procedure
In this study, A359 alloy is used as a base metal. The elemental composition of the
A359 alloy is given in Table 1. The reinforcements are used as B4C and Al2O3. The
thermophysical properties of all selected materials are given in Table 2. The particles
size of the reinforcement materials Al2O3 and B4C are 15 lm and 30 lm, respectively.
These reinforcements are added to the matrix material in the portions of 2%, each by
weight.
Table 3. Basic physical and mechanical properties of the tested hybrid MMC A359/Al2O3/B4C
[22].
Composite Density Strength Hardness Thermal Toughness
(gm/cm3) (MPa) (HRC) conductivity (J/m2)
(W/m.K)
A359/Al2O3/B4C 2.723 119.2 54.4 136 10.1
The water pressure is generated by PTV75-60 pump with two pressure intensifiers
(operating pressure of 40–415 MPa, max. flow of 7.8 lmin−1 at 415 MPa). The pro-
cess parameters selected for the study purpose are abrasive mass flow rate, traverse
speed of nozzle and rotational speed of workpiece. The working range of these process
parameters is decided by machine specifications and from the results of the pilot runs.
Table 4 shows the process parameters for AWJ turning and their level of design.
Table 4. Variable process parameters in AWJT process and their level of design.
S. No. Process parameters Symbol Level of
design
−1 0 +1
1 Abrasive mass flow rate (gm/min) A 200 300 400
2 Traverse speed (mm/min) B 10 20 30
3 Rotational speed (rpm) C 200 400 600
The other technological parameters are kept constant and are given in Table 5.
Three levels of machining are decided for each process parameter. A cylindrical
workpiece of selected hybrid MMC of diameter 20 mm is used for turning purpose.
Each experiment is performed for 10 mm turning length, and a depth of cut is 4 mm.
The turning operation of AWJT is shown in Fig. 1.
Two output responses namely surface roughness and MRR were selected to
evaluate the machining performance. Response surface methodology (RSM) is used to
analyse and optimise the response variables. Minitab 17 software is used to develop the
model and mathematical relations by the Box-Behnken design of response surface
methodology. The box-Behnken design is selected for all combination of the factors at
three levels (high +1 and low −1), three central points at confidence level 95% and
significance level 5%. The process involved 15 experimental observations at random
sets of the design of three input variables.
The machinability of hybrid MMC is analysed for AWJ turning. Table 6 shows
the experimental design and set of input parameters for each experiment along with
experimental observations of output responses. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) test
is conducted to verify the significance of the model, model terms, lack of fits and error.
Table 7 shows the ANOVA results for surface roughness and MRR.
From the ANOVA results, it is clear that the quadratic mathematical model
designed for all response variables are significant for the analysis. It is indicated from
the ANOVA table that all three process parameters have a significant effect
on the responses surface roughness and MRR. The calculated F-values are found
greater than the standard F-values (6.61) for the significant terms. It indicates
the negligible effect of residuals in the model which is desirable for an error proof
equation. The final predicted regression equations regarding coded factors for surface
roughness and MRR are shown in Eqs. 1 and 2.
Surface roughness ðlmÞ ¼ 9:860 0:00644 Abrasive mass flow rate 0:0306 Traverse Speed
þ 0:00022 Rotational speed 0:000003 Abrasive mass flow rate2
þ 0:000861 Traverse Speed2 þ 0:000002 Rotational speed2
ð1Þ
þ 0:000061 Abrasive mass flow rate Traverse Speed
0:000007 Abrasive mass flow rate Rotational speed
0:000018 Traverse Speed Rotational speed
Parametric Study During Abrasive Water Jet 77
Table 7. (continued)
Source SS DOF MS F F Value p-value
Value (std)
Rotational speed 7090.02 1 7090.0 632.43 6.61 <0.0001
Abrasive mass flow 1077.81 1 1077.8 96.14 6.61 0.0002
rate Traverse Speed
Abrasive mass flow 390.06 1 390.06 34.79 6.61 0.0020
rate Rotational speed
Traverse speed Rotational 274.56 1 274.56 24.49 6.61 0.0043
speed
Residual 56.05 5 11.21
Lack of fit 34.60 3 11.53 1.08 5.41 0.5150
Pure error 21.45 2 10.73
Cor total 23277.70 14
R-Sqr. = 99.76% Adj R-Sqr. = 99.33% Pre. R-Sqr. 97.41%
MRR mm3 =min ¼ 599:4 0:342 Abrasive mass flow rate 2:353 Traverse Speed
0:0056 Rotational speed þ 0:000242 Abrasive mass flow rate2
0:0858 Traverse Speed2 þ 0:000261 Rotational speed2
ð2Þ
þ 0:01641 Abrasive mass flow rate Traverse Speed
þ 0:000494 Abrasive mass flow rate Rotational speed
0:004142 Traverse Speed Rotational speed
From the ANOVA table, it is clear that all three process parameters have a sig-
nificant effect on surface roughness and MRR of the machined surface. From the
response table, it is also revealed that the minimum surface roughness measured
as 6.0545 µm at abrasive mass flow rate 400 gm/min, traverse speed 20 mm/min
and rotational speed 600 rpm. The maximum surface roughness value is 8.3825 µm
at abrasive mass flow rate 200 gm/min, traverse speed 30 mm/min and rotational speed
400 rpm. The similar range of values were also reported by other researchers [23, 24].
The maximum MRR is measured as 565.02 mm3/min at an abrasive mass flow rate
400 gm/min, traverse speed 20 mm/min and rotational speed 200 rpm. The minimum
MRR is measured as 434.72 mm3/min at an abrasive mass flow rate 200 gm/min,
traverse speed 20 mm/min and rotational speed 600 rpm. Figure 2 shows the 3D
response surfaces of surface roughness against each set of process parameters.
The effect of individual parameters on surface roughness indicated that while
increasing the abrasive mass flow rate and rotational speed, surface roughness
decreases. However, the surface gets rougher at a higher traverse speed of nozzle. It is
due to the fact that the material removal in AWJ process shows the plough nature [17,
22]. If abrasive mass flow rate increases then the mixture of abrasive and water
becomes homogeneous. It increases the continuity in jet density from entry to exit,
which reduces the plough nature and creates a smoother surface. The increase of
traverse speed reduces the interaction of abrasive particle at the machined surface,
Parametric Study During Abrasive Water Jet 79
which leads to increase in the ploughing nature and hence increases the roughness. In
case of MRR (Fig. 3), the analysis of individual process parameters shows that by
increasing the abrasive mass flow rate, MRR also increases. On the other hand, at
increasing traverse speed and the rotational speed of workpiece, MRR decreases. This
is due to the fact that with increase in rotational speed, the deviation of jet increases
which does not allow effective interaction with rotating workpiece and the abrasive jet.
Due to this at higher rpm a lower MRR is obtained. Increasing the abrasive mass flow
rate enhances the number of abrasives striking per unit area of the machined surface
hence the MRR increases.
The above Figs. 2 and 3 revels the effect of individual parameters on the machining
outcomes when it is considers separately. However, it is a difficult task to set the
optimized set of process parameters to get both responses (minimum surface roughness
and maximum MRR) in a single experimental run. Hence, the composite desirability
approach is used to identify the values of process parameters to get a combined
optimised response. The objective is to minimize the surface roughness and maximise
MRR. The feasible response values and corresponding process parameter values are
shown in Fig. 4. The intersection point of red colour line and the response curve will
considered as optimized value of the individual process parameter. It also indicated that
at abrasive mass flow rate of 400 gm/min, traverse speed 10 mm/min and rotational
speed nearly 260 rpm, the optimized set of output responses (minimum surface
roughness 6.1814 µm and maximum MRR 577.94 mm3/min) can be achieved. The
graph indicates that the composite desirability for optimised responses is 93.47%.
It indicates that, if both the response are desired in a single experiment then it can be
achieved by 93.47% of their individual responses.
The modified desirability value of surface roughness and MRR is 87.41%, 99.94%,
respectively. A confirmation experiment was performed to check the validity
of the predicted model. The surface roughness and MRR values are measured
as 6.2565 µm and 561.325 mm3/min, respectively. From results, it can be concluded
that the experimental values are nearly close to the predicted values and hence, proves a
suitable mathematical model for a combined set of machining responses.
4 Conclusion
From the results, it can be concluded that AWJ turning processes can be successfully
applied for the turning of hybrid MMC workpiece. In this case, the material eroded
from the cylindrical surface by striking of high-speed abrasive particles on the
machined surface. The surface roughness is found in the range of 6.0545 µm
to 8.3825 µm, which is quite higher. This is due to the plough nature of AWJ process
with full of furrows and cutting traces which leads to the significantly higher surface
roughness. Another reason of higher surface roughness is the dislodgment of rein-
forcement particles which are not able to cut during turning operation. The minimum
and maximum MRR found in AWJ turning process is 434.72 mm3/min and 565.02
mm3/min, respectively. However, the present work is limited to the machining behavior
of the produced hybrid MMC in terms of surface roughness and MRR only. The other
related works like surface quality can also be considered as future work. The other
methods of non-conventional machining like laser turning can also develop to compare
the machining results and surface quality.
References
1. Srivastava, A., Dixit, A.R., Tiwari, S.: Experimental investigation of wire EDM process
parameters on aluminum metal matrix composite Al2024/SiC. Int. J. Adv. Res. Innov. 2,
511–515 (2014)
2. Hull, D., Clyne, T.W.: An Introduction to Composite Materials. Cambridge Univ. Press,
Cambridge (1996)
3. Rohatgi, P.K., Guo, R.Q., Huang, P., Ray, S.: Friction and abrasion resistance of cast
aluminium alloy- fly ash composites. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 28, 245–250 (1997)
4. Garg, H.K., Verma, K., Manna, A., Kumar, R.: Hybrid metal matrix composites and further
improvement in their machinability- A review. Int. J. Latest Res. Sci. Technol. 1(1), 36–44
(2012)
5. Blickwedel, H., Guo, N.S., Haferkamp, H., Louis, H.: Prediction of abrasive jet cutting
performance and quality. In: Proceedings of the 10th International Symposium on Jet
Cutting Technology, pp. 163–179. Amsterdam, Netherland (1990)
6. Muller, F., Monaghan, J.: Non-conventional machining of particle reinforced metal matrix
composite. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 40, 1351–1366 (2000)
Parametric Study During Abrasive Water Jet 83
23. Nag, A., Srivastava, A.K., Dixit, A.R., Chattopadhyaya, S., Mandal, A., Klichová, D.,
Hlaváček, P., Zeleňák, M., Hloch, S.: Influence of abrasive water jet turning parameters on
variation of diameter of hybrid metal matrix composite. In: Applications of Fluid Dynamics.
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5329-
0_36
24. Mardi, K.B., Dixit, A.R., Srivastava, A.K., Mallick, A., Scucka, J., Hlaváček, P., Hloch, S.,
Zeleňák, M.: Effect of water pressure during abrasive waterjet machining of Mg-based
nanocomposite. Applications of Fluid Dynamics. Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering
(2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5329-0_46
Effect of Frequency Change During Pulsed
Waterjet Interaction with Stainless Steel
Abstract. In the present work a detailed effect of pulsating water jet treatment
with the variation of standoff distance on the flat austenitic stainless steel surface
has been studied. During the experimentation, at a traverse speed of 30 mm/s
accidently the change in frequency was encountered in the repeated test (under
same treatment condition) which has been reported in this work. The frequency
was changed from f = 20.11 kHz to f = 20.27 kHz during the treatment process
at the pressure of p = 70 MPa with variation in standoff distance was increased
from z = 5 mm up to z = 101 mm (with step distance of 2 mm between suc-
cessive standoff distance). The change in microstructural topography of the
treated surface under the above-mentioned conditions was observed using
scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The strengthening mechanism on the
surface and sub-surface region due to the plastic deformation phenomenon
caused by the impact of the pulsating jet was evaluated by Vickers micro-
hardness test. The micro hardness test was conducted along the depth of the
treated region to analyze the effects in the sub-surface layers. Also, the erosion
stages at different standoff distance was evaluated by scanning the surface by
optical MicroProf FRT profilometer in order to analyze the nature of erosion
phenomenon with the variation of standoff distance and frequency during the
treatment process. The results obtained indicates that the change in frequency of
the pulsations and the variation in standoff distance has a significant impact on
the surface integrity of the treated material. As compare to the untreated surface
the hardness of the treated surface was increased up to a certain depth and the
higher frequency of pulsations has shown better improvement in the hardness
values. The above observations elaborated the effect of an important parameter
frequency and standoff distance for better and effective utilization of the tech-
nology for the surface treatment application.
1 Introduction
The striking advantages of water jet technology over the years makes it useful for wide
areas of application like cutting, cleaning, surface layer removal, disintegration [1] etc.
However, still the efforts are made to improve the performance of technology from the
environmental and economical point of view [2]. With the recent growth and devel-
opment in the industrialization and technologies, it has become essential to adopt a
method which reduces the power consumption and cost while maintaining its quality.
In view of this the water jet technology has undergone various modifications. In the
recent years a new method of saving the energy and reducing the power consumption is
adopted by increasing the efficiency of the jet in form of pressure pulsations. This
method focusses on the generation of pulses via means of acoustic generators where the
pressure pulsations are initiated by acoustic actuator present inside the acoustic
chamber [3]. The acoustic actuator converts the electric power into mechanical
vibrations and are amplified by the mechanical amplifier. These amplified vibrations
are then transferred from the liquid waveguide to the nozzle system. The acoustic
chamber is equipped with tunable resonant chamber for matching the natural frequency
of the system to the frequency of pressure pulsations [3]. However, there are other
methods adopted for pulse generation like nozzles integrated with mechanical devices,
self-resonating nozzles and ultrasonic nozzles but these methods have certain disad-
vantages like the lifetime of the moving components in mechanical devices is low, in
self-resonating nozzles low depth of modulations of a liquid jet is obtained and in
ultrasonic nozzles high wear rate of the tip of the vibrating transformer and the
increased weight of the cutting tool [3]. The method of generation pulsations by
acoustic generator overcomes the above disadvantages. This method of pulse genera-
tion has been investigated for various applications in the recent years like disintegration
of materials like copper [4], aluminium [5], bone cement [6], stainless steel [2],
descaling applications [7], renovating of concrete surfaces [8], disintegration of rocks
[9]. Foldyna et al. [2] studied the influence of pulsating water jet impact on the erosion
pattern of austenitic stainless steel at an operating pressure of 10 MPa, 20 MPa and
30 MPa. A three stage erosion phenomenon occurred during the treatment process: in
the first stage plastic or brittle deformation in the impacted zone occurs, in the second
stage formation of erosion pits and its merging to form erosion crater takes place, in the
third stage the depth of these craters increases. Foldyna et al. [5] also investigated the
effect of pulsating water jet impact on aluminium surface where the aluminium sample
surface was exposed to various pulsating jets under different operating conditions. The
resulting surface was analyzed using optical microscopy and image analysis and was
observed that pulsating water jet erodes aluminium surface deeply and effectively at a
low pressure of 20 MPa. Klich et al. [10] also observed the effect of pulsating water jet
on aluminium alloy with variously modified surfaces using fan jet nozzle of 2 mm
diameter and 10° splash angle. The erosion of the surface layers were analyzed and its
relation with the varying traverse speed at constant z = 55 mm was studied. The results
obtained by surface roughness analysis showed that the initial surface properties has a
significant effect on the final topography. While investigating the surface topography
obtained by disintegrating the copper alloys (brass and bronze) using pulsating water
Effect of Frequency Change During Pulsed Waterjet Interaction 87
jet [4] (using flat nozzle at a pressure of 40 MPa with z = 55 mm) it was observed that
the average value of the roughness parameters was effected by the tensile strength and
hardness value of the material. At higher traverse speed and number of transitions
lower surface roughness was obtained in bronze however, in the case of brass at lower
traverse speed and the lower number of transitions are suitable surface was obtained.
These applications majorly focused on understanding how variation in process
parameters like jet pressure, traverse speed of the nozzle, diameter and geometry of the
nozzle affects the performance of the technology and its comparison to the other
technologies (continuous water jet, abrasive water jet) [11], but none of these studies
focused on understanding the effect of variation of the standoff distance and frequency
of pulsation during the treatment by ultrasonically generated pulsed water jet. The
present study focusses on determining optimum standoff distance for the surface
treatment application and also the effect of change in frequency of pulsation (which
was encountered accidently during the treatment process) on the surface quality has
been reported.
Initially, the erosion phenomenon on flat austenitic stainless steel (AISI 304) sur-
face with the variation of standoff distance was explored by evaluating the depth of the
treated region using optical MicroProf FRT profilometer. Further, the microstructural
topography of the treated region at various standoff distances was observed under a
scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The strengthening effect of the technology was
evaluated by the micro hardness measurements which was conducted along the depth
of the treated surface using Vickers micro hardness tester. Overall, this study elaborated
the effect of an important parameters standoff distance and frequency of pulsations for
better and effective utilization of the technology for the surface treatment application.
The austenitic stainless steel 304 grade was selected as the material due to its signif-
icant properties like corrosive resistance, high toughness, formability, ductility and
drawability [12]. It is being used for wide applications in mechanical, automotive and
nuclear industries [13]. The stainless steel of grade 304 has also its application in
orthopedics, food and chemical processing industries [14].
The stainless steel AISI 304 sample of size 1000 mm 100 mm 10 mm having
mechanical and chemical properties mentioned in Table 1 was subjected to the treat-
ment process under pulsating water jet machine. The pulsating water jet machine
constitutes: a HAMMELMANN HDP 253 plunger pump (maximum operating pres-
sure of 250 MPa and flow rate of 40 l/min), an ABB robot IRB 6640–180/2.55 which
controls the motion of the PWJ head, and an ultrasonic generator ECOSON WJ-UG-
630-40 which contributes to the pulse generation.
The sample was clamped on the working table with the pulsating water jet head
positioning at 90° to the treated surface (Fig. 1(a)). The treatment was performed under
the experimental conditions mentioned in Table 2 with variation in z from 5 mm to
101 mm (z changing by 2 mm at every 20 mm treated region) under each condition
(Fig. 1(b)).
88 M. Srivastava et al.
Fig. 1. (a) Experimental setup (b) Scheme adopted for treating the surface by varying the
standoff distance from zmin (minimum standoff distance) to zmax (maximum standoff distance)
Effect of Frequency Change During Pulsed Waterjet Interaction 89
In order to understand the erosion phenomenon under the subjected conditions the
treated regions (Fig. 2) was scanned using optical MicroProf FRT profilometer and the
depth of each region was evaluated using SPIP 6.6.1 software. The surface topography
of the treated region was analyzed under a scanning electron microscopy (SEM). To
determine the effect of this plastic deformation the hardness measurements along the
depth of the treated region was conducted using Vickers Hardness testing machine
Shimadzu HMV Micro Hardness Tester under a load of 50 g for 10 s.
Fig. 3. Effect of variation of standoff distance on the surface treated with changing frequencies
on depth of the treated surface.
It is evident from the plot Fig. 3 that the slight change in frequency effects the
erosion phenomenon on the treated surface when the other parameters remains con-
stant. In the region between z = 35 mm to 65 mm for the frequency of 20.11 kHz the
erosion effect was prominent and for the frequency 20.27 kHz the z = 55 mm to
75 mm showed the erosion effect. The change in the range of erosion effect with the
changing frequency is due to the break up length of the pulsating water jet i.e. with an
Effect of Frequency Change During Pulsed Waterjet Interaction 91
increase in frequency pulses of shorter length will be produced [5]. The difference in
the peak values of the depth obtained under both the frequency conditions is due to the
effect of the striking pulse which hits with maximum energy at the peaks of the
wavefront. In case of high frequency, f = 20.27 kHz the jet didn’t strike the surface at
the peak of the wavefront hence the depth obtained in this condition is low as compare
to the depth obtained in low frequency (f = 20.11 kHz). The change in frequency
encountered during the treatment process is potentially due to the wear of the
sonotrode.
The changes in the microstructural topography observed with the variation in the
standoff distance is attributed to the frequency of the impacting jet with high pressure.
effect of variation of standoff distance (at a pressure p = 70 MPa and traverse speed
v = 30 mm/s) for both the frequencies was plotted as a function of depth along the
treated surface (Figs. 6 and 7). The indentation points along the depth of the treated
surface made during the measurements is shown in Fig. 5.
Fig. 6. Hardness measurements along the depth of the treated region at p = 70 MPa,
v = 30 mm.s −1, f = 20.11 kHz.
For both the frequencies as compare to the hardness of initial untreated sample
there was a significant increase in the hardness observed after the treatment process by
pulsating water jet. At the frequency of f = 20.11 kHz, up to the depth of approxi-
mately 180 µm there was an increase in the hardness values in the sub-surface layers
with a maximum hardness of 503 HV at the depth of 30 µm. Also, it was observed that
for lower z = 43 mm the maximum increase in the hardness was recorded. This is
because the pulsations generated at this standoff distance are well developed and has
sufficient impacting energy to cause large plastic deformation on the impacting surface
and therefore, affecting its sub-surface layers. This observation is also very much
evident from the surface topography at the z = 43 mm (Fig. 4(a)). Further, when the
frequency of the pulsations was slightly increased to f = 20.27 kHz similar trend was
observed as in the previous case. The increase in hardness was observed up to the depth
of approximately 180 µm with maximum hardness recorded as 518 HV at the depth of
30 µm. However, no particular trend was observed with the variation of z. The max-
imum increase in the hardness was recorded at z = 61 mm. This again corresponds to
94 M. Srivastava et al.
Fig. 7. Hardness measurements along the depth of the treated region at p = 70 MPa,
v = 30 mm.s −1, f = 20.27 kHz.
the surface topography of the region treated at z = 61 mm where the deep pits were
observed due to the large plastic deformation caused by the impacting jets.
4 Conclusion
• The different stages of erosion phenomenon observed during the variation of the
standoff distance may be useful in determining the range of parameters for the
surface treatment application.
• The microhardness of the sub-surface along the depth of the treated surface has
been improved as compared to the initial hardness (423 HV) of the untreated
surface. At frequency f = 20.11 kHz and f = 20.27 kHz, the maximum hardness
values obtained were 518 HV and 503 HV respectively at the depth of 30 µm.
Till now not much study has been conducted on using pulsating water jet tech-
nology for the surface treatment application. This study gives a broader aspect of the
variation of parameters like frequency and determining optimum standoff distance
which will be helpful in determining the range parameters for the surface treatment
application with minimal effect on surface roughness. Further, more variations in
frequency parameter can be studied along with the variation in the pressure of the jet
and traverse speed of the nozzle. This will be helpful in understanding the dependency
of frequency parameter on the water jet process parameters.
Acknowledgements. This work was supported by VEGA 1/0096/18 and the joint collaborations
of the Indian Institute of Technology (Indian School of Mines), Dhanbad, India, and the Institute
of Geonics of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Ostrava- Poruba, Czech Republic. The experi-
ments were conducted at the Institute of Geonics of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Ostrava-
Poruba, Czech Republic, with the support of the Institute of Clean Technologies for Mining and
Utilization of Raw Materials for Energy Use - Sustainability Program, Reg. No. LO1406
financed by Ministry of Education, Youth, and Sports, of the Czech Republic, and with the
support for the long-term conceptual development of the research institution RVO: 68145535.
p -pressure [MPa]
−1
v -traverse speed [mm.s ]
f -frequency [kHz]
d -diameter of nozzle [mm]
z -standoff distance [mm]
SEM -scanning electron microscopy
References
1. Foldyna, J.: Use of Acoustic Waves for Pulsating Water Jet Generation. Acoust. Waves -
From Microdevices to Helioseismology. 323–342 (2011)
2. Foldyna, J., Klich, J., Hlavacek, P., Zelenak, M., Scucka, J.: Erosion of metals by pulsating
water jet. Teh. Vjesn. Gaz. 19, 381–386 (2012)
3. Cited, R., Zimmerman, T.G., Alto, P.: US. Patent. 2, 0–3 (1985)
96 M. Srivastava et al.
4. Lehocka, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Krolczyk, J.B., Carach, J., Krolczyk, G.M.:
Copper alloys disintegration using pulsating water jet. Meas. J. Int. Meas. Confed. 82, 375–
383 (2016)
5. Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Ščučka, J., Martinec, P., Valíček, J., Páleníková, K.: Effects of
pulsating water jet impact on aluminium surface. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 209, 6174–
6180 (2009)
6. Hloch, S., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Zeleňák, M., Hlaváček, P., Hvizdoš, P., Kľoc, J., Monka,
P., Monková, K., Kozak, D., Magurová, D.: Disintegration of bone cement by continuous
and pulsating water jet. Tech. Gaz. 3651, 593–598 (1848)
7. Descaling by pulsating water jet. (2015)
8. Sitek, L., Foldyna, J., Martinec, P., Ščučka, J., Bodnárová, L., Hela, R.: Use of pulsating
water jet technology for removal of concrete in repair of concrete structures. Balt. J. Road
Bridg. Eng. 6, 235–242 (2011)
9. Tripathi, R., Srivastava, M., Hloch, S., Chattopadhyaya, S., Das, A.K., Pramanik, A.:
Performance analysis of pulsating water jet machining during disintegration of rocks by
means of acoustic emission, pp. 515–524 (2018)
10. Klich, J., Klichova, D., Foldyna, V., Hlavacek, P., Foldyna, J.: Influence of variously
modified surface of aluminium alloy on the effect of pulsating water jet. Strojniški Vestn.
J. Mech. Eng. 63, 577–582 (2017)
11. Zelenak, M., Foldyna, J., Scucka, J., Hloch, S., Riha, Z.: Visualisation and measurement of
high-speed pulsating and continuous water jets. Meas. J. Int. Meas. Confed. 72, 1–8 (2015)
12. Srivastava, M., Hloch, S., Tripathi, R., Kozak, D., Chattopadhyaya, S., Dixit, A.R., Foldyna,
J., Hvizdos, P., Fides, M., Adamcik, P.: Ultrasonically generated pulsed water jet peening of
austenitic stainless-steel surfaces. J. Manuf. Process. 32, 455–468 (2018)
13. Srivastava, M., Tripathi, R., Hloch, S., Rajput, A., Khublani, D., Chattopadhyaya, S.,
Dixit, A.R., Foldyna, J., Adam, P., Klich, J., Zelenak, M., Klichov, D.: Surface Treatment of
AISI 304 Using Pulsating Water Jet Peening, pp. 535–548 (2018)
14. Arola, D., Alade, A.E., Weber, W.: Improving fatigue strength of metals using abrasive
waterjet peening. Mach. Sci. Technol. 10, 197–218 (2006)
15. Clitheroe, S.L.: The physical and microstructural properties of peened austenitic stainless
steel. Ph.D. thesis, Univ. Manchester (2011)
Microstructure, Properties and Damage
Mechanisms by Water Jet Cutting of TiB2-Ti
Cermets Prepared by SPS
1 Introduction
The titanium diboride ceramics are electrically and thermally conductive materials with
very high hardness, good wear and temperature resistance and with high elastic
modulus. All these properties make it a suitable choice for many applications like
armors, cutting tools, turbine blades, and wear resistant parts working in severe con-
ditions. Preparation of pure titanium diborides, though, is a difficult task and obtaining
a sufficient density requires high sintering temperatures and long dwelling times. This
leads to the intense grain growth causing decrease of mechanical properties, mainly
fracture toughness and strength [1–3]. This unfavorable fact leads to the increasing
effort in the investigation of TiB2 based composites toughened by metal additive.
Composites with Ti addition are interesting materials thanks to their excellent
mechanical and electrical properties. In the present study, TiB2 and TiB2+Ti
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 97–104, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_11
98 V. Puchý et al.
composites were made by pulsed electric current sintering (PECS) or spark plasma
sintering (SPS). The advantage of this sintering technique is in its high heating rates
and short dwell times in comparison with conventional methods [4, 5]. It is considered
that SPS prepared TiB2 material will be used for the surface treatment of titanium and
titanium alloys via electro spark deposition (ESD) method [6]. ESD deposition enables
to produce hard and wear-resistant coatings on metallic substrates. The only essential
condition is that both, substrate and electrode materials, ought to be electrically con-
ductive. Significant advantage is that due to the diffusion of the electrode material into
the substrate and vice versa relatively good bonding between the layer and the substrate
occurs. ESD method enables to use titanium and titanium alloys (thanks to increase of
their surface hardness and wear resistance) as sonotrode cutting tools [7] and also for
biomedical applications in tooth implants [8].
The aim of the present paper is to explore the microstructure and mechanical
properties of TiB2+Ti composites with various amount of Ti, and to investigate the
influence of the two cutting speeds of the abrasive water jet machining on the efficiency
and damage mechanisms of TiB2+Ti composite materials.
HDH Ti powder (purity 99.4%, supplied by Kimet Special Metal Precision Casting
Co., Ltd., China) was used for the investigations. The powder is of typical angular
shape due to the HDH preparation method. Further, TiB2 powder also of angular shape
(purity 99%, -400 mesh, supplied by ESK Ceramics GmbH & Co. KG, Germany) was
used as a matrix powder. The powder size distributions were determined using Fritch
Analysette 22 laboratory equipment. For Ti powder it is d10 = 12 µm, d50 = 25 µm
and d90 = 45 µm. In the case of TiB2 it is d10 = 4 µm, d50 = 16 µm and d90 = 34 µm.
The TiB2 with Ti powder mixture was dry mixed in Turbula mixer (WAB AG,
Switzerland) for 30 min prior SPS. The TiB2+Ti powder was loaded into graphite die
with an inside diameter of 20 mm. SPS (Type HP D 10SD, FCT Systeme, Germany)
was performed in a vacuum (5 Pa). A pulsed direct electric current was applied with a
pulse duration of 15 ms and pause time of 3 ms throughout all the experiments. The
temperature was measured using a top pyrometer focused inside a hole in the punch at
distance of 4 mm from the sample. In the present study, the SPS schedule was varied to
assess the effects of temperature, heat rate and pressure on the glass-ceramic specimens,
as shown in Fig. 1. In all experiments, a minimum pressure of 7 MPa was applied to
ensure constant contact of the electrodes with the die/punch/sample system.
The die/punch assembly was wrapped in a graphite insulating felt and placed in the
SPS. The powder was then heated in low vacuum (10 Pa). The monolithic TiB2 was
densified at 2100 °C and 50 MPa for 10 min, while composites were densified at
1850 °C and 35 MPa for 10 min. The sintering temperature for the composites was
selected based on the fact that the melting point of Ti is 1668 °C. The density was
found using Archimedes method, hardness and indentation fracture toughness by
indentation methods using Vickers diamond tip loaded by 98.1 N. The cutting
experiments were performed on a CNC abrasive water jet machine with a 2D X-Y
cutting table PTV WJ2020-2Z-1xPJ with inclinable cutting head, especially designed
Microstructure, Properties and Damage Mechanisms 99
Fig. 1. Thermal, mechanical loading cycles, densification curves during SPS process of TiB2+Ti
composites and mechanisms of kerf geometry - schematic illustration.
for cutting with water and abrasive water jet. The machine was equipped with pump
pressure 200 MPa. Throughout the experiments, alumina abrasives with mesh size of
80 were used. The abrasives were delivered with feed speed 150 g/min using gravity
feed. The nozzle speeds were 20 mm/min and 200 mm/min. The impact angle was kept
constant at 90º throughout the experiments. The taper produced on kerf walls were
observed by light optical microscope Olympus GX71. The top width and bottom width
were measured using the Image J software for Windows. These width measurements
are used to calculate taper ratio using Eq. (1).
Wt
Kerf taper ratio ¼ ð1Þ
Wb
Where Wt = kerf top width and Wb = kerf bottom width. Depth and width of any
eroded cavity were estimated as the average of five measurements. The specific erosion
rate, ER, rate was calculated as follows:
h:b:vT
ER ¼ ð2Þ
mP
where h is the erosion depth, b is the average eroded width, vT is the traverse rate of the
machining head, and mP is the abrasive mass-flow rate. Because the erosion rate is the
ratio between the volumetric removal rate and the abrasive mass-flow rate, it is given in
mm3/g.
The study was performed to identify significance and influence of process parameters
on microstructure, kerf taper ratio and specific erosion rate of spark plasma sintered
TiB2+Ti composites. Measured results of microstructures, mechanical properties and
erosion parameters are summarized in Tables 1 and 2.
Monolithic TiB2 samples sintered at temperature (2100 °C) with a holding time of
10 min. attained 96.9% of theoretical density whereas TiB2+Ti samples sintered at the
100 V. Puchý et al.
relatively low temperature (1900 °C) attained from 85% to 98.5%. Figure 2 shows the
microstructure of sintered samples. In monolithic TiB2 (Fig. 2a), microstructure
exhibits no grain growth, contains some porosity (<3%), and average grain size is
25 µm. Figure 2b shows the least dense microstructure of TiB2 containing 10 vol.%
Ti. The Ti phase is interconnected and relatively homogenously distributed in the TiB2
matrix. With further increasing amount of Ti the composite density increases again
(Table 1).
Vickers hardness tests specify that the composite materials have a much lower
hardness. The comparative indents of those four materials were made with 9.81 N load.
The hardness of monolith material is about 19.4 GPa while that of the composite
materials is much lower and reaches maximum of about 12.5 GPa for TiB2+20%Ti.
The maximum of observed AWJ cut-edge roughness is 3.89 µm for monolith material
and minimum roughness is 3.61 µm in the case of TiB2+15%Ti composite. It is
observed that roughness decreases with increase in Ti content (Fig. 3) due to less
abrasive particles impingement and overlapping of machining action. As shown in
Table 2, it is clear that decrease in traverse speed decreases in cut-edge roughness due
to increased cutting ability of the jet. Increase of Ti volume in composites results in
decrease in cut-edge roughness due to larger amount of the ductile phase (Ti) which
deforms in plastic way. Also, bottom regions of cut of the composite samples show
more prominent trend to jet deflection Fig. 3d, that is why the bottom kerf width is
significantly smaller than the top one, and in the case of the higher speed 200 mm/min.
the jet did not cut through the material completely (Fig. 5b). During machining, the
AWJ penetrates into composite material easily, but deflection occurs when jet impinges
at Ti interface. Therefore, a sudden variation in jet penetration rate causes painting of
titanium on the cut-edge, Fig. 4d. In the present study, trans-granular cracking is
observed in samples machined with higher traverse speed, trans-granular cracks occur
due to stresses greater than required to generate the crack tips in the material.
Fig. 2. SEM images of the microstructure of monolithic TiB2 (a) and composite TiB2+10%Ti
samples (b).
During AWJ machining, erosive actions remove the material. Also, while gener-
ating the kerf, the expansion of jet makes cavities within the eroded space. The OM,
SEM and confocal microscopy studies show that samples with 10%Ti have rough cut
surface thanks to incomplete distribution of Ti in TiB2 matrix and relatively high
porosity due to imperfect sintering.
Fig. 3. OM of the kerf edges of monolith TiB2 samples (a) jet entry and (b) jet exit and
composite TiB2+15%Ti samples (c) jet entry and (d) jet exit.
102 V. Puchý et al.
In composites with higher amounts of Ti, its distribution in TiB2 matrix is quite
uniform as can be seen from fracture surface SEM images in Fig. 4. Furthermore, the
effect of Ti amount on the microstructure of sintered samples is observable. With the
higher amount of Ti in the samples, Figs. 4a–d show the erosion surfaces. Despite
considerable brittle fractures, ductile erosion areas can be observed in erosion surface
of composite materials. The brittle fracture surfaces are light with visible cracks, while
the ductile erosion or plastic surfaces appears dark. It indicates that the ductile erosion
mechanism does exist and an erosion machining method is dominantly characterized by
the ductile erosion. Titanium film damps the erosion process on the cut-edge surface
due to lower abrasion by water jet that reduces quantity of eroded cavities. Similar
observations are reported in [9, 10] where it was noted that damping is more severe in
erosion resistant materials. Ductile erosion can achieve micromaterial removal and the
eroded surface is smooth without any fracture. Decreasing roughness with increasing
amount of the ductile Ti is documented in Fig. 6. Impacting alumina particles can be
sometimes observed embedded onto the surfaces of the cut, Fig. 5a.
Fig. 4. SEM images of the kerf surface of monolith TiB2 (a), composite TiB2+10%Ti (b),
TiB2+15%Ti (c) and TiB2+20%Ti samples (d).
Microstructure, Properties and Damage Mechanisms 103
Fig. 5. SEM images of a cluster of alumina aggregate particles inside a notch cavity of
TiB2+10%Ti (a) and cut notch of TiB2+20%Ti (b) by cutting speed 200 mm/min.
Fig. 6. Axonometric plots of monolith TiB2 (a), composite TiB2+10%Ti (b), TiB2+15%Ti
(c) and TiB2+20%Ti samples (d) cut-edge surface, cutting speed 20 mm/min., showing
decreasing roughness with increasing Ti content.
4 Conclusions
AWJ cutting of TiB2+Ti composites with 0–20% Ti addition was studied. Kerf taper
ratio, kerf width and specific erosion rate with the composition (microstructure), and
the variation in process parameters have been analyzed. It can be concluded:
1. Cutting-edge surface roughness decreases with increase in amount of Ti.
2. Kerf taper ratio increases and specific erosion rate decreases with increasing Ti
content. Kerf top width decreases with increase in traverse rate.
104 V. Puchý et al.
3. Addition of Ti improved the performance of the composites. The future work will
be devoted to improve their densification and thus to achieve better microstructure.
The effect of the AWJ cutting parameters is worth of further investigation.
Acknowledgement. This work was supported by the projects “CeKSiM”, ITMS 26220120056,
of the Operational Program “Research and Development” financed through ERDF, by APVV-15-
0014 (ProCor) and VEGA 1/0096/18.
References
1. Chao, S., Goldsmith, J., Banerjee, D.: Titanium diboride composite with improved sintering
characteristics. Int. J. Refract. Metal Hard Mater. 49, 314–319 (2015)
2. Chlup, Z., Bača, Ľ., Halasová, M., Neubauer, E., Hadraba, H., Stelzer, N., Roupcová, P.:
Effect of metallic dopants on the microstructure and mechanical properties of TiB2. J. Eur.
Ceram. Soc. 35, 2745–2754 (2015)
3. Huang, S.G., Vanmeensel, K., Malek, O.J.A., Van der Biest, O., Vleugels, J.: Microstructure
and mechanical properties of pulsed electric current sintered B4C–TiB2 composites. Mater.
Sci. Eng. A 528, 1302–1309 (2011)
4. Omori, M.: Sintering, consolidation, reaction and crystal growth by the spark plasma system
(SPS). Mater. Sci. Eng., A 287, 183–188 (2000)
5. Orru, R., Licheri, R., Locci, A.M., Cincotti, A., Cao, G.: Consolidation/synthesis of
materials by electric current activated/assisted sintering. Mater. Sci. Eng. R Rep. 63(4–6),
127–287 (2009)
6. Kováčik, J., Baksa, P., Emmer, Š.: Electro spark deposition of TiB2 layers on Ti6Al4 V
alloy. Acta Metall. Slovaca 22(1), 52–59 (2016)
7. Emmer, Š., Baksa, P., Kováčik, J.: Effect of microstructure on the sonotrode properties of
tool materials Ferro-titanit WFN and steel CPM 10V. Kovove Mater. 53, 423–428 (2015)
8. Viskić, J., Schauperl, Z., Ćatić, A., Balog, M., Krizik, P., Gržeta, B., Popović, J., Ortolan,
S.M., Mehulić, K.: Effects of wire EDM on the microstructure of P/M titanium samples.
Acta Stomatol. Croat. 48(4), 285–291 (2014)
9. Choi, G.S., Choi, G.H.: Process analysis and monitoring in abrasive water jet machining of
alumina ceramics. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 37(3), 295–307 (1997)
10. Momber, A.W., Kovacevic, R.: Hydro-abrasive erosion of refractory ceramics. J. Mater. Sci.
38, 2861–2874 (2003)
Investigation on Feed Rate Influence
on Surface Quality in Abrasive Water Jet
Cutting of Composite Materials, Monitoring
Acoustic Emissions
1 Introduction
Composite materials, like Carbon Fiber Reinforced Plastics (CFRP), are used mainly in
automotive and aerospace industry [1] because of its specific characteristics, such as:
high strength to weight ratio, high modulus, corrosion and thermal resistance [2].
Abrasive water jet is an innovative tool, which can be used for processing all kind
of materials [3]. Water jet processing uses a very high-pressure water jet, which acts
either by itself or in mixing with abrasive particles [4]. This fluid tool can be used for
machining operations, like cutting [3], milling [5] and turning [6].
Using abrasive water jet, materials like titanium alloy, aluminum, stainless-steel,
composites or even ceramics, could be processed at a high dimensional accuracy and a
good surface quality [7]. Because this tool acts with small cutting forces, low
mechanical loading and reduced interface temperature [8], abrasive water jet cutting
(AWJC) is often use in industry for CFRP cutting [9].
The main process parameters of the AWJC process are: water pressure, feed rate,
abrasive mass flow and standoff distance [4]. For manufacturing precise parts with
a low surface roughness, it is important to optimize the process parameters [10]. The
most important parameter is the feed rate because it is adjusted to obtain the quality
characteristics [3]. Increasing the feed rate the surface roughness is increasing also, in
case of composite materials [11].
The AWJC is a complex process, which involves many parameters with a strong
effect on cutting quality. For this reason, non-destructive testing such as Acoustic
emission (AE) is used to study this process [12]. The main application of AE is online
controlling and monitoring of manufacturing processes [13].
AE is an energy wave with high frequency (20 kHz–2 MHz) and low amplitude,
propagated trough the material by a wide range of processes. Acoustic emission (AE) is
defined in standard BSEN1330-9:2000 [14]. During the last 30 years, AE has been
used in monitorization of a wide range of processes like: AWJ cutting [13], milling [15]
and turning [16], evaluation of grinding process, tool wear in turning and milling
processes.
The evaluation of the AE signals, generated by AWJC, is made analyzing the
following parameters: amplitude, frequency [12], bursts energy [13], power spectral
density [14], etc.
In this paper the influence of traverse feed rate on the surface roughness of the cut
surface is studied using AE signal generated.
The surface cut by AWJC is divided in three zones: initial damage zone, smooth
cutting zone and rough cutting zone (see Fig. 1) [4]. To understand the influence of this
main process parameter, traverse feed rate on surface quality, each zone must be
analyzed.
Fig. 1. The main zones of a surface cut Fig. 2. Omax 2626 abrasive waterjet center.
by AWJC [4].
2 Experimental Procedure
The experimental study was conducted on an abrasive waterjet center, Omax 2626, (see
Fig. 2). It is equipped with an OMAX high pressure pump (output pressure of maxi-
mum 400 MPa) and an electronic abrasive delivery system Alffi (0–600 g/min). The
cutting system used in this experiment is new, to avoid the errors generated by the wear
of orifice and focusing tube. The process parameters used on this study are presented in
Table 1. The variation range of the process studied parameter (feed rate) was selected
within the equipment limits (0–4500 mm/min) and the common ranges used for CPRF
Investigation on Feed Rate Influence on Surface Quality 107
cutting: 50, 1000, 2000, 3000 and 4000 mm/min. Passive piezoelectric AE-sensors of
type Vallen VS900-M were used to measure the AE. This sensor VS900-M has a high
sensitivity over a broad frequency range with compromises regarding the flatness of
response. The response frequency (fPeak) is from 100 up to 900 kHz [17].
First sensor was fixed with plastic glue on the middle of the workpiece at 30 mm
from the cutting line. This distance, 30 mm, was maintained for all the trails by moving
the sensor. The second sensor was fixed on the cutting head, like in the schematic
representation from Fig. 3.
Preamplifiers 2/4/6 Physical Acoustic were used to amplify the AE signal. The gain
could be selected between 20/40/60 dB and internal bandpass filters is 01–1.2 MHz.
For this case a gain of 20 dB was selected. Each experiment was repeated by 5 times.
The monitoring system was made using a National Instruments data acquisition
board (DAQ). This board PCI-6111 can be used to acquire AE signal at 5M samples/s
for up to four channels. The AE sensors were connected to the analogue input of the
DAQ through the connection box NI 2110. The software packages used were from
National Instruments. To control the data acquisitions was used NI LabView 2015 and
for data analyses was used NI DIAdem 2015.
108 I. A. Popan et al.
Fig. 4. The main phases of the AE signal obtain during the experiment.
The raw data of the AE signal is continuous during the cutting and a burst is
observed when the jet enters or exit from the workpiece. In this paper is analyzed the
continuous AE signal, obtained during the cutting. Making a time-domain analysis of
the raw AE signal, the signal provides a clear information about the cutting.
By increasing the feed rate, from 50 up to 4000 mm/min, the RMS amplitude of the
signal is increasing from 0.309 up to 1.2 V (see Fig. 5). In this study the RMS (Root
Mean Square) amplitude value of the raw signal is used.
For obtaining more information about the signal, a frequency domain analysis was
made. The frequency domain was obtained using the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). To
estimate the Power Spectral Density (PSD) of the AE signal, the Hanning method was
used. The frequency domain analyzed was the response frequency (fPeak) of the
sensor, 100–900 kHz.
In Fig. 6 is represented the feed rate influence of the on Power Spectral Density
(PSD). Increasing the feed rate from 50 up to 4000 mm/min, the PSD is increasing
Investigation on Feed Rate Influence on Surface Quality 109
Fig. 5. The raw data of the AE signal obtained during the cutting.
from 0.37 10−6 up to 5.7 10−6 V2/Hz. This variation was detected between
100–150 kHz. This observation proves that, the process parameters are influencing the
AE signal in case of cutting the CFRP material, at 100–150 kHz frequency.
The surface roughness was measured on each zone of the cut surface: initial
damage zone (0.5 mm from the top edge), smooth cutting zone (in the middle of the cut
surface) and rough cutting zone (0.5 mm from the bottom edge). The surface roughness
parameter Ra and RMS Amplitude of the AE signal are presented in Table 2.
Table 2. The surface roughness parameter Ra µm and RMS Amplitude V of the AE signal.
Feed rate Initial damage Smooth cutting Rough cutting AERMS
mm/min zone Ra µm zone Ra µm zone Ra µm amplitude V
50 1.65 1.46 1.56 0.309
1000 2.01 1.85 2.7 0.695
2000 2.62 2.2 4.58 0.928
3000 3.3 3.05 5.7 0.998
4000 3.8 3.5 6.3 1.2
Fig. 7. The influence of the traverse feed rate onto surface roughness (a) and onto RMS
amplitude of the AE signal (b).
4 Conclusions
This monitoring with AE of the AWJC process, in case of cutting composite materials
CFRP has been proved to be a reliable for studying and online monitoring. On this
experimental study was observed a clear connection between AE signal and feed rate.
112 I. A. Popan et al.
Acknowledgments. This work was supported by a grant of the Romanian National Authority
for Scientific Research and Innovation, CNCS/CCCDI–UEFISCDI, project number PN-III-P2-
2.1-BG-2016-0216, within PNCDI III, Technical University of Cluj-Napoca through the research
Contract no. 2001/12.07.2017, Internal Competition CICDI-2017 and the H2020 AMaTUC
project (GA 691787).
References
1. Vitale, P., Francucci, G., Rapp, H., Stocchi, A.: Manufacturing and compressive response of
ultra-lightweight CFRP cores. Comp. Struct. 194, 188–198 (2018)
2. Popescu, A., Hancu, L., Bere, P.: Research concerning the optimum extrusion temperature
for reinforced polyamide. Appl. Mech. Mater. 371, 394–398 (2013)
3. Shanmugam, D.K.: A study of delamination on graphite/epoxy composites in abrasive
waterjet machining. Comp. Part A 39, 923–929 (2008)
4. Popan, I.A., Contiu, G., Campbell I.: Investigation on standoff distance influence on kerf
characteristics in abrasive water jet cutting of composite materials. In: MATEC Web of
Conferences, vol. 137, p. 01009 (2017)
5. Rabani, A., Madariaga, J., Bouvier, C., Axinte, D.: An approach for using iterative learning
for controlling the jet penetration depth in abrasive waterjet milling. J. Manuf. Process. 22,
99–107 (2016)
6. Nag, A., Srivastava, A., Dixit, A., Chattopadhyaya, S., Mandal, A., Klichová, D., Hlaváček,
P., Zeleňák, M., Hloch, S.: Influence of abrasive water jet turning parameters on variation of
diameter of hybrid metal matrix composite. In: Applications of Fluid Dynamics, pp. 495–
504 (2018)
7. Filip, A.C., Mihail, L.A., Vasiloni, M.A.: An experimental study on the dimensional
accuracy of holes made by abrasive waterjet machining of Hardox steels. In: MATEC Web
of Conferences, vol. 137, p. 02003 (2017)
8. Popan, I.A., Balc, N., Carean, A., Luca, A., Ceclan, V.: Developing a new program to
calculate the optimum water jet cutting parameters. Acad. J. Manuf. Eng. 9 (2011)
9. Putz, M., Rennau, A., Dix, M.: High precision machining of hybrid layer composites by
abrasive waterjet cutting. Procedia Manuf. 21, 583–590 (2018)
Investigation on Feed Rate Influence on Surface Quality 113
10. Deam, R.T., Lemma, E., Ahmed, D.H.: Modelling of the abrasive water jet cutting process.
Wear 257(9–10), 877–891 (2004)
11. Schwartzentruber, J., Spelt, J.K., Papini, M.: Prediction of surface roughness in abrasive
waterjet trimming of fiber reinforced polymer composites. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 122,
1–17 (2017)
12. Hloch, S., Valíček, J., Kozak, D., Tozan, H., Chattopadhyay, S., Adamčík, P.: Analysis of
acoustic emission emerging during hydro abrasive cutting and options for indirect quality
control. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 66, 45–58 (2013)
13. Lissek, F., Kaufeld, M., Tegas, J., Hloch, S.: Online-monitoring for abrasive waterjet cutting
of CFRP via acoustic emission: evaluation of machining parameters and work piece quality
due to burst analysis. In: ICMEM 2016. Procedia Engineering, vol. 149, pp. 67–76 (2016)
14. Rabani, A., Marinescu, I., Axinte, D.: Acoustic emission energy transfer rate: a method for
monitoring abrasive water jet milling. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf 61, 80–89 (2016)
15. Tripathi, R., Srivastava, M., Hloch, S., Adamčík, P., Chattopadhyaya, S., Dasa, A.K.:
Monitoring of acoustic emission during the disintegration of crock. In: International
Conference on Manufacturing Engineering and Materials, ICMEM 2016. Procedia Engi-
neering, vol. 149, pp. 481–488 (2016)
16. Barry, J., Byrne, G., Lennon, D.: Observations on chip formation and acoustic emission in
machining Ti–6Al–4V alloy. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 41, 1055–1070 (2001)
17. http://www.vallen.de
Comparison of Non-destructive Sensing
Methods on Surface Created by Waterjet
Technology
1 Introduction
New measurement methods and equipment opens new areas in the analysis of the
surface texture properties. Surface functionality is influenced by production methods
[1]. Dimensional and geometric accuracy is required for all functional surfaces.
Inappropriate selection of the surface quality leads to unnecessary production cost
increase or even failure. [2, 3]
The erosion capability of the jets is widely exploited for many applications in
modern industry. Water jet technology achieved significant progress during last decades
in applications such as cutting of wide range of materials, surface cleaning and removal
of surface layers [4]. Plain water jets (WJ) are generated by the change of pressure
energy of water to kinetic energy by the acceleration of the water flow in the nozzle [5].
Maximum pressures currently used to generate plain water jets are up to 700 MPa. This
jet type is suitable for cutting of softer materials (rubber, paper, wood, plastic etc.),
cleaning of materials from paints and coatings and removal of surface layers.
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 114–123, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_13
Comparison of Non-destructive Sensing Methods on Surface 115
The article focuses on the evaluation of the disintegrated material volume removed
from the samples by a water jet. The study presents a quantified disintegrated material
volume by means of an optical profilometer MicroProf FRT, a digital microscope
VHX-5100 and X-ray computed tomography (X-Ray CT). It defines new methods of
volume parameter measurements. Results of values of volume parameters obtained
from the surface of the experimentally created samples from EN AW 6060 material are
presented.
Industrial X-Ray computer tomography (X-Ray CT) represents non-destructive
imaging method picturing examined object in defined, target oriented 2D cuts in area of
interest of the examined object, X-Ray CT method is mainly used for non-destructive
studying inner structure of examined objects such as defects, pores, inclusions, dense
non-homogeneity etc. This non-destructive method can be also used for studying
surface defects, for measuring their volumes, areas, roughness and dimensions. In this
paper we used X-Ray CT for measuring volume of kerf made by high pressure water jet
(HPWJ) in order to compare with traditionally used, above mentioned, optical methods.
Using industrial X-Ray computer micro-tomography (X-Ray µ-CT) is exceptionally
advantageous. By this X-ray µ-CT can be achieved resolution of individual building
units (so called voxels) in the CT volume or cross-sections at the level of unit or first
tens of micrometers [6].
2 Experimental Setting
High-pressure water was supplied to the water jet head by a plunger pump capable to
deliver up to 40l∙min−1 of water at operating pressure up to 250 MPa. The head was
equipped with commercially available nozzle with orifice diameter of 0.047 in.
Test samples were prepared from aluminium alloy EN AW 6060. Dimensions of
sheet metal were 50 100 5 mm.
To expose the surface of the sample to effect of water jet, following testing pro-
cedure was developed. Robotic arm ensured the nozzle movement with exactly pro-
grammed trajectory. The traversing velocity of the nozzle was set to 0.5 mm∙s−1 during
the experiments; stand-off distance was set to 50 mm. This stand-off distance was
determined as optimal one for given experimental conditions in previous tests. The
angle of incidence was set to 90°.
Tests were performed at operating pressure of 100 MPa. The area of each sample
was exposed to the action of water jet. After the testing kerf was performed, abrasive
water jet technology was used to cut the samples from sheet metal to eliminate thermal
effects on the sample properties. The final dimension of samples was 10 mm in
diameter (see Fig. 1).
116 J. Klich et al.
Fig. 1. Samples.
3 Methodology of Measurement
Fig. 2. (a) 3D visualization of the kerf scan and parts of the base material, (b) representation of
the area of material removal (blue marked area), (c) histogram, (d) sample plane cut, where the
profile of the kerf and the removed material volume are indicated.
sample takes approximately ten minutes. The monitored parameter in the planned
experiment was the removed material volume V [mm3]. Its calculation was made using
the VHX-5000 software. The evaluation of the collected volume of material from the
individual kerfs was carried out as evaluation by Optical profilometer. First, it was
necessary to get a 3D scan of the topography of the kerf and the base material. Figure 3
(a) illustrates a 3D visualization of a kerf created by a water jet, where material
removing is apparent and representation of the area of material removal (yellow marked
area). The software calculates the volume between the actual kerf surface and the plane
of the sample surface. In Fig. 3(c) the profile of the kerf is drawn, where the blue
marked area shows the volume of material removed.
3.3 X-Ray CT
For the purpose of this study we used X-Ray µ-CT scanner XT H 225 ST made by
Nikon Metrology which can be characterized as follows:
• Full system control and image processing software (3D CT Pro – reconstruction
software and VGStudio MAX 2.2 with additional modules for custom image
analysis).
• Rotating systems of X-Ray CT scanning with X-ray conical beam.
These inspection system cover a wide range of applications in the field of X-Ray
CT and radiography, including the research materials and geomaterials analysis (e.g.
structure, porosity, defects) as well as inspection of small castings, plastic parts and
complex mechanisms, palaeontology (e.g. inspection of bones, sculls, fossils),
archaeologists dimensional measurement of internal an surface components, digital
archiving of models, defectoscopy of the machines and equipment parts, analysis of the
biological structures etc.
For reconstruction of the 3D CT volume of used samples, we acquired 3 141 2D
radiographic projections (images) of the individual sample at a known rotational angle
during one full sample turn (360°). The exposition time of the one radiographic pro-
jection was 2000 ms consisting of two radiographic frames (1000 ms). The scanning
and reconstruction process of one sample takes approximately two hours and resulting
118 J. Klich et al.
Fig. 3. (a) 3D visualization of the kerf scan and parts of the base materiál and representation of
the area of material removal (yellow marked area), (b) sample where the profile of the kerf
(c) profile of the kerf and the removed material volume are indicated.
Fig. 4. (a) Visualization of CT data representing the analyzed specimen, (b) scheme of threshold
value determination based on histogram of the voxel values distribution in CT volume.
Fig. 5. (a) Interlaced plane through the upper base of the cylindrical sample, defining the upper
margin of individual ROIs, (b) graphical visualization of the used ROI for calculation of removed
material.
Fig. 6. Example of visualization of the removed material after its segmentation in the cylindrical
and prism ROI – Sample No 1.
Fig. 7. The characteristic transverse tomographic cross-section of the groove created by HPWJ.
Comparison of Non-destructive Sensing Methods on Surface 121
3.000
Optical Profilometer
2.500 MicroProf FRT
V [mm2]
Fig. 8. Average value of the specific (unit) area of the removed material expressed.
4 Conclusion
The study has proven the possibility of use all three methods in order to determine
volume of disintegrated material by HPWJ. Using optical methods, very close volume
values of disintegrated material were measured unlike X-ray µ-CT method, which
shown result volume values of disintegrated material still about 13,5 to 19,5% higher
even in case of comparable ROI localized in the mid part of the sample. After checking
CT data, overall procedure and calibrating all X-ray µ-CT system, no faults, that could
explain quite high values deviance, were found. After detailed analysis of tomography
of cuts in area of kerf surface it can be concluded that complex morphology of this
surface can explain differences in the results. In Fig. 9 we can see detail of surface
morphology of produced kerf by HPWJ, from which it is obvious that in individual
produced kerfs there are under-surface areas of disintegrated material that cannot be
intercepted by optical methods, but X-ray µ-CT method is very well able to recognize
and analyse these hidden areas. The advantage of X-Ray µ-CT against other two used
methods is the ability to catch, visualise and analyse surfaces that are determined of
such shape where for one (x; y) position of analysed surface there exist two or more
coordinates (positions). Such complex types of surfaces can be found e.g. at Electron
122 J. Klich et al.
Beam Melting (EBM) and Selective Laser Melting (SLM) metal powder bed fusion
additive manufacturing (AM) technique [7].
Time demand of measuring is an important parameter when comparing the above
mentioned contactless methods. The process of scanning and reconstructing of one
sample using a digital microscope takes about ten minutes. While using Optical pro-
filometer and X-ray µ-CT for scanning the surface, the measuring takes two hours. The
advantage of the digital microscope against the two other methods is a big time saving
with twelve times faster measuring of one sample.
Acknowledgments. This article was written within the scope of a project of the Institute of
Clean Technologies for Mining and Utilisation of Raw Materials for Energy Use – Sustainability
Program, (Reg. No. LO1406). The presented work was also supported by a project for the long-
term conceptual development of research organisations RVO: 68145535 and Czech Ministry of
Industry and Trade project No. FV30233. The authors are very thankful for the support.
References
1. Sitek, L., Bodnárová, L., Souček, K., Staš, L., Gurková, L.: Analysis of inner structure
changes of concretes exposed to high temperatures using micro x-ray computed tomography.
Acta geodynamica et geomaterialia 12(1), 79–89 (2015)
2. Lehocká, D., Klichová, D., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Hvizdoš, P., Fides, M., Botko, F.:
Comparison of the influence of acoustically enhanced pulsating water jet on selected surface
integrity characteristics of CW004A copper and CW614 N brass. Measurement 110, 230–238
(2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement.2017.07.005
3. Lehocká, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Hvizdoš, P., Fides, M., Botko, F., Cárach, J.:
Surface integrity evaluation of brass CW614 N after impact of acoustically excited pulsating
water jet. Procedia Eng. 149, 236–244 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2016.06.662
4. Peng, G., Ishizuka, M., Hayama, S.: An improved CIP-CUP method for submerged water jet
flow simulation. JSME Int. J. Ser. B. Fluids Therm. Eng. 44(4), 497–504 (2001). https://doi.
org/10.1016/S1001-6058(16)60700-X
5. Peng, G., Yang, C., Oguma, Y., et al.: Numerical analysis of cavitation cloud shedding in
a submerged water jet. J. Hydrodyn. 28(6), 986–993 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/S1001-
6058(16)60700-X
Comparison of Non-destructive Sensing Methods on Surface 123
6. Vavro, M., Souček, K., Daněk, T., Matýsek, D., Georgiovská, L., Zajícová, V.: Utilization of
X-ray computed micro-tomography to evaluate iron sulphide distribution in roofing slates.
Q. J. Eng. Geol. Hydrogeol. (2018)
7. Townsend, A., Pagani, L., Scott, P.J., Blunt, L.: CT measurement of re-entrant additively
manufactured surfaces. In: Abstract Booklet of 8th Conference on Industrial Computed
Tomography, 6th–9th February 2018, Wels Austria (2018)
Investigation of Limestone Cutting Efficiency
by the Abrasive Water Suspension Jet
Andrzej Perec(&)
Abstract. The paper concern to the impact of the Abrasive Water Suspension
Jet (AWSJ) limestone cutting process parameters, such as abrasive flow rate,
diameter and length of the forming nozzle jet under reduced pressure on the
depth of cut. Achieving such a high efficiency in the processing of this rock
results from the use of circular motion of the liquid to create a stream. This has
become possible due to the replacement of a low-efficiency injector mixer with a
new mixer in which the hydro-abrasive mixture is generated directly under high
pressure. The conducted research allowed to determine the best geometric
dimensions of the working nozzle and abrasive flow rate to achieve the best
machining effects were achieved.
1 Introduction
One of the fastest growing advanced technologies is high-pressure water jet cutting.
This advanced production technology competes effectively with conventional methods
of materials separation. It is caused primarily by its universal character, resulting from
the wide possibilities of cutting both various materials, as well as cutting complicated
shapes or conducting it in extreme conditions (hazard of fire, explosion, etc.) and
environmental friendliness [1, 2].
The disadvantage of existing AWJ systems for cutting under 400–600 MPa is the
use for the generation of the jet the injector-mixer. It is poor performance device,
especially in the case of very high speed differences in mixed media. The elimination of
the injector-mixer and the use of circular flow rinsing to mix the pre-formed abrasive
mixture and water directly under high pressure allows for similar machining effects.
The effects of the abrasive machining process are determined by the phenomena
occurring in the abrasive grain contact zones with the workpiece. Studying these
phenomena in real conditions is very difficult or even impossible [3–5]. Therefore,
other modern methods were used, such as computer numerical simulations and, of
course, modeling using statistical and mathematical methods.
Computational Fluid Dynamics simulation model of the AWSJ nozzle was used by
Deepak et al. to find some relations between operational parameters and jet efficiency
[6]. They found that the increase in inlet pressure causes a significant increase in the
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 124–134, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_14
Investigation of Limestone Cutting Efficiency by the AWSJ 125
surface friction coefficient that approaches peaks with a sudden change in flow in the
critical section of the geometry, and linear increase of the average kinetic output of the
stream. However, the output energy decreases with the increase in the volume fraction
of the abrasive particles.
Computational fluid dynamic (CFD) modeling was used by Kowsari et al. [7] to
derive a generalized relation between channel geometry and erosive flow (the non-
linearity function), which was used in an existing numerical-empirical model to predict
the depths, widths, and shapes of ASJM micro-channels in sintered ceramics and by
Liwszyc et al. [8] to flows simulation in Abrasive Suspension-Injection cutting system.
Among the statistical and mathematical methods, the orthogonal array method was
also used for modeling of AWJ machining. The prediction of machining effects using
this method was applied both to the cutting depth [9] and the quality of the treated
surface [10] as well as the efficiency of the cutting process [11].
Successfully modeling processing can use the response surface method. Majumder
et al. [12] used the Response Surface Methodology (RSM) to evaluate the minimum
surface roughness of the cut low carbon steel by abrasive water jet. A statistical model
was generated to predict surface roughness.
Also at Shandong University, Liu et al. [13] investigated the effect of operating
parameters at on depth of penetration and surface roughness (Ra) in turning of alumina
ceramics using abrasive waterjet. The quadratic regression models were developed to
predict the depth of penetration and Ra by experiments using Response Surface
Methodology. Thus the developed model can be effectively used to predict the depth of
penetration and surface roughness in the machining of alumina ceramics.
Lehocka et al. [14] studied the disintegration effect of ultrasound-enhanced pul-
sating water jet (PWJ) technology on brass CW614N. The mathematical model on
basis RSM was developed and confirmed. The experiment and results present a part of
an extensive research focused on describing the PWJ disintegration efficiency for metal
materials.
The limestone used for research comes from the quarry of Morawica/Poland and is
called the “Kielce marble”. It is a hard limestone, has a fine-grained structure, a
conchoidal fracture, the color of coffee with milk. Limestone from Morawica have the
following properties:
• Density: 2780 kg/m3
• Compressive strength: 82–117 MPa
Limestone can be treated with conventional methods only by means of cutting, but
to achieve high performance, use expensive diamond saw blades that allow cutting only
in straight lines. This limitation can be eliminated by the use of the Abrasive Water Jet
technology.
Fig. 1. Test rig: (a) view: 1 – AWSJ device, 2 – Water pump, 3 – Cutting table, 4 – Control
device, (b) hydraulic diagram, (c) abrasive flow characteristic (d) detail of the cutting process
[21].
Table 2. (continued)
No Nozzle length [mm] Nozzle ID [mm] Abrasive flow rate [g/s] Cutting depth [mm]
41 100 2.00 50 16.07
42 100 2.00 60 19.80
43 100 2.00 70 22.83
44 100 2.00 80 22.46
45 100 2.00 90 23.00
46 100 2.25 50 19.69
47 100 2.25 60 20.61
48 100 2.25 70 23.93
49 100 2.25 80 25.07
50 100 2.25 90 22.36
51 100 2.50 50 20.94
52 100 2.50 60 22.76
53 100 2.50 70 28.83
54 100 2.50 80 27.51
55 100 2.50 90 27.50
56 100 2.75 50 24.60
57 100 2.75 60 29.73
58 100 2.75 70 31.94
59 100 2.75 80 34.67
60 100 2.75 90 33.94
between the process variables and the observed responses under consideration.
A polynomial equation of second order for determining the regression model value is:
Xk Xk
y ¼ b0 þ bx þ
i¼1 i i i¼1
bii x2i e ð1Þ
where:
y is the corresponding response,
xi indicates values of the i-th machining parameter,
b0, bi, bii are the regressions coefficients,
e is the error obtained during cutting.
The effect of control factors (independent variables) on the process was made through
ANOVA (ANalysis Of Variance). The results of this analysis display the figures given
in Table 3.
The analysis was performed for a 95% confidence level (a = 0.05). The P-value
of <0.05 implies that the model factor is significant.
130 A. Perec
All factors have most significant impact on cutting depth. The capability of the
model was tested with an R-squared calculation. In regression, a R-squared coefficient
of determination is a statistical measure of how well the regression line approximates
the real data points. Table 4 presents a standard error of the regression S = 1.69165,
and R-squared = 90.22% and R-squared adjusted = 88.47% and an R-squared pre-
dicted on 86.36%. Such high and little differing values show that the raw data fit
satisfactory to the regression line.
To measure multicollinearity, the variance inflation factor (VIF) was tested. VIF
measures how much the variance of an estimated regression coefficient increases if
predictors are correlated. For the VIF = 1, there is no multicollinearity but if the VIF
is >1, the predictors may be moderately correlated. For all tested factors there no
multicollinearity (VIF = 1.00) was observed.
On grounds of coefficients the final cutting depth control models was formulated:
where:
Dc is cutting depth [mm],
lN is nozzle length [mm],
dN is nozzle ID [mm],
ma is abrasive flow rate [g/s].
The normal scattering chart of cutting depth is presented in the Fig. 2.
Fig. 2. Scattering chart for depth of cut. Fig. 3. An exemplary view of the
limestone surface cut. Pressure
28 MPa, traverse speed = 2 mm/s,
abrasive flow rate = 80 g/s, nozzle
ID = 2.75 mm, nozzle length =
75 mm.
It can be concluded, that the points are close to a straight line. Therefore, it suggests
that the mathematical model which has been developed is satisfactory.
Figure 3 shows an example view of the cut limestone surface. It is visible on the
tarnish, and in the lower part, clear arched machining marks that are completely
invisible in the upper part. Triangular uncut, characteristic of waterjet cutting, is very
slender in this material.
The surface response chart of the effect of nozzle ID and length on cutting depth are
shown in Fig. 4. The maximum cutting depth for 75 mm length nozzle can be observed
at all abrasive flow rates. Decreasing of the nozzle ID results in a decrease in cutting
depth due to a smaller energy of abrasive grains, and hence a smaller number of cutting
edges. The nature of this relationship was observed with all tested abrasive flow rates.
The surface response plot of the effect of a nozzle length and abrasive flow rate on
cutting depth (Fig. 5) shows that cutting depth is at the maximum for a middle nozzle
length (75 mm) and abrasive flow rate for each nozzle ID. The lowest values of the
cutting depth for the extreme nozzle length and abrasive flow rate were observed.
132 A. Perec
Fig. 4. The impact of nozzle ID and length on the cutting depth at abrasive flow rate: (a) 50 g/s,
(b)70 g/, (c) 90 g/s.
Fig. 5. The impact of nozzle length and abrasive flow rate on the cutting depth with nozzle ID:
(a) 2.000 mm, (b) 2.375 mm, (c) 2.750 mm.
Fig. 6. The impact of nozzle ID and abrasive flow rate on the cutting depth with nozzle length:
(a) 50 mm, (b) 75 mm, (c) 100 mm.
The surface response graph of the effect of nozzle ID and abrasive flow rate on
cutting depth are shown in Fig. 6. Also in this case, the maximum cutting depth for
an middle abrasive flow rate (equal to 70 g/s) can be observed. The increase in nozzle
length leads to a growth in the cutting depth value. The biggest depth of cut is reached
with the middle long (75 mm) nozzle. In this case too, the character of this relationship
was observed with all tested nozzle length.
Investigation of Limestone Cutting Efficiency by the AWSJ 133
4 Conclusions
References
1. Perec, A.: Environmental aspects of abrasive water jet cutting. Ann. Set Environ. Protect.
- Rocznik Ochrona Srodowiska 20 (2018)
2. Perec, A.: Disintegration and recycling possibility of selected abrasives for water jet cutting.
DYNA 84, 249–256 (2017)
3. Kukielka, L., Krzyzynski, T.: New thermo-elastic thermo-visco-plastic material model and
its application. Zeitschrift fur Angewande Mathematik und Mechanik. 80(sup. 3), S595–
S596 (2000)
4. Kukielka, L., Kukielka, K., Kułakowska, A., Patyk, R., Bohdal, L.: Incremental modelling
and numerical solution of the contact problem between movable elastic and elastic/visco-
plastic bodies and application in the technological processes. Appl. Mech. Mater. 474, 159–
164 (2014)
5. Nadolny, K., Sutowski, P., Herman, D.: Analysis of aluminum oxynitride AlON (Abral®)
abrasive grains during the brittle fracture process using stress-wave emission techniques. Int.
J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 81, 1961–1976 (2015)
6. Deepak, D., Anjaiah, D., Karanth, K.V., Sharma, N.Y.: CFD simulation of flow in an
abrasive water suspension jet: the effect of inlet operating pressure and volume fraction on
skin friction and exit kinetic energy. Adv. Mech. Eng. 4, 1–8 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1155/
2012/186430
134 A. Perec
7. Kowsari, K., Nouraei, H., Samareh, B., Papini, M., Spelt, J.K.: CFD-aided prediction of the
shape of abrasive slurry jet micro-machined channels in sintered ceramics. Ceram. Int. 42,
7030–7042 (2016)
8. Liwszyc, D., Liwszyc, A., Liwszyc, J., Perec, A.: Abrasive Slurry–Injection Jet (AS IJ) a
New CNC Cutting Technology. In: 2011 WJTA American Waterjet Conference, Houston,
p. E-2. WaterJet Technology Association (2011)
9. Perec, A.: Abrasive suspension water jet cutting optimization using orthogonal array design.
Procedia Eng. 149, 366–373 (2016)
10. Perec, A., Pude, F., Kaufeld, M., Wegener, K.: Obtaining the selected surface roughness by
means of mathematical model based parameter optimization in abrasive waterjet cutting.
Strojniski vestnik – J. Mech. Eng. 10, 1–9 (2017)
11. Hu, G., Zhu, W., Cai, H., Xu, C., Bai, Y., Cheng, J., Yuan, J., Yu, T.: Mathematical model
for abrasive suspension jet cutting based on orthogonal test design. J. Shanghai Univ.
(English Edition) 13, 37–44 (2009)
12. Majumder, S.K., Mandal, B., Das, S., Das, P.K.: An experimental investigation on surface
roughness achieved during abrasive water-jet machining of low carbon steel. J. Assoc. Eng.
India 87, 26–32 (2017)
13. Liu, D., Huang, C., Wang, J., Zhu, H., Yao, P., Liu, Z.: Modeling and optimization of
operating parameters for abrasive waterjet turning alumina ceramics using response surface
methodology combined with Box-Behnken design. Ceram. Int. 40, 7899–7908 (2014)
14. Lehocká, D., Klich, J., Botko, F., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Kepič, J., Kovaľ, K., Krejči, L.,
Storkan, Z.: Pulsating water jet erosion effect on a brass flat solid surface. Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol. 97, 1099–1112 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-018-1882-4
15. Prazmo, J., Sobczak, R., Perec, A.: Abrasive grain disintegration during high-pressure
abrasive water jet cutting in the abrasive reuse aspect. In: Klichova, D., Sitek, L. (eds.)
Conference on Water Jetting Technology: Water Jet 2017 – Research, Development,
Application, pp. 137–150. Ústav geoniky AV ČR, v.v.i. (2017)
16. Perec, A.: Abrasive grain breakage process during the high-pressure waterjet formation. In:
WJTA American Waterjet Conference, p. C-2. WaterJet Technology Association (2011)
17. Martinec, P., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Ščučka, J., Vašek, J., Martinec, P.: Abrasives for AWJ
cutting (2002)
18. Sobczak, R., Prazmo, J., Perec, A., Chmielik, I.: Dust free surface treatment parameters of
the three-phase jet, generated in the sandbot device. MM Sci. J. 872–876 (2016)
19. King, H.: Limestone: rock uses, formation, composition, pictures. https://geology.com/rocks/
limestone.shtml
20. Perec, A., Pude, F., Stirnimann, J., Wegener, K.: Feasibility study on the use of fractal
analysis for evaluating the surface quality generated by waterjet. Tehnički vjesnik 22,
879–883 (2015)
21. Perec, A.: Influence of conditions highpressure, suspensive, hydroabrasive jet creation onto
cutting materials parameters in lower working pressure aspect. Koszalin University of
Technology, Koszalin (1995)
22. Perec, A.: Some aspects of hydroabrasive suspensive jet cutting of aluminum alloy. In: Lee,
C.-I., Jeon, S., Song, J.-J. (eds.) 7th Pacific Rim International Conference on Water Jetting
Technology, pp. 349–356. Korean Society of WJT (2003)
23. Perec, A.: Some aspects of hydroabrasive suspensive jet cutting of syenite. In: 17-th
International Conference on Water Jetting: Advances and Future Needs, Mainz (2004)
24. Perec, A.: Experimental research into alternative abrasive material for the abrasive water jet
cutting of titanium. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 97, 1529–1540 (2018)
Erosion Test with High-speed Water Jet
Applied on Surface of Concrete Treated
with Solution of Modified Lithium Silicates
Abstract. The paper focuses on the erosion resistance test based on surface
treatment by a high-speed water jet applied on concrete. A reference concrete
sample and concrete samples with three types of solution of modified lithium
silicates applied on the concrete surface were tested under various erosion
conditions. Two different jet impact angles (45° and 90°) were investigated.
A significant difference in the erosion rate in the surface layers was observed
comparing the untreated concrete and the concrete treated by various solutions
of modified lithium silicates, but only in the initial phase of erosion.
1 Introduction
Cement-based composites used for the constructions of dams, drainage tunnels, canals,
etc. are affected by progressive erosion by rapidly flowing water together with abrasive
wear caused by the occurrence of small particles in the water flow (e.g. [2]). High
durability and erosion resistance of the material used are more significant for the
resistance against this type of loading than the very high material strength.
The durability of the concrete structure depends not only on the materials used,
their interconnections and inner structure, but especially on physical and chemical
influences of the environment. In case of concrete structures exposed to effects of
flowing water, such as dams, canals, sewers and drains, harbor constructions, etc., one
of the main forms of degradation is associated with erosive processes. Erosion caused
by the surface wear of the concrete structures by rapidly flowing water is characterized
by gradual concrete degradation and transport of the fragmented material on the
concrete surface [10].
One of the possibilities to increase the resistance of concrete against the erosive
wear is the use of special impregnations creating a durable protective layer on the
concrete surface. Progressive lithium silicate-based impregnating agents penetrate into
the pores of the surface layer of the concrete, chemically react with the free lime
occurring in the cement surface layer and form a dense microstructure that is chemi-
cally durable and resistant against the erosion and abrasion.
The erosion of concrete structures exposed to flowing fluids (clean water, water
with small particles such as sand or sewage water) is a long-term process; it usually
takes several months to years before certain damage can be observed. However, the
damage can be detected in shorter time due to the application of accelerated testing
methods. That is why the attention is focused on the development of appropriate
methods for evaluation of the resistance of materials against the erosive wear. One of
the progressive ways to an accelerated mechanical simulation of the erosion are the
methods applying high-speed water flows and different strategies of their action on the
surface of a studied material. The logical selection of the water jet/flow technology is
based on its similarity to the real erosive process. Several studies on the erosion of
cement composites using accelerated tests have been published so far. Some works
focused on the use of pure water jets without additives [7], other works described the
application of abrasive water jets [1, 5, 6, 9] or effects of artificially created cavitation
[8]. The authors’ contribution to the problem of the accelerated simulation of the
erosive wear of concrete is based on many years of experience with the degradation of
cement composites by high-speed water flows [3, 4, 11], etc.
The aim of this research is to verify the suitability of the use of plain water jet for
the accelerated erosion tests on concrete samples which are surface-treated by special
solutions based on lithium silicates.
2.1 Materials
A preliminary study on the resistance of concrete samples with three lithium silicate
solutions applied on the surface against the flowing water under in short-time erosion
tests was performed. The concrete samples with the same composition and mechanical
properties were prepared for the testing. After mixing and casting, the mixtures were
cured and hardened for 28 days. The compressive strength was measured according to
EN 12390–3 Testing hardened concrete - Part 3: Compressive strength of test speci-
mens, the flexural strength was measured according to EN 12390–5 Testing hardened
concrete - Part 5: Flexural strength of test specimens. Compositions and properties of
the composites tested are provided in Tables 1 and 2.
Three types of the solution of modified lithium silicates (Table 3) were conse-
quently applied on sample surfaces according to the recommendations by manufac-
turers of solutions. In the text below, the individual solution of modified lithium
silicates are marked at random as the sample A, B and C to be avoid any legal dispute
with the manufacturers of the solutions.
Erosion Test with High-speed Water Jet 137
Fig. 1. Experimental application of the water jet on concrete sample (left – jet impact angle of
45°; right – jet impact angle of 90°).
Fig. 2. Combination of trajectories used for one erosion cycle during treatment of concrete
specimens by the water jet.
Ve
Vr ¼ ; ð1Þ
te
te ¼ N tc : ð2Þ
Erosion Test with High-speed Water Jet 139
N is the number of milling cycles and tc is the time needed for one milling cycle.
Unlike the removed volume of material Ve, the volumetric erosion rate Vr indicates the
rate of erosion of surface layers of the testing samples and better determinates the
erosion abilities of the high-speed water jet impacting on the densified surface layer.
Fig. 4. Results of the erosion testing made in concrete samples: the maximum depth of erosion
Hmax in various numbers of cycles (angle of jet impact 45°).
Fig. 5. Results of the erosion testing made in concrete samples: the maximum depth of erosion
Hmax in various numbers of cycles (angle of jet impact 90°).
dependent on whether or not the sample was treated using the solution. The water jet
penetrates directly under the densified layer and the differences between individual
samples are eliminated. During the first and possibly the second milling cycle, the
protective layer is being removed, which obviously reduces the erosive wear.
At the jet impact angle of 90°, results of the erosion are similar to the results
achieved at the jet impact angle of 45°, except that the value of the average maximum
depth is higher. This is due to the fact that at the angle of 45° the applied forces of the
water jet are decomposed, and a proportion of the energy impinging on the sample
surface is reflected.
Erosion Test with High-speed Water Jet 141
Fig. 6. Results of the erosion testing made in concrete samples: the volumetric erosion rate Vr in
various numbers of cycles (angle of jet impact 45°).
Fig. 7. Results of the erosion testing made in concrete samples: the volumetric erosion rate Vr in
various numbers of cycles (angle of jet impact 90°).
142 P. Hlaváček et al.
4 Conclusion
Based on experimental results, the following can be concluded from the investigations:
1. Two quantitative parameters were used for the erosion assessment, namely the
maximal depth of erosion Hmax and the rate of volumetric erosion Vr. It can be said
that both parameters have similar informative power.
2. Higher erosion resistance was observed by concretes with solution of modified
lithium silicates, but only in the initial phase of erosion.
3. The resistance of treated surface layers against the erosion caused by the water flow
differs significantly according to the manufacturers of impregnation agents. How-
ever, all tested solutions increased the erosion resistance of the treated surface layer.
4. In general, the erosion rate is lower at the jet impact angle of 45° compared to the jet
impact angle of 90° due to the reflection of a proportion of the impinging water jet
energy. While the perpendicular impact of the jet on the studied surface can be
associated to real case of impact of water to bottom of stilling basin, the impact at the
angle of 45° corresponds better to the natural flow of fast flowing streams on the
concrete surfaces for instance in effluent weirs, canals, wastewater disposal system etc.
Acknowledgement. This work was supported by grant of the Czech Science Foundation (18-
25035S) and by project of the Institute of Clean Technologies for Mining and the Utilization of
Raw Materials for Energy Use – Sustainability program, reg. no. LO1406 financed by the
Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic. Some parts of presented work
was also supported by a project for the long-term conceptual development of research organi-
sations RVO: 68145535. The authors are very thankful for the support.
References
1. Binici, H., Aksogan, O., Gorur, E.B., Kaplan, H., Bodur, M.N.: Hydro-abrasive erosion of
concrete incorporating ground blast-furnace slag and ground basaltic pumice. Constr. Build.
Mater. 23, 804–811 (2009)
2. Galvao, J.C.A.: Abrasive effects observed in concrete hydraulic surfaces of dams and
application of repair materials
3. Hela, R., Bodnárová, L., Sitek, L., Foldyna, J.: High-speed water jet technology for
renovation of concrete structures - new trends and possibilities. Cement-Wapno-Beton, vol.
15, 268 p. (2010)
4. Hlaváč, L.M., Bodnárová, L., Janurová, E., Sitek, L.: Comparison of continuous and pulsing
water jets for repair actions on road and bridge concrete. Baltic J. Road Bridge Eng. 7, 53–59
(2012). https://doi.org/10.3846/bjrbe.2012.08
5. Horszczaruk, E.K.: Hydro-abrasive erosion of high performance fiber-reinforced concrete.
Wear 267, 110–115 (2009)
6. Hu, X.G., Momber, A.W., Yin, Y.G.: Hydro-abrasive erosion of steel-fibre reinforced
hydraulic concrete. Wear 253, 848–854 (2002)
7. Hu, X.G., Momber, A.W., Yin, Y.: Erosive wear of hydraulic concrete with low steel fiber
content. J. Hydraul. Eng. 132, 1331–1340 (2006)
8. Momber, A.W.: Short-time cavitation erosion of concrete. Wear 241, 47–52 (2000)
Erosion Test with High-speed Water Jet 143
9. Momber, A.W.: Effects of erodent flow energy and local exposure time on the erosion of
cement-based composites at high-speed hydro-abrasive flow. Wear 378–379, 145–154
(2017)
10. Saegrov, S., Hafskjold, L.S., Konig, A., et al.: Wastewater network challenges and solutions.
In: Hlavinek, P., Kukharchyk, T., Marsalek, J., Mahrikova, I. (eds.) Conference NATO
Advanced Research Workshop on Integrated Urban Water Resources Management, Senec,
Slovakia, 19–23 Oct 2005, NATO Science for Peace and Security Series C-Environmental
Security, pp. 147–158. Springer, Dordrecht (2006)
11. Sitek, L., Bodnárová, L., Válek, J., et al.: Effects of water jet on heat-affected concretes. In:
Juozapaitis, A., Vainiunas, P., Zavadskas, E.K. (eds.) Modern Building Materials, Structures
and Techniques, Procedia Engineering, vol. 57, pp. 1036–1044 (2013). https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.proeng.2013.04.131
Analysis of Micro Continuous Water Jet Based
on Numerical Modelling and Flow Monitoring
1 Introduction
The high-speed water jet (WJ) represents a progressive technology that is used in
a variety of industrial applications for cutting, drilling, milling, turning, surface
blasting and structuring. A circular water nozzle converts the pressure energy
(<600 MPa) of water into the kinetic energy [1]. Operating conditions used to generate
high-speed water jet require a high resistance and durability of the nozzle material.
Nozzles are usually made of ruby, sapphire or diamond with an internal diameter of
0.05 to 0.5 mm [2]. High resistance of the diamond material requires corresponding
micro-cutting tool for orifice preparation. A micro cutting tool material cannot be easily
processed using conventional methods. Up to now, such tools have been primarily
fabricated by grinding or electrical discharge machining. A new method based on
picosecond laser used for shape modification of the diamond nozzles was tested by
Eberle in his doctoral thesis [3].
It is obvious that the process preparation of the diamond nozzles is a very complex
task. There are many technological, material, and physical aspects that influence the
final geometrical shape and quality of the orifice manufacture. All these factors have an
impact on jet properties during its generation. Experimental results of nozzle testing at
the Department of Material Disintegration at the Institute of Geonics show that quality
and accuracy of the nozzle manufacture have a significant impact on its proper func-
tionality and lifetime. A lot of numerical studies have been already focused on the
simulation of the flow inside the nozzle using the ideal CAD geometries. Results of
nozzle designs and measurements can vary due to geometrical deviations and surface
irregularities of manufacture.
This paper focuses on analysis of continuous micro water (CWJ) jets based on
numerical modelling, visualization and flow monitoring. The main motivation is to
compare a numerical calculation and measuring methods designed for the CWJs
analysis. The main emphasis is placed on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simu-
lation and determination of water flow properties during generation of the water jet.
Numerical modelling of flow inside the nozzle is performed based on real 3D geometry
received from computed tomography. For the purpose of experimental testing, a closed
water circuit includes low-pressure water pump and flow diagnostics was designed.
The optical - spectroscopic methods of Particle Tracking Velocimetry (PTV), Laser
Induced Fluorescence (LIF) and Shadowgraph were applied together with fluorescent
polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) seeding particles for determination the jet velocity
fields. A series of experiments was conducted to measure of flow properties. The basic
methods and principles used in the experiment are described below. Results of mea-
surements are consequently compared with numerical studies.
2 Methods
Fig. 2. Numerical model of the nozzle and calculated fluids flow fields, input pressure of
14 MPa.
148 M. Zelenak et al.
The CFD model was created based on the information acquired by the X-ray
computing tomography. The scanned surface in “STL” mesh file format was modified in
the CAD software (SpaceClaim) to a 3D volume. The 3D model was consequently used
for the creation of the CFD model of the given nozzle. It can be seen in (Fig. 2a). Due to
this procedure, very accurate geometric data were used for the calculation. Processing of
accurate input data was a basic condition for the achievement of high-quality results.
The numerical model simulated a two-phase turbulent flow of compressible water
and incompressible air in the above-described space. The turbulent flow was defined by
the two-equation RANS model SST-kx. The 3D multiphase flow was solved as
a steady-state equation.
3 Experiment
The experimental assembly used for the visualisation and velocity measurement of
CWJs generated by a Kärcher water pump (max. flow rate of 11.7 l.min−1 at the
operating pressure of 14, 5 MPa) connected to a water head, water catching tank and
recording system. The water head equipped with a scanned diamond nozzle oriented to
the catching tank was fixed in the holder placed on the frame. A schematic drawing of
the experimental water circuit is presented in Fig. 5. The PMMA fluorescent seeding
Analysis of Micro Continuous Water Jet 149
Fig. 3. 2D PTV recording system combined with shadowgraphy used for CWJ visualization.
Fig. 4. PMMA seeding particles saturated with the Rhodamine B fluorescent dye.
150 M. Zelenak et al.
particles in an amount of 3 g were mixed into 15 L of pure water and put into the tank.
This arrangement allowed repeated visualization of particles (by their repeated passage
through the water nozzle). The hydraulic flow rate and the pressure was monitored
using a turbine flow meter with a digital unit and a pressure sensor with 0.1%
resp. 0.15% accuracy. Data acquisition and processing was performed in the LabVIEW
Interface and MS Excel.
The LaVision recording system equipped with Imager Pro X2 M CCD camera (op-
erating in double frame mode), a microlens with band-pass filter, Nd: YAG NL 135-15
double-pulse laser (wavelength of 532 nm, pulse width of 9 ns, 135 mJ max. energy) and
optical diffusor (diameter of 110 mm) was used for a water jet velocity measurments.
The velocity of seeding particles was measured at reference pressures of 8, 9, 10,
11, 12, 13, 14 MPa. The size of the field of view of a recording window positioned
immediately behind the nozzle outlet was 24 18 mm. One thousand double frame
images were taken at one recording sequence at each pressure level. Time delay
between laser pulses of the first and second frame illumination was 0.75 µs.
Analysis of Micro Continuous Water Jet 151
Table 2. Results of pressures and flow measurement, pavg – average value of pressure,
Qavg – average value of flow rate, SEM – standard error of the mean.
pavg [MPa] SEM [MPa] Qavg [l.min−1] SEM [l.min−1]
7.9809 0.011 0.3517 0.0003
9.0006 0.041 0.3792 0.0009
10.0403 0.016 0.3998 0.0004
11.0206 0.008 0.4186 0.0003
12.0242 0.100 0.4386 0.0018
13.0539 0.039 0.4588 0.0009
13.9618 0.017 0.4780 0.0005
The shape of the flow field in the given domain was calculated for seven levels
corresponding to the values of pressure received from the measurement. The deviation
between the measured and calculated volume flow rates is around 8%. This deviation is
caused by virtualization of the nozzle into the 3D model. It was observed that the
lowest diameter measured on the CAD model was 0.24 mm instead of the real diameter
of 0.25 mm verified by optical measurement. In this case, inaccuracy of the CAD
model fitting was in this case 0.01 mm. Comparison of theoretical flow rates for the
diameter of 0.24 mm and 0.25 mm using discharge coefficient u = 0.96 is illustrated
also in the graph Fig. 7. The measured values of the flow corresponded well with
theoretical calculation.
The velocities of PMMA seeding particles in the water jet flowing downstream of
the nozzle exit under various experimental conditions are presented in Table 3. For
calculated average values of particle velocities at the given pressures, standard error of
the mean is also calculated.
The graphical distribution of water jet velocities behind the nozzle outlet under
different operating pressures is illustrated in Fig. 8. The graph represents the distri-
bution of jet velocities acquired from numerical models and measurements. The green
line shows velocity of jet calculated by CFD in Fluent. The calculation was performed
based on the determination of volume flow rate in the lowest area of 3D CAD nozzle
orifice under given border conditions. The red line represents the average values of the
velocities of the PMMA seeding particles examined by optical measurement inside the
water jet flow. The brown line represents the velocity of the water jet calculated based
on direct volume flow rate and pressure measurements after determining the discharge
coefficient for the tested nozzle.
152 M. Zelenak et al.
Fig. 6. Schematic drawing of the measured area with detail of a field of view at nozzle outlet.
Table 3. Results of PMMA seeding particles velocities, N – number of particles, vavg – average
velocity of seeding particles, SEM – standard error of the mean.
Pressure [MPa] N [-] vavg [m.s−1] SEM [m.s−1]
8 298 116.86 1.58
9 271 126.94 1.17
10 215 135.91 1.18
11 254 141.06 1.85
12 280 147.97 1.56
13 251 155.06 1.95
14 375 160.83 2.45
Analysis of Micro Continuous Water Jet 153
Fig. 8. Influence of operating pressure on average velocity of jet - comparison of theoretical and
measured values.
It is obvious from the graph in Fig. 8 and from Tables 2 and 3 that an increase in
water pressure (i.e. increase in water jet velocity) results in an increase in the flow rate
of water and velocities of PMMA particles downstream of the nozzle exit. It can be
stated that the measured average velocities of seeding particles follow the same trend at
increasing operating pressure as the theoretically calculated velocity of CWJ. In
addition, the results show a good agreement of measured data with model studies.
The results of the CFD calculation, direct flow monitoring and PTV optical mea-
surement correspond well with the theoretical model of velocity described by the
following Eq. (1):
sffiffiffiffiffi
2p
v¼u ð1Þ
q
where p is the operating pressure [Pa], q is the water density [kg.m−3] and u is the
nozzle discharge coefficient (u ¼ 0:96 was used in the calculation). This simple model
is also illustrated in the graph in Fig. 8. Only the optical investigation using PMMA
seeding particles at pressures of 8, 9 MPa shows certain data deviation and worse
agreement with all studies performed.
5 Conclusion
The results and analyses of the micro CWJs flow based on numerical modelling,
visualization and monitoring show very good conformity of theoretical and practical
tests. The presented optical experiments using the PMMA seeding particles show that
the designed measuring assembly and procedures are suitable for investigating of water
154 M. Zelenak et al.
jet velocities at tested pressure ranges. A very high precision of the turbine flow meter
guarantees observation of the flow parameters o with respect to an overall nozzle
efficiency.
Determination of jet velocities using the PTV based on the tracking of seeding
particles in the flow is an indirect measurement method. Therefore, selection of par-
ticles, their size and mechanical properties are essential in order to avoid significant
discrepancies between fluid and particle motion. Higher accuracy of measurement
results can be achieved with the use of smaller particles with density close to the
density of the fluid medium. Standard error of the mean will be then smaller. On the
other hand, the implementation requirements of the experiment are demanding, espe-
cially as regards the image resolution, detection capabilities, the volume of the prepared
suspension and, in particular, the cost of the experiment. The designed closed water
circuit allowing repeated passage of the fluorescent particles through the water jetting
system solves the problem of their relatively high purchase price.
During the experiment, the Rhodamine B fluorescent particles are partially released
into the air in the form of micro droplets. As the Rhodamine B molecules can have
carcinogenic effects, it is advisable to carry out the experiments in a separate envi-
ronment using a suction system and protective equipment.
Based on the initial experience, design of an experimental setup usable for testing
real pressure parameters (<100 MPa) commonly used to generate the high-speed water
jet in both scientific and industrial applications is planned.
Acknowledgements. This article was written in connection with the project of the Institute of
Clean Technologies for Mining and the Utilization of Raw Materials for Energy Use –
Sustainability program, reg. no. LO1406 financed by the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports
of the Czech Republic, and with support for the long-term conceptual development of the research
institution RVO: 68145535.
References
1. Putz, M., Dittrich, M., Dix, M.: Process monitoring of abrasive waterjet formation.
Procedia CIRP 14, 43–46 (2016)
2. Carach, J., Hloch, S., Petru, J., Nag, A., Gombar, M., Hromasova, M.: Hydroabrasive
disintegration of rotating Monel K-500 workpiece. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 96, 981–1001
(2017)
3. Eberle, G., Dold, C., Wegener, K.: Picosecond laser fabrication of micro cutting tool
geometries on polycrystalline diamond composites using a high-numerical aperture micro
scanning system, In: LASE - SPIE Photonics West, San Francisco, USA, pp. 935103-1–
935103-9 (2015)
4. https://www.nikon.com/products/industrial-metrology/support/download
5. Riha, Z., Zelenak M.: Flow field analysis in abrasive head as tool for high-speed abrasive jet
cutting. In: Water Jet 2017, pp. 153–163 (2017). ISBN 978-80-86407-71-5
6. Zelenak, M., Scucka J., Soucek, K.: Velocity measurements on continuous micro water jet
using fluorescent PMMA seeding particles. In: Water Jet 2017, pp. 221–231 (2017). ISBN
978-80-86407-71-5
Analysis of Micro Continuous Water Jet 155
7. Raffel, M., Willert, C., Kompenhans, J.: Particle Image Velocimetry, a Practical Guide.
Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York (1998)
8. LaVision, Particle Master Shadow, Manual, Göttingen (2012)
9. LaVision, Flow master, Manual, Göttingen (2012)
An Acoustic Emission Study of Rock
Disintegration by Pulsating Water-Jet
1 Introduction
cumbersome process due to these reasons the pulsating water jet comes into the profile
[4]. Pulsating water-jet technology is an environment friendly process which causes no
heat affected zone [5]. In the recent years, this technology has been widely used for
cutting, cleaning and disintegration applications on various metals and non-metals,
ceramics, biomedical materials, and another form of composites materials [5, 6]. This
technology has numerous advantageous such as reduced noise, dust and vibration,
preservation of surrounding material. In addition to that, it eliminates the requirement
of high-pressure pumps making this cost-effective technology [7]. Foldyna et al. [8]
performed experiments on basalt, granite, and sandstone to check the performance
analysis of pulsating water-jet over continuous waterjet under the same parametric
conditions. They found that the pulsating water jet has more regular slots with a
maximum depth as compared to the continuous water-jet material. Foldyna et al. [9]
also used pulsating water jet technology for removing the degraded surface layers of
the concrete. A series of experiments was conducted to evaluate the performance of
pulsating water jet and continuous water jet. The result showed that pulsating water jet
has achieved higher efficiency in comparison to the continuous water jet in all the
configuration test.
In the recent year, non-destructive testing has achieved more popularity due to
available sensors devices and software tools. Non-destructive testing is widely used in
for applications like underground mining but direct field application of this technology
is still limited. It directly provides material property values and characteristics which is
responsible for the determining the rock mass behavior [10]. Acoustic emission
(AE) consists of high-frequency transient elastic waves that can be originating from a
sudden release of energy at a localized point within a loaded material [11]. Acoustic
emission has been widely used in industries and various other fields such as steam
pipes and pressure vessels, composites materials, monitor the welding and corrosion
progress, metals and also applied numerous structural components. It is a technique to
direct monitor the defects formation and failure of structural materials. However, it can
provide information on the stress field, fatigue and the fracture pattern behavior. Tri-
pathi et al. [5] investigated disintegration of rock by monitored the acoustic emission
during the PWJ and compared the phenomenon with a continuous water jet. The
relation between the acoustic signals and controlled parameters in terms of the depth
and width of the cut was determined. In this study, acoustic emission method is used as
a devious monitoring tool to stimulate a better control over the process parameters to
attain the required disintegration level. Hloch et al. [12] studied the AE technique to
measure the fault condition during the cutting operation with minimum human inter-
vention. The AErms value observed the dependencies within the time section t on the
cutting head traverse speed v moreover, AWJ technology can be used as an online
control function to monitor the head traverse speed. Hassan et al. [13, 14] envisaged the
actual depth of cut in AWJ cutting under normal cutting conditions by AE technique.
For the observation of the depth during the process, the strain gauge and sensors were
installed on the workpiece. The AErms shows the linear relationship between the depths
of cut and could be used for its on-line monitoring. Knill et al. [15] proposed the
acoustic emission technique to record the signal during uniaxial loading of rock
sample. They found the nature of acoustic emission signal relationship with a variable
parameter such as pulse rate, signal energy content and amplitude distribution. Mathis
158 R. Tripathi et al.
and chmelik et al. [16] investigated the acoustic emission phenomena, which is helpful
to assess the twining and slip activity during the plastic deformation. Behind of these
possible mechanism is responsible for the motion of the dislocation, which is caused by
the stress relaxation process. There are numerous authors have been addressed the
theoretical calculations of the impingement depth of the AWJ in ductile materials and
brittle materials. By contrast it is not possible to achieve the performance of online
monitoring and controlling of the depth during AWJ. A very few authors concentrated
the online monitoring during pulsating water-jet.
The main aim of this paper deals with an application of acoustic emission mea-
surement as an on-line monitoring tool for analyzing the disintegration phenomenon of
rock by pulsating water jet which locally affects the structural integrity of rocks. The
correlation between rock disintegration and dynamic signal behaviour was obtained for
granite materials at various settings of jet parameters.
Silesian granite is taken as material, which is extracted from zulova locality in the
Ostrava. These experiments were carried out in the Institute of Geonics at Ostrava. The
technological assembly (Fig. 1a) of the setup consists of a Hammelmann HDP with the
maximum operating pressure of 160 MPa, the maximum flow rate of 67 1.min−1 and
ABB robot IRB 6640 180/2.55 used for manipulation of the cutting head. Pulsation
effect was generated by Ecoson WJ-UJ 630-40 ultrasonic device with the modulation
frequency of 20 kHz. The circular nozzle (STONEAGE) of diameter d = 1.9 mm was
used for the experiments under various parametric conditions mentioned in Table 1.
During the experiments, three acoustic sensors were clamped in the three positions.
First sensor was clamped directly on the workpiece, data was collected by the
accelerometers PCB IMI (series type 607 A11) with an integrated cable. The sensor
was connected to the measurement system of NI PXI by the under acoustic emission
observation.
After the disintegration, the disintegrated grooves were scanned using optical
Profilo meter and depth was evaluated by the SPIP software.
Figure 2 shows the profile of the grooves along the x-axis (cross-section of the grooves)
generated during PWJ disintegration. These profiles are generated by SPIP 6.2.6 soft-
ware, evaluated by the scanned surfaced using optical Profilometer. In the Fig. 2a the
maximum depth of the cut of 2 mm was observed at a traverse speed of v = 1 mm/s. At
a traverse speed of v = 2 mm.s−1 also the maximum depth obtained is approximately
2 mm. The reason behind this phenomenon is the maximum interaction time during
impacting of the jet at lower traverse speed. However, at a higher traverse speed of
v = 3 mm.s−1 and v = 4 mm.s−1 higher depth of cut of approximately 2.8 mm and
3.5 mm was obtained. This is the mainly due to the inhomogeneity of the granite
material and impact of the pulses that some abrupt profile of the grooves were observed.
An Acoustic Emission Study of Rock Disintegration by Pulsating Water-Jet 159
Fig. 1. (a) Experimental Setup (b) Recorded acoustic emission signal (c) Treated granite sample
at 20 MPa.
The pattern of the acoustic emission as a function of the time is determined by the
time distribution of impulsive deformation, which occurs within the material, depends on
the type of material. Figure 2 shows the acoustic emission signals with the burst emis-
sions recorded during the disintegration phenomenon. The continuous nature of the
signals corresponds to the microscopic deformations taking place during the disinte-
gration, as the result of the stress generated by the impacting jet. At pump pressure
p = 20 MPa and v = 1 mm.s−1 two major burst emission can be observed with a max-
imum amplitude ±200 V at a duration of 20 s, as shown in Fig. 2a. In the Fig. 2b, at a
traverse speed 2 mm.s−1 two major burst emission can be noticed with maximum
amplitude ±200 V and a duration of 26 s. At higher traverse speed of v = 2 mm.s−1 and
3 mm.s−1, same trend was observed with the amplitude of ±100 V and a duration 50 s.
160 R. Tripathi et al.
Fig. 2. Profile of the grooves along x-axis (a) 1 mm.s−1 (b) 2 mm.s−1 (c) 3 mm.s−1 (d) 4 mm.s−1.
Fig. 3. Acoustic Emission signals recorded during disintegration (a) 1 mm.s−1 (b) 2 mm. s−1
(c) 3 mm. s−1 (d) 4 mm. s−1.
An Acoustic Emission Study of Rock Disintegration by Pulsating Water-Jet 161
Figure 2b showed the highest peak value in comparison to others as the grooves were
disintegrated at the lowest traverse speed of v = 1 mm.s−1, i.e. the jet interacts with the
material for a longer duration causing more impact energy. The initial peaks of the signal
have less intensity due to an insufficient impacting energy of water jet at the beginning.
The sharp point at the end represents the transition of waterjet over the edge of the sample.
The acoustic signals generated during the disintegration of the grooves at traverse
speed of v = 1 mm.s−1, 2 mm.s−1, 3 mm.s−1 and 4 mm.s−1 can be related to the sur-
face morphology of the generated grooves in the Fig. 2. It was evident from the Figs. 2
and 3 that at the maximum disintegration depths the signals showed the bust emissions
with maximum amplitude however; at the starting and end of the disintegration process
low amplitude emissions were observed. The acoustic signals demonstrated the state of
ongoing deformation process taking place due to the interaction of the pulsating jet and
also the materials response to the impact.
4 Conclusion
The pulsating water jet technology is an optimistic tool not only for manufacturing
industries but also for the other industries including civil and mining engineering and
architectural fields due to its distinctive features of working at a lower pressure while
maintaining its quality. This technology is capable of achieving a very important
alternative application to the classical operation of sand and ball blasting.
From the above study we can conclude that:
1. Acoustic Emission Signals measurement during disintegration showed the increase
with the increment in the traverse speed. The heterogeneity of the signal in terms of
the amplitude in the time course of the above modulated (downhill) signal is
possibly because the very cutting profile is more irregular (in width and in depth).
2. No particular trend was observed in depth of cut during disintegration of pulsating
water-jet by means of the acoustic emission. However during surface topography
analysis of the cross-section of the grooves maximum depth of cut were obtain at
higher traverse-speed.
3. It was found that the acoustic emission signal generated during pulsating water jet
depends upon on the depth of the grooves formed in the traverse direction.
4. Under all the traverse speed acoustic emission signals follows the burst nature. It
was observed the most promising result of the pulsating water-jet during disinte-
gration of granite material.
5. The acoustic emission behaviour was observed the obtain the elicited acoustic signal
under different conditions act as control mechanism during the cutting process.
6. It is assumed as a non-destructive tool to monitor the ongoing process of the
material disintegration during cyclic loading.
Acknowledgements. This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development
Agency under contract no. APVV-207-12. Experiments were conducted with the support of the
project of the Institute of Clean Technologies for Mining and Utilization of Raw Materials for
Energy Use– Sustainability Program, reg. no. LO1406 financed by the Ministry of Education,
162 R. Tripathi et al.
Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic, and Institute of Geonics of the CAS with support for the
long-term conceptual development of the research institution RVO: 68145535.
References
1. Agioutantis, Z., Kaklis, K., Mavrigiannakis, S., Verigakis, M., Vallianatos, F., Saltas, V.:
Potential of acoustic emissions from three point bending tests as rock failure precursors. Int.
J. Min. Sci. Technol. 26, 155–160 (2016)
2. Lei, X., Masuda, K., Nishizawa, O., Jouniaux, L., Liu, L., Ma, W., Satoh, T., Kusunose, K.:
Detailed analysis of acoustic emission activity during catastrophic fracture of faults in rock.
J. Struct. Geol. 26, 247–258 (2004)
3. Dehkhoda, S.: Experimental and Numerical Study of Rock breakage by Pulsed Water Jets.
Dissertation PhD Thesis, University of Queensland (2011)
4. Dehkhoda, S., Hood, M.: The internal failure of rock samples subjected to pulsed water jet
impacts. Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. 66, 91–96 (2014)
5. Tripathi, R., Srivastava, M., Hloch, S., Chattopadhyaya, S., Das, A.K., Pramanik, A.,
Klichová, D., Adamcik, P.: Performance analysis of pulsating water jet machining during
disintegration of rocks by means of acoustic emission. In: Lecture Notes in Mechanical
Engineering. pp. 515–524 (2018)
6. Lehocka, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., Hloch, S., Krolczyk, J.B., Carach, J., Krolczyk, G.M.:
Copper alloys disintegration using pulsating water jet. Meas. J. Int. Meas. Confed. 82, 375–
383 (2016)
7. Srivastava, M., Tripathi, R., Hloch, S., Rajput, A., Khublani, D., Chattopadhyaya, S.,
Dixit, A.R., Foldyna, J., Adamčík, P., Klich, J., Zelenak, M., Klichová, D.: Surface
Treatment of AISI 304 Using Pulsating Water Jet Peening. In: Lecture Notes in Mechanical
Engineering. Eng. pp. 535–548 (2018)
8. Sitek, L., Martinec, P., Jekl, P.: Rock cutting by pulsing water jets. In: Proceedings of the
International Symposium of the International Society for Rock Mechanics (Eurock 2005),
pp. 129–134 (2005)
9. Foldyna, J.: New potentional of high-speed water jet technology for renovating concrete
structures. Slovak J. Civ. Eng. 19, 1–7 (2011)
10. Mechanics, R., December, R.E., Li, C.: Acoustic Emission Characteristics and Failure of
Uniaxially Stressed Granitic Rocks: The Effect of Rock Fabric (2002)
11. Tian, S., Sheng, M., Li, Z., Ge, H., Li, G.: Acoustic emission characteristics of sedimentary
rocks under high-velocity waterjet impingement. Rock Mech. Rock Eng. 1–10 (2017)
12. Hloch, S., Valíček, J., Kozak, D., Tozan, H., Chattopadhyaya, S., Adamčík, P.: Analysis of
acoustic emission emerging during hydroabrasive cutting and options for indirect quality
control. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 66, 45–58 (2013)
13. Hassan, A.I., Chen, C., Kovacevic, R.: On-line monitoring of depth of cut in AWJ cutting.
Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 44, 595–605 (2004)
14. Momber, A.W., Mohan, R.S., Kovacevic, R.: On-line analysis of hydro-abrasive erosion of
pre-cracked materials by acoustic emission. Theor. Appl. Fract., Mech (1999)
15. Knill, J.L., Franklin, J.A., Malone, A.W.: A study of acoustic emission from stressed rock.
Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. 5, 87–88 (1968)
16. By, P.: World’ s largest Science, Technology & Medicine Open Access book publisher
Exploring Plastic Deformation of Metallic Materials by the Acoustic Emission Technique
(2012)
Evaluation of Possibility of AISI 304 Stainless
Steel Mechanical Surface Treatment
with Ultrasonically Enhanced
Pulsating Water Jet
1 Introduction
generated flow is crucial for determination of the application area. The water jet can be
used as continuous and discontinuous and with [1] or without abrasive addition.
Material disintegration with discontinuous water jet without abrasive addition is
characterized by water hammer effect (repeated impacts of high-kinetic clusters of
liquid on the material surface) [2], Intensified water jet has high disintegration effi-
ciency. Material is disintegrated at low pressures without abrasives.
Discontinuous water jet is suitable for applications affecting the material surface
such as surface treatment, surface roughening and cleaning of surface in various areas
in industry. The mechanical properties of water drops offer a wide range of applications
in engineering and the consumer industry [3]. The destructive potential of a PWJ finds
applications in the remediation of concrete structures [4], mining industry and rock
disintegration (rock cutting [5] and breakage of rocks [6]), surface roughening [7],
descaling [8], and surface treatment of ornamental stones. The current research shows
the potential of a PWJ in orthopedic applications (reimplantation of endoprothesis [9]).
water. The pulses are generated by applying ultrasonic impulses in the sonotrode,
which is main component of the PWJ cutting head (Fig. 1A). The pressure pulses [27]
cause the outflow of water to have a variable output speed. A continuous WJ is broken
down to single clusters owing to the effect of the accelerated parts of the WJ (Fig. 1B).
An interruption is caused by reducing the distance between the WJ and its accelerated
parts. Subsequently, a material gets disintegrated by the effect of the impact of the high
kinetic-energy water clusters (Fig. 1B).
2 Experimental Procedure
Austenitic stainless steel AISI 304 (Table 1) was used as experimental material. AISI
304 is most wide spread stainless steel with high corrosion resistance, good weldability
and cold formability. Mentioned steel is resistant to water, humidity, water steam and
weak organic and inorganic acids. Application field lies in engineering, nuclear,
pharmaceutics, chemical and food production industry.
One sample of stainless steel AISI 304 was prepared, for describe of PWJ effect at
traverse speed v = 100 mm.s−1. The sample was disintegrated with technological
factors values shown in Table 2. Sample was evaluated based on surface and sub-
surface characteristics. Surface of sample was measured by the MircoProf FRT optical
profilemeter. Disintegration efficiency based on roughness parameters Ra [lm], Rz
[lm], Rp [lm] and Rv [lm] was evaluated in software SPIP. The surface of the groove
was observed using an electron microscope JEOL JSM 7000F (Fig. 3). The metallo-
graphic analysis was performed for the material structure study (Fig. 4). The sample
was transverse cut and subsequently grinded on MTH KOMPAKT 1031 and acid
etched. The sample was electrolytic etched in oxalic acid solution. Microhardness was
measured on a Vickers CV DAT 400 hardness tester (application load - 200 g, time -
10 s) (Fig. 5).
Evaluation of Possibility of AISI 304 Stainless Steel 167
3 Results
3.1 Surface Topography Evaluation
Surface topography was evaluated with using an optical profilemeter and a scanning
electron microscope (SEM).
In area of mechanical hardening (strengthening, peening) (Fig. 2) of the surface,
there is no significant erosion. The PWJ does not have enough time and energy to
significantly disintegrate surface and only affects the surface layer. Small surface
deformation was observed and no erosion craters were created. There was a slight
change in roughness profile parameter Ra from Ra = 1.21 lm to 1.71 lm. For
parameter Rz [lm], the change was more pronounced by 3.32 lm. From the com-
parison of parameters Rp [lm] and Rv [lm], the value Rp [lm] increased by 0.74 lm
and Rv [lm] increased by 2,6 lm, which means that on the surface is mainly created
microscopic craters and depressions. There were no material extrusions above the
groove surface.
Fig. 2. AISI 304 stainless steel groove surface disintegrated at traverse speed v = 100 mm.s−1,
frequency f = 20.25 kHz and number of impacts n = 202 impacts per mm; 3D and real view.
visible on fracture area in Fig. 3, with small ratio of intercrystalic fracture extending to
lower boundary of neighbor grains (Fig. 4A1 and B1).
Fig. 3. AISI 304 stainless steel groove surface disintegrated at traverse speed v = 100 mm.s−1,
frequency f = 20.25 kHz and number of impacts n = 202 impacts per mm, observed with SEM:
A – magnification 200x; B – magnification 500x; C – magnification 1000x; D – magnification
2000x.
Fig. 4. Transverse cut thought AISI 304 stainless steel disintegrated at traverse speed
v = 100 mm.s−1, frequency f = 20.25 kHz and number of impacts n = 202 impacts per mm;
A – white light, B – polarized light
Evaluation of Possibility of AISI 304 Stainless Steel 169
4 Conclusions
Traverse speed v [mm.s−1] directly affect the time effect of the pulsating water jet on
the material. This directly affects the number of impacts on the surface unit. PWJ
erosion effect on material depends on time of interaction and applied force. Works [33]
and [34] proves significance of impact count on disintegration efficiency. The erosion
efficiency of PWJ decreased with lower number of impacts. Effect of PWJ on various
types of material was described in [28–32] and confirmed findings in research [33] and
[34]. In the research [32] was assumed that there is a possibility of surface peening
using an acoustically enhanced pulsating water jet. Study in this article suggests
applicability of this assumption.
The results of the topography and surface roughness evaluation of AISI 304
stainless steel surface show slight erosion of material. Surface quality slightly changed
(Ra profile parameter was increased by only 0.5 lm). Small microscopic craters (Rv
[lm] profile parameter) were predominantly created on surface. Craters are charac-
terized with predominant pitting mechanism and prevails fracture mechanism of
material removal.
Slight deformation of the AISI304 stainless steel surface was demonstrated during
the evaluation sub-surface characteristics in area of perpendicular impact of
PWJ. AISI304 stainless steel was disintegrated with pressure 70 MPa, traverse speed
170 D. Lehocká et al.
100 mm.s−1 and frequency 20,25 kHz (it represents 200 impacts per millimeter).
Deformation was observed to a depth of maximum 0.6 mm (600 lm).
Sub-surface deformation strengthening with minimal influence of material surface
(surface peening) can be assumed, based on results of this study. Stated assumptions
need to be validated by residual stress measurements in the area of PWJ effect. If strain
hardening will be considered as surface peening will be possible to introduce com-
pressive stress to surface layer. Material will gain fatigue strength and resistance to
micro cracking. Application of mentioned way of approach is significant in increasing
of utility properties in cyclic load.
PWJ regulation is possible at other settings of technology assembly and disinte-
gration factors. For this reason, area of PWJ disintegration is investigated. Research is
focused on investigation of using various types and diameters of nozzles, pressures and
ultrasonic frequencies. Optimal stand-off distance of cutting head from target material
is investigated too. The erosive effects depend on the chemical composition and
physical and mechanical properties of the selected material. For these reasons, optimal
setting of disintegration factors and study of surfaces created using PWJ is currently
intensively investigated.
References
1. Valicek, J., Harnicarova, M., Panda, A., et al.: Mechanism of creating the topography of an
abrasive water jet cut surface. In: Machining, Joining and Modifications of Advanced
Materials, vol. 61, pp. 111–120. Springer, Singapore (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-
981-10-1082-8_12
2. Raudensky, M., Horak, A., Horsky, J., et al.: Hydraulic descaling improvement, findings of
jet structure on water hammer effect. Rev. de Metall.-Cah. d Inf. Tech. 104(2), 84–90 (2007).
https://doi.org/10.1051/metal:2007133
3. Kirols, H.S., Kevorkov, D., Uihlein, A., Medraj, M.: The effect of initial surface roughness
on water droplet erosion behaviour. Wear 342, 198–209 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
wear.2015.08.019
4. Sitek, L., Foldyna, J., Martinec, P., et al.: Use of pulsating water jet technology for removal
of concrete in repair of concrete structures. Baltic J. Road Bridge Eng. 6(4), 235–242 (2011).
https://doi.org/10.3846/bjrbe.2011.30
5. Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Martinec, P., et al.: Rock cutting by pulsing water jets. In: Eurock
2005: Impact of Human Activity on the Geological Environment, Brno, Czech Republic,
pp. 129–134. A A Belkema Publisher (2005)
6. Dehkhoda, S., Hood, M.: An experimental study of surface and sub-surface damage in
pulsed water-jet breakage of rocks. Int. J. Rock Mech. Min. Sci. 63, 138–147 (2013). https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmms.2013.08.013
Evaluation of Possibility of AISI 304 Stainless Steel 171
7. Klich, J., Klichova, D., Hlavacek, P.: Effects of pulsating water jet on aluminium alloy with
variously modified surface. Tech. Gaz. 24(2), 341–345 (2017). https://doi.org/10.17559/TV-
20140219100749
8. Hnizdil, M., Raudensky, M.: Descaling by pulsating water jet. In: METAL 2010 - 19th
International Conference on Metallurgy and Materials, Roznov pod Radhostem, Czech
Republic, pp. 209–2013. Tanger LTD (2010)
9. Hloch, S., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., et al.: Disintegration of bone cement by continuous and
pulsating water jet. Tech. Gaz. 20(4), 593–598 (2013)
10. Turski, M., Clitheroe, S., Evans, A.D., et al.: Engineering the residual stress state and
microstructure of stainless steel with mechanical surface treatments. Appl. Phys. A – Mater.
Sci. Process. 99(3), 549–556 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00339-010-5672-6
11. He, Y., Yoo, K.B., Ma, H., Shin, K.: Study of the austenitic stainless steel with gradient
structured surface fabricated via shot peening. Mater. Lett. 215, 187–190 (2018). https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.matlet.2017.12.021
12. Jayalakshmi, M., Bhat, B.R., Bhat, K.U.: Effect of shot peening coverage on surface
nanostructuring of 316L stainless steel and its influence on low temperature plasma-nitriding.
Mater. Perform. Charact. 6(4), 561–570 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1520/MPC20160079
13. Kalainathan, S., Sathyajith, S., Swaroop, S.: Effect of laser shot peening without coating on
the surface properties and corrosion behavior of 316L steel. Opt. Lasers Eng. 50(12), 1740–
1745 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optlaseng.2012.07.007
14. Todaka, Y., Umemoto, M., Tsuchiya, K.: Comparison of nanocrystalline surface layer in
steels formed by air blast and ultrasonic shot peening. Mater. Trans. 45(2), 376–379 (2004).
https://doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.45.376
15. Sun, Q.Q., Han, Q.Y., Xu, R., et al.: Localized corrosion behaviour of AA7150 after
ultrasonic shot peening: corrosion depth vs. impact energy. Corros. Sci. 130, 218–230
(2018). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2017.11.008
16. Botko, F., Hatala, M., Kormos, M.: Using edgecam for creating CNC programs in education
process. In: IEEE 13th International Symposium on Applied Machine Intelligence and
Informatics (SAMI), Herľany, Slovakia, pp. 255–259. IEEE (2015)
17. Muruganandhan, R., Mugilvalavan, M., Thirumavalavan, K., Yuvaraj, N.: Investigation of
water jet peening process parameters on AL6061-T6. Surf. Eng. 34(4), 330–340 (2018).
https://doi.org/10.1080/02670844.2017.1394564
18. Jiang, W.C., Luo, Y., Wang, H., Wang, B.Y.: Effect of impact pressure on reducing the weld
residual stress by water jet peening in repair weld to 304 stainless steel clad plate. J. Press.
Vessel Technol.-Trans. ASME 137(3), 031401 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4029655
19. Azhari, A., Sulaiman, S., Rao, R.K.P.: A review on the application of peening processes for
surface treatment. In: 2nd International Manufacturing Engineering Conference and 3rd
Asia-Pacific Conference on Manufacturing Systems (IMEC-APCOMS 2015), Kuala
Lumpur, Malaysia (2015). IOP Conference Series-Materials Science and Engineering, vol.
114, Article number: 012002. IOP Publishing Ltd., (2016). https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-
899x/114/1/012002
20. Bai, F.S., Saalbach, K.A., Long, Y.Y., et al.: Capability evaluation of ultrasonic cavitation
peening at different standoff distances. Ultrasonics 84, 38–44 (2018). https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.ultras.2017.10.013
21. Macron, A., Melkote, S.N., Castle, J., et al.: Effect of jet velocity in co-flow water cavitation
jet peening. Wear 360, 38–50 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2016.03.027
22. Bai, F.S., Saalbach, K.A., Wang, L., et al.: Impact of time on ultrasonic cavitation peening
via detection of surface plastic deformation. Ultrasonics 84, 350–355 (2018)
172 D. Lehocká et al.
23. Peng, G., Oguma, Y., Shimizu, S.: Visualization observation of cavitation cloud shedding in
a submerged water jet. In: 3rd Symposium on Fluid-structure-Sound Interactions and
Control (FSSIC), Perth, Australia (2015). Fluid-Structure-Sound Interactions and Control.
Lecture Notes in Mechanical Engineering, pp. 229–234. Springer, Berlin (2016). https://doi.
org/10.1007/978-3-662-48868-3_37
24. Zhang, Y.N., Qian, Z.D., Wu, D.Z., et al.: Fundamentals of cavitation and bubble dynamics
with engineering applications. Adv. Mech. Eng. 9(3) (2017). https://doi.org/10.1177/
1687814017698321
25. Peng, G., Oguma, Y., Shimizu, S.: Numerical analysis of cavitation cloud shedding in
a submerged water jet. In: 2nd Conference of Global Chinese Scholars on Hydrodynamics
(CCSH 2016), Wuxi, China, pp. 263–269. China Ocean Press (2016)
26. Kušnerová, M., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., et al.: Innovative approach to advanced modulated
waterjet technology. Tech. Gaz. 19(3), 475–480 (2012)
27. Ríha, Z., Foldyna, J.: Ultrasonic pulsations of pressure in a water jet cutting tool. Tech. Gaz.
19(3), 487–491 (2012)
28. Lehocka, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., et al.: Copper alloys disintegration using pulsating water
jet. Measurement 82, 375–383 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement.2016.01.014
29. Lehocká, D., Klich, J., Foldyna, J., et al.: Surface integrity evaluation of brass CW614 N
after impact of acoustically excited pulsating water jet. In: ICMEM 2016, International
Conference on Manufacturing Engineering and materials. Procedia Engineering, Nový
Smokovec, Slovakia, vol. 149, pp. 236–244. Elsevier Science BV (2016). https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.proeng.2016.06.662
30. Lehocka, D., Klichova, D., Foldyna, J., et al.: Comparison of the influence of acoustically
enhanced pulsating water jet on selected surface integrity characteristics of CW004A copper
and CW614 N brass. Measurement 110, 230–238 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measure
ment.2017.07.005
31. Lehocka, D., Simkulet, V., Legutko, S.: Assessment of deformation characteristics on
CW004A copper influenced by acoustically enhanced water jet. In: MANUFACTURING
2017, 5th International Scientific-Technical Conference on Advances in Manufacturing,
Poznan, Poland, pp. 717–724. Springer, Cham (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-
68619-6_69
32. Lehocká, D., Botko, F., Simkulet, V., et al.: Study of surface topography of CW004A copper
after PWJ disintegration. In: MMS Conference, 2nd EAI International Conference on
Management of Manufacturing Systems, Starý Smokovec, Slovakia. ACM (2018). https://
doi.org/10.4108/eai.22-11-2017.2274347
33. Foldyna, J., Klich, J., Hlavacek, P., et al.: Erosion of metals by pulsating water jet. Tech.
Gaz. 19(2), 381–386 (2012)
34. Thomas, G.P., Brunton, J.H.: Drop impingement erosion of metals. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. Ser.
A Math. Phys. Sci. 314, 549–565 (1970). https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1970.0022
Non–traditional Machining
of Inconel 600 Material
1 Introduction
Nickel-based super alloys are of great interest to aircraft, space and nuclear industries
because of their resistance to heat and high temperature operation [1, 2]. Inconel 600 is
used in the production of a variety of aircraft bodies and engines that must withstand
the high temperatures in the aerospace industry with excellent mechanical properties,
resistance to corrosion. It is non-magnetizing and very abrasive, which is very durable
[2, 3]. Inconel 600 is a standard material for nuclear reactors and has excellent strength
even at very high temperatures.
Includes non-conventional processing such as Abrasive Water Jet, where nickel-
based super alloys are cut through abrasive impact through pressurized water-
accelerated abrasives [4]. While avoiding the effects of heating in the material, technical
requires some important features. Water jets were introduced in the US in the 1970s and
were only used for cleaning purposes. The technology has been developed to include
abrasive water jets [1–5]. The water jet process provides many unique capabilities and
advantages that can prove effective and effective in cost warfare. Learning more about
water jet technology opens the door to putting these cost-cutting capabilities to work.
Beyond cost reduction, the water jet process is considered the most versatile and fastest
growing process in the world [5–7]. Water jetting does not use toxic gases or liquids and
water jets do not create hazards or vapors. A truly versatile, productive, cold cutting
operation. Machining with abrasive water jet (AWJ) is a non-traditional cutting process
that uses high-pressure water to produce high-speed flow and allows machining from
soft to hard material [1–5]. A versatile process that can be used in many manufacturing
applications such as cutting, milling, cleaning and surface finishing, and negligible heat
in the cutting process offer unique advantages such as the affected zone, high maneu-
verability and low processing power [5–8].
This study was formulated, what is the effect of the main factors and levels of AWJ
process on surface roughness?
Some controllable parameters of the AWJM are the water jet nozzle and orifice size,
water spray pressure, abrasive grain size, abrasive material, abrasive flow rate, nozzle
feed rate, nozzle standoff distance, nozzle angle and work piece composition. In this
study, a total of 9 experiments were carried out with the Taguchi test set consisting of
nozzle standoff distance, nozzle feed speed and abrasive flow rate, each of 3 levels. The
process parameters and levels are given in Table 1. Taguchi L9 experimental setup is
shown in Table 2.
applications are widely used in chemical processing industry aviation industry heat
treatment industry electricity production plants heat treatment radiation pipes and
catalyst support materials for nitric acid production. The mechanical properties and
chemical composition of Inconel 600 are given in Tables 3 and 4. The sample size
(60 mm 60 mm 10 mm) was used. The abrasive material used is Garnet 80 mesh
size and the pump pressure is fixed at 350 MPa. Processing of the Inconel 600 material
in an abrasive water jet cut is shown in Figs. 1 and 2. The planning experimental
process was carried out and the appropriate data were collected and analyzed with
statistical methods leading to valid and objective results. The method of analysis
depends on the design of the experiments used directly. Most researchers have iden-
tified parameters of the abrasive water jet processing process that greatly affect the
response parameters. If some of these parameters are in order, the process parameters
such as Nozzle standoff distance, nozzle angle, feed rate, number of passes, abrasive
material, abrasive particle size, abrasive shape and abrasive mass flow rate, tube
diameter and focusing tube length, pressure hole diameter etc. In this study, the process
176 F. Kartal and S. Hloch
parameters were selected as the nozzle feed rate (mm/min) abrasive flow rate (g/min)
and nozzle distance (mm) to analyze the effect of the nickel based super alloy, Inconel
600, on the surface roughness.
For surface roughness quality, “smaller is best” criteria are considered for optimization.
Figure 3 shows the interaction graph of surface roughness with processing parameters.
It is seen that the abrasive flow rate, nozzle traverse and nozzle standoff distance are
important influences for surface roughness. The data obtained from the experimental
studies are subjected to variance analysis (ANOVA) to determine the statistical relia-
bility of the effects of the parameters on the mean surface roughness and how the
different levels bring about variability. The significance level for ANOVA analysis was
chosen as 95%. If the P value (probability value P) is less than 0.05, the effect on the
output of the parameter is considered to be statistically significant. The total variance of
the variance rates is determined by separating each of the processing parameters and
the variability resulting from the error. The surface roughness results obtained from the
experiments based on the Taguchi methodology are given in Table 5. The ANOVA
results for average surface roughness are presented in Table 6 to determine the effect of
each resulting factor.
ANOVA is used to find the percentage of each parameter and its interactions.
ANOVA is an assessment tool that provides a perspective on the percentage contri-
bution among all the control factors and the most influential variables for the single
thought machining response. The S/N ratio for surface roughness is considered to be
“smaller and better”. The minimum surface roughness value was observed when the
nozzle feed rate was 100 mm/min, the abrasive flow rate was 500 g/min and the nozzle
Non–traditional Machining of Inconel 600 Material 177
distance was 4 mm. The optimum surface roughness was 200 mm/min, the abrasive
flow rate was 300 g/mm. It is clear that the nozzle feed rate and nozzle standoff
distance has a significant effect on the surface roughness. Accordingly, the Inconel 600
material should be in the form of A1B3C3 most suitable for the lowest surface
roughness when processed under specified conditions. The formula obtained from the
simple linear regression analysis shown in Eq. 1 is used to estimate the surface
roughness at the 95% confidence interval. An abrasive flow rate of 300 g/min may be
economically feasible.
SRðlmÞ ¼ 5:20320:005237 Transverse speed ðmm=minÞ þ 0:000654 Abrasive flow rate ðg=minÞ
ð1Þ
þ 0:1231 Standoff distance ðmmÞ
4 Conclusions
A simple linear regression analysis and Taguchi was performed to determine the
relationship between the machining parameters and surface roughness in the AWJ
machining process. Based on an experimental investigation, a study on the cutting of
nickel-based Inconel 600 with abrasive water jet was presented.
The lowest surface roughness values occurred at the lowest nozzle feed rate. The
results of the research show that the nozzle feed rate (77%) has the highest effect on the
surface roughness.
The mathematical model developed using ANOVA in this study was found to be
satisfactory, giving a R2 value of 98.48%. For this reason, this model can be used to
evaluate the measured response at the processing of Inconel 600 material under
selected optimum values. when the nozzle feed rate value was increased from
100 mm/min to 200 mm/min, the roughness value increased by 10%. in this study it
was observed that for the lowest surface roughness the nozzle feed rate was
100 mm/min, the abrasive flow rate was 500 g/min and the nozzle standoff distance
was 4 mm.
References
1. Escobar-Palafox, G.A., Gault, R.S., Ridgway, K.: Characterization of abrasive water-jet
process for pocket milling in Inconel 718. Procedia CIRP 1, 404–408 (2012)
2. Sidda Reddy, D., Seshu Kumar, A., Sreenivasa Rao, M.: Parametric optimization of abrasive
water jet machining of Inconel 800H using Taguchi methodology. Univ. J. Mech. Eng. 2(5),
158–162 (2014)
3. Ay, M., Çaydaş, U., Hasçalik, A.: Effect of traverse speed on abrasive waterjet machining of
age hardened Inconel 718 nickel-based superalloy. Mater. Manuf. Process. 25(10), 1160–
1165 (2010)
Non–traditional Machining of Inconel 600 Material 179
4. Kechagias, J., Petropoulos, G., Vaxevanidis, N.: Application of Taguchi design for quality
characterization of abrasive water jet machining of TRIP sheet steels. Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol. 62(5–8), 635–643 (2012)
5. Cárach, J., Hloch, S., Hlaváček, P., Ščučka, J., Martinec, P., Petrů, J., Zlámal, T., et al.:
Tangential turning of Inconel alloy 925 using abrasive water jet technology. Int. J. Adv.
Manuf. Technol. 82(9–12), 1747–1752 (2016)
6. Nair, A., Kumanan, S.: Multi-performance optimization of abrasive water jet machining of
Inconel 617 using WPCA. Mater. Manuf. Process. 32(6), 693–699 (2017)
7. Sadat, A.B., Reddy, M.Y., Wang, B.P.: Plastic deformation analysis in machining of Inconel-
718 nickel-base super alloy using both experimental and numerical methods. Int. J. Mech. Sci.
33(10), 829–842 (1991)
8. Courbon, C., Sajn, V., Kramar, D., Rech, J., Kosel, F., Kopac, J.: Investigation of machining
performance in high pressure jet assisted turning of Inconel 718: a numerical model. J. Mater.
Process. Technol. 211(11), 1834–1851 (2011)
(Un)conventional Technology Session
Mapping Requirements and Roadmap
Definition for Introducing I 4.0
in SME Environment
1 Introduction
requirements [3]. On the other hand, when the degree of customization is high, then
possible incompatibilities between optional component types may cause serious prob-
lems such as customer dissatisfaction [4]. One possible way to eliminate or reduce the
customer disappointment is eliminating infeasible configuration options, caused by
incompatibilities between optional component types, within a product platform [5].
A great challenge for the future lies in the transfer of Industry 4.0 expertise and
technologies in small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs). SMEs represent the
backbone of the economy and have an enormous importance in the development
programs of the European Union for strengthening the competitiveness of European
enterprises. Although the high potential of Industry 4.0 in SMEs, the main limit lies in
a lack of methodological frameworks for its implementation and application.
Accordingly, presented research outputs aims to help in overcoming this gap through
proposed solutions.
The next section of this paper is focused on the existing literature, which relates to
proposed method. The third section describes the methodology of proposed method, in
which three main areas of the I4.0 concept, namely, smart logistics, smart production,
and organizational and managerial models are considered. The subsequent part of the
paper shows the practical application of the requirements mapping on the experimental
group consisting of 10 selected SMEs. The next section of the paper analyses and
evaluates the obtained results from questionnaires according to the proposed
methodology. Finally, concluding remarks are summarized.
2 Related Works
3 Methodological Framework
The proposed readiness self-assessment method and roadmap model aims to identify
readiness status and define future targets within the three main areas, namely [23]:
– smart logistics,
– smart production,
– and organizational and managerial models.
Each of these areas is divided into 5 related categories and each category include 5
levels to select from.
Mapping of innovative requirements of small and medium-sized enterprises in the
context of the strategy Industry 4.0 consisted of the following steps:
– creation of the questionnaire;
– mapping of requirements;
– results processing.
– If the company only identified the current state without the request to change
(e.g. level in current and planned state is the same), then the Rate of the change
(R) was assigned to this category as R = 0;
– if the company identified the request to change, then R = 1. Since the change
can be expressed over the interval (1, 5) from one level change to a change of
five levels, each request has been assigned a Weighting value of W. Weighting
values based on the level of change, while change in the range of one level
equals 1, 2; of two levels equals 1, 4; of three levels equals 1, 6; of four levels
equals 1, 8 and of five levels equals 2. The resulting Value for each category
was determined by the equation:
X10
V¼ i¼1
R i Wi ð1Þ
Fig. 1. Results of mapping of individual requirements for smart logistics, smart production, and
organizational and managerial models.
190 V. Modrak et al.
Applying the self-assessment method and roadmap model from Sect. 3, results of
mapping of individual requirements of the 10 companies are graphically depicted in the
Fig. 1.
The category importance values V for the three areas were calculated in accordance
with Sub-Sect. 3 of the methodology. The results of V and cumulated values in % are
listed in the Table 5 according to their order of category of significance (OCS).
Table 5. Determination of the order of category of significance for all the areas.
Areas SMART production SMART logistics Organizational and
managerial models
OCS 1.2 1.4 1.1 1.3 1.5 2.1 2.4 2.3 2.2 2.5 3.5 3.3 3.1 3.2 3.4
V 10, 2 9, 2 7, 8 5, 4 5, 2 11, 8 11, 4 11 9, 4 8 11, 6 10, 2 9, 4 7, 6 7, 6
% 27 51 72 86 100 23 45 66 85 100 23 46 66 83 100
Differences in values V for all three areas are minimal, so it is inappropriate to use
the Pareto principle to determine important and irrelevant categories. For this reason,
values will only be used to determine the order of category significance.
In the next step, there were calculated the average current and required levels for
each category of each three areas in order to identify the requirements of small and
medium-sized enterprises in the context of the strategy Industry 4.0. The obtained
results are graphically shown in Fig. 2.
As can be seen from the Fig. 2, the most significant requirements were identified
for the area of smart production, the next important area is smart logistics and the least
significant is area of organizational and managerial models.
In order to validate obtained results from population sample represented by 10
SMEs (subjects –S) by asking the questions, the overall internal consistency of the
questionnaire can be measured by Cronbach’s alpha [24]. For this purpose, the
obtained data were arranged into Table 6.
Subsequently, Cronbach’s alpha coefficients were separately calculated for the
current states and the required states by using the formula [25]:
P 2
k si Þ
a¼ 1 ; ð4Þ
ð k 1Þ s2t
Mapping Requirements and Roadmap Definition for Introducing I 4.0 191
Fig. 2. Spider graph of differences between current states and required states.
5 Conclusions
Summarizing the obtained results, it can be expected that effort of SMEs related with
Industry 4.0 challenges will be focused:
(a) in the production domain especially on:
• use of RFID technologies for data processing,
• using mobile user interfaces,
• using machines with internet connection,
• use of ICT to identify statuses in the production,
• introduction of IoT into the production;
(b) in the logistics domain especially on:
• implementing of automatic control into delivery processes,
• introduction of autonomous inventory management;
(c) in the organizational and managerial domain especially on:
• application of the organizational models of production for mass customized
products.
Moreover, the study presented in this paper offered possible generic Industry 4.0
maturity model as self-assessment tool to provide companies to help them understand
their current state in the field of Industry 4.0.
The given results will be in our future work used for development of technical
solutions and managerial methods for transitions from the current technical/technological
states to the required states.
Acknowledgement. This paper has been supported by the project with acronym SME 4.0 and
titled as “SME 4.0 - Smart Manufacturing and Logistics for SMEs in an X-to-order and Mass
Customization Environment” with funding received from the European Union’s Horizon 2020
research and innovation program under the H2020-EU.1.3.3, Project ID: 734713 and by VEGA
project Nr. 1/0419/16 granted by the ME of the Slovak Republic.
Mapping Requirements and Roadmap Definition for Introducing I 4.0 193
References
1. Kagermann, H., et al.: Umsetzungsempfehlungen für das Zukunftsprojekt Industrie 4.0:
Deutschlands Zukunft als Produktionsstandort sichern; Abschlussbericht des Arbeitskreises
Industrie 4.0. Forschungsunion (2013)
2. Modrak, V., Marton, D., Bednar, S.: Modeling and determining product variety for mass-
customized manufacturing. Procedia CIRP 23, 258–263 (2014)
3. Modrak, V., Soltysova, Z.: Novel complexity indicator of manufacturing process chains and
its relations to indirect complexity indicators. Complexity 2017, 15 (2017)
4. Modrak, V., Soltysova, Z., Modrak, J., Behunova, A.: Reducing impact of negative
complexity on sustainability of mass customization. Sustainability 9(11), 2014 (2017)
5. Dima, I.C., Gabrara, J., Modrak, V., Piotr, P., Popescu, C.: Using the expert systems in the
operational management of production. In: 11th WSEAS International Conference on
Mathematics and Computers in Business and Economics, pp. 307–312 (2010)
6. UNITY Consulting and Innovation – via The Network Effect. https://www.slideshare.net/
MarketingUNITY/supply-chain-management-71050225
7. Leyh, C., Bley, K., Schäffer, T., Forstenhäusler, S.: SIMMI 4.0 - a maturity model for
classifying the enterprise-wide it and software landscape focusing on Industry 4.0. In:
Federated Conference on Computer Science and Information Systems (FedCSIS), Gdansk,
pp. 1297–1302 (2016)
8. Anderl, R.: Industrie 4.0–Digital transformation in product engineering and production. In:
21st International Seminar on High Technology-Smart Products and Smart Production. At
Piracicaba (SP), Brazil (2016)
9. Agca, O., Gibson, J., Godsell, J., Ignatius, J., Wyn Davies, C., Xu, O.: An Industry 4
readiness assessment tool. WMG International Institute for Product and Service Innovation
University of Warwick (2017). https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/wmg/research/scip/
industry4report/final_version_of_i4_report_for_use_on_websites.pdf
10. Ibarra, D., Ganzarain, J., Igartua, J.I.: Business model innovation through Industry 4.0: a
review. Procedia Manuf. 22, 4–10 (2018)
11. Kans, M., Ingwald, A.: Business model development towards service management 4.0.
Procedia CIRP 47, 489–494 (2016)
12. Arias-Perez, J.E., Durango-Yepes, C.M.: Exploring knowledge management maturity from
funcionalist and interpretivist perspectives. Entramado 11(1), 94–104 (2015)
13. Geissbauer, R.; Vedso, J.; Schrauf, S.; Industry 4.0: Building the digital enterprise. Retrieved
from PwC Website (2016). https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/industries-4.0/landing-
page/industry-4.0-building-your-digital-enterprise-april-2016.pdf
14. Stock, T., Seliger, G.: Opportunities of sustainable manufacturing in industry 4.0.
Procedia CIRP 40, 536–541 (2016)
15. Ganzarain, J., Errasti, N.: Three stage maturity model in SME’s toward industry 4.0.
J. Industr. Eng. Manag. 9(5), 1119 (2016)
16. Ivanov, D., Sokolov, B., Ivanova, M.: Schedule coordination in cyber-physical supply
networks Industry 4.0. IFAC-Papers Online 49(12), 839–844 (2016)
17. Chromjakova, F.: Flexible man-man motivation performance management system for
Industry 4.0. Int. J. Manag. Excell. 7(2), 829–840 (2016)
18. Zhong, R.Y., et al.: Intelligent manufacturing in the context of industry 4.0: a review.
Engineering 3(5), 616–630 (2017)
19. Singh, P.M., Van Sinderen, M.J., Wieringa, R.J.: Smart logistics: an enterprise architecture
perspective. In: 29th CAiSE Conference CAiSE Forum, pp. 9–16 (2017)
194 V. Modrak et al.
20. Chavarría-Barrientos, D., et al.: A methodology to create a sensing, smart and sustainable
manufacturing enterprise. Int. J. Prod. Res. 56(1-2), 584–603 (2018)
21. Making Industry 4.0 Real – using the acatech I4.0 Maturity Index. https://www.infosys.com/
engineering-services/white-papers/Documents/industry-4.0-real.pdf
22. Hofmann, E., Rüsch, M.: Industry 4.0 and the current status as well as future prospects on
logistics. Comput. Ind. 89, 23–34 (2017)
23. Rauch, E., Dallasega, P., Matt, D.: Critical factors for introducing lean product development
to small and medium sized enterprises in Italy. Procedia CIRP 60, 362–367 (2017)
24. Cortina, J.M.: What is coefficient alpha? an examination of theory and applications. J. Appl.
Psychol. 78(1), 98 (1993)
25. Machin, D., Campbell, M.J., Walters, S.J.: Reliability and method comparison studies. In:
Medical Statistics, 4th edn., 209 p. Wiley, England (2007)
Dimensional Characterization of Prosthesis
Bearings for Tribological Modelling
1 Introduction
Total hip replacement (THR) is one of the most common orthopedic surgical proce-
dures performed worldwide involving applications of biomaterials, with 1.5 million
estimated operations per-formed annually. In this total joint replacement, three com-
ponents are present: a femoral stem with a spherical head mounted on top and a
spherical cup inserted in the pelvic bone. The spherical head articulates against the
spherical cup ensuring joint mobility during the gait [1]. It is estimated that the joint
replacements surgical implants degrade after 10–15 years of use [2]. In the last year, the
increase in life expectancy and in activity levels lead to a continuous request for
improvement of their performance to offer longer term improved quality of life. In
order to understand and to evaluate the preclinical and clinical performance of the THR
many researches have been carried out [3]. One of the factors that significantly
influence the durability of hip prostheses is the contact stresses in bearing surfaces. In
fact they are critical for the progress of the wear [4]. During its useful life, a hip
prosthesis is subject to three-dimensional motions and variable loads due to human
activity (e.g. ambulation, stair climbing etc.). This means that the tribo-surfaces always
undergo varying contact stresses which over time cause wear and damage to the
bearing surfaces. Undesirable phenomena which, as a result, lead to osteolysis and
aseptic loosening [5]. For these reasons and for its importance in the performance of
these devices, in recent years, numerous authors have tried to explain the lubrication
mechanisms of normal human joints [6, 7] and the problems of friction and wear in the
case of the joint replacement [8]. Wear debris released by soft material as the ultra-high
molecular weight polyethylene UHMWPE) commonly used for the acetabula cup
reduce the life of hip implants [9], therefore the “hard-on-soft” bearing pairs (metal-on-
UHMWPE and ceramic-on-UHMWPE) [10] have been replaced by the availability of
new materials with high wear resistance. In addition, advanced surface finish and
coating techniques, recently developed, have further improved the performance of
these devices. Although, recently, hard-on-hard bearing couples are used in the THR
(metal-on-metal and ceramic-on-ceramic) in order to reduce wear debris generation
there are still many vital problems. Among these we find the osteolysis due to both
metal wear debris in the case of metal-on-metal implants and to the ceramic fracture
caused by the unexpected loading of the edge in the case of ceramic-on-ceramic
implants. These problems are mainly related to the correct knowledge and prediction of
the lubrication mechanisms of the tribo-system in terms of prosthesis design and in
terms of surface characterization of the prosthetic implants. In fact, many studies, both
theoretical (Analytical modeling [11], FEM analysis [12]) and experimental (in-vitro
and in-vivo) have shown that the initial conditions (analysis of the shape of the
prosthetic joint and of dimensional parameter) and the superficial roughness [13] (to-
pographic analysis of the surfaces in contact) are of fundamental importance for the
correct functioning and the long duration of hip implants. For this reason, the aim of
this study is to present a new methodology for the characterization of the shape of the
articular surfaces and for the topographic analysis of the contact surfaces of the hip
prosthesis. In this study, two ceramic-on-ceramic hip replacements were used for the
experimental analysis. The first step was the analysis of the shape and the measurement
of dimensional parameters. Once the coordinates of the points that define the surface
under study are obtained, they were applied fitting algorithms to allow form tolerance
deviation from the ideal geometry of substitution. The last step was the analysis of the
surfaces by using confocal microscopy.
Dimensional Characterization of Prosthesis Bearings 197
In this study two femoral spherical heads and two spherical cup were investigated (see
Fig. 1). Note that in despite the cups and heads geometry and manufacturing processes
are made independently, the conformity of the couple resides in its fit. Clearance
between cup and head governs the lubrication regime so it is a main figure of merit in
the dimensional characterization, both at macro (shape) and micro (roughness) levels.
Fig. 1. The ceramic femoral spherical heads and the spherical cups.
Fig. 2. Measuring prosthesis bearing through (a) the CMM and (b) confocal microscope.
3 Results
other. In Table 1 the mean radius R is calculated through a programmed sphere fitting
algorithm following the accurate Levenberg-Marquardt least-square method. Maximum
and minimum radius values, as well as the root mean square error (R rmse) are set for
spread assessment. Sphericity of the surfaces is the difference of the maximum and
minimum radius. Mean, maximum and minimum clearances for each prosthesis are
calculated based on the difference between the cup and the head.
100
Femoral head roughness parameters
80
10X 20X
60
40
20
0
Sa [nm] Sq [nm] Ssk Sku Sz [nm] Sv [nm] Sp [nm] Smr1 Sfd Sdc0_5
[%] [nm]
Fig. 3. Comparison across the two magnifications of the roughness parameters acquired on the
femoral head.
200 R. D’Amato et al.
Fig. 4. Comparison across the two magnifications of the roughness parameters acquired on the
acetabular cup.
0.04
0.03
10X 20x
0.02
0.01
0
Sds [1/μm²] Sdq
0.035
0.03
10X 20X
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
1 2
From the topographical analysis they were gained the roughness values charac-
terizing each surface. Regarding the femoral head, the data retrieved are summarized in
Fig. 3, whereas in Fig. 4 they are shown the parameters relative to the acetabula
cup. Sds and Sdq required a different scale and are shown in separated histograms
presented in Figs. 5 and 6.
4 Discussion
Spherical shape is more accurate and less variable in prosthesis head (about 3 µm) than
cups (samples in the range of 5 to 9 µm). The sphericity of the components, but more
particularly in the case of heads, is in the order of magnitude of micrometers, is at the
typical order of magnitude of roughness. The results make sense, due to the manu-
facturing difficulty of making a precise cavity versus a convex head. The mean radius
of heads differs in the order of tens of micrometer, when the differences be-tween the
cups is at micrometer level. In the same direction, root mean square error of radius is an
order or magnitude higher in cups than in heads. Considering each different prosthesis,
the mean clearance ranges from 24 to 50 µm in the specimen, but the range of
clearance between the cup and head is of the same range, between 15 and 18 µm,
denoting the same variability in each prosthesis, made by the same manufacturing
processes. Noteworthy, the same model of prosthesis pre-sets a clearance that is double
in one specimen with respect the other. This can represent a significant influence in the
lubrication regime, because the film thickness or lambda ratio can be double for a
similar roughness. That means different lubrication transition regime with the same
prosthesis model that could become significant differences in wear, in despite of the
same conditions of patient use.
The results of the surface topography underline the difference in term of roughness
indicators derived with two different magnifications. The data obtained are useful to
identify the starting conditions of a hip implant. Roughness is, in fact, one of the main
characteristic that influence the lubrication and therefore the wear of a tribo-couple. It is
well known that the lubrication regime is strictly related to the mean heights of the
coupled surfaces in relative motion [16]. Sa, Sqa and Sz are valuable indicators of such
aspect. The first two parameters reached the values of less than 10 nm for both the
interacting surfaces, whereas the third is around 50 nm and 75 nm respectively with
10 and 20 for both the head and the cup. Ssk is almost zero in each case, indi-
cating a normal distribution of the peaks and valleys along the surfaces, namely an
almost symmetric profile. Sku has values about 4, which means that the asperity height
distribution presents wide wings and a narrow central peak. Skewness and Kurtosis are
generally suitable parameters in characterizing respectively the surface capacity of
trapping the lubricant and the geometry of the contact interface [17].
Sv and Sp are, as known, strongly influenced by the local deformity of the surface
and are less effective in describing the surface characteristic. Their values are sensibly
different head between head and cup and also between the two magnifications.
Sds, indicating the spatial density, is below 0.01 µm−2 as analyzed by the
10 magnification, but increases to around 0.03 µm−2 under the 20 lens. Sdq
maintains its values below 0.01, showing a slightly increase under the higher
202 R. D’Amato et al.
magnification. Along with Sq, these parameters has been related to wear by Greenwood
and Tripp [18]. They introduced the product SqbSds, where b is the mean summit of
radius curvature of peaks in the surface topography. The plasticity index, in this form,
can be expressed as:
0
E
w¼ Sq b Sds ð1Þ
H
In the Eq. (1) E0 is the Hertzian elastic modulus, from the combination of the
elasticity of the two materials. A different expression, of the plasticity index, suggested
by Mikic takes into account the Sdq parameter:
0
E
w¼ Sdq ð2Þ
H
As stated by Blunt and Thomas [19], it is physically reasonable that such combi-
nation of parameters ought to correlate with wear behavior. Increase of the roughness,
thus of the summit density and of the wear sites, influences the wear in the direction of
rising. As verified by Blunt and Thomas, the SqbSds parameter, combined with the
material property ratio (E′/H), gives fine agreement with wear behavior, thus allowing
for a pre-screening for material combinations excluding weak combinations.
5 Conclusions
Acknowledgements. This work has been developed in the framework of the Project DPI2016-
78476-P “Collaborative development of software standards, and traceability and inter-comparison
Dimensional Characterization of Prosthesis Bearings 203
studies for the metrological characterization of surfaces”, of the 2016 call of I+D Projects in the
Spanish National Programme of Scientific and Technical Research Excellence Promotion, sub-
programme of Knowledge Generation.
The authors gratefully acknowledge Dr. Saverio Affatato from the Medical Technology
Laboratory of the Rizzoli Orthopedic Institute (ITALY) for providing the femoral head and
acetabular cup analyzed in this study.
References
1. Affatato, S., Ruggiero, A., Merola, M.: Advanced biomaterials in hip joint arthroplasty.
A review on polymer and ceramics composites as alternative bearings. Compos. Part B 83,
276–283 (2015)
2. Ruggiero, A., D׳Amato, R., Gómez, E., Merola, M.: Experimental comparison on
tribological pairs UHMWPE/TIAL6V4 alloy, UHMWPE/AISI316L austenitic stainless
and UHMWPE/AL2O3 ceramic, under dry and lubricated conditions. Tribol. Int. 96, 349–
360 (2016)
3. Kurth, M., Eyerer, P., Ascherl, R., Dittel, K., Holz, U.: An evaluation of retrieved
UHMWPE hip joint cups. J. Biomater. Appl. 3(1), 33–51 (1988)
4. Rieger, W.: Ceramics in orthopedics–30 years of evolution and experience. In: World
Tribology Forum in Arthroplasty, pp. 283–294 (2001)
5. Visuri, T., Pukkala, E.: Does Metal-on-Metal Total Hip Prosthesis Have Influence on
Cancer? A Long-term Follow-up Study, in World Tribology Forum in Arthroplasty,
pp. 181–188. Hans Huber, Seattle (2001)
6. Ruggiero, A., Gómez, E., D’Amato, R.: Approximate closed-form solution of the synovial
fluid film force in the human ankle joint with non-Newtonian lubricant. Tribol. Int. 57, 156–
161 (2013)
7. Ruggiero, A., Gòmez, E., D’Amato, R.: Approximate analytical model for the squeeze-film
lubrication of the human ankle joint with synovial fluid filtrated by articular cartilage. Tribol.
Lett. 41(2), 337–343 (2011)
8. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E.: Experimental analysis of tribological behavior of
UHMWPE against AISI420C and against TiAl6V4 alloy under dry and lubricated
conditions. Tribol. Int. 92, 154–161 (2015)
9. Affatato, S., Ruggiero, A., De Mattia, J.S., Taddei, P.: Does metal transfer affect the
tribological behaviour of femoral heads? Roughness and phase transformation analyses on
retrieved zirconia and Biolox® Delta composites. Compos. Part B Eng. 92, 290–298 (2016)
10. Ruggiero, A., Merola, M., Affatato, S.: Finite element simulations of hard-on-soft hip joint
prosthesis accounting for dynamic loads calculated from a musculoskeletal model during
walking. Materials (Basel) 11(4), 574 (2018)
11. D’Amato, R., Calvo, R., Gó Mez, E.: Sensitivity study of the morphometric fitting on the
pressure field inside ankle joints. Case Stud. Mech. Syst. Signal Process. 1, 8–14 (2015)
12. Ruggiero, A., Affatato, S., Merola, M., De, M.C.: FEM analysis of metal on UHMWPE total
hip prosthesis during normal walking cycle. In: Proceedings of the XXIII Conference of the
Italian Association of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics (AIMETA 2017), pp. 4–7 (2017)
13. Ruggiero, A., Merola, M., Affatato, S.: On the biotribology of total knee replacement: a new
roughness measurements protocol on in vivo condyles considering the dynamic loading from
musculoskeletal multibody model. Measurement 112, 22–28 (2017)
204 R. D’Amato et al.
14. Calvo, R., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E., Domingo, R.: Integration of error compensation of
coordinate measuring machines into feature measurement: Part II—experimental imple-
mentation. Sensors 16(10), 1705 (2016)
15. Laurian, T., Tudor, A.: Tribological influence the clearance in the hip prosthesis. In: 8th
International Tribology Conference, 8–10, Belgrade, Serbia, pp. 65–70 (2003)
16. Dowson, D., McNie, C.M., Goldsmith, A.A.J.: Direct experimental evidence of lubrication
in a metal-on-metal total hip replacement tested in a joint simulator. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng.
Part C J. Mech. Eng. Sci. 214(1), 75–86 (2000)
17. Timsit, R.S.: Electrical contacts resistance: fundamental principles. In: Slade, P.G. (ed.)
Electrical Contacts: Principles and Applications, p. 1104. Marcel Dekker, Inc, New York
(1999)
18. Greenwood, J.A., Tripp, J.H.: The contact of two nominally flat rough surfaces. Proc. Inst.
Mech. Eng. 185(1), 625–633 (1970)
19. Blunt, L., Thomas, T.R.: Wear ranking of hard on hard bearings for prosthetic hip joints.
Wear 257(12), 1208–1212 (2004)
Accelerated Method of Cutting Tool
Quality Estimation During Milling Process
of Inconel 718 Alloy
1 Introduction
Machining processes, such as turning and milling are considered as one of the most
important categories of manufacturing processes in industrial practice. These processes
are long established, but everyday new challenges are arising for the machinists, as it is
required to process new materials, with complex thermophysical behavior or create
more complex shapes without increasing considerably the manufacturing costs. One of
the most important problems in cutting processes is the wear of cutting tool, directly
related to the manufacturing cost. When the wear of the cutting tool exceeds a specific
limit, it is replaced by a new cutting tool; tool wear is accelerated, when unfavorable
machining conditions are used, especially for special categories of workpiece material,
such as hardened steel, titanium or nickel alloys, composite materials and ceramics.
In particular, when machining Inconel 718, a widely used nickel superalloy for
aerospace applications special attention should be paid in order to prevent premature
tool failure. This alloy, has increased strength, is corrosion and creep resistant up to
relatively high temperatures, has low thermal conductivity and is rapidly hardening
under specific conditions [1–3]. In the relevant literature several researchers have dealt
with the prevention of tool wear during machining of Inconel 718. Li, Zeng and Chen
et al. [1] conducted experiments of up and down milling at two different cutting speed.
They concluded that mechanism of tool wear was flank wear and chipping, that during
up milling more rapid progression of tool wear was observed and that tool wear led to a
gradual increase of all forces components. Sugihara, Nishimoto, Enomoto et al. [2]
conducted high speed machining experiments on Inconel 718 workpieces. They found
that, at the early stages of tool wear, the predominant mechanism was diffusion wear
and at the later stages chipping and proposed the use of textured cutting tools for high-
speed machining of nickel superalloys. Grzesik et al. [3] conducted turning experi-
ments with three different coated cutting tool inserts at 5 different cutting speeds in the
range of 65–125 m/min. It was found that the predominant wear mechanism was notch
wear and correlations between wear, cutting forces, friction coefficient as well as
specific energy were established.
Xavior et al. [4] performed a comprehensive study of Inconel 718 machining with
three different cutting speed, depth of cut and feed values, as well as three different
insert types and cooling conditions. D’Addona, Raykar, Narke [5] employed a carbide
cutting tool at four different cutting speeds and observed cutting tool wear, cutting
forces and surface roughness. It was found that the lowest surface roughness was
obtained with 190 m/min cutting speed and that notch wear was the predominant wear
mechanism. Cantero et al. [6] investigated the effect of using different carbide tools
under dry and wet machining conditions at two different cutting speeds and were able
to detect the wear mechanism and tool life for each case. Hadi et al. [7] performed up
and down milling tests at three different cutting speeds, feeds and depths of cut. Their
findings indicated that tool wear is larger during up-milling, notch wear is the main
wear mechanism and that different chip morphology is obtained in up and down milling
(segmented and discontinuous, serrated chip, respectively). Li et al. [8] conducted end
milling experiments with cutting tools at three levels of initial wear and various
machining conditions. Apart from other findings, they showed that fatigue life of
machined parts in not significantly affected when cutting tool has VB value lower than
0.2 mm. Liao, Lin and Wang [9] investigated the tool wear during slot and side milling
of Inconel 718 workpieces with two different feed speeds with regard to cutting
temperature, plastic deformation and chip morphology.
In the present work, milling experiments of an Inconel 718 workpiece are con-
ducted with a view to validate a novel approach regarding the tool wear experiments.
More specifically, the proposed method offers a reliable way to conduct tool wear
Accelerated Method of Cutting Tool Quality Estimation During Milling Process 207
experiments at multiple cutting speeds with a single cutting tool, in order to obtain
results regarding both tool quality and recommended cutting speed range for each tool.
This method is finally applied to milling cases with three different cutting tools in order
to be verified.
The value of the final average torque value is computed by an appropriate algorithm
which is employed in the optimization process. This algorithm, presented also with the
flowchart in Fig. 1, requires the definition of some basic inputs such as the machining
time for the first cutting speed, the number of cutting speeds used in the tests and
machining parameters e.g. feed. Then, the average torque value at the end of the last
pass conducted at each speed is calculated using a regression formula derived from
208 W. Habrat et al.
preliminary tests and progressively the final average torque value is calculated. When
the optimum value for R, leading to a final torque value near 1.8, is determined the
optimization process is completed and details about the realization of the “accelerated”
method such as machining time for each cutting speed can be computed.
Fig. 2. Experimental results of average torque for the “accelerated” experiment in the range of
cutting speed of 90–170 m/min for tool A.
where: Mc is the average torque value, d is a constant that takes into account the
influence of feed and depth of cut and all other factors not included in the formula;
b and c are power exponents determining the impact of cutting speed vc and cutting
time tc. Based on experimental studies, it is assumed that the cutting torque for the new
tool is approximately 1 Nm.
210 W. Habrat et al.
a ¼ d vcc ð3Þ
Mc ¼ 1 þ a tcb ð4Þ
Mc ¼ 1 þ a tc ð5Þ
Further analysis was conducted to obtain the values for parameter a for each cutting
speed. According to this analysis, a correlation between a and vc was obtained:
Fig. 3. Experimental results of average torque for the “accelerated” experiment in the range of
cutting speed of 90–170 m/min for tool B.
Fig. 4. Experimental results of average torque for the “accelerated” experiment in the range of
cutting speed of 90–170 m/min for tool C.
Finally, for the third cutting tool, tool life was shown to be much shorter as the
value of 1.7 Nm is reached earlier than in the cases of the previous two cutting tools, as
can be seen from Fig. 4.
212 W. Habrat et al.
4 Conclusions
In the present work, a new method for conducting tool wear experiments at multiple
cutting speeds with a single cutting tool was proposed, based on experimentally derived
regression models and an optimization approach. Milling experiments for Inconel 718
workpieces were at first conducted, in order to derive the regression models and then,
experiments with three different cutting tools were used to verify the developed model.
It was determined that a wear indicator on the flank surface is difficult to apply for
evaluation of the milling tool with complex geometry. In this case, the average cutting
torque is better.
In the case of tool B, the results of experimental studies were compared with the
predicted values from the developed model. Good compatibility with the results has
been shown.
From these results, it was found that the proposed method can successfully provide
conclusions about tool life using average torque as wear indicator, as well as indicate
the suitable range of cutting speeds for obtaining lower wear rates.
Acknowledgements. The author would like to acknowledge, that this research has been carried
out as part of a project funded by the Polish National Centre for Research and Development.
Project No. INNOLOT/I/2/2013.
References
1. Li, H.Z., Zeng, H., Chen, X.Q.: An experimental study of tool wear and cutting force
variation in the end milling of Inconel 718 with coated carbide inserts. J. Mater. Process.
Technol. 180(1–3), 296–304 (2006)
2. Sugihara, T., Nishimoto, Y., Enomoto, T.: Development of a novel cubic boron nitride
cutting tool with a textured flank face for high-speed machining of Inconel 718. Precis. Eng.
48, 75–82 (2017)
3. Grzesik, W., Nieslony, P., Habrat, W., Sieniawski, J., Laskowski, P.: Investigation of tool
wear in the turning of Inconel 718 superalloy in terms of process performance and
productivity enhancement. Tribol. Int. 118, 337–346 (2018)
4. Xavior, M.A., Manohar, M., Jeyapandiarajan, P., Madhukar, P.M.: Tool wear assessment
during machining of Inconel 718. Procedia Eng. 174, 1000–1008 (2017)
5. D’Addona, D.M., Raykar, S.J., Narke, M.M.: High speed machining of Inconel 718: tool
wear and surface roughness analysis. Procedia CIRP 62, 269–274 (2017)
6. Cantero, J.L., Diaz-Alvarez, J., Miguelez, M.H., Marin, N.C.: Analysis of tool wear patterns
in finishing turning of Inconel 718. Wear 297(1–2), 885–894 (2013)
7. Hadi, M.A., Ghani, J.A., Che Haron, C.H., Kasim, M.S.: Comparison between up-milling
and down-milling operations on tool wear in milling Inconel 718. Procedia Eng. 68, 647–
653 (2013)
8. Li, W., Guo, Y.B., Barkey, M.E., Jordon, J.B.: Effect tool wear during end milling on the
surface integrity and fatigue life of Inconel 718. Procedia CIRP 14, 546–551 (2014)
9. Liao, Y.S., Lin, H.M., Wang, J.H.: Behaviors of end milling Inconel 718 superalloy by
cemented carbide tools. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 201(1–3), 460–465 (2008)
10. Habrat, W.F.: Effect of bond type and process parameters on grinding force components in
grinding of cemented carbide. Procedia Eng. 149, 122–129 (2016)
An Investigation on Tool Flank Wear
Using Alumina/MoS2 Hybrid Nanofluid
in Turning Operation
1 Introduction
The near dry machining (NDM) or minimum quantity lubrication (MQL) is the tech-
nique which helps in reducing the quantity of cutting fluid during machining [1].
Maruda et al. [2] observed a significant reduction in surface roughness using MQL
technique over dry machining. Moreover, Maruda et al. [3] noticed that the use of MQL
has yielded significant reduction in cutting tool wear rate. However, small quantity of
conventional fluids may not be the preferred choice to achieve lower tool wear due to its
poor thermal properties. Therefore, an alternative cutting fluid is needed with improved
thermophysical and tribological properties. To achieve the desired thermophysical
properties, the nanometre-sized particles may be added into conventional fluids, which
are called ‘nanofluids’ [4]. Vajjha and Das [5] noticed an improvement of 22.4% in
thermal conductivity at 6 vol. % of Al2O3 as compared to base fluid at room temperature.
In other studies, Yang [6] and Choi et al. [7] recorded severe increment of approx. 200%
and 150% respectively in thermal conductivity with the addition of multi-walled carbon
nanotube (MWCNT) in base fluid. Furthermore, Tansen et al. [8] observed that the
inclusion of small fraction of MWCNT nanoparticles into alumina-mixed solution has
significantly enhanced the heat carrying capacity. Interestingly, the higher thermal
conductivity affects the tool life positively [9]. Zhang et al. [10] investigated the effect of
addition of two nanoparticles (MoS2-CNT hybrid) in base fluid during grinding process.
The experimental results showed that lower value of G ratio and surface roughness
(Ra = 0.328 lm) was recorded with the application of MoS2-CNTs hybrid nanofluid as
compare to monotype nanoparticles (MoS2 or CNTs) mixed nanofluids. This may be
attributed to the synergistic behaviour of MoS2 and CNT nanoparticles mixed cutting
fluid. Furthermore, Singh et al. [11] investigated alumina/graphene hybrid nano-
lubricant during machining of AISI 304 steel and observed a significant reduction in
surface roughness and machining forces. Interestingly, the lower machining forces result
in obtaining good quality machined surface [12].
From the review of available literature it is evident that the hybridization of two
different types of nanoparticles enhances the machining performances of the cutting
fluids. Few researchers have reported some work on the hybrid nanoparticles enriched
cutting fluids. However, to the best of author’s knowledge, their investigations are
restricted to few machining processes such as grinding, milling and drilling. Moreover,
their application as a cutting fluids during turning operation for improved tool life is not
reported so far. This motivated the authors to investigate the effect of hybridization of
alumina (Al2O3) and molybdenum-disulphide (MoS2) on tool flank wear.
In present study, the attempt has been made to investigate the effect of mixing of
two different types of nanoparticles such as alumina and molybdenum disulphide in
base fluid. The mixing ratio of both nanoparticles is fixed in a volumetric proportion of
90:10 (Al2O3:MoS2). The tribological and spreadability of different nanoparticle
fractions (0.25, 0.75 and 1.25 vol. %) is measured on pin-on-disc tribometer and
goniometer, respectively [13]. Thereafter, tool flank wear (VB) is measured under the
application of alumina and its hybrid nanofluid using MQL technique on turning
operation of AISI 304 steel.
In the present study, the base fluid was prepared by mixing 5 vol. % vegetable oil in
distilled water. The water based nanofluid containing 25% of Al2O3 nanoparticles
(Dia. = 45 nm), was purchased from Alfa Aesar® and a water-based nanofluid having
MoS2 (30 nm in size) was procured from Sigma-Aldrich. The prepared hybrid nano-
fluid was the mixture of 90% of Al2O3 and 10% of MoS2 in volumetric ratio same base
fluid in three volumetric fractions (0.25%, 0.75% and 1.25% vol.). The NH22 lathe
(Make – HMT, NH 22/1500) machine tool was used to machine the AISI 304 steel
using mist of Al2O3 nanofluid and its hybrid nanofluid using MQL technique as
explained in [13]. The machining variables are tabulated in Table 1.
An Investigation on Tool Flank Wear Using Alumina/MoS2 Hybrid Nanofluid 215
Base fluid
0.7 Nanoparticle Al-MoS2 hybrid
volumetric fraction 1.25 vol.% Al2O3 nanofluid
0.6
Dry
Coefficient of friction
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300
Time (sec)
This may be attributed to the formation of nano-film between the sliding surfaces
due to its superior spreadability over mono type nanofluid. The maximum spreadability
was recorded with Al-MoS2 hybrid nanofluid as 38.6° at 0.25 vol. % followed by
Al2O3 nanofluid as 41.9º at 1.0 vol. %, as shown in Fig. 2. The minimum contact angle
represents a maximum wetting area per unit liquid volume.
216 A. K. Sharma et al.
40
20
0
0.00 0.25 0.50 0.75 1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75
Nanopartcile concentration (vol.%)
nano-cutting fluid, due to its lubricity (Fig. 1) and better wettability (Fig. 2) compared
to the conventional fluid, the tool could retain its original hardness for longer
machining time. Furthermore, the reduction in the tool wear could be achieved due to
the ball bearing effect of nanoparticles between the machining interfaces. The lower
contact angle also helped in reducing the cutting temperature, which lead to reduced
tool wear as well. Because of its superior tribological properties and spreadability
(Figs. 1 and 2) over tool surface, Al-MoS2 hybrid nanofluid maintained the cutting
tool’s temperature at lower values, as a result of which, the tool sustained its sharpness
of the cutting edge and resulted in lower tool wear (Fig. 4).
218 A. K. Sharma et al.
Fig. 3. The response surfaces for Al-MoS2 nanoparticle volumetric fraction (/) versus V and f.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4. Tool flank wear using (a) alumina (b) Alumina/MoS2 nanofluid.
4 Conclusion
• The hybridization of alumina and molybdenum disulphide reduces the coefficient of
friction. The lowest value (*0.14) is recorded at 1.25 vol. % Al-MoS2 hybrid
nanofluid.
• A significant variation in contact angle (wettability) with increase of nanoparticle
concentration is observed. Al-MoS2 hybrid exhibits minimum contact angle at
0.25 vol. % and alumina based nanofluid yields minimum value at 1.0 vol. %.
• The mixing of alumina and molybdenum disulphide reduces the tool flank wear as
compare to monotype nanofluids. The lowest value of tool flank wear (60.16 lm)
was observed with the use of Al-MoS2 hybrid nanofluid.
An Investigation on Tool Flank Wear Using Alumina/MoS2 Hybrid Nanofluid 219
The mixing of alumina and MoS2 in a fixed volumetric ratio (90:10) has enhanced
its tribological and machining performances. Moreover, the investigation can be
extended to optimize the nanoparticle mixing proportion, and effect of shape and size
of nanoparticles on their tribological and machining performances. Furthermore, the
hybridization of nanoparticles may be investigated in other applications like heat
exchangers, and lubricants under extreme pressure conditions.
References
1. Singh, R.K., Dixit, A.R., Mandal, A., Sharma, A.K.: Emerging application of nanoparticle-
enriched cutting fluid in metal removal processes: a review. J. Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. 39
(11), 4677–4717 (2017)
2. Maruda, R., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Królczyk, G.M.: Improving the efficiency of
running-in for a bronze–stainless steel friction pair. J. Fric. Wear 36(6), 548–553 (2015)
3. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Feldshtein, E., Nieslony, P., Tyliszczak, B., Pusavec, F.:
Tool wear characterizations in finish turning of AISI 1045 carbon steel for MQCL
conditions. Wear 372–373, 54–67 (2017)
4. Sharma, A.K., Singh, R.K., Tiwari, A.K., Dixit, A.R.: Characterization and experimental
investigation of Al2O3 nanoparticle based cutting fluid in turning of AISI 1040 steel under
minimum quantity lubrication (MQL). Mater. Today Proc. 3, 1899–1906 (2015)
5. Vajjha, R.S., Das, D.K.: A review and analysis on influence of temperature and
concentration of nanofluids on thermophysical properties, heat transfer and pumping power.
Int. J. Heat Mass Trans. 55, 4063–4078 (2012)
6. Yang, Y.: Carbon nanofluids for lubricant application; Ph.D. thesis. University of Kentucky,
United States (2006)
7. Choi, S.U.S., Zhang, Z.G., Yu, W., Lockwood, F.E., Grulke, E.A.: Anomalous thermal
conductivity enhancement in nanotube suspensions. Appl. Phys. Lett. 79(14), 2252–2254
(2001)
8. Tanshen, M.R., Lee, S., Kim, J., Kang, D., Noh, J., Chung, H., Jeong, H., Huh, S.: Pressure
distribution inside oscillating heat pipe charged with aqueous Al2O3 nanoparticles,
MWCNTs and their hybrid. J. Cent. South Univ. 21, 2341–2348 (2014)
9. Twardowski, P., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Hloch, S.: Investigation of wear and tool life
of coated carbide and cubic boron nitride cutting tools in high speed milling. Adv. Mech.
Eng. 7(6), 1–9 (2015)
10. Zhang, Y., Li, C., Jia, D., Li, B., Wang, Y., Yang, M., Hou, Y., Zhang, X.: Experimental
study on the effect of nanoparticle concentration on the lubricating property of nanofluids for
MQL grinding of Ni-based alloy. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 232, 100–115 (2016)
11. Singh, R.K., Sharma, A.K., Dixit, A.R., Tiwari, A.K., Pramanik, A.: Performance evaluation
of alumina-graphene hybrid nano-cutting fluid in hard turning. J. Clean Prod. 162, 830–845
(2017)
12. Nieslony, P., Cichosz, P., Krolczyk, G.M., Legutko, S., Smyczek, D., Kolodziej, M.:
Experimental studies of the cutting force and surface morphology of explosively clad Ti –
steel plates. Measurement 78, 129–137 (2016)
13. Sharma, A.K., Tiwari, A.K., Dixit, A.R., Singh, R.K.: Novel uses of alumina-MoS2 hybrid
nanoparticle enriched cutting fluid in hard turning of AISI 304 steel. J. Manuf. Process. 30,
467–482 (2017)
14. Sharma, A.K., Tiwari, A.K., Dixit, A.R.: Mechanism of nanoparticles functioning and effects
in machining processes: a review. Mater. Today Proc. 2(4–5), 3539–3544 (2015)
Additive Printing of Gold Nanoparticles
on Paper Substrate Through
Office Ink-Jet Printer
Abbreviations
AuNPs Gold Nanoparticles
LED Light Emitting Diodes
TFT Thin Film Transistors
USP Ultrasonic Spray Pyrolysis
TEM Transmission Electron Microscopy
DLS Dynamic Light Scattering
UV-vis Ultra-violet visible spectroscopy
ICP-OES Inductively Coupled Plasma with Mass Optical Emission Spectroscopy
AFM Atomic Force Microscopy
SEM Scanning Electron Microscopy
PVP40 Polyvinylpyrrolidone
D.I. De-ionized water
1 Introduction
Ink jet printing of the metal nanoparticles specifically Gold Nanoparticles (AuNPs) [1]
had recently become a successful viable alternative to the conventional approaches
(such as vapor deposition, photolithography) [2] due to its easiness in operation,
economical in cost and its flexibility as well as versatility [3]. Various application of
printed AuNPs in integrated circuits in LED displays [4], sensing [5], thin film tran-
sistors (TFT) [6], ceramics [7], bio-materials for tissue engineering [8] as well as in
different bio-medical applications [9] had made them as a promising technology in
different areas.
A bottom-up synthesis method, Ultrasonic Spray Pyrolysis (USP) is relatively
simple in construction [10], economically viable [11], and flexible in synthesizing
various types of metal nanoparticles (NPs) with desirable characteristics in the form of
colloidal suspension as well as in dry powder form [12]. It is one of the most suited
method for the large scale as well as up-scaled production for AuNPs that can be
utilized as a raw material for preparing conductive AuNPs ink [13]. Our previous
works in the synthesis [14] and characterization of AuNPs through USP [15] from
different precursors [16] had helped in choosing the optimum parameters for obtaining
the target properties of AuNPs for further use.
The article presents the synthesis of AuNPs from the Gold (III) Acetate precursor
through USP in the form of colloidal suspension. Initially, the synthesized AuNPs were
characterized through ICP-OES analysis (concentration), TEM (shape), DLS (size
distribution) and UV-vis (maximum absorbance wavelength). Subsequently, AuNPs
were concentrated for preparing the ink and was analyzed through AFM. The feasi-
bility analysis of printing on the photo paper substrate through a low cost office ink jet
printer was tested. The printed pattern were further investigated through SEM for
analyzing the distribution of AuNPs on the substrate.
Gold (III) Acetate (Au(CH3COO)3, Alfa Aesar, Germany, 99.9%), Hydrochloric acid
(HCl, 30% concentrated, Honeywell Fluka GmbH, Germany), Sodium Hydroxide
(NaOH, concentration of 40 g/mol in pellets, Panreac AppliChem GmbH, Germany),
Polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP40, Sigma Aldrich, Merck KGaA, Germany), Nitrogen (N2,
99.9%, Westfalen AG, Germany), Hydrogen gas (H2, 99.9%, Westfalen AG,
Germany), De-ionized water (purified with the Millipore system), Premium Photo
glossy Paper (A4 size, mass - 200 g/m2 with 5760 DPI, Kodak, India).
222 M. Shariq et al.
Table 1. USP synthesis of AuNPs from Gold (III) Acetate precursor with the following
parameters: Initial Concentration [Au], Evaporation (T1) and reaction zone temperature (T2), Gas
flow rate – Carrier (N2) and Reducing gas (H2) and Running time (in hour) as mentioned.
Exp. No. Precursor [Au] T1 (°C) T2 (°C) N2 (l/min) H2 (l/min) Running Collection
(g/l) Time (h) medium
1 Gold 1 120– 200– 1–1.5 1–1.5 3–4 0.1 weight
(III) Acetate 150 250 % PVP40 in
D.I. water
carries out the printing process. It was left idle for a few hours opening the valve to permit
flow into the cartridge. After printing for one time, the printed pattern were observed to
be prominent. It was made thicker by repeating multiple prints on the pattern.
SEM. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) with Sirion 400NC (FEI, USA) was used
for the analysis. A small sample of the unprinted and printed pattern paper was sticked
onto the carbon film holders for the analysis. It was done in ESEM mode due to non-
conductive paper substrate.
Statistics and Diagrams. Data were presented as a representative experiment or as a
mean ± standard deviation (SD) of at least 3 independent experiments. The differences
between control experimental samples were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test
with Bonferoni post test and values at p < 0.05 or less were considered to be statis-
tically significant. Microsoft Office Tools was used for plotting the graphs and figures.
AuNPs from the precursor Gold (III) Acetate having initial [Au] of 1 g/l were suc-
cessfully synthesized through USP. A heavy thick cloud of the aerosol were generated
with the help of ultrasonic generator operating at the highest intensity. These aerosol
droplets were transported to the evaporation zone maintained in the temperature range
of 120 °C–150 °C in order to completely evaporate the water content. While the
reaction zone temperature was maintained at 200 °C–250 °C for the thermal decom-
position of the precursor into the final AuNPs. The optimum gas flow rates of 1–
1.5 l/min was used for the carrier and reducing gases during the process. AuNPs were
finally collected in the solution of 0.1% weight of PVP40 and D.I water in the col-
lection bottles. The violet color of the solution gave an indication for the successful
experimentation.
Further, the presence of AuNPs were confirmed by the TEM investigation as shown
in Fig. 1(a). They were largely ellipsoidal in shape with a calculated circularity of 0.53
while a small percentage were agglomerated forming the potato shape. This agglom-
eration can be mainly attributed due to the phenomenon of uneven sintering of AuNPs
in the reaction zone. The surface of the AuNPs were seemed to be free from visible
defects such as cracks, porosity and pinholes etc.
The hydrodynamic size distribution of the AuNPs was measured by DLS as shown
in Fig. 1(b). It can be divided into three groups with respect to AuNPs diameter: 14–
28 nm having 77% of AuNPs, 28–56 nm having 22.6% and above 56 nm having
0.4%. The AuNPs height was below 50 nm. The zeta potential measured was
32.8 ± 1.6 mV indicating the sufficient stability without agglomeration. The maxi-
mum UV-vis absorbance wavelength of the AuNPs was measured at 532 nm as shown
in Fig. 1(c).
Additive Printing of Gold Nanoparticles on Paper Substrate 225
Fig. 1. Characterization of the AuNPs synthesized from Gold (III) Acetate through
USP. (a) TEM, (b) Size Distribution through DLS measurement, (c) UV-vis spectroscopy.
The obtained AuNPs from the USP were subsequently concentrated and filtered
through syringe filters for preparation of concentrated AuNPs ink as shown in Fig. 2(a)
and its AFM image at Fig. 2(b). These post processes were done in order to avoid the
clogging problems in the cartridge nozzle of office ink jet printer (Fig. 2(c)) with the
increased concentration. The SEM image (Fig. 2(d)) of the surface topography of the
photo paper before printing revealed micro fibers which will act as macro as well as
micro pores for the absorption of the AuNPs ink The AuNPs printed pattern on the
paper substrate were observed to be prominent even after one print. It was made thicker
by allowing multiple prints as shown in Fig. 2(f). The AuNPs ink filled these pores
after the printing process providing a better adhesion and absorption properties for the
paper substrate. Thus, sufficient stability of AuNPs had been achieved on the surface of
the printed patterns. The ellipsoidal morphology of the AuNPs under the size range of
below 50 nm were appropriate enough for the smooth flow behavior through the
nozzles. Though the AuNPs printed pattern looked continuous to the naked eye, when
observed under SEM microscopy, the density of the AuNPs were low and discontin-
uous. AuNPs in the image as shown in Fig. 2(g) were clearly visible in the white micro
regions. These AuNPs appeared in this color due to the interaction of electron beam
with printed AuNPs on paper. In order to use these printed patterns for high end
applications, the concentration of AuNPs should be increased further above 1500 ppm.
226 M. Shariq et al.
Fig. 2. Ink-jet printing of the AuNPs on paper substrate. (a) Concentrated AuNPs ink, (b) AFM
characterization of the prepared ink, (c) EPSON L210 Office ink jet printer, (d) Photo paper used
as substrate, (e) SEM image of the Photo paper, (f) Printed pattern on the paper, (g) SEM image
of the printed pattern on the paper.
4 Conclusions
AuNPs were successfully synthesized from the precursor Gold (III) Acetate under the
chosen parameters of evaporation and reaction zone temperature, gas flow rates of
carrier and reducing agents through USP. AuNPs had the following properties: Mostly,
non-agglomerated in nature and ellipsoidal shaped with a circularity of 0.53 with three
size distributions: 14–28 nm having 77% of AuNPs, 28–56 nm having 22.6% and
Additive Printing of Gold Nanoparticles on Paper Substrate 227
above 56 nm having 0.4%. Moreover, the AuNPs with height below 50 nm having zeta
potential value of 32.8 ± 1.6 mV and maximum absorbance wavelength of 532 nm.
The customized ink comprising of concentrated and stable AuNPs was successfully
prepared. It is clearly reflected in the ink jet printing capability of AuNPs ink used in
low cost EPSON L210 office printer on the photo paper substrate. Ellipsoidal shaped
under the mentioned size range of AuNPs were appropriate for printing with this printer
due to its smooth flow behavior through the nozzle. These printed patterns showed the
possibility of printing with higher concentrations of AuNPs in future for flexible
electronics and bio-medical applications.
Acknowledgement. The study was supported by the European Union – Erasmus Mundus
Action 2 Lot 13 Euphrates Program and Slovenian Research Agency ARRS Slovenia (P2-120,
Martina Program and OP20.00369).
References
1. Cui, W., Lu, W., Zhang, Y., Lin, G., Wei, T., Jiang, L.: Gold nanoparticle ink suitable for
electric-conductive pattern fabrication using in ink-jet printing technology. Colloids Surf.
A Physicochem. Eng. Asp. 358(1–3), 35–41 (2010)
2. Khan, Y., Pavinatto, F.J., Lin, M.C., Liao, A., Swisher, S.L., Mann, K., Subramanian, V.,
Maharbiz, M.M., Arias, A.C.: Inkjet-printed flexible gold electrode arrays for bioelectronic
interfaces. Adv. Funct. Mater. 26, 1004–1013 (2016)
3. Määttänen, A., Ihalainen, P., Pulkkinen, P., Wang, S., Tenhu, H., Peltonen, J.: Inkjet-printed
gold electrodes on paper: characterization and functionalization. ACS Appl. Mater.
Interfaces. 4(2), 955–964 (2012)
4. Yoshioka, Y., Jabbour, G.: Inkjet printing of oxidants for patterning of nanometer-thick
conducting polymer electrodes. Adv. Mater. 18, 1307–1312 (2006)
5. Bietsch, A., Zhang, J., Hegner, M., Lang, H.P., Gerber, C.: Rapid functionalization of
cantilever array sensors by inkjet printing. Nanotechnology 15, 873 (2004)
6. Jang, J.: Displays develop a new flexibility. Mater. Today 9(4), 46 (2006)
7. Derby, B.: Inkjet printing ceramics: from drops to solid. J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 31, 2543–2550
(2011)
8. Boland, T., Xu, T., Damon, B., Cui, X.: Application of inkjet printing to tissue engineering.
Biotechnol. J. 1, 910–917 (2006)
9. Rudolf, R., Majerić, P., Tomić, S., Shariq, M., Fercec, U., Friedrich, B., Vučevićc, D.:
Morphology, aggregation properties, cytocompatibility & anti-inflammatory potential of
citrate-stabilized AuNPs prepared by modular ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. J. Nanomater.
2017, 9365012 (2017)
10. Majerič, P., Rudolf, R., Anžel, I., Bogović, J., Stopić, S., Friedrich, B.: Synthesis of NiTi/Ni-
TiO2 composite nanoparticles via ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. Mater. Technol. 49(1), 75–80
(2015)
11. Htay, M.T., Hashimoto, Y., Momose, N., Ito, K.: Position-selective growth of ZnO
nanowires by ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. J. Cryst. Growth 311(20), 4499–4504 (2009)
12. Montero, M.A., Chialvo, M.R.G., Chialvo, A.C.: Preparation of gold nanoparticles
supported on glassy carbon by direct spray pyrolysis. J. Mater. Chem. 19(20), 3276–3280
(2009)
228 M. Shariq et al.
13. Bogović, J.: Synthesis of the oxide and metal/oxide nanoparticles by the Ultrasonic Spray
Pyrolysis. Ph.D. Dissertation, Faculty of the Georesources & Materials Engineering, RWTH
Aachen University, Aachen (2015)
14. Majerič, P., Jenko, D., Friedrich, B., Rudolf, R.: Formation mechanisms for gold
nanoparticles in a redesigned ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. Adv. Powder Technol. 28(3),
876–883 (2017)
15. Majerič, P., Jenko, D., Budič, B., Colić, M., Friedrich, B., Rudolf, R.: Formation of non-
toxic Au nanoparticles with bimodal size distribution by a modular redesign of ultrasonic
spray pyrolysis. Nanosci. Nanotechnol. Lett. 7(11), 1–10 (2015)
16. Shariq, M., Majerič, P., Friedrich, B., Budic, B., Dixit, A.R., Rudolf, R.: Application of Gold
(III) Acetate as a new precursor for the synthesis of gold nanoparticles in PEG through
ultrasonic spray pyrolysis. J. Clust. Sci. 28(3), 1647–1665 (2017)
Preliminary Study on Staggered Herringbone
Micromixer Design Suitable
for Micro EDM Milling
1 Introduction
Miniaturization is a recent trend in analytical chemistry and life sciences [1] as well as
in non-silicon micromachining technologies [2]. In the past two decades, miniatur-
ization of fluid handling and fluid analysis has emerged in the interdisciplinary field of
microfluidics. Advantages of the microfluidic systems derive from significantly larger
specific surface-to-volume ratios and consequently in superior heat exchange properties
compared to conventional scale technology, permitting very fast heating and cooling of
reaction mixtures. Due to the small amount of chemicals needed and high rate of heat
and mass transfer, these systems are an extremely efficient tool for organic synthesis as
well as for process intensification [3].
micromixers an outline for efficient SHM design which is compatible with MET,
especially micro EDM milling technology.
Fig. 1. (a) Typical geometry of a staggered herringbone micromixer (SHM) and schematic
representation of the helical motion of fluid above the grooves. (b) Sample of the machined
geometries. (left) A straight groove (width 90 µm, depth 70 µm) and (right) staggered
herringbone groove (width 70 µm, depth 40 µm).
The working principal of the SHM is as follows: the fluid enters the grooves which
guide it to the edges of the main channel where it re-enters the main stream again. This
lateral displacement causes helical motion of the fluid and precipitates mixing.
In our case we limited the cross-section of the main channel to w = 0.2 mm and
h = 0.05 mm.
The tool electrode used was a tungsten carbide cylindrical rod with a nominal
diameter of 0.3 mm. Hydrocarbon oil was used as dielectric. All experiments were
performed using corrosive resistant steel X2CrNiMo17-12-2 as a workpiece.
The experiments performed for the construction of the technological model are
more thoroughly described in [9]. Only brief description is given here. Small grooves
(widths between 40 µm to 120 µm) of different depths (up to 100 µm) were machined
in order collect the experimental data on material removal rate (MRR), electrode
dressing times and electrode wear. The range of sizes of grooves was selected around
optimal dimensions suitable for micromixing. A sample groove scans are presented in
Fig. 1b.
The process parameters applied were suggested by the machine CAD/CAM suit-
able for finishing operations. The process parameters for electrode diameters of dE
0.05 mm were set as follows: energy index E to 13, negative polarity of the electrode,
width of discharge pulse tp to index 2, discharge frequency fp to 180 kHz, discharge
current index ip to 100, ignition voltage u to 90 V, gain index to 100, gap index gi to
74, machining layer depth z1l to 0.7 µm and the number of controls of electrode axial
wear nCON to every 10 µm of machined depth. For dE = 0.04 mm system suggests finer
settings with lower pulse current iP (index 80) and voltage u (77 V) values.
• electrode dressing time crucially depends on the electrode working length (lWL) thus
tED was modelled as:
• duration of electrode wear control is defined by the set layer control depth (every
10 µm) and the depth of the machined groove:
Corresponding SHM designs are parametrically denoted in Table 1. There, also mixing
performances (CoV) are presented. Eight different SHM designs were simulated and
compared in the view of their mixing performance.
Among tested designs it can be noted, that for the groove geometry with
a = 0.1 mm and d = 0.4 mm the highest number of grooves can be machined within
the TTOT, i.e. 15 (NG x NHC, see Fig. 2#3). This is due to higher MRR which linearly
rises with the electrode diameter, thus more grooves can be machine in TTOT. For
deeper grooves (d = 0.6 mm) at the same width (a = 0.1 mm) 3 grooves less can be
machined (see Fig. 2#4).
By same reasoning, despite removing a significantly less amount of workpiece
volume, when machining the smallest dimensions of grooves (a = 0.07 mm,
d = 0.4 mm), only 12 grooves are machined in TTOT (see Fig. 2#1 and #2).
Preliminary Study on Staggered Herringbone Micromixer Design 235
Fig. 2. Mixing performance of different SHM designs. Green color denotes complete mixing
(CoV = 0.5 mol/m3). #1: a = 0.07 mm, d = 0.04 mm, NG = 2, NHC = 6, CoV = 0.32; #2:
a = 0.07 mm, d = 0.04 mm, NG = 6, NHC = 2, CoV = 0.47; #3: a = 0.1 mm, d = 0.04 mm,
NG = 3, NHC = 5, CoV = 0.15; #4: a = 0.1 mm, d = 0.06 mm, NG = 3, NHC = 4, CoV = 0.19.
Operation conditions are defined by Re = 3 and Pe = 3670.
From Fig. 2 and Table 1 it can be deduced that the number of grooves in the half-
cycle plays a crucial role in the mixing performance of the design. The results show,
that more alternations of groove apex position in a particular design, denoted by higher
number of half-cycles, favor mixing performance. This is due to introduction of higher
flow disorder by the grooves, resulting in a more complex flow pattern.
The influence of groove depth on mixing can be inferred from the comparison of
the designs #3 (d = 0.4 mm) and #4 (d = 0.6 mm). Despite having 3 grooves less, the
#4 design performs similarly well. Thus, deeper grooves have favorable influence on
the mixing process.
When comparing our favorable designs with the ones reported in the literature [5–
7] it can be deduced that with wider and deeper grooves efficient mixing can be
achieved. Furthermore, narrow and shallow grooves render weaker mixing. Probable
cause for reported SHM realizations with smaller grooves lies in used microfabrication
method, namely soft lithography, which is suited for low aspect ratio groove
fabrication.
4 Conclusions
In this paper the influence of the micro EDM milling technology on the favorable SHM
design was studied. In the first part, the construction of the technological model of the
micro EDM milling is briefly presented. The technological model is suitable for various
groove like geometries, as are present in the SHM designs.
In the second part the technological model was used for the SHM design opti-
mization via CFD simulations. From the obtained results it can be concluded that micro
EDM milling is suitable technology for machining custom design SHM micromixers.
Due to EDM milling characteristics wider groove widths are machined faster, thus
making the micromixer machining cheaper. It was shown, that also wider grooves in
comparison to dimensions reported in literature, enhance mixing. Simulations show
that overall mixing performance crucially dependent on the orientation of the apex of
236 I. Sabotin et al.
the grooves, thus the number of grooves in a half-cycle. Simultaneously, groove depth
is an influential factor, where deeper grooves have positive effect on mixing.
In the future work the research will be directed in detailed analysis of mentioned
influential factors (i.e. number of grooves in a half-cycle and groove depth as well as
different main channel cross-sections). Furthermore, analysis using additional mixing
quantification identifiers (e.g. helicity of the flow, entropic measures, striation thick-
ness, etc.) should be performed in order to better understand the favorable influence of
wider and deeper grooves on mixing.
Acknowledgments. The authors would like to thank to the Slovenian Research Agency for
supporting the work in the frame of Research programme Innovative production systems and
processes P2-0248 (B). A special thanks goes to the Department of Industrial Engineering,
University of Padua, for support and enabling the access to the state of the art micro EDM milling
machine.
References
1. Hessel, V., Löwe, H., Schönfeld, F.: Micromixers—a review on passive and active mixing
principles. Chem. Eng. Sci. 60, 2479–2501 (2005)
2. Alting, L., Kimura, F., Hansen, H.N., Bissacco, G.: Micro engineering. CIRP Ann. -Manuf.
Technol. 52, 635–657 (2003)
3. Cvjetko, M., Nidari-Plazl, P.: Ionic liquids within microfluidic devices. In: Ionic Liquids:
Theory, Properties, New Approaches. InTech (2011)
4. Nguyen, N.T., Wu, Z.: Micromixers—a review. J. Micromech. Microeng. 15, R1–R16
(2005)
5. Stroock, A.D., Dertinger, S.K.W., Ajdari, A., Mezic, I., Stone, H.A., Whitesides, G.M.:
Chaotic mixer for microchannels. Science (80) 295, 647–651 (2002)
6. Williams, M.S., Longmuir, K.J., Yager, P.: A practical guide to the staggered herringbone
mixer. Lab Chip 8, 1121 (2008)
7. Du, Y., Zhang, Z., Yim, C., Lin, M., Cao, X.: A simplified design of the staggered
herringbone micromixer for practical applications. Biomicrofluidics 4, 024105 (2010)
8. Gjuraj, E., Kongoli, R., Shore, G.: Combination of flow reactors with microwave-assisted
synthesis: smart engineering concept for steering synthetic chemistry on the “fast lane”.
Chem. Biochem. Eng. Q. 26, 285–307 (2012)
9. Sabotin, I., Tristo, G., Valentincic, J.: Approach to technological modeling of micro EDM
milling. In: Proceedings of the 4 M/ICOMM2015 Conference, Milan, Italy, pp 71–74 (2015)
10. Kukuková, A., Noël, B., Kresta, S.M., Aubin, J.: Impact of sampling method and scale on
the measurement of mixing and the coefficient of variance. AIChE J. 54, 3068–3083 (2008)
11. Sabotin, I., Tristo, G., Junkar, M., Valentinčič, J.: Two-step design protocol for patterned
groove micromixers. Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 91, 778–788 (2013)
Experimental Analysis of the Cutting Force
Components in Laser-Assisted Turning
of Ti6Al4V
1 Introduction
Titanium and its alloys are widely used in many branches of industry. Machinability of
the titanium alloys due to their physical properties is limited. These alloys are classified
as difficult-to-cut materials because of their low thermal conductivity, high chemical
reactivity and low modulus of elasticity [1]. Four main areas of research and devel-
opment of machining of titanium alloys can be indicated – machining with high
pressure [2] and cryogenic cooling [3], ultrasonic-assisted machining [4] and laser-
assisted machining (LAM).
LAM is a hybrid cutting process (e.g. turning, milling) with the assisted of laser
beam as the heat source which heats the workpiece in front of the cutting region (see
Fig. 1). At higher temperature, the specific cutting energy is lower, what improves
workability. One of the principles of the LAM process is reduce the cutting force
necessary to machine. Moreover, Anderson et al. [5] confirmed large economic benefits
of LAM, in case of machining Inconel 718 alloy. In case of the nickel alloys, there are
many research in the field of LAM [6, 7] where the beneficial effect of laser-assisted
machining of Inconel 718 alloy on cutting force were presented [8].
2 Experiment Details
2.1 The Test Stand
The research on turning center MAG VDF 220 CD adapted for laser-assisted
machining were performed. The source of the laser beam was TRUMPF TruDiode
3006 diode laser (laser power - 3 kW). The measurements of the cutting force com-
ponents using a Kistler dynamometer type 9257B were made (see Fig. 2).
Fig. 2. CNC turning center MAG VDF 220 CD adopted for laser-assisted machining.
Cutting Tools and Process Parameters. For the tests, cutting tools with C geometry
inserts CNMG 120412-UP made of submicron cemented carbides (KC5010) were
applied (holder: PCLNR 2525 M12). The established process parameters range took
industrial recommendations and preliminary research results into consideration
(Table 2). Laser lens distance was set up for laser spot diameter 1 mm and the laser
beam was bring forwarded 0.5 mm relative to the cutting tool.
240 W. Habrat et al.
Design of Experiment. For the design of experiment the RSM method was used –
rotatable central composite design (CCD). The analysis of the results was performed
using the Design-Expert 11 software.
The results of test of the components of cutting force for the various adjustable
parameters of the LAM process are shown in Table 3.
Table 3. The results of tangential Fc and thrust Fp components of cutting force for each run.
Std Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3 Response 1 Response 2
Cutting speed vc Feed rate f Power P Force Fc Force Fp
(m/min) (mm/rev) (W) (N) (N)
1 90 0.1 500 102.9 124.7
2 150 0.1 500 83.5 122.0
3 90 0.3 500 175.5 165.8
4 150 0.3 500 164.8 163.
5 90 0.1 1500 67.0 96.9
6 150 0.1 1500 74.3 101.2
7 90 0.3 1500 139.8 130.40
8 150 0.3 1500 149.7 138.30
9 80.5 0.2 1000 122.3 123.50
10 159.4 0.2 1000 122.3 130.20
11 120 0.068 1000 63.3 92.60
12 120 0.33 1000 169.4 154.70
13 120 0.2 342 131.0 158.00
14 120 0.2 1658 112.8 132.20
15 120 0.2 1000 125.9 131.20
16 120 0.2 1000 121.4 132.20
17 120 0.2 1000 123.1 133.30
18 120 0.2 1000 123.0 133.40
19 120 0.2 1000 122.7 133.50
20 120 0.2 1000 124.3 132.10
Experimental Analysis of the Cutting Force Components 241
To evaluate if the model fits the experimental data, the analysis of variance
(ANOVA) for the adopted the modified quadratic model was conducted. The analysis
showed a significant influence of laser power P and feed rate f and interaction between
laser power and cutting speed on the tangential cutting force Fc.
For coded low cutting speed vc = 90 m/min and coded high feed rate f = 0.3
mm/rev the reduction of tangential cutting force was over 24% for changes of laser
power P in range 500–1500 W (see Fig. 3).
Fig. 3. The effect of the laser power P and feed rate f on the tangential cutting force Fc for
cutting speed vc = 90 m/min.
For coded high cutting speed vc = 150 m/min and coded high feed rate f = 0.3
mm/rev the reduction of tangential cutting force Fc was only about 10% for changes of
laser power P in the same range (see Fig. 4).
The decrease effect of tangential cutting force for the laser-assisted turning results
from the reduction of plasticizing stress value for higher temperatures and the
microstructure changes. The impact of the laser beam changes the proportional share of
the alpha and beta phases of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy. Figure 5 shows exemplary
microstructures obtained after laser heating of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy with the laser
scanning speed corresponding with cutting speed and the same kinematic of the pro-
cess. On the microstructures a melted zone and a temperature-impact border could be
observed.
Effect of laser beam power density on the tangential cutting force is observed as an
interaction between laser power and cutting speed in the elaborated model (1).
242 W. Habrat et al.
Fig. 4. The effect of the laser power P and feed rate f on the tangential cutting force Fc for
cutting speed vc = 150 m/min.
Fig. 5. The microstructures of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy after laser scanning with the power
P = 1200 W and scanning speed (a) 80 m/min and (b) 160 m/min.
The depth of melted zone significantly depends on laser scanning speed corresponding
to the cutting speed.
Also in case of thrust force Fp the modified quadratic model was conducted. The
significance of the impact of the model terms was determined. The analysis showed
lack of significance interaction between the parameters on the thrust forces Fp.
Experimental Analysis of the Cutting Force Components 243
For coded low cutting speed vc = 90 m/min and coded high feed rate f = 0.3
mm/rev the reduction of tangential cutting force was over 27% for changes of laser
power P in range 500–1500 W (see Fig. 6).
Fig. 6. The effect of the laser power P and feed rate f on the thrust force Fp for cutting speed
vc = 90 m/min.
The mathematical model of the thrust force Fp was obtained. The fitted model is
expressed as Eq. (2):
Lack of interaction in model (2) indicates other phenomena then for tangential force
that affect the reduction of the thrust forces Fp. The influence of reduction of plasti-
cizing stress value for higher temperatures is indisputable but changes the morphology
of microstructure after laser heating probably does not affect the thrust force.
In order to determine the factors influencing changes of the thrust force during
laser-assisted turning, surface roughness were analyzed. The quality indicators of
surface layer condition depends on machinability indicators, and it is particularly
important in the case of titanium alloys utilized in aerospace technology. In this
application area, additional quality requirements are defined.
244 W. Habrat et al.
Figure 7 shows examples of surface images obtained for constant cutting param-
eters and various laser heating powers for laser assisted turning. Roughness parameters
were also determined. The obtained results show the dependence of the surface mor-
phology after LAM on the laser power. The phenomenon can result from the changes
of cutting conditions after heating and it can be related to a change of thrust force.
However, this requires confirmation in further studies.
Fig. 7. Surface images and roughness parameters obtained for cutting speed vc = 120 m/min,
f = 0.2 mm, depth of cut ap = 0.25 mm and various laser power P after laser-assisted turning.
4 Conclusions
In the research, the effect of laser power and process parameters on tangential and
thrust forces in the laser-assisted turning of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy has been studied
using RSM method. The mathematical models were effectively established to predict
and optimize the cutting force components. Furthermore, the ANOVA analysis
revealed that the models can be successfully applied.
Experimental Analysis of the Cutting Force Components 245
The analysis showed a significant influence of laser power and feed rate and
interaction between laser power and cutting speed on the tangential cutting force. In
case of thrust force, lack of significance influence of interaction between the parameters
was recognized.
For coded low cutting speed, maximum reduction of tangential and thrust forces
was observed for a feed rate 0.3 mm/rev. The reduction of tangential cutting force was
over 24% and reduction of thrust force was over 27%, for the increase of laser power
from 500 to 1500 W.
The laser beam power density influences on the depth of melted zone and changes
of tangential force. The density depends on laser scanning speed corresponding to the
cutting speed.
Analysis of changes in cutting conditions after heating and its relation with thrust
force requires further studies.
Acknowledgements. This scientific research work is supported by National Centre for Research
and Development (NCBiR) of Poland grant No. PBS3/B5/36/2015 “Laser-assisted machining of
super alloys and titanium alloys used in aircraft engine structures”.
References
1. Sun, S., Brandt, M., Dargusch, M.S.: Characteristics of cutting forces and chip formation in
machining of titanium alloys. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 49, 561–568 (2009)
2. Habrat, W.F., Laskowski, P., Markopoulos, A.P.: Machining with high-pressure cooling. In:
Davim, J.P. (ed.) Metal Cutting Technologies. De Gruyter, Berlin (2016)
3. Trabelsi, S., Morel, A., Germain, G., Bouaziz, Z.: Tool wear and cutting forces under cryogenic
machining of titanium alloy (Ti17). Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 91, 1493–1505 (2017)
4. Roy, A., Silberschmidt, V.: Ultrasonically assisted machining of Titanium alloys. In:
Machining of Titanium Alloys, pp. 131–147 (2014)
5. Anderson, M., Patwa, R., Shin, Y.C.: Laser-assisted machining of Inconel 718 with an
economic analysis. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 46, 1879–1891 (2006)
6. Balbaa, M.A., Nasr, M.N.A.: Prediction of residual stresses after laser-assisted machining of
Inconel 718 using SPH. Procedia CIRP 31, 19–23 (2015)
7. Wojciechowski, S., Przestacki, D., Chwalczuk, T.: The evaluation of surface integrity during
machining of Inconel 718 with various laser assistance strategies. In: MATEC Web
Conference, vol. 136, p. 1006 (2017)
8. Woo, W., Lee, C.: A study of the machining characteristics of AISI 1045 steel and Inconel
718 with a cylindrical shape in laser-assisted milling. Appl. Therm. Eng. 91, 33–42 (2015)
9. Habrat, W.F.: Experimental investigation of effect of the laser-assisted finish turning of ti-
6al-4v alloy on machinability indicators (2017)
10. Rashid, R.A.R., Sun, S., Wang, G., Dargusch, M.S.: The effect of laser power on the
machinability of the Ti-6Cr-5Mo-5V-4Al beta titanium alloy during laser assisted
machining. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 63, 41–43 (2012)
11. Xi, Y., Zhan, H., Rashid, R.A.R., Wang, G., Sun, S., Dargusch, M.: Numerical modeling of
laser assisted machining of a beta titanium alloy. Comput. Mater. Sci. 92, 149–156 (2014)
12. Ayed, Y., Germain, G., Salem, W., Ben Hamdi, H.: Experimental and numerical study of
laser-assisted machining of Ti6Al4V titanium alloy. Finite Elem. Anal. Des. 92, 72–79
(2014)
Critical Failure Analysis of Lower Grinding
Ring of Ball and Race Mill
1 Introduction
Ball and race mill is a mechanical device used for pulverizing the coal for combustion
in boilers of thermal power plants. The ball and race mill consists of a lower grinding
ring connected to the drive assembly through a mechanical part yoke and stationary
upper grinding ring with the application of pressure from set of springs situated on the
thrust ring. 10 nos. of hollow steel balls are carried between these two grinding rings.
The lower grinding ring receiving the raw coal at the centre rotates and in turn rotates
the balls. In this process the coal trapped in between the grinding rings gets pulverized
and moves toward the outer edge of the lower grinding ring. This pulverized fuel is
then entrained in the high velocity flow of primary air, which enters the mill through
the air ports between the nozzle gap and the lower grinding ring. The coal air mixture is
carried up to the classifier, where the coarser particles are returned for further grinding
and finer ones go into the mill outlet pipes for distribution to boiler burners. The Fig. 1
shows the ball and race mill. One of the critical components of ball and race mill is
lower grinding ring, the failure of which leads to the forced outage of the working of
ball and race mill, resulting in huge losses. Therefore, it is highly necessary to
investigate the root cause of failure of critical component of ball and race mill and to
take remedial actions to prevent technical as well as economic losses. Such case was
observed in BPSCL (A Joint Venture Company of SAIL & DVC) on 19 June 2017.
Therefore, need arises to carry out the complete failure analysis of this failed lower
ring. Some research works have also been carried out in this area. Dennies [1], Wulpi
[2] and Brooks and Choudhury [3] have presented guidelines and methods of failure
analysis. Graham [4] has described the several strategies for failure analysis of any
equipment. Similarly, Ryder et al. [5] has elaborated the general practice in failure
analysis and prevention. Vander Voort [6] has presented failure analysis practices.
Particular rock conditions such as hard carbonates with chert inclusions [7] and con-
glomerates [8], and Interblended formations [9] have led to recurring failures and other
drilling difficulties. Gupta et al. [10] has carried out the failure analysis of tubes
consisting of several steps for analysing the failure. The present study has developed
a generalized methodology for investigation of failed crushing ring by considering
feasible influential factors with suggestions for remedial actions.
The lower crushing ring is made of material through casing as listed in Table 1.
Figure 2 shows the new lower grinding ring & broken grinding ring. This ring is
3250 mm in outer circumference with 90 mm core thickness and 130 mm race depth
for holding balls. The hardness of ring should be 550 BHN as required. Figure 3 shows
the arrangement of grinding rings inside a ball and race mill. It shows the position of set
of springs (04 nos. of set of springs), thrust ring and lower grinding ring.
Fig. 3. Arrangement of Grinding Rings, Balls and springs inside of Ball & Race Mill.
Critical Failure Analysis of Lower Grinding Ring of Ball and Race Mill 249
The failed cast crushing ring was made of cast steel. After installation in ball and race
mill, it gave life only 2861 running hours against 6500 running hours useful life.
Considering all aspects of operational and influential parameters, a generalized
methodology is developed. It is illustrated as a graphical set up in Fig. 4. A flow
diagram consisting of all steps of methodology of failed lower crushing ring is shown
in Fig. 5.
Fig. 4. Setup for methodology (1) Broken ring (2) EDS analysis, (3) hardness measurement,
(4) Microscope, (5) Erection process, (6) Operational parameters
250 G. K. Guptaa and S. Chattopadhyayab
The broken part of lower grinding ring was visually inspected and found direct sep-
aration of particles with evidence of surface cracks. The broken part has been shown in
Figs. 6 and 7. The ring was broken from the outer periphery after giving 2861 h against
useful life of 8000 h. Core thickness of ring was found 67 mm against 90 mm of core
thickness of new ring and race depth was 130 mm against 115 mm of new ring.
Critical Failure Analysis of Lower Grinding Ring of Ball and Race Mill 251
5 Conclusions
Ring Chemistry was found well within specified range. Microstructure study revealed
that Microstructure consists of Eutectic carbide in the matrix of Martensite & Bainite,
which was desired microstructure for Ni hard material. Hardness was not well within
the limit. The breakage of bottom ring occurred from the outer periphery of the ring,
which was an indication of radial load on the ring due to external thrust by the balls. It
was very much undesirable, as this type of ball and race mill can withstand only axial
Critical Failure Analysis of Lower Grinding Ring of Ball and Race Mill 253
load. There was no spring load on thrust ring which had caused the radial movement of
the ball in ball track of the lower grinding ring. It finally produces radial thrust on the
collar of the ring and lower ring had failed from that area.
References
1. Dennies, D.P.: How to Organize a Failure Investigation. ASM International, Ohio (2005)
2. Wulpi, D.J.: Techniques of failure analysis. In: Miller, B. (ed.) Understanding How
Components Fail. ASM International, Ohio (2000)
3. Brooks, C.R., Choudhury, A.: Metallurgical Failure Analysis. McGraw-Hill, New York
(1993)
4. Graham, R.: Strategies for failure analysis. ASM Adv. Mater. Process. 172(11), 45–50
(2004)
5. Ryder, D.A., Davies, T.J., Brough, I., Hutchings, F.R.: General practice in failure analysis.
Failure analysis and prevention. Metals handbook, American Society for Metal, Ohio (1986)
6. Vander Voort, G.F.: Conducting the Failure Examination Practice. ASM Handbook. ASM
International, Ohio (2002)
7. German, V., et al.: Conical diamond element bit sets new performance benchmarks drilling
extremely hard carbonate/chert formations. In: Perm Region Russia SPE/IADC Drilling
Conference and Exhibition, pp. 1905–1920 (2015)
8. Xu, Z., et al.: Hybrid drill bit combining fixed-cutter and roller-cone elements exceeds
expectations in challenging application in Tarim Basin China. In: IADC/SPE Asia Pacific
Drilling Technology Conference, Thailand, pp. 348–354 (2014)
9. Al-Enezi, D., et al.: Focused engineering initiative produces new 16-in roller cone TCI
design to solve carbonate. In: Drilling challenges in Northern Kuwait 19th SPE Middle East
Oil and Gas Show and Conference, Bahrain, pp. 441–449 (2015)
10. Gupta, G.K., Chattopadhyaya, S.: Critical failure analysis of superheater tubes of coal based
boiler. Strojniški vestnik - J. Mech. Eng. 63(5), 287–299 (2017)
The Influence of the Application of EP Additive
in the Minimum Quantity Cooling Lubrication
Method on the Tool Wear and Surface
Roughness in the Process of Turning
316L Steel
Abstract. The paper presents the influence of the application of the EP additive
based on pure phosphor in minimum quantity cooling lubrication. During
investigation, three methods of cooling the cutting zone have been applied in the
process of turning 316L steel: dry machining, MQCL, MQCL + EP. The wear
of the tool depending on the cooling method has been monitored, as well as its
influence on the machined surface roughness. Scanning analysis has shown
formation of a tribofilm as result of the application of the EP additive on the
surface of a plate with (Ti, Al) N coating deposited by the PVD method.
Experimental evidence suggests that the application of the MQCL + EP method
results in reduction of the VBB parameter as compared to dry machining and
cooling with emulsion mist up to the moment of the tool coating damage. It has
been found that, as result of the application of the EP additive in the MQCL
method, after damage of the (Ti, Al) N coating rapid increase of the tool wear
takes place and, consequently, increase of the machined surface, which is due to
the reaction with the base material (sintered carbide). This is caused by the
chemical action of pure phosphor without the carbon matrix on the exposed area
of the tool made of sintered carbide; the latter appears as result of adhesive wear
of the coating
1 Introduction
authors explain it with a break of the coating due to a crater formation on the rake face
and chemical reaction of the active molecules contained in the EP additive with the
exposed material of the tool. The least wear has been found with the application of the
pouring method. The researchers say that, in the case of one-layer tools coated by the
PVD method, this is caused by the reduced temperature of the tool, which ultimately
leads to later wear in the form of a crate. In the case of multilayer tools with CVD
coating, the degree of plastic deformation suffered by the tool and, consequently,
convexity appearing on the flank face, has also been reduced due to lower temperatures
of the tool.
In many works, the influence various extreme pressure [27], nanoparticles [22, 28]
is still investigated, as well as evolution of the supply of the active medium, e.g. due to
synergism between electrostatic spraying (ES) and machining with minimized lubri-
cation (MQL) [19]. The present paper discusses the influence of the EP additive applied
in the environment friendly cooling method, MQCL, on the tool wear and the machined
surface roughness when machining the 316L steel which is a commonly used material
for dental and orthopedic implants in the medical industry.
2 Experimental Procedure
The tests have been performed with the use of a universal centre lathe designated
CU502. The tool made of sintered carbide has been covered with (Ti, Al) N coating
with the thickness of 3 µm, with the symbol SNUN120408-PF and fixed in the tool
holder, CSRNR2525, with the wedge geometry: main tool angle: Kr = 75°, auxiliary
tool angle, Kr’ = 15o, tool inclination angle, ks = −6°; rake angle, co = −6°; corner
radius, re = 0.8 mm. The following machining parameters have been applied: vc =
210 m/min; f = 0.1 mm/rev; ap = 0.5 mm. The machined material was stainless steel,
316L, with the following chemical composition: Cmax – 0.03%; Simax – 0.1%; Smax –
0.015%; Pmax – 0.045%; Mnmax – 2%; Cr – 16.5–18.5%; Mo – 2–2.5%; Ni – 10–13%;
Nmax – 0.11%.
Formation of the active medium in the MQCL and MQCL + EP method has been
effected with the use the Micronizer Lenox 1LN whose diagram can be seen in Fig. 1a.
The device is provided with three spraying nozzles with the diameter of 1.2 mm for
maximum intensity of compressed air. In the tests, the following parameters of the
active medium formation have been used: compressed air flow intensity, P = 5.8 l/min;
active medium mass flow intensity, E = 26.4 g/h; nozzle distance from the cutting
zone, l = 0.3 m [2]. The pressure of compressed air was 0.48 MPa.
The active medium in the MQCL method was the emulsion concentrate, Emul-
gol S, based on highly refined mineral oil which is used in machining of stainless steels.
It contains, among others, such additives as: ionic and non-ionic emulsifiers, corrosion
inhibitors and enriching substances. In the MQCL method, concentration of 8% has
been applied in accordance with the producer’s recommendation for stainless steel
turning. The extreme pressure additive, EP, has been added to the active medium in the
concentration of 5% in the MQCL + EP method.
In the tests of the tool wear, the average width of the abrasive wear band on the
flank face in zone B VBB has been chosen for monitoring. The tool wear has been
The Influence of the Application of EP Additive 257
Fig. 1. Micronizer Lenox LN1: (a) general diagram, (b) location of the device nozzles.
measured with the use of a universal microscope, Dino Lite AM7013MZT which is
provided with a 5-megapixel sensor for performing images with measurement accuracy
of up to 0.001 mm. The tests have been performed till the value if index VBB 0.3 mm
has been achieved in accordance with the standard, PN-ISO 3685. The total working
time for the plates used in various cooling methods has been determined on the basis of
the initial tests.
Scanning analysis of the tools has been performed on the microscope, JEOL JSM-
5600LV coupled to an X-ray microanalyzer, EDS, which makes it possible assess the
quantitative, qualitative and chemical condition of the surface under examination.
Roughness of the machined surface has been examined by means of the profilo-
graphometer, PM – 02C monitoring parameter Ra. It is a contact device projecting the
surface after machining basing on roughness models. The design of the PM -02C has
allowed for measurements directly on the detail fixed in the lathe grip.
Determination of the wear of the tool in the process of turning 316L stainless steel is an
important issue in respect of productivity in machining hard-to-machine materials.
Monitoring of the tool wear always plays an important role in order to reduce unde-
sirable influence on the machining process and quality of the machined surface. The
dominating factors influencing the tool wear are cutting parameters (cutting speed,
feed), cooling method, tool geometry, tool properties (chemical, physical and
mechanical ones), etc. For the effective conditions of lubricating the zone of the tool-
machined material contact, the role of the active medium as a cooling and lubricating
agent has been considered in the paper. The influence of the cutting zone cooling in the
process of turning 316L stainless steel on the wear index, VBB, can be seen in Fig. 2.
In the case of the MQCL + EP cooling method, (Fig. 2c) small wears of the flank
face have been observed up to 42 min. Compared to dry machining (Fig. 2a), the VBB
258 R. W. Maruda et al.
Fig. 2. The average width of the abrasive wear band on the flank face, VBB, of the tool in
turning of the 316L steel depending on the method of cooling: (a) dry machining; (b) MQCL
method; (c) MQCL + EP method; (d) comparative assembly.
values are by about 64% smaller; compared to the MQCL method (Fig. 2b) by about
40% in the considered time. Emulsion mist cooling clearly reduces the disadvantageous
thermal effects influencing the process of cutting by lowering the temperature in the
cutting zone. Previous tests prove that the application of emulsion mist, where water
constitutes about 90%, during the process of turning stainless steels, lowers the tem-
perature and this, in turn, increases productivity of the manufacturing process by
reducing the tool wear in time [29, 30]. However, after 42 min rapid increase of the
tool wear takes place in the MQCL + EP cooling conditions. This is due to the abrasion
of the coating and the chemical reactions between the EP additive molecules and the
sintered carbide, P25. Initially, the tool wear (t < 42 min – MQCL + EP) takes place as
result of the mechanisms of adhesive wear. Additionally, phosphor sets on the tool
coating forming a thin layer of tribofilm [4] and, consequently reduces the influence of
the adhesive wear, which causes the difference between the wedge wear when cooled
with emulsion mist with the additive (MQCL + EP) and with the emulsion mist alone
(MQCL). However, after the tool coating is broken, mechanism of rapid wedge
The Influence of the Application of EP Additive 259
material loss arises because the application of pure phosphor as the EP additive
accelerates precipitation of the tungsten carbide grains from the bonding cobalt
material. The phosphor molecules are stopped between the tool and the moving
chip. Then the molecules start functioning as a grinding wheel and accelerate the loss
of the basic material of the tool. Analysis of the tool wear after 60 min of work
(Fig. 2c) indicates clear loss of the wedge material, particularly on the main cutting
edge, which is proved by the results of scanning analysis (Fig. 3).
Fig. 3. The results of scanning analysis of the flank face in the conditions of cooling by the
MQCL + EP method: (a) selected area for linear analysis; (b) SEM of the linear analysis;
(c) intensity of elements distribution in linear analysis.
For the scanning analysis of the flank face (Fig. 3) five elements have been chosen:
phosphor as the major component of the EP additive, aluminium and titanium as the
major components of the coating, iron and chromium as the major components of the
stainless steel, 316L. On the flank face, three zones of variable conditions of forming
phosphor based tribofilm have been observed. In zone I, where the biggest losses of the
wedge material occur, small quantities of phosphor have been found, which proves that
phosphor negatively influences the compounds of sintered carbide, P25. As result of
high temperatures occurring in the cutting zone, phosphor reacts with the tungsten
carbides causing more loss of the tool material as compared to cooling with the emulsion
mist alone. In zone II, where the wedge is still with the coat (as evidenced by the content
of its major components, aluminium and titanium) phosphor sets on the tool surface
forming so called safeguard layer in the form of tribofilm. Farther from the cutting zone
(zone III) the value of phosphor decreases. This is due to the fact that temperature drops
and, consequently, not all the droplets supplied to the cutting zone evaporate in 1 s [9].
260 R. W. Maruda et al.
The roughness of the 316L steel surface machined after turning, depending on the
cooling method, can be seen in Fig. 4. Examination of the surface roughness after
turning the 316L stainless steel presented together with statistics (for each measurement
the median, as well as the lower and upper quartile have been marked) has shown that
the influence of the cooling method depends to a large extent on the wear of the tool.
The lowest values of the Ra parameter have been found up to the 48th min in the case of
MQCL + EP cooling method and beyond 48 min for the MQCL method. The reason is
rapid increase of the tool wear after 42th min of work for cooling by emulsion mist with
the EP additive. Then torn off particles the sintered carbide of the tool can make micro
damages of the machined surface of the 3126L stainless steel. This is also proved by
the results of the Ra parameter after 60 min of work, where wide measurement range
has been recorded (from 1.41 µm to 2.20 µm. Reduction of roughness up to the 42nd
min in the case of MQCL + EP method can be related to the reduction of friction in the
contact between the tool and the machined object, particularly between the flank face
and the newly formed surface layer.
Fig. 4. Roughness parameter, Ra, after turning 316L stainless steel, depending on the cooling
method: (a) dry machining; (b) MQCL method; (c) MQCL + EP method; (d) collective assembly.
The Influence of the Application of EP Additive 261
4 Conclusion
The investigation has shown that the roughness of machined 316L stainless steel
surface depends on the wear of the tool and on the method of the cutting zone cooling.
In the present paper, the following conclusions have been drawn:
1. When applying the MQCL method with the EP additive, strong interaction between
the tool – coating material and the presence of phosphor as the EP additive has been
observed. Scanning analysis of the tool for the MQCL + EP method shows for-
mation of a tribofilm on the (Ti, Al) N coating which causes reduction of the tool
wear and, consequently, prevents the mechanisms of adhesive wear as long as the
coating is not broken. However, damage of the coating exposes the substrate of the
tool, which leads to chemical reactions between phosphor and the sintered carbide
substrate. The result is a rapid leap of the VBB value in the MQCL + EP method.
2. The application of MQCL cooling by emulsion mist alone causes reduction of the
average width of the abrasive wear band on the flank face in zone B by 5% to 30%
as compared to dry machining.
3. The lowest values of the Ra parameter have been observed up to the moment of the
(Ti, Al) N coating wear in the conditions of MQCL + EP cooling and after the
coating damage for the MQCL method. The effect of reduction of the machined
surface roughness is a result of the cooling properties of water which is 90% of the
active medium in the MQCL method, which reduces the quantity of heat dissipated
to the machined material.
References
1. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Feldshtein, E., Pusavec, F., Szydlowski, M., Legutko, S.,
Sobczak-Kupiec, A.: A study on droplets sizes, their distribution and heat exchange for
minimum quantity cooling lubrication (MQCL). Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 100, 81–92
(2016)
2. Kujawinska, A., Diering, M., Rogalewicz, M., Żywicki, K., Hetman, Ł.: Soft modelling-
based methodology of raw material waste estimation. In: Burduk, A., Mazurkiewicz, D.
(eds.) Intelligent Systems in Production Engineering and Maintenance – ISPEM 2017.
Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, vol. 637. Springer, Cham (2018)
3. Kujawinska, A., Diering, M., Zywicki, K., Rogalewicz, M., Hamrol, A., Hoffmann, P.,
Konstanczak, M.: Methodology supporting the planning of machining allowances in the
wood industry. In: SOCO. Springer, Leon (2017)
4. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Feldshtein, E., Nieslony, P., Tyliszczak, B., Pusavec, F.:
Tool wear characterizations in finish turning of AISI 1045 carbon steel for MQCL
conditions. Wear 372–373, 54–67 (2017)
5. Tai, B.L., Stephenson, D.A., Furness, R.J., Shih, A.J.: Minimum quantity lubrication
(MQL) in automotive powertrain machining. Procedia CIRP 14, 523–528 (2014)
6. Bustillo, A., Pimenov, DYu., Matuszewski, M., Mikolajczyk, T.: Using artificial intelli-
gence models for the prediction of surface wear based on surface isotropy levels. Robot.
Comput. Integr. Manuf. 53, 215–227 (2018)
262 R. W. Maruda et al.
7. Matuszewski, M., Mikolajczyk, T., Pimenov, DYu., Styp-Rekowski, M.: Influence of the
structure of the isotropy of the machined surface on the wear process. Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol. 88(9), 2477–2483 (2017)
8. Su, G.S., Guo, Y.K., Song, X.L., Tao, H.: Effects of high-pressure cutting fluid with different
jetting paths on tool wear in cutting compacted graphite iron. Tribol. Int. 103, 289–297
(2016)
9. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Research emulsion mist
generation in the conditions of minimum quantity cooling lubrication (MQCL). Teh. Vjesn. –
Tech. Gaz. 22(5), 1213–1218 (2015)
10. Li, B., Li, C., Zhang, Y., Wang, Y., Yang, M., Jia, D., Zhang, N., Wu, Q.: Effect of the
physical properties of different vegetable oil-based nanofluids on MQLC grinding
temperature of Ni-based alloy. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 89(9–12), 3459–3474 (2017)
11. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Michalski, M., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S.: Structural
and microhardness changes after turning of the AISI 1045 steel for minimum quantity
cooling lubrication. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 26(1), 431–438 (2017)
12. Stachurski, W., Sawicki, J., Wójcik, R., Nadolny, K.: Influence of application of hybrid
MQL-CCA method of applying coolant during hob cutter sharpening on cutting blade
surface condition. J. Clean. Prod. 171, 892–910 (2018)
13. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Analysis of contact phenomena
and heat exchange in the cutting zone under minimum quantity cooling lubrication
conditions. Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 41(2), 661–668 (2016)
14. Outeiro, J.C., Umbrello, D., Saoubi, R.M.: Experimental and numerical modelling of the
residual stresses induced in orthogonal cutting of AISI 316L steel. Int. J. Mach. Tools
Manuf. 46(14), 1786–1794 (2006)
15. Manimaran, G., Pradeep Kumar, M., Venkatasamy, R.: Influence of cryogenic cooling on
surface grinding of stainless steel 316. Cryogenics 59, 76–83 (2014)
16. Evans, C., Bryan, J.B.: Cryogenic diamond turning of stainless steel. CIRP Ann. 40(1), 571–
575 (1991)
17. Okada, M., Hosokawa, A., Asakawa, N., Ueda, T.: End milling of stainless steel and
titanium alloy in an oil mist environment. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 74(9–12), 1255–1266
(2014)
18. Chuangwen, X., Ting, X., Huaiyuan, L., Zhicheng, S., Hongbing, J., Mandong, L.: Friction,
wear, and cutting tests on 022Cr17Ni12Mo2 stainless steel under minimum quantity
lubrication conditions. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 90(1–4), 677–689 (2017)
19. Xu, X., Huang, S., Wang, M., Yao, W.: A study on process parameters in end milling of
AISI-304 stainless steel under electrostatic minimum quantity lubrication conditions. Int.
J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 90(1–4), 979–989 (2017)
20. Krolczyk, G.M., Maruda, R.W., Nieslony, P., Wieczorowski, M.: Surface morphology
analysis of Duplex Stainless Steel (DSS) in clean production using the power spectral
density. Measurement 94, 464–470 (2016)
21. Weinert, K., Inasaki, I., Sutherland, J.W., Wakabayashi, T.: Dry machining and minimum
quantity lubrication. CIRP Ann.-Manuf. Technol. 53(2), 511–537 (2004)
22. Duchosal, A., Werda, S., Serra, R., Courbon, C., Leroy, R.: Experimental method to analyze
the oil mist impingement over an insert used in MQL milling process. Measurement 86,
283–292 (2016)
23. Zhang, Y., Li, C., Jia, D., Li, B., Wang, Y., Yang, M., Hou, Y., Zhang, X.: Experimental
study on the effect of nanoparticle concentration on the lubricating property of nanofluids for
MQL grinding of Ni-based alloy. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 232, 100–115 (2016)
The Influence of the Application of EP Additive 263
24. Dhar, N.R., Islam, M.W., Islam, S., Mithu, M.A.H.: The influence of minimum quantity of
lubrication (MQL) on cutting temperature, chip and dimensional accuracy in turning AISI-
1040 steel. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 171(1), 93–99 (2006)
25. Itoigawa, F., Childs, T.H.C., Nakamura, T., Belluco, W.: Effects and mechanisms in minimal
quantity lubrication machining of an aluminum alloy. Wear 260(3), 339–344 (2006)
26. Jayal, A.D., Balaji, A.K.: Effects of cutting fluid application on tool wear in machining:
Interactions with tool-coatings and tool surface features. Wear 267(9–10), 1723–1730 (2009)
27. Maruda, R.W., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Lukianowicz, C., Stoic, A.: Effect of anti-wear
additive on cutting tool and surface layer of workpiece state under MQCL conditions. Teh.
Vjesn. – Tech. Gaz. 22(5), 1219–1223 (2015)
28. Su, Y., Gong, L., Li, B., Liu, Z., Chen, D.: Performance evaluation of nanofluid MQL with
vegetable-based oil and ester oil as base fluids in turning. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 83(9–
12), 2083–2089 (2016)
29. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S., Michalski, M., Legutko,
S.: The influence of the cooling conditions on the cutting tool wear and the chip formation
mechanism. J. Manuf. Process. 24, 107–115 (2016)
30. Vieira, J.M., Machado, A.R., Ezugwu, E.O.: Performance of cutting fluids during face
milling of steels. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 116(2–3), 244–251 (2001)
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling
to Apply Feed Rate Strategies in the Drilling
of Unsupported CFRP-Structures
Abstract. In the drilling of flexible work pieces, the work piece movement
makes the prediction of the machining time more difficult. This is due to the
variance between the defined machining parameters and the effective machining
conditions at the cutting edges. Consequently, feed rate strategies cannot be
applied on the basis of the machining parameters. Therefore, a mechanistic
modelling approach will be presented, which allows to calculate the feed forces
in an unsteady drilling process. Thereby, the relative position between work
piece and drilling tool can be known at any time. The model allows the con-
sideration of the tool geometry, whereby drilling processes with state of the art
step drills can be simulated. In the end, the prediction of characteristic drilling
phases can be used to determine the timing to apply feed rate strategies to reduce
push-out delamination. The practicability of the simulation and the efficiency of
two different feed rate strategies will be shown for unsupported drilling pro-
cesses with the typical aeronautics composite material M21/T800S.
1 Introduction
The clamping devices for large two-dimensional work pieces require a lot of space
during the machining process as well as in the storage time. While machining, the focus
is mainly on realizing little overhangs of the work pieces as well as on the application
of the clamping force near the machining location [3]. Additionally, complex three-
dimensional CFRP-geometries are very cost-intensive, which reduces profitability at
small quantities [4]. The usage of local hold-down devices solves the problem only
partially, because in the consequence, interfering work piece edges and post processing
arise [3]. Overall, there is still a need of action to optimize the processing technology in
the area of CFRP-machining. Tolerating work piece flexibility during drilling can be an
alternative. But this method may require customized feed rate strategies to reduce push-
out delamination, as they are used for conventional drilling operations in CFRP.
drilling tool. They also utilize the relative feed rate, which has already been introduced
in [11]. The calculation is performed in the phases of the tool entry, the full engage-
ment of the main cutting edges and the tool exit. Thereby, the cutting process is
assumed for an ideal cutting edge without any wear features. Because of the high
number of geometric characteristics like the angle of inclination, the rake angle, the
point angle, the spiral angle and the chisel edge length, the model requires a numerical
solution using the Runge-Kutta-method. The applicability is therefore complex.
Overall, the accuracy of the model is good with deviations of <10%. For the verifi-
cation of the model, drilling experiments were carried out with a double-sided clamping
of 2.0 mm CFRP plates with varying clamping distances and feed rates.
Fig. 1. Representation of the applied step drill geometry with variable point angle and the
associated projected lengths of the main cutting edges. The schematic sketch shows the reference
points for the feed force model with a step drill. Other geometric features are: d/D = 3.9/5.9 mm,
Lstep = 2.0 mm, spiral angle = 35° and clearance angle = 13.5° ± 1.5°.
Unless otherwise specified, a feed rate of 0.06 mm/rev and a cutting speed of
100 m/min is applied. The measurement of the feed force and the monitoring of the
process duration is done with the load cell Kistler type 9257B and the cutting force
dynamometer Kistler type 9125A11. The measurement data evaluation is carried out
with the software FlexPro of the company Weisang. On top of the load cell a clamping
system is used, which allows supported drilling processes as well as the drilling of
flexible work pieces in different clamping conditions (see Fig. 2) the presented
investigations unsupported drilling is done exclusively on single-sided clamped
bending beams on the right side of the figure with a specimen width of 20 mm and a
maximum length of 100 mm. The drilling position is described by the actual local work
piece flexibility in 8 different positions between 0 and 52.4 µm/N. Each drilling
sequence starts at the end of the bending beam and progresses towards the clamping.
Fig. 2. Clamping device for the experimental drilling series of flexible CFRP-structures as one-
sided clamped bending beams and the determination of the specific feed forces.
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling to Apply Feed Rate Strategies 269
Fig. 3. Algorithm for modeling the cutting depth at any point of time during a conventional
drilling process with a twist drill.
270 F. Lissek et al.
To calculate the phase-dependent cutting depth and the resulting cutting section A,
additional designations on the drilling tool are introduced. The reference points P1 and
P2 are illustrated in Fig. 3 as well as the three drilling phases named as cutting start,
full engagement and tool exit. These phases are shown for two different work piece
thicknesses. The feed distance of the drilling tool starts from P1 at the tip of the drill
and is referred to by the symbol s. The zero point of s is defined at the moment of the
first contact between drilling tool and work piece. It is continued in positive counting
mode as the feed distance progresses. Since a constant feed rate can be assumed for the
drilling tool movement, s is known exactly at any time and therefore the chipping
thickness h.
The projected cutting edge length Lce is an important decision criterion, which has
to be compared with the workpiece height hwp in the first instance. If hwp exceeds Lce , a
full engagement can take place. In this case the left path of the flow chart in Fig. 3 is
used for calculation. If this condition is not fulfilled, the main cutting edges will not be
engaged over the complete tool diameter at any point of time. This leads to the right
path of the flow chart, in which the maximum cutting depth is limited. As a result, the
occurring forces are directly affected by the reduced maximum cutting section.
Throughout the algorithm, P1 and P2 are needed to distinguish the process phases
constantly. The algorithm in Fig. 3 can also be applied for the modeling of the unsteady
drilling process. This is done by using a control loop, as illustrated in Fig. 4.
Fig. 4. Control loop for modeling unsteady drilling processes with varying relative feed rates.
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling to Apply Feed Rate Strategies 271
If the effective feed force is known, the caused deflection can be determined by the
material specific local flexibility. Since the deformation is oriented in the feed direction,
a relative movement between tool and work piece takes place. This movement can be
described by subtracting the deflection from the feed distance of the drilling tool. To
distinguish between the feed distance of the drilling tool and the feed distance calcu-
lated after deduction of the work piece deformation, this can be named as relative feed
distance or the relative feed speed. A reduced feed speed results in a smaller cutting
section and lower feed forces, which in turn influences the work piece deformation.
The calculation of the cutting depth is done by the specifications in Fig. 3.
Simultaneously the relative feed rate is determined as a function of the relative
movement between tool and work piece in the control loop in Fig. 4. In doing so, the
cutting section and the adapted process forces can be described. With this approach the
needed chipping values can be calculated as a function of the actual feed force at any
time. The feed force itself is calculated by using a feed force model, which will be
described in the following Sect. 2.3.
To include the step tool geometry in the simulation, the definition of the reference
point P2 must be changed and additionally P3 and P4 must be introduced. The adjusted
reference points are illustrated by Fig. 1. The basic algorithm for calculating the cutting
depth does not change. However, the comparison with the workpiece height and thus
the distinction between partial engagement and full engagement must be made for both
of the projected main cutting edge lengths Lce1 and Lce2 . Finally, the total cutting depth
results from the sum of the cutting depths of the primary and the secondary drilling
stage of the step drill. All the described algorithms are implemented with the Matlab
Simulink software of the company MathWorks in version 16.4a.
0 ceff ðhÞdh
Rh
ceff ¼ ð2Þ
h
Considering the actual cutting edge radius, the point angle and the standard machining
parameters of this study (see Fig. 2), a numerical calculation of the average effective
rake angle yields to the values listed in Table 1. However, to obtain the displayed
results a case differentiation must be made according to Eq. 3. This takes into account
the transition from the cutting edge radius to the manufactured rake angle c.
272 F. Lissek et al.
(
sin1 rhb 1Þ if ceff \c
ceff ðhÞ ¼ ð3Þ
c ¼ const if ceff c
As the manufactured rake angle changes depending on the tool radius, c = 5° has been
assumed in the center of the drill nearby the chisel edge and c = 35° corresponds to the
rake angle at the maximum tool radius. In consequence, the manufactured rake angle of
the drilling tools is only slightly involved in the machining process. In contrast, the
major part of the cutting work is done directly at the cutting edge radius. Because of the
strongly negative values of ceff in Table 1, it can be assumed that ploughing effects
dominate in the applied cutting conditions. Furthermore, the chip thickness is reduced
due to the evasive movement of the work piece, which leads to even smaller rake
angles for unsteady drilling processes.
Table 1. Calculation of the average effective rake angle for the supported drilling of CFRP with
regard to the cutting edge radius and the point angle. The applied machining parameters are
f = 0.06 mm/rev and vf = 100 m/min.
Point angle r Manufactured rake Assumed cutting edge radius rb
angle c 5 µm 15 µm 25 µm 35 µm
Average effective rake angle ceff
70° 5° −6° −28° −44° −51°
35° 12° −28° −44° −51°
130° 5° −2° −8° −30° −40°
35° 20° −16° −30° −40°
The determination of the specific feed force can therefore be done in relation to the
quotient h=rb [21]. In line with standard usage and by the reason of the ploughing-
dominated drilling, for the presented study a simplified approach was chosen, ignoring
the influence of the chisel edge (see Fig. 5). In this regard the specific feed force is
measured directly in the drilling process under constant cutting conditions at four
different chip thicknesses and a varying cutting edge radius. Figure 5a shows the
evaluation method for the point angles of 70° and 130°. For both of the exemplary
measurements, the material was doubled. The basic values of the specific feed force
kf :r1 and the corresponding exponents mf :r1 can be seen in Fig. 5b. The shown values
are determined at h=rb = 1. If the quotient h=rb is integrated into the original Kienzle-
equation, the following modified equation results for the calculation of the feed force.
ð1mf :r1 Þ
h
Fz ¼ kf :r1 rb b ð4Þ
rb
This equation is used in the control loop according to Fig. 4 to calculate the time
dependent feed forces for an unsteady drilling process.
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling to Apply Feed Rate Strategies 273
Fig. 5. Simplified determination of the basic values of the specific feed forces and the
corresponding exponents in a ploughing-dominated drilling process in CFRP. (a) Exemplary
determination of the feed force at full engagement of the cutting edges. The chip thickness is
0.04 mm at a point angle of 70° and 130°. (b) Summary of the basic values of the specific feed
force and the corresponding exponents. Measurements have been done for chip thicknesses of
0.01, 0.04, 0.08 and 0.12 mm. The cutting edge radius is between 10 and 50 µm.
Fig. 6. Development of the push-out delamination in the threshold area for the drilling of
flexible work pieces with a point angle of 130°.
3.2 Evaluation of the Simulated Feed Forces and the Processing Time
Since the threshold area could be quantified in the previous section, the time-dependent
simulation of the feed force is now done for the local flexibilities of 0, 6.9 and
32.3 µm/N. 0 µm/N is defined to be fully supported. 6.9 and 32.3 µm/N each represent
a drilling process before and after the threshold area.
Figure 7 shows the comparison of the simulation results with the experiment for the
local flexibilities below the threshold area. The calculation was carried out for each
point angle with two cutting edge radiuses each. A material thickness of 4.3 mm was
assumed. The diagrams also show the absolute deviations DFz;max of the maximum feed
force and the deviations DtQs of the point of time of the exit of the chisel edge.
Comparing the point angle geometries, for 70° the maximum feed force is achieved
in the primary drilling stage right after the beginning of the drilling process. The total
load is then reduced in two subsequent steps. Since the exit process of the chisel edge
and the entry process of the secondary drilling stage take place simultaneously, this is
caused by a constant chip width b instead of a full engagement of the main cutting
edges. The two remaining tool geometries with 100° and 130° point angle correspond
to a characteristic force curve of a step drill and thus show a full engagement of the
main cutting edges. This is due to the reduced projected main cutting edge lengths in
comparison to a 70° point angle.
In the experiment, the increase of the cutting edge radius and the simultaneous
change in local flexibility from 0 to 6.9 µm/N primarily results in an offset of the feed
force. The total drilling duration changes only slightly, but tends to decrease. Despite
the slight loss of stiffness of the work piece, the increased feed speed during the tool
exit already takes effect at this point. The simulation takes into account the balanced
state between tool and work piece as a function of the local flexibility, even if the
drilling tool starts to exit the work piece. As a result the simulation does not reflect
changes of the feed speed due to the spring back process. Especially for the larger
cutting edge radius, larger deviations occur with respect to the total drilling time in the
experiment. In absolute terms, for the supported drilling process the simulation is 5 to
51 ms above the experimental measured values and for unsupported drilling at
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling to Apply Feed Rate Strategies 275
Fig. 7. Comparison of the simulated feed force Fz with the experimental measurement at the
local flexibility of 0 and 6.9 µm/N and different point angles (a–c) with varying cutting edge
radius.
6.9 µm/N the deviation is between 103 and 191 ms. However, the exit of the chisel
edge can be predicted for all processes with a deviation of DtQs < 100 ms.
High movement speeds of the work piece during the spring back only occur, when
the lower limit of the threshold area at 6.9 µm/N is exceeded. This is why a local
flexibility of 32.3 µm/N was selected for the evaluation of the capabilities of the model
to simulate drilling processes with characteristic spring back movements. In this regard
Fig. 8 summarizes the simulated and the experimentally determined force curves of the
three different point angle geometries for unsupported drilling. Apart from the increase
in local flexibility, the remaining boundary conditions of the drilling operation
remained unchanged.
Considering the unsupported drilling process up to the time of the exit of the chisel
edge, the deviation of the simulated force level and the prediction of the processing
time are consistent with the simulation results described above. However, at the
beginning of the spring back processes it becomes clear that the curves no longer
correlate with each other. In addition, it must be pointed out at that ploughing-
dominated machining processes for CFRP machining can only be assumed with
276 F. Lissek et al.
Fig. 8. Comparison of the simulated feed force Fz with the experimental measurement at the
local flexibility of 32.3 µm/N and different point angles (a–c) with varying cutting edge radius.
decide on the timing of feed strategies. Since the speed component during the spring
back process is decisive for the degree of push-out delamination, the relative feed per
tooth must be reduced in this phase of unsteady drilling. To achieve this goal, two feed
strategies were applied before the chisel edge exits the work piece:
• By stopping the feed of the step drill, the movement component of the drilling tool
is completely suspended. Afterwards the tool exits solely by reason of the elastic
force of the work piece. Since this feed strategy should be applied equally for all
local flexibilities, the feed rate stop is limited to a period of 3 s.
• Increasing the rotation speed at a constant feed speed of 318 mm/min reduces the
feed per tooth and the relative feed during the spring back movement. In the series
of tests the maximum usable rotation speed is limited to 15000 rev/min due to the
used machining center.
Using the feed force model, the start of the respective feed strategy in an unsteady
drilling process was set to 0.1 s before the exit of the chisel edge. The calculated
process time was then converted into the movement coordinates of the drilling tool.
The effects of the two strategies on the development of the push-out delamination as a
function of the local flexibility are finally shown in Fig. 9 this purpose, the average
area-weighted delamination factors were determined. As a point angle of 130° induces
the highest work piece deformation during drilling, this tool is shown as an example at
three different states of tool wear. Overall, the feed rate stop and the increase in
rotation speed achieve a significant reduction in push-out delamination after exceeding
the threshold area. In all cases the damage level of the lower local flexibility can be
maintained.
A final evaluation of the feed strategies can be carried out by the calculation of the
relative feed per tooth. Figure 10 shows the time-dependent relative feed values for
both of the feed strategies in comparison to the standard parameters. The start of the
feed strategy always occurs at the same time, but a time shift can be seen in the diagram
due to the normalized x-axis.
Fig. 9. Comparison of the delamination factors using feed strategies (a) and (b) based on the
feed force model. Drilling with a point angle of 130° at varying local flexibilities.
278 F. Lissek et al.
Fig. 10. Comparison of the relative feed using feed strategies (a) and (b) based on the feed force
model. Unsupported drilling with a point angle of 130° at a local flexibility of 32.3 µm/N and a
cutting edge radius between 28.8 and 32.6 µm.
After the start of the feed strategy, the feed stop causes a continuous reduction of
the calculated relative feed per tooth towards zero. At this point, this corresponds to the
gradual reduction of the work piece deformation until the chisel edge exits. In addition
the maximum relative feed is reduced by 0.41 mm. A higher reduction of the maximum
relative feed rate is achieved by the temporary increase of the rotation speed. An
absolute feed reduction of 0.56 mm can be recorded here. Thus the behavior of the
calculated relative feed rates confirms the development of the area-weighted delami-
nation factors in Fig. 9. At the same time, it is proven that the simulation accuracy of
the time-dependent feed force model is sufficient to determine the timing for the
application of feed strategies.
In this study a mechanistic model was developed to apply feed strategies for the drilling
of flexible CFRP work pieces. The basic findings of the machining theory according to
Victor & Kienzle are used to combine a modified feed force equation with a drilling
phase model and a control loop. Due to the ploughing-dominated cutting process at low
chip thicknesses, the tool wear can be included and the maximum feed force as well as
the timing of the exit of chisel edge can be determined. The accuracy of the time
prediction is less than 100 ms and the deviations of the feed forces are a maximum of
4.4%. Due to the design of the simulation, speed changes in the spring back process of
the work piece currently cannot be reproduced. However, this is not necessary for a
practical application of the model.
The experimental verification of the model showed that the increase of push out
delamination with increasing local flexibility can be prevented by using feed rate
Time-Dependent Feed Force Modelling to Apply Feed Rate Strategies 279
strategies. In the series of drilling experiments the relative feed rate during the work
piece spring back has been reduced due to a feed stop and the increasing of the rotation
speed. In absolute values the feed rate reduction is up to 0.56 mm. The drilling tests
thus provide an excellent basis for simplifying clamping devices.
In the next step, the model can be applied to the specific cutting forces to predict the
resulting drilling torques. Due to the low machining forces in CFRP machining, this
additionally requires an examination of the friction influences on the peripheral cut-ting
edge of the drilling tool. Furthermore, it is possible to implement a distinction of cases
into the control loop to distinguish between shear-dominated and ploughing-dominated
cutting processes. Eventually this allows to simulate the cutting force during the work
piece spring back as well.
References
1. Heumer, W.: Meisterprüfung für den Bohrer. VDI-Nachr. 37, 13–14 (2014)
2. Müller-Hummel, P., Richter, J., Möller, B.: Neue Werkstoffe erfordern neue Allianzen.
Werkstatt Betr. 10, 66–67 (2008)
3. Enßle, M.: Zusammenspiel von Fertigungsmittel un Zerspanstrategie bei der Bearbeitung
von Faserverbund-Bauteilen für die Luftfahrt: Einfluss der Werkstückeinspannung. In:
Bearbeitung von Verbundwerkstoffen: Spanende Bearbeitung von CFK, Stuttgart (2013)
4. Klotz, S., Gerstenmeyer, M., Zanger, F., Schulze, V.: Influence of clamping systems during
drilling of carbon fiber reinforced plastics. Procedia CIRP 13, 208–213 (2014)
5. Capello, E.: Workpiece damping and its effect on delamination damage in drilling thin
composite laminates. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 2(148), 186–195 (2004)
280 F. Lissek et al.
6. Heberger, L., Nissle, S., Gurka, M., Kirsch, B., Aurich, J.C.: Qualitätssteigerung von
Bohrugen in Faserkunststoffverbunden: Untersuchung des Einflusses verschiedener
Einspannstrategien. Werkstattstech. Online 105(7/8), 501–507 (2015)
7. Dogrusadik, A., Kentli, A.: Comparative assessment of support plates’ influences on
delamination damage in micro-drilling of CFRP-Laminates. Compos. Struct. 173, 156–167
(2017)
8. Lissek, F., Kaufeld, M.: Aufs Abstützen kommt es an: Bearbeitungskriterien für die
Zerspanung labiler CFK-Strukturen. Werkstatt Betr. 12, 36–40 (2019)
9. Eisseler, R., Jakob, P., Schaal, M., Weiland, S.: Bohren von CFK. In: Bearbeitung von
Verbundwerkstoffen: Spanende Bearbeitung von CFK, Stuttgart (2013)
10. König, W., Wulf, C., Graß, P., Willerscheid, H.: Machining of fiber reinforced plastics.
CIRP Ann. 34(2), 537–548 (1985)
11. Lissek, F., Bergmann, J.-P., Kaufeld, M.: Machining of CFRP: drilling and milling of
unstable work pieces. In: 58th Ilmenau Scientific Colloquium, Ilmenau (2014)
12. Klotz, S., Lepold, A., Zanger, F., Schulze, V.: Experimental investigation of clamping
systems and the resulting change of cutting conditions while drilling carbon fiber reinforced
plastics. Procedia CIRP 62, 15–20 (2017)
13. Marcus, H.: Die Theorie elastischer Gewebe und ihre Anwendung auf die Berechnung
biegsamer Platten unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der trägerlosen Pilzdecken. Springer,
Berlin (1932)
14. Stiglat, K., Wippel, K.: Platten. Wiley Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim (1973)
15. Luo, B., Li, Y., Zhang, K., Cheng, H., Liu, S.: Effect of workpiece stiffness on thrust force
and delamination in drilling thin composite laminates. J. Compos. Mater. 5(50), 617–625
(2015)
16. Lazar, M.-B., Xirouchakis, P.: Mechanical load distribution along the main cutting edges in
drilling. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 213(2), 245–260 (2013)
17. Schmid, M., Schmid, S., Hintze, W., Clausen, R., Schütte, C.: Patentschrift Fiber Cracker.
Deutschland Patent DE 10 2010 012 963 A1 (2010)
18. Victor, H.: Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Schnittkräfte beim Drehen, Hobeln und Bohren.
Dissertation, München, Technische Hochschule Hannover (1956)
19. Kienzle, O.: Die Bestimmung von Kräften und Leistungen an spanenden Werkzeugen und
Werkzeugmaschinen. VDI-Z Integr. Prod. 94, 299–305 (1952)
20. Anand, R.S., Patra, K.: Mechanistic cutting force modelling for micro-drilling of CFRP
composite laminates. CIRP J. Manufact. Sci. Technol. 16, 55–63 (2017)
21. Anand, R.S., Patra, K.: Size effects in micro drilling of carbon fiber reinforced plastic
composite. Prod. Eng. 8(3), 301–304 (2014)
22. Faraz, A., Biermann, D., Weinert, K.: Cutting edge rounding: an innovative tool wear
criterion in drilling CFRP composite laminates. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 49(15),
1185–1196 (2009)
Recognition of Assembly Parts
by Convolutional Neural Networks
Abstract. The paper describes the experiments with the use of deep neural
networks (CNN) for robust identification of assembly parts (screws, nuts) and
assembly features (holes), to speed up any assembly process with augmented
reality application. The simple image processing tasks with static camera and
recognized parts can be handled by standard image processing algorithms
(threshold, Hough line/circle detection and contour detection), but the aug-
mented reality devices require dynamic recognition of features detected in
various distances and angles. The problem can be solved by deep learning CNN
which is robust to orientation, scale and in cases when element is not fully
visible. We tested two pretrained CNN models Mobilenet V1 and SSD
Fast RCNN Inception V2 SSD extension have been tested to detect exact
position. The results obtained were very promising in comparison to standard
image processing techniques.
Today’s consumer industry is made up of a large number of products and their possible
configurations, which is a direct response to the ever-growing demand of customers. It
is generally known that traditional assembly lines are synchronous. This means that the
flow of material and work is predefined depending on the customer’s order. The
assembly steps are continuously delegated and performed on each workstation. At the
same time all the workstations on the line are synchronized. With the arrival of the
Industry 4.0 concept and deployment of its supporting technologies (digital twin, RFID
technology, virtual and augmented reality, big data, deep learning), there is also the
necessity of changing and deploying asynchronous assembly lines. Applications of
such lines can be found in several areas of industry: consumer electronics, furniture,
clothing, and automotive production. Because of the variation in production, it is
almost unnecessary to co-operate with the machine during the assembly process. For
the Industry 4.0 concept, cooperative robots were defined as the main element suitable
The experimental assembly is provided as a gear pump device and consists of 14 parts.
The experimental assembly can have a total of 16 variations. Variable elements are gear
shafts, gears and drive shafts. The individual elements are also distinguished in size and
color. The main elements necessary for the assembly of the gear pump assembly
Recognition of Assembly Parts by Convolutional Neural Networks 283
including the variable parts are as follows (see Fig. 1): body of pump, pump cover,
shaft sets, set of gears, drive wheel sets, screws, nuts.
For the development of virtual assembly assistant one needs to detect assembly
elements (screws, washers, nuts) and assembly features (holes or cuts) by a vision
system.
The main principle of standard recognition consists of two basic tasks to be solved:
• Detection of the components based on its contour and dimension;
• Detecting the connecting element on the main assembly part.
For simple detection of mounting elements (hole position) experiments with Hough
circle transformation algorithm and parts by contour detection with approximation have
been suggested. Advanced detection of assembly part and product features have been
tested by transfer learning of deep networks.
Fig. 2. Principle and example of part detection by threshold, contour and line approximation.
284 K. Židek et al.
On the other hand, Hough circle transformation (assembly feature detection) is able
to detect incomplete circular shape to detect contours algorithm. The main disadvan-
tage of this approach is that only a circle can be detected and if angle of view is
changed the detection fails (ellipse shape of the element). Example of using the
algorithm is shown in the following Fig. 3. The standard circle Hough transformation
can be extended to ellipse detection to increase reliability of feature detection in other
angles of view [12].
Image database for training and testing consists of basic assembly part set for three
groups (hexagon nuts/screws, holes). The example set is shown on the Fig. 5.
Recognition of Assembly Parts by Convolutional Neural Networks 285
The deep learning techniques provide very robust detection with noisy images,
higher level of image deformation and detect feature in any angle of view (Fig. 6). The
trained neural network model is reliable for single part in the field of view. The
problem with detection is for example shadow on shiny surfaces and if any other part
overlaps the other.
Fig. 6. Example of classification and position for test images (nuts, screws, holes).
The proposed solution uses an indirect view of a physical (real) environment. The
indirect view allows the use of any device equipped with a rear view camera and
a display with a sufficient resolution and sufficient image processing power, e.g. effi-
cient tablet or smartphone. The solution uses low-cost hardware and software based on
a free open source or licenses free of charge libraries. The principle scheme shows
software interconnection to hardware device (see Fig. 8).
The software solution is designed exclusively for the Android operating system.
Basic image processing and deep network model execution provides an add-on created
by Android Studio. Image processing and deep neural network model runtime is
written by NDK in C++ language and uses popular open source OpenCV image
processing library. The connection of image processing/deep learning with VR/AR is
provided by the above-mentioned Unity engine. Control logic is coded by C# language
later compiled to native code with NDK. For experimental part, a tablet with holder
(Lenovo Tab3) and smartphone (Samsung S7) for virtual reality has been used, as can
be seen in Fig. 9. The example of the software solution (see Fig. 9 right) presents the
link between the existing component with the additional information (detected hole) for
inserting the virtual component (virtual 3D model in the image).
The main factor for the CPU performance is the screen resolution of the device. AR
includes two more important factors of performance: camera sensor capturing with
Recognition of Assembly Parts by Convolutional Neural Networks 287
The experimental results of teaching process reliability have been checked for three
groups. The first transfer learning was tested for assembly part (hexagonal screw, nut).
The next for assembly feature on main assembly part (different assembly holes with
variable size). Acquired precision (reliability) is shown in Table 1.
Table 1. Table of achieved precision with selected model for two tested CNN models.
Tested element Tested image Mobilenet V1 Fast RCNN Inception V2
Hole test example hole 0.99917966 9.95420396e-01
no SSD position 55%
Nut test example nut 0.9999702 9.99994874e-01
no SSD position 98%
Screw test example screw 0.9997631 9.99632955e-01
no SSD position 99%
The retrain of CNN was stopped manually after no significant improvements of the
precision. Graphical result for retrained Fast RCNN Inception V2 is shown on Fig. 10.
Fig. 10. Graph of transform learning (nut class) loss: classification (left), position (right).
288 K. Židek et al.
6 Conclusion
The article presented implementation and usability of deep neural network in industrial
area for speeding up assembly process with the use of augmented devices (smart
glasses). The identification of parts and features in assembly part can be recognized by
deep learning networks with SSD extension. Two deep learning configurations of
layers pretrained on COCO dataset have been tested. The first tested network config-
uration was “Mobilenet version 1” and the second “Faster RCNN inception version 2”.
The mobilenet was significantly faster but with lower precision and without single shot
detection (SSD). The learning process to teach new assembly feature from product is
time consuming. With a standard image processing techniques it is hard to achieve this
level of robustness and invariability. The presented methods implemented to selected
assembly product can be used for similar group of assembly tasks with some modifi-
cations. The experiments proved that CNN can replace standard image processing
techniques and can reach 95–99% reliability with untrained samples. The main prob-
lems are still with detection of parts in groups with overlapping and with shiny surfaces
with reflection. Detection of holes fails in position detection on side views (decreases to
50%). The experiments extend groups of research paper aimed to industrial use of Deep
learning NN cited in introduction. The future works in will focus on retraining other
deep network configurations for example (Mobilenet V2, Inception V3). The research
will follow with an implementation to CUDA devices (Nvidia Tegra TX2) or to devices
with specialized processing unit NPU (neural processing unit) or APU (artificial pro-
cessing unit) by NNAPI. The plan is to teach CNN to recognize more industrial parts
(different types of screws, nuts, bolts, shafts, threads, etc.).
Acknowledgement. This work was supported by the Agency for Research and Development
under the contract no. APVV-15-0602.
References
1. Agrawal, A.: Putting VR/AR to work (Editorial material). IEEE Comput. Graphics Appl.
38(1), 115–118 (2018)
2. Takaseki, A.R., Nagashima, R., Kashima, H., Okazaki, T.: Development of anchoring
support system using with AR toolkit. In: 2015 7th International Conference on Emerging
Trends in Engineering and Technology, pp. 123–127 (2015)
3. Liu, H.Y., Wang, L.H.: An AR-based worker support system for human-robot collaboration.
In: 27th International Conference on Flexible Automation and Intelligent Manufacturing,
FAIM 2017, vol. 11, pp. 22–30 (2017)
4. Chuck, C., Laskey, M., Krishnan, S., Joshi, R., Fox, R., Goldberg, K., et al:. Statistical data
cleaning for deep learning of automation tasks from demonstrations. In: 13th IEEE
Conference on Automation Science and Engineering (IEEE CASE), 20–23 August,
pp. 1142–1149. IEEE, Xian (2017)
5. Bosse, S., Maniry, D., Muller, K.R., Wiegand, T., Samek, W.: Deep neural networks for no-
reference and full-reference image quality assessment. IEEE Trans. Image Process. 27(1),
206–219 (2018)
Recognition of Assembly Parts by Convolutional Neural Networks 289
6. Zhang, W., Li, C.H., Peng, G.L., Chen, Y.H., Zhang, Z.J.: A deep convolutional neural
network with new training methods for bearing fault diagnosis under noisy environment and
different working load. Mech. Syst. Signal Process. 100, 439–453 (2018)
7. Saucedo-Espinosa, M.A., Escalante, H.J., Berrones, A.: Detection of defective embedded
bearings by sound analysis: a machine learning approach. J. Intell. Manuf. 28(2), 489–500
(2017)
8. Patil, K., Kulkarni, M., Sriraman, A., Karande, S.: Deep learning based car damage
classification. In: 2017 16th IEEE International Conference on Machine Learning and
Applications (ICMLA), pp. 50–54 (2017)
9. Liang, J., Mahler, J., Laskey, M., Li, P.S., Goldberg, K.: Using dVRK teleoperation to
facilitate deep learning of automation tasks for an industrial robot. In: 13th IEEE Conference
on Automation Science and Engineering (IEEE CASE), 20–23 August, pp. 1–8. IEEE, Xian
(2017)
10. Komarov, A.S., Buehner, M.: adaptive probability thresholding in automated ice and open
water detection from RADARSAT-2 images. IEEE Geosci. Remote Sens. Lett. 15(4),
552–556 (2018)
11. Rasche, C.: Rapid contour detection for image classification. IET Image Proc. 12(4),
532–538 (2018)
12. Manzanera, A., Nguyen, T.P., Xu, X.L.: Line and circle detection using dense one-to-one
Hough transforms on greyscale images. EURASIP J. Image Video Process. 18 (2016)
The Use of Technology Local Heating by Laser
for Turning of Difficult to Machine Materials
Abstract. The article deals with the use of the local laser heating during turning
of hard machined materials. The application of heating using laser technology is
applied especially to reduce the wear of cutting tools and increasing their
durability and decreasing costs associated with machining process. The aim of
the experiment was to compare the costs associated with production of a valve
seat made of CrNi 58/41. Current machine equipment was replaced by RNC 400
Laserturn hybrid lathe. The choice of the proposed solution was verified on the
basis of technical and economic evaluation.
1 Introduction
More frequent use of high strength alloys and other hard machinable materials,
including ceramic, requires new technologies for their effective machining. Laser
technologies bring local surface strength and hardness of material. The advantage of
preheating in front of tool blade is to reduce tool wear during machining and oppor-
tunity to machine by higher cutting speed.
The experiment described in this article compares existing technology of valve seat
technological process made of CrNi58/41 with lase technology using lase preheating.
The comparison is processed on basis of the machine times of the individual operations
in the technical and economical evaluation.
Technology using preheating was first used at the end of 19th century. It has been
observed that metals tend to deform more easily when they’re heated. During pre-
heating, difference of hardness of cutting tool and workpiece increases, resulting
reduced cutting forces, surface improvement and longer tool life. This is achieved by
heat applying to the workpiece before or during machining. High intensity local heat
energy input of the heat source significantly reduces strength of the material when
heated above specific temperature depending on the composition of each material (see
Fig. 1). Softened metal is easily machined by conventional cutting processes then.
Fig. 3. Axial laser heating: (a) side view, (b) front view.
The Use of Technology Local Heating by Laser 293
speed, which leads ti a prolongation of the machine time. In come cases, it is necessary
to use a coolant. In addition, great emphasis is placed on machine stiffness and tool and
workpiece clamping.
3.3 Machines
For current technology a DOOSAN LYNX 220 LSYC lathe is used. This lathe has
a sloping bed and is designed for machining small and medium workpieces with great
precision. It is suitable for machining in serial production of shafts and flanges. The
machine is fitted with two spindles, with a maximum speed of n = 6000 min−1. Lathe
can be fitted up to 25 tools.
For laser assisted turning a RNC 400 Laserturn is designed (see Fig. 5). It combines
a classic lathe with laser processing. The machine has an integrated laser on turret, the
laser beam is guided through optical devices with VDI-40 interface, which is covered
against contact with the chip, coolant and lubricant. Laser is controlled via NC 38
system that does not require expert service.
Tools
Tool to parts production are the same for existing and prosed technology using pre-
heating. For external turning, the VBD CNMG-120412E-NM interchangeable insert is
used in the DCLNR/L 2020 K 12 knife holder. The same insert is mounted in A25T
The Use of Technology Local Heating by Laser 295
DCLNR/L 12 that is used for internal turning. Another replaceable blade pad is
VBD VCGT 130302E-SF2 that is used for finishing operations. It is mounted in the
SVXCR/L 2020 K13 knife holder for external turning and in the A20S-SVQCR/L 13
knife holder for internal turning. The last replaceable blade pad is VBD LFUX
030802TN which is designed for grooving. The pad is mounted in the XLCFR/L
2016 K 03 knife holder.
Roughing operations are omitted. The exception is the roughing cycle between
diameters ∅110 mm and ∅120 mm, where tool for roughing is used to accelerate the
process and then finishing turning.
The proposed laser preheater technology is better at 0,07 h agains existing tech-
nology, which is 37% reduction. The total cost per piece was reduced by 22 CZK, for
the whole series savings of 505 CZK. The cost savings for one piece is 19%. By
comparing the results, we find that by locally heating the laser we will significantly
reduce the machine time by 39% (see Table 6).
5 Conclusion
Acknowledgement. Article has been done in connection with projects Education system for
personal resource of development and research in field of modern trend of surface engineering -
surface integrity, reg. no. CZ.1.07/2.3.00/20.0037 financed by Structural Founds of Europe
Union and from the means of state budget of the Czech Republic and by project Students Grant
Competition SP2018/150 and SP2018/136 financed by the Ministry of Education, Youth and
Sports and Faculty of Mechanical Engineering VŠB-TUO.
References
1. König, W., Zaboklicki, A.K.: Laser-assisted hot machining of ceramics and composite
materials. In: International Conference on Machining of Advanced Materials: NIST Special
Publication, Gaithersburg, vol. 847, pp. 455–463 (1993)
2. Saleem, H.: Comprehensive Materials Processing. Elsevier, Ireland (2014)
3. Sun, S.: Parametric investigation of laser-assisted machining of commercially pure titanium.
Adv. Eng. Mater. 10, 565–572 (2008)
4. Salem, W.B.: Laser assisted turning during finishing operation applied to hardened steels and
Inconel 718. In: Laser Assisted Net Shape Engineering: Proceedings of the LANE 1994,
Bamberg, vol. 1, pp. 455–464 (1994)
5. Hongtao, D.: Improving machinability of high chromium wear-resistant materials via laser–
assisted machining. Mach. Sci. Technol. 17(2), 246–269 (2013)
6. Fremut, P., Podrabsky, T.: Konstrukční oceli 1. CERM, Brno (1996)
7. RNC Hochleistungs-CNC-Drehmaschinen: http://www.monforts-wzm.de/en/produkte/lasert-
urn/rnc-400-technische-daten.html. Accessed 01 May 2018
Contributions to the Development
of an Ontology in Logistics of Manufacturing
1 Introduction
The scope of logistics management is very wide, starting from the military area (where
the bases of science called logistics were recorded) and in many different economic
areas. The logistic management is pervasive in all types of industrial activities. The
concept of industrial logistics has experienced an exponential development and a
crystallization as the self-sustaining science in the 50 s when the level of military
logistics experience was very high and many specialists were redirecting to civilian
domains, market demand was increasing and also the increase in service level was a
means to increase competitiveness. From a simply point of view, the problem of
logistics of manufacturing is to respond to the challenge of securing for manufacturing
activities the raw of materials and materials necessary, in the required assortments, in
the necessary quantities, in the right place and at the right time, all at an optimum price.
It is a spatial and temporal synchronization of resources with the demands of the
manufacturing system (Fig. 1).
From the theoretic point of view the management of logistics of manufacturing is
the process of planning, implementing and efficient controlling of the effective flow and
storage of materials, services and the flow of information from the point of origin to
point of consumption for the purpose of conforming to customer requirements.
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 299–306, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_32
300 N. S. Ungureanu et al.
The concept of ontology has been used in recent years, especially in many areas with
applicability in knowledge management and computer assisted cooperation. By its
peculiarities, ontology is used to share existing information in an area of interest. It is
conducive to the representation and use of data relationships and is also effective in
knowledge-based reasoning.
A broadly accepted definition for the notion of ontology is that given by Gruber [9]
namely: Ontology is a formal specification of conceptualization. Gruber [9] states that
the term conceptualization is an abstract notion, a simplified view of the world we want
to represent for a particular purpose. Regardless of the community type which will
change and share knowledge through an ontology, whether human actors or agents (in
the framework of artificial intelligence), ontologies establish a common terminology,
for this reason conceptualization requires a proper formalization. As defined by Gruber
[9] conceptualization refers to objects, concepts and other entities that are supposed to
exist in a particular area of interest, as well as the relationships that hold them together.
Regardless of the field, an ontology consists of several elements, the most important
being: concepts, relationships, attributes, instances, and axioms. In other words, a
conceptualization is an abstract and simplified vision of the world we want to represent
for a certain purpose. Formal specification involves the existence of a vocabulary of
representation in which the objects of the domain and the relations between them can
be formally represented.
An important role in product ontology has the “feature” of the product. The concept
of “feature” first appeared in the field of product engineering, where it was given the
following definition: “a representation of the shape aspects of a product that can be
made in a generic form and that is functionally significant for the phase of the life of
some products” [4]. Initially, it was closely related to the geometry of the product.
However, because product development does not only include engineering activities,
product information is not limited to geometry, it has a much richer and more complex
semantic content (functional, structural, behavioral, technological, etc.). In order to
capture this semantic content, the meaning of “feature” is extended to have a relevant
definition depending on the context in which it is used, reducing the gap between
geometry and other product information.
Several approaches to developing ontologies are known in several areas: biology
(Gene Ontology [8], Lewis [14], Myhre et al. [19]), medicine (Bickmore et al. [2],
Matei [17], design (Contraş & Pintescu [7]) and geosciences (Hu et al. [11], Jung et al.
[12]), special products like machines or industrial equipment problems are treated
briefly in Barbau et al. [1], Panetto et al. [20].
A comprehensive study on the role of knowledge management in the field of supply
chain management (SCM) was done by Marra et al. [16]. Authors reviewed more than
50 journal articles in which knowledge management approaches are proposed in supply
chain context. The main results highlighted in their study were: Knowledge manage-
ment and its role for SCM; a large interest on applying knowledge management in
supply chains projects and the missing recommendations on knowledge accumulation
and sharing their results to other projects with different scenarios of supply chain
302 N. S. Ungureanu et al.
networks. Samuel et al. [21] describe the knowledge management activity as an enabler
for SCM and suggest a more practical framework for knowledge management in
supply chains. However, the results on creating frameworks for knowledge manage-
ment are at a very low and abstract level that focuses on capturing tacit and explicit
knowledge among supply chain partners. To achieve the competitiveness of the supply
chain, Samuel et al. [21] discusses the need to take into account the concepts and
semantic relations of supply chain networks in conceptual models and ontologies.
Another review on ontologies for SCM was done by Scheuermann and Leukel [23]
and assess to extent of linkages between ontology engineering and SCM concepts. In
their research authors have identified 16 SCM ontologies, from which only a few have
adopted ontology engineering techniques. Particularly, few proposals only reuse the-
oretical conceptualizations on SCM from literature and previous works for ontology
development. Another group of them present only aspects of expressiveness of
ontology languages or demonstrate ontology’s utility by metrics or evaluation methods.
Further, in the field of logistics, the ontological engineering has been applied first
and foremost, in the area of supply chain management (SCM) (Leukel and Kirn [13];
Scheuermann and Hoxha [23] and was subsequently applied in other logistics areas
such as transportation (Taniguchi et al. [24]), storage management (Panetto, Dassisti,
and Tursi, 2012), packaging and product distribution (Lian et al. [15]). Leukel and Kirn
[13] have studied the SCM domain and proposed an ontology with the following main
concepts: process with subclasses plan, source, make, deliver, return and metrics. In
(Scheuermann and Hoxha [23]) authors presents an approach of SCM ontology with
improved characteristics of flexibility and decentralization. Main logistics resource
concepts like process, service or resource are included into a modularly organized
ontology. Possible application of the developed ontology fosters semantic annotation of
logistics services as well as semantic interoperability, information integration and
reasoning capabilities for future intelligent applications. Hendi et al. [10] extend an
ontology of logistics activities with concepts and capabilities of optimization of
logistics resources. The proposed system is intended to be part of an exhaustive
framework to support users in development of logistics applications.
3 Approach
In order to build an ontology that covers the logistics processes we have followed the
methodology presented by Uschold and Gruninger [25] that combines a top-down and
bottom-up practices for ontology engineering. The ontological approach for this domain
is fostering the modularity, extensibility and maintainability as follows (Fig. 3):
• Modularity. This allow a separation of different parts of the ontology in order to be
more flexible in the development of specific concepts. Also, this approach allows
the involved team in logistics activities to be more efficient and collaborative.
Contributions to the Development of an Ontology 303
• Extensibility. This facilitate the further improvement of the ontology for the purpose
of other scopes on other logistics or SCM applications. For example, the core
ontology that describes main aspects of logistics processes could be extended with
new features related to other enterprise business processes.
• Maintainability. This characteristic simplifies the process of identifying and
reviewing deficiencies of the ontology, to implement new requirements in order to
satisfy the changes that could occur in ontology.
The first step in creating the Logistics Ontology was to identify relevant concepts
which describe logistics domain. In this way, top level concepts identified were
Activity, Service, Operations and Company. In the Activity class are grouped main
logistics activities (Fig. 2). For these activities a Company could make an Offer or
order a Request, these operations being grouped into Operations top class. These
operations, offered or requested by a company, refers a service which correspond for
any activity undertaken within the company. In this way, a company could perform or
can make an offer or request for services. For fully determination of specified service
one can have access to configuration parameters such as resources involved in the
service, information about the type of process or location of the logistics service. These
parameters can be accessed within the parameter class with its Resource, Process, and
Location subclasses.
A complete implementation of the proposed ontology is presented in Fig. 4.
304
N. S. Ungureanu et al.
4 Conclusions
In this paper authors proposes a core ontology that specifies the main concepts used in
logistics operations. Further, if it is extended with other features, the ontology can be
promoted as a working tool in the logistics activity of the enterprise. The ontology has
been developed from scratch and is developed in accordance with internal work
specifications within the logistics activities. Benefiting from the background in logis-
tics, developing a specific ontology in this field is not a relatively simple task. This is
due to the complexity of the issues to be considered, and to the principles and methods
of creating ontologies. On the one hand, the theoretical and methodological knowledge
of logistics operations must be abstracted in the terms and concepts specific to onto-
logical engineering, and on the other hand, the knowledge and abilities of creating and
modeling ontologies must be applied to translating this knowledge into practice. the
approach presented in this paper is intended to be a bridge between areas of completely
distinct expertise, even if the result has not yet been validated by experts in the field.
However, the obtained result sets the foundations for the development of new
ontologies in a field where they do not excel by refinement and granularity and can also
be used to develop complex working tools specific to the collaborative environment
within a modern enterprise. Further research will be conducted in:
• extending the ontology of manufacturing to all areas of manufacturing processes
that are not touched into present work;
• the integration of the resulted ontology into industrial ontology that covers main
activities of an enterprise;
• evaluation of the ontology of manufacturing and further ones in order to validate
research results with practical case studies.
References
1. Barbau, R., Krima, S., Rachuri, S., Narayanan, A., Fiorentini, X., Foufou, S., Sriram, R.D.:
OntoSTEP: enriching product model data using ontologies. Comput. Aided Des. 44(6),
575–590 (2012)
2. Bickmore, T.W., Schulman, D., Sidner, C.L.: A reusable framework for health counseling
dialogue systems based on a behavioral medicine ontology. J. Biomed. Inform. 44(2),
183–197 (2011)
3. Bonnardel, N., Marmèche, E.: Evocation processes by novice and expert designers: Towards
stimulating analogical thinking. Creat. Innov. Manag. 13(3), 176–186 (2004)
4. Bronsvoort, W.F., Van Den Berg, E., Bidarra, R., Noort, A.: Essential developments in
feature modelling. In: Proceedings of the CAD/Graphics’2001. In: 7th International
Conference on Computer Aided Design and Computer Graphics, Kunming, China, pp. 6–15
(2001)
5. Brunetti, G., Grimm, S.: Feature ontologies for the explicit representation of shape
semantics. Int. J. Comput. Appl. Technol. 23(2), 192–202 (2005)
6. Cioca, M., Cioca, L.I., Duta, L.: Web technologies and multi-criteria analysis used in
enterprise integration. Stud. Inform. Control 20(2), 129–134 (2011)
306 N. S. Ungureanu et al.
7. Contraş, D., Pintescu, A.: Defining spatial relations in a specific ontology for automated
scene creation. Carpathian J. Electron. Comput. Eng. 6(1), 50 (2013)
8. Gene Ontology Consortium: Gene Ontology annotations and resources. Nucleic Acids Res.
41(D1), D530–D535 (2013)
9. Gruber, T.R.: A translation approach to portable ontology specifications. Knowl. Acquis.
5(2), 199–220 (1993)
10. Hendi, H., Ahmad, A., Bouneffa, M., Fonlupt, C.: Logistics optimization using ontologies.
In: The 4th International Conference on Complex Systems and Applications, ICCSA 2014
(2014)
11. Hu, Z., Tang, G., Lu, G.: A new geographical language: a perspective of GIS. J. Geog. Sci.
24(3), 560–576 (2014)
12. Jung, C.T., Sun, C.H., Yuan, M.: An ontology-enabled framework for a geospatial problem-
solving environment. Comput. Environ. Urban Syst. 38, 45–57 (2013)
13. Leukel, J., Kirn, S.: A supply chain management approach to logistics ontologies in
information systems. In: Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on Business
Information Systems (BIS08). LNBIP, pp. 95–105. Springer (2008)
14. Lewis, S.E.: Gene Ontology: looking backwards and forwards. Genome Biol. 6(1), 103
(2005)
15. Lian, P., Park, D.W., Kwon, H.C.: Design of logistics ontology for semantic representing of
situation in logistics. In: Second Workshop on Digital Media and its Application in Museum
& Heritages, pp. 432–437 (2008)
16. Marra, M., Ho, W., Edwards, J.S.: Supply chain knowledge management: a literature review.
Expert Syst. Appl. 39(5), 6103–6110 (2012)
17. Matei, O.: Defining an ontology for the radiograph images segmentation. Paper presented at
the 9th International Conference on Development and Application Systems, Suceava,
Romania (2008)
18. Monkova, K., Monka, P.: Qualitative parameters of complex part produced by additive
approach. In: 8th International Conference on Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
(ICMAE), pp. 691–694 (2017)
19. Myhre, S., Tveit, H., Mollestad, T., Lægreid, A.: Additional Gene Ontology structure for
improved biological reasoning. Bioinformatics 22(16), 2020–2027 (2006)
20. Panetto, H., Dassisti, M., Tursi, A.: ONTO-PDM: Product-driven ONTOlogy for Product
Data Management interoperability within manufacturing process environment. Adv. Eng.
Inform. 26(2), 334–348 (2012)
21. Samuel, K.E., Goury, M.L., Gunasekaran, A., Spalanzani, A.: Knowledge management in
supply chain: an empirical study from France. J. Strateg. Inf. Syst. 20(3), 283–306 (2011)
22. Kaplonek, W., Nadolny, K., Krolczyk, G.M.: The use of focus-variation microscopy for the
assessment of active surfaces of a new generation of coated abrasive tools. Meas. Sci. Rev.
16, 42–53 (2016)
23. Scheuermann, A., Hoxha, J.: Ontologies for intelligent provision of logistics services. In:
The Seventh International Conference on Internet and Web Applications and Services (2012)
24. Taniguchi, E., Thompson, R.G., Yamada, T.: New opportunities and challenges for city
logistics. Transp. Res. Procedia 12, 5–13 (2016)
25. Uschold, M., Gruninger, M.: Ontologies: principles, methods and applications. Knowl. Eng.
Rev. 11(2), 93–136 (1996)
Advanced Output Characteristics of Welding
Power Source for Pulsed GMAW
1 Introduction
Arc metal inert gas welding is currently the predominant process of joining metals and
metal alloys. Among many variants of this process, the pulse welding process is of
particular importance [1]. The main advantage of using the pulse arc is the ability to
control the material transfer in the arc. This makes it possible to improve the process
stability, to obtain welds of better properties, to control the heat input to the welded
joint, as well as to increase the welding efficiency [2].
In the literature dealing with the problems of forces acting on liquid metal droplets,
the view prevails that it is the electromagnetic force that has the most important effect
on liquid metal droplet detachment [3]. Hence, the majority of studies are based on
investigating the influence of the pulse amplitude, Ii, on the number and the time of
detachment of liquid metal droplets [4].
In the pulse arc welding process, the proper electrode melt is obtained by setting the
descriptive parameters of the welding characteristic at specific levels. Respective
current–voltage relationships can be represented using the output static characteristic of
the power supply, which represents the dependence of the voltage measured at the
source output terminals as a function of current flowing in the main power (output)
circuit, with a fixed position of the source controller and with a resistance load, when
current changes are infinitely slow [5]. In a general, the output characteristic shapes the
variation of current in the working point region during welding, thus significantly
influencing the mode of base plate and electrode melt.
Output characteristic of pulsed power source had been investigated by Pan [6], as
well as Wang et al. [7] who indicated stepped output characteristic. However, voltage
and current measured as average values of duty cycle and the data don’t show dif-
ference between modern power supplies. The paper aims to proposal for the new
method for measuring the output characteristics of the power supply employed for
pulse welding.
2 Experimental Procedures
Table 1. Special programmable value of arc welding parameters for second series of tests.
No. Base current Pulsed frequency Pulse time Peak voltage Peak current Arc length
1.1 30 0 – – – –
1.2 30 250 4 40 – –
2.1 30 0 – – – –
2.2 30 250 4 – 450 80%
is responsible for the time release of a voltage-current pulse with a longer duration until
a welding puddle forms. Then the system proceeds with pulse operation in the working
region denoted with the dark lines. This method of start arc ignition (Fig. 2) allows a
spatter-free start-up of the welding process with correct fusion into the base material
(which should be utilized especially in the case of short sections, e.g. tack welds), also
at high electrode wire feed rates.
Fig. 1. Programmable output characteristic of power source for pulsed gas metal arc welding.
Uq – output voltage; Iq – output current; Uq0 – open circuit voltage; Iz0 – initial short circuit
current; Ib0- minimum base current, Ibt- actual base current; Ii min, Ii max – minimum and
maximum pulse current; I – arc start region; II – base current region and slope of base
characteristic; III – transition phase and slope of transition characteristic; IV.1 – working voltage
region of pulse phase; IV.2 – working current region of pulse phase.
Region II corresponds to the power supply’s operation in a base current phase. Due
to the rate of rise of the characteristic, the base current value will be dependent, though
negligibly, on the actual arc length. In the pulse phase, the working point either lies on
the rising voltage characteristic IV.1, or moves into the constant-current region IV.2,
e.g. when welding with a short section of the extended electrode wire.
The transition phase, as represented by region III, is a theoretical line, whose
displacement during the real process depends on the obtained maximum pulse current
and voltage in the base phase. It should be noted, however, that the rising curve in the
phase of pulse current build-up and falling depends on the pulse modulation system
employed in the control system and corresponds to the programmed current change
dynamic that assures stable arc burning, depending on the wire diameter and electrode
310 K. Makles et al.
Fig. 2. Arc ignition scheme realized with the use of programmable static characteristic.
material used. During the actual working process, it is therefore hard to regard
explicitly such a characteristic as output.
where Tsqe is time constant self-regulation of the arc (s), ki is electrode tip heating
coefficient from arc (mm(As)−1), ku is resistance heating coefficient (mm(Vs)−1), Es
Advanced Output Characteristics of Welding Power Source for Pulsed GMAW 311
is voltage gradient in arc column (Vmm−1), Rsq is dynamic resistance of power supply
– welding arc (VA−1).
In practice, the value of the resistance of the Rsq system can be estimated using the
divergence angle between the welding source output characteristic and the static arc
characteristic (a on the Fig. 3). As the static arc characteristic in welding by the
MIG/MAG method within high welding currents has a rising behaviour and the voltage
gradient in the arc column has a relatively small value (0.7 – 1.5 Vmm−1), it is
advantageous to use either a flat or slightly rising current source characteristic.
Fig. 3. Simplified output characteristic of pulsed power source OZAS SYNERMIG 400 (U-I
type of output characteristic) and moving of working point due arc length change. UqI –
programmable value of peak voltage, Ii – actual working current in operating point; ls – static arc
characteristic; II – working region of base current; III – working region of pulse phase.
Not considering the voltage drop resulting from the change in the resistance of the
active electrode wire section, the displacement of the working point from A0’ to A0
along the vertical characteristic involves a considerable change in pulse current. In
a similar manner, the occurrence of momentary changes in wire feed rate during
312 K. Makles et al.
Fig. 4. Simplified output characteristic of pulsed power source Cloos GLC 353 Quinto Profi(I-I
type of output characteristic) with the feedback of the minimum value of the pulse current with
the welding characteristics. IV – region of pulse current and current characteristic slope, V –
region of short-term current increase.
welding should be taken into account. Reducing the pulse amplitude leads to an
incorrect pulse cycle without cutting off the drop formed at the wire tip. This is due to
the reduction in the magnetic force that detachment the drop, whose value depends
primarily on the pulse current value. This condition results in a large-volume drop that
is detached upon several pulse cycles under the effect of its own gravity, generally
causing a considerable liquid metal splatter (Fig. 5). Since such a situation is unac-
ceptable for high-alloy materials and those sensitive to disturbances in the gas shield
(stainless steel or titanium alloys), a programmed minimum pulse phase current, Ii min,
needs to be introduced to the constant-voltage system. The output characteristic is
shown in Fig. 4 (measurement with settings 2.1 and 2.2 in Table 1).
In a system of this type, the working point in the pulse phase moves between curves
IV - V, depending on the actual arc length in the pulse current phase, creating an arc
length regulation system based on the average programmed pulse current, which is
performed by an appropriate control module. For point A0 to be stable during the
Advanced Output Characteristics of Welding Power Source for Pulsed GMAW 313
Fig. 5. Explosion bubble droplet into fragments, subsequent current pulses not detached the
droplet, causes spattering.
course of shortening the arc to ls1, an excess of output voltage must exist. Because the
system’s work at point B causes a considerable reduction in arc voltage, which can be
insufficient for stable metal transport, the control system provides the capability to pass
from steep characteristic IV to flat characteristic V. Corresponding to new working
point A1 is an increase in pulse current, that is an acceleration of electrode wire fusion,
with an appropriate voltage reserve. With small arc length changes, the appropriate
slope of the characteristic dIi/dUq (about 0,25 VA−1) enables the pulse current to be
maintained without a considerable change in the declared value. So, the output char-
acteristic, which can be called multi-segment, is formed by a series of curves. The
minimum pulse current setting and the slope of the characteristic in region V provide in
this case additional parameters necessary to be defined in the arc welding characteristic.
They enable, however, a constant arc length and pulsed frequency to be retained, and
thus permanent fusion into the base material.
4 Conclusion
The analysis of the collected research material in the form of measurement data from
loading the arc power supplies with a rheostat has enabled the determination of output
characteristics of the equipment under examination. It is proposed that, when referring
to pulse sources with programmable characteristics, the term output characteristic
should be used in the case of examining the dependence of the output current on the
output voltage with fixed parameters characterizing the welding process, while the term
simplified output characteristic should be applied to current–voltage values obtained
under conditions corresponding to the working points of the welding arc.
In future work will then be tested experimentally behaviours of arc working point
and metal transfer stability with different output characteristics and arc length controller
with the use dynamic change of CTWD during welding for a different physical
properties of wire electrode materials. This will improve matching the output charac-
teristics to the welded material.
314 K. Makles et al.
References
1. Ghosh, P.K., Dorn, L., Hubner, M., Goyal, V.K.: Arc characteristics and behaviour of metal
transfer in pulsed current GMW welding of aluminum alloy. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 194,
163–175 (2007)
2. Harwig, D.D., Dierksheide, J.E., Yapp, D., Blackman, S.: Arc behaviour and melting rate in
the VP-GMAW process. Weld. Res. Suppl. 85(10), 52–62 (2006)
3. Jones, L.A., Eagar, T.W., Lang, H.J.: Magnetic forces acting on molten drops in gas metal arc
welding. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 31, 93–108 (1998)
4. Xiao, J., Zhang, G.J., Zhang, W.J., Zhang, Y.M.: Active metal transfer control by utilizing
enhanced droplet oscillation part 1: experimental study. Weld. J. Suppl. 93(8), 282–291
(2014)
5. Kensik, R.: Exploitation of Welding Machines. Czestochowa University of Technology Press,
Czestochowa (1995)
6. Pan, J.L., Zhang, R.A., Wu, Z.Q., Chen, Q: System for weld penetration control. In:
Proceedings of the International Conference on Improved Weldment Control with Special
Reference to Computer Technology, pp. 219–222. Pergamon Press, Vienna (1988)
7. Wang, Q., Qi, B., Cong, B., Yang, M.: Output characteristic and arc length control of pulsed
gas metal arc welding process. J. Manuf. Process. 29(10), 427–437 (2017)
Investigation of the Effect of Johnson-Cook
Constitutive Model Parameters on Results
of the FEM Turning Simulation
1 Introduction
ð1Þ
Where:
rp – Equivalent plastic stress, ep- plastic strain, έp- strain rate, έo – reference strain
rate, T- temperature, Tt- melting temperature, Tot- room temperature, A, B, C, m, n-
material-specific model parameters
Johnson-Cook model parameters for different workpiece materials can be found in
open literature. It is worth noting that parameter values for the same workpiece material
vary for different publications. Besides parameter values, available works by other
authors vary in areas such as process parameters, workpiece and tool geometry, finite
element type and mesh density, used FEM software etc. Therefore it is not possible to
definitely pinpoint the effect of changes in only J-C model parameter values on sim-
ulation results, without changes in its other aspects.
In this work, the authors have changed only the values of material-specific J-C
model parameters, while the rest of the simulation will remain unchanged. This was
done with the aim of better understanding the effect of said parameters on simulation
results.
3 Input Data
Presented FEM simulations were conducted with the use of Abaqus/CAE software.
Tool and workpiece geometries were modelled within the program. Workpiece model
was meshed with the use of C3D8R elements, a global element length of L = 5∙10−6 m
was used. The cutting tool was modelled as a rigid body, with rake and lead faces
divided into 15 elements each, while 10 elements were used for the tool nose. The
following process parameters were assumed for simulation purposes: cutting speed
vc = 60 m/min, feed f = 0.15 mm/rev, and cutting depth ap = 1 mm. Tool and work-
piece geometry along with boundary conditions are presented in Fig. 1.
Investigation of the Effect of Johnson-Cook Constitutive Model 317
A Johnson-Cook ductile fracture model expressed with Eq. (2) [1] was used to
model material fracture initiation:
p
e_ b
epD ¼ ½d1 þ d2 expðd3 gÞ 1 þ d4 ln 0 1 þ d5 H ð2Þ
e_
Where:
έpD- equivalent strain at fracture, έp – strain rate, έo – reference strain rate, H ̅-
dimensionless temperature, d1d5- material-specific parameters, η- Stress triaxiality
parameter
A constant value of displacement at failure Uf was used for modelling material
failure. Its value was assumed on the basis of previous research by the authors,
regarding the effect of different Uf values on simulation results [7].
Moreover, it was necessary to specify the physical properties of the workpiece
material and ductile fracture parameters. Material properties and ductile fracture
parameters are presented in Table 1.
Four different sets of J-C model parameters available in open literature for Ti6Al4V
titanium alloy were assumed for research purposes. Their values are presented in
Table 2.
4 Simulation Results
Obtained simulation results were analyzed on the account of cutting force values, chip
shape and stress distribution.
318 P. Löschner and K. Jarosz
Table 2. Values of J-C model parameter sets for Ti6Al4V titanium alloy [6, 8–10].
Set number Literature A, Pa B, Pa C n m
S1 [6] 862∙106 331∙106 0.012 0.34 0.8
S2 [8] 1098∙106 1092∙106 0.014 0.93 1.1
S3 [9] 860∙106 683∙106 0.035 0.47 1
S4 [10] 1000∙106 870∙106 0.033 0.47 1.02
In Fig. 2, cutting force values vs. machining time for used parameter sets are
shown. There are noticeable differences in both values and courses of simulated cutting
force.
Fig. 2. Cutting force values vs. machining time for used Johnson-Cook model parameter sets.
The lowest cutting force value was noted for S1 parameter set. It can also be seen
that for S1 parameters, a slowest rise in cutting force value can be observed, with
cutting force reaching its maximum value of Fcmax = 169 N around approximately
0.15 s, which is half of total simulated cutting time. Higher maximum cutting force
value (Fcmax = 182 N) was noted for set S2, with cutting force reaching its maximum
value after a simulation time of 0.12 s.
A constant, approximately linear increase in cutting force value in the initial cutting
time (t = 0-0.03 s) can be seen for S3 and S4 parameter sets. Comparatively highest
cutting force values were also noted for these sets, equaling respectively Fcmax = 193
for S3 and Fcmax = 225 in the case of S4. The force value simulated with the use of the
fourth shows the closest match to available experimental results for the used range of
machining parameters [11].
Obtained chip shapes were compared for simulation times of t = 0.12 s (critical
stress) and t = 0.15 s (material fracture initiation). Stress distribution in the workpiece
material for the same time periods was also analyzed.
Investigation of the Effect of Johnson-Cook Constitutive Model 319
Simulation results for used J-C model parameter sets are shown in Figs. 3, 4, 5 and
6. Substantial differences in stress distribution and critical stress values can be seen.
The highest stress value was noted for set S4 (rS4 = 1733 MPa), whereas the lowest
one was noted for S1, equaling rS1= 1139 MPa. Therefore, the difference between the
lowest and highest value obtained for assumed J-C model parameter values is
594 MPa.
Fig. 3. Simulation results for S1 parameter set at simulation times of (a) t = 0.12 s,
(b) t = 0.15 s.
Discrepancies between used sets were also noted in the chip formation process. In
the case of S1 and S2 sets, at the simulation time of t = 0.15 s, a portion of workpiece
material has fractured, forming a single discontinuous chip. For S3 and S4 sets, only
a formation of a single crack in the shear band region can be seen (note Figs. 5b and
6b). It has to be noted that workpiece material separation and chip formation in the case
of S3 and S4 sets occurs at the simulation time of t = 0.18 s. This is reflected with the
drop in cutting force value at that time that is evident in Fig. 2. A highest drop in
cutting force value during material separation and chip formation can be seen in the
case of S1 set, equaling 94 N. Force value drops during chip formation for other used
parameter sets equal respectively: S2 = 31 N, S3 = 58 N, S4 = 45 N.
In Fig. 7, the effect of changes in Johnson-Cook model parameter values on
equivalent plastic stress related to plastic strain is presented. A correlation between
plastic stress and cutting force values obtained for each parameter set can be seen. Sets
for which plastic stress values are higher yield higher values of cutting force in the
FEM simulation. The following critical stress values in crack zones seen in Fig. 6 were
noted for used sets: S1 = 1066 MPa at strain of 0.26, S2 = 1425 MPa at strain of 0.45,
S3 = 1554 MPa at strain of 0.86 and finally S4 = 1733 MPa at strain 0.82.
320 P. Löschner and K. Jarosz
Fig. 4. Simulation results for S2 parameter set at simulation times of (a) t = 0.12 s,
(b) t = 0.15 s.
Fig. 5. Simulation results for S3 parameter set at simulation times of (a) t = 0.12 s,
(b) t = 0.15 s.
Investigation of the Effect of Johnson-Cook Constitutive Model 321
Fig. 6. Simulation results for S4 parameter set at simulation times of (a) t = 0.12 s,(b)
t = 0.15 s.
A substantial effect of alternating J-C model parameter values while keeping the rest of
the simulation setup unchanged can be noted. Basing on simulation results, the authors
have drawn the following main conclusions:
1. Differences in J-C model parameter affect the course of the cutting force value vs.
machining time function and different peak cutting force values Fcmax;
2. A drop in cutting force value is evident during material separation and chip for-
mation in the case of all assumed parameters sets. Analogically, a rise in cutting
force value is seen when reaching critical stress in the workpiece material;
322 P. Löschner and K. Jarosz
3. Changes in J-C model parameter values significantly affect stress distribution in the
workpiece, stress fields and critical stress values.
4. It is worth noting that cutting force values obtained for all simulation values are
underestimated in comparison to available experimental data for analogical
machining parameters and tool-workpiece material. The best agreement of simu-
lation and experimental results in the aspect of cutting force was shown for the S4
parameter set.
Presented findings can be applied to choose the proper set of parameters for
machining simulations in the situation when the end user already possesses experi-
mental data. Presented findings show a clear link between simulation results and
assumed J-C model parameters alone, which could not be clearly established by ana-
lyzing previous work by the other authors, as simulation setups and even used software
varied for different simulations.
The main conclusions are that changing the values of Johnson-Cook model
parameters while keeping the rest of the simulation setup intact results in clearly
noticeable changes in simulated chip shape, stress and cutting force components.
Future research by the authors will focus on experimental validation of obtained
simulation results with the aim of determining which used set of parameters has the
best agreement with experimental results in terms of chip shape and cutting force.
References
1. Kosmol, J., Mieszczak, W.: Zastosowanie metody elementów skończonych do modelowania
procesu wiercenia. Modelowanie Inżynierskie 6, 169–176 (2009)
2. Guo, Y.B., Yen, D.W.: A FEM study on mechanisms of discontinuous chip formation in
hard machining. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 155, 1350–1356 (2004)
3. Özel T., Zeren E.: Finite element method simulation of machining of AISI 1045 steel with a
round edge cutting tool. In: Proceedings of the 8th CIRP International Workshop on
Modeling of Machining Operations. Verl. Wiss. Scripten, Zwickau (2005)
4. Karpat, Y.: Temperature dependent flow softening of titanium alloy Ti6Al4V: an
investigation using finite element simulation of machining. J. Mater. Process. Technol.
211(4), 737–749 (2011)
5. Maranhão, C., Davim, J.P.: Finite element modelling of machining of AISI 316 steel:
numerical simulation and experimental validation. Simul. Model. Pract. Theory 18(2), 139–
156 (2010)
6. Zhang, Y., Outeiro, J.C., Mabrouki, T.: On the selection of Johnson-Cook constitutive model
parameters for Ti-6Al-4V using three types of numerical models of orthogonal cutting.
Procedia CIRP 31, 112–117 (2015)
7. Löschner, P., Niesłony, P., Jarosz, K.: Wpływ przemieszczenia niszczącego na wyniki
symulacji numerycznej MES. Zeszyty Naukowe Politechniki Rzeszowskiej – Mechanika
89(4), 487–496 (2017)
8. Zhang, Y., Marek, T., Nelias, D., Gong, Y.: FE-model for titanium alloy (Ti-6Al-4V) cutting
based on the identification of limiting shear stress at tool-chip interface. Int. J. Mater. Form.
4(1), 11–23 (2011)
Investigation of the Effect of Johnson-Cook Constitutive Model 323
9. Chen, G., Ren, C., Yang, X., Ji, X.: Guo, T: Finite element simulation of high-speed
machining of titanium alloy (Ti–6Al–4V) based on ductile failure model. Int. J. Adv. Manuf.
Technol. 56(9), 1027–1038 (2011)
10. Wu, H.B., Zhang, S.J.: 3D FEM simulation of milling process for titanium alloy Ti6Al4V.
Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 71(5–8), 1319–1326 (2014)
11. Sun, S., Brandt, M., Dargusch, M.S.: Characteristics of cutting forces and chip formation in
machining of titanium alloys. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf 49(7), 561–568 (2009)
Comparative Analysis of Surface Finishing
for Different Cutting Strategies of Parts Made
from POM C
Abstract. This paper focuses on the comparing the resulting surface after
finishing holes machined with different cutting technologies. The machined
material is Polyoxymethylene polymer POM C. The cutting technologies that
were used are: helicoidal milling, contour milling, head boring, and reaming.
The main purpose of this paper is to establish the most appropriate finishing
technology for a hole, depending on its functional role. The article compares
each finishing process following the qualitative differences that occur. Quali-
tative analysis refers to the dimensional, shape and quality precision of the
obtained surface. Surface quality was evaluated through its main parameters:
surface roughness and surface texture. Following the evaluation of the worked
surfaces, it was found that there are considerable differences between the fin-
ishing strategies that were used. The differences are considerable enough that
one should consider using one technology instead of another depending on the
use case. The results of this paper help in making faster decisions about what
finishing technology to use when finishing holes in a POM C part depending on
the functional purpose of the machined hole.
1 Introduction
At the present, the industry is increasingly using more plastic because of the many
advantages it brings, such as: cost price, good machinability, and acceptable
mechanical properties. Of all the plastic materials commonly used to obtain the parts by
cutting, polymer POM C is frequently used, especially in mechanical engineering,
automotive and textile industries. This material is a thermoplastic polymer, that has low
elastic modulus, high mechanical strength and stiffness, high surface hardness, good
sliding properties, high wear resistance, high coefficient of thermal expansion and
internal stresses [1].
The quality of the surface obtained after finishing is important for the functionality
of a certain part within in a product. This is why obtaining a high surface quality in the
most advantageous technological conditions is desirable. Because a similar quality can
be obtained using different processing operations involving different costs, it is
important to know what the recommended technology for finishing is.
There are numerous researches that study the connection between surface rough-
ness, cutting forces, cutting power, and material removal rate, among which:
– Panc et al. in [2] where different ways of finishing a bore (precise hole) using helical
milling, contour milling, head boring and reaming were presented;
– Keresztes et al. [3] made a comparative study between cutting forces for different
polymers;
– Chabbi et al. [4, 5] shows how the cutting parameters influence surface roughness,
cutting forces, cutting power and productivity during turning of polyoxymethylene
(POM C) polymer;
– Kaddeche et al. [6] studied surface roughness, cutting force, and temperature rise
during the machining of two types of polymers.
The continuous evolution of industry resulting from the numerous researches in the
field, led to the development of the fourth industrial revolution, the so-called Industry
4.0. It focuses on bringing highly customized products to the customer, at a lower cost.
This implies various diagnostic systems of the process equipment, tooling, and the
machined surface [7]. A few aspects of the machined surface of the POM C material are
presented in this paper. By understanding the input parameters and the machining
process, better diagnostic systems can be designed and automated.
The purpose of this paper is to present a comparative analysis of four bore finishing
technologies commonly used for POM C polymer machining.
Starting from the research presented in [2, 4–6], the current research fills the gap in
the existing literature regarding the qualitative differences that appear when using
different finishing operations to obtain the same surface.
The results of this research can be used in the larger context of Industry 4.0, by
establishing the right machining operations depending on the part requirements, such as
a certain surface roughness or texture, dimensional precision and so on.
2 Experimental Procedure
To reach the proposed aim, the methodology presented briefly in Fig. 1 was used. First,
a rough boring operation was performed bringing the holes to a diameter of 19.80 mm.
Next the holes were finished by means of four types of operations: reaming, helical
milling, contour milling and head boring. These types of operations are heavily used in
industry for precise hole finishing on a milling machine or machining center. The same
cutting depth was set for all operations, 0.2 mm, to get similar cutting forces. Finally,
for each precise hole the dimensional accuracy, shape error and surface roughness were
determined.
The last step consisted of analyzing the data and drawing the conclusions based on
the obtained results.
Fig. 2. The workpiece, (a) Photograph of the workpiece fixed on the fixture devices,
(b) Drawing workpiece.
Figure 2 shows the workpiece fixed to CNC milling machine before the finishing
process.
The quality of the precision holes was determined by measuring the dimensional and
surface quality characteristics. The dimensional accuracy and shape error were deter-
mined, and the measurement data were stored in an Excel worksheet. An average was
calculated for the diameter, the circularity and the cylindricity.
In the case of processed surface, the main indicators for surface characterization
were determined: surface roughness and surface texture.
Better dimensional precision is obtained in the case of precise hole machining with
head boring. Through helical milling and contour milling, precise hole can also be
obtained, but the processing precision is obtained from radius corrections done on the
end mill tool. An easy method of obtaining precise holes is by using reamers. Their
disadvantage is that for each hole size you need a different tool.
328 N. Panc et al.
Figure 3 shows that circularity changes depending on bore depth. In this case, for
a 30 mm depth, the maximum deviation from circularity occurs at the beginning of the
process. It can also be seen that the minimum value of the circularity is obtained in the
middle section measurement resulting in a barrel shape that affects the cylindricity of
the precision hole.
Figure 4 shows that the highest deviation from cylindricity is in the case of helical
milling and head boring operations. The possible explanation for these deviations is
due to process kinematics consisting in tool displacing after a helix-like generating
curve and a straight guiding curve along the hole axis. Elastic deformations and returns
are considered the main causes of deviations from circularity.
Fig. 5. The surface profile in the case of reaming obtained through scanning.
Fig. 6. The surface profile in the case of helical milling obtained through scanning.
Fig. 7. The surface profile in the case of contour milling obtained through scanning.
330 N. Panc et al.
Fig. 8. The surface profile in the case of head boring obtained through scanning.
The tribological behavior of the obtained surface through the four methods will be
different. This is visible from the analysis of the maximum profile valley depth (Rv)
value. In the case of this parameter we will consider the average of the valley depth
rather than that of the peak height. This means that the bearing capacity is superior in
the case of head boring or helical milling. This conclusion also appears from the
profiles presented in Figs. 5, 6, 7 and 8 where valley depth is more pronounced than
peak height for helical milling and head boring. The presence of deeper valleys means
that the oil film is maintained better and reduces wear. The conclusions relating to the
way in which the Ra parameter influences bearing capacity and wear intensity of a
surface are consistent with the ones in papers [8, 9].
The Rc parameter is a potential process control parameter because it is very sen-
sitive to process change. The influence of the finishing technology used on surface
quality can be established by comparing the obtained Rc values for each technology.
For finishing precise holes, head boring or reaming are preferred compared to helical
milling or contour milling.
4 Conclusions
Following the studies done on the possible finishing operations for obtaining high
quality precise holes, the following conclusions can be drawn:
• Each type of operation leaves its particular mark on the quality of the manufactured
surface.
• To obtain a high dimensional accuracy it is recommended to use either head boring
or reaming.
• The tribological behavior of the obtained surface through helical milling and head
boring is superior to the one obtained through reaming or contour milling because it
maintains the lubricant film better and has a higher bearing capacity.
These results were obtained as a result of a comparative study on a limited number
of manufactured surfaces. For future research, the results can be validated on a larger
number of surfaces obtained through the same working operations. Other materials can
also be used to test if the results obtained on Polyoxymethylene polymer POM C are
applicable. As a result, it can be determined if the qualitative differences that occur
when using the different finishing strategies are material specific or if the differences
manifest themselves on other materials like steel, bronze, cast iron or aluminum alloys
as well.
Acknowledgment. The results presented in this paper were obtained with the support of the
Technical University of Cluj-Napoca through the research Contract no. 2002/12.07.2017,
Internal Competition CICDI-2017.
332 N. Panc et al.
References
1. Popescu, A., Hancu, L., Sabau, E., Radu, S.A.: Mechanical characteristics improvement for
extruded products made of reinforced polyamide. Acta Tech. Napoc.-Ser. Appl. Math.
Mech. Eng. 57(2), 201–204 (2014)
2. Panc, N., Bocanet, V., Bulgaru, M., Beldean, C.: Research on holes finishing operations
performance by cutting. Acta Tech. Napoc.-Ser. Appl. Math., Mech., Eng. 57(1), 47–50
(2014)
3. Keresztes, R., Kalácska, G., Zsidai, L., Dobrocsi, Z.: Machinability of engineering polymers.
Sustain. Constr. Des. 2(1), 106–114 (2011)
4. Chabbi, A., Yallese, M.A., Nouioua, M., Meddour, I., Mabrouki, T., Girardin, F.: Modeling
and optimization of turning process parameters during the cutting of polymer (POM C)
based on RSM, ANN, and DF methods. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 91, 2267–2290 (2017)
5. Ghabbi, A., Yallese, M.A., Meddour, I., Nouioua, M., Mabrouki, T., Girardin, F.: Predictive
modeling and multi-response optimization of technological parameters in turning of
Polyoxymethylene polymer (POM C) using RSM and desirability function. Measurement
95, 99–115 (2017)
6. Kaddeche, M.K., Chaoui, K., Yallese, M.A.: Cutting parameters effects on the machining of
two high density polyethylene pipes resins. Mech. Ind. 13, 307–316 (2012)
7. Kraynev, D.V., Bondarev, A.A., Tchigirinsky, Y.: On-line monitoring and parameter control
of a surface microprofile. Procedia Eng. 206, 1285–1291 (2017)
8. Wang, X.: An experimental study of the effect of ultrasonic vibration assisted wire sawing on
surface roughness of sic single crystal. Acad. J. Manuf. Eng. 15(4), 6–12 (2017)
9. Nedezki, C., Trif, A., Bugnar, F., Detesan, O., Lazarescu, L.: Experimental study of surface
roughness in the case of turning of free-cutting steel AUT20 (22S20). Acad. J. Manuf. Eng.
15(3), 49–54 (2017)
10. Bocanet, V., Panc, N.: The influence of hole finishing strategies on quality. In: MATEC Web
of Conferences, vol. 137 (2017)
11. Ceclan, V.A., Popan, I.A.: Grozav., S.D., Miron-Borzan, C.S., Kurik, I.: The analyses of
working parameters for a 3D complex part manufacturing by CNC machine. Appl. Mech.
Mater. 808, 286–291 (2015)
12. Popan, I.A., Popan, A., Comsa, C.S., Carean, A.: Analysis of process parameters influence
on the drilling process using carbide drills for steel ST52-3. In: MATEC Web of
Conferences, vol. 94 (2017)
Investigation of the Effect of Process
Parameters on Surface Roughness in EDM
Machining of ORVAR® Supreme Die Steel
1 Introduction
The Electric discharge machining (EDM) process is a material removal process which
relies on heat generation to melt and vaporize a select portion of the workpiece material
by ionization within the dielectric medium, in which the workpiece is dipped. EDM has
seen particularly profound use in the manufacturing of injection molds. The electric
discharges produced by the EDM machine tool generate impulsive pressure by
dielectric explosion, which removes the melted material. It is to be noted that a portion
of removed workpiece material is flushed incompletely, meaning it resolidifies on the
machined surface. This leads to formation of cracks and pores, which reduce surface
quality [1]. Electrical discharges occur in a continuous manner at a high frequency,
with each one producing a crater at the workpiece surface. The shape of individual
craters is roughly vertically symmetric and shallow. Surfaces after EDM can be
characterized as matte in appearance, with shallow craters and resolidified machining
debris. The resultant surface is dependent on a variety of factors, including discharge
energy. Shallow craters and fewer, smoother surface irregularities can be observed for
lower discharge energy values, whereas higher discharge energy produces deeper
craters and more evident and plentiful surface irregularities [2].
Surface finish and roughness parameters after EDM machining have been the focus
of many works by other authors. Kiyak et al. [1] have examined the effect of pulse
current and individual pulse time on surface roughness in EDM machining of tool steel.
An equation for determining arithmetical mean surface roughness Ra basing on either
pulse current or individual pulse time was given in work [3]. Keskin et al. [2] have
devised an equation which correlates both pulse time and current with arithmetical
mean surface roughness Ra. The effect of voltage on surface roughness was investi-
gated in [3, 4]. The effect of pulse current on material removal rate was the subject of
research conducted by Sameh et al. [5], showing the increase in material removal rate
for higher pulse current values. The effect of peak pulse current and pulse time was
investigated by Rahman et al. [6]. The effect of electrode shape on workpiece accuracy
was the subject of research conducted in [7]. Gostimirovic et al. have studied the effect
of chosen process parameters on EDM process performance [8]. Available studies on
EDM machining of die steels focus mainly on investigating the effect of cutting with
the use of Wire-cut Electro Discharge Machining [9–11] or the effect of electrode
material on process performance [12].
This study aims to investigate the effect of both pulse current and voltage on surface
roughness in EDM machining of ORVAR® Supreme hot work die steel with a square
copper electrode. The evaluation of results was conducted with the use of 3D surface
roughness parameter measurements.
2 Experimental Setup
Prior to EDM machining, samples were milled and ground. Each sample was
divided into five separate areas, each corresponding to different pulse current value.
Two different pulse voltage and five different pulse current values were assumed for
research purposes, while individual pulse time was set as constant. Values used for
experimental research are presented in Table 2.
Investigation of the Effect of Process Parameters on Surface Roughness 335
The following surface roughness parameters were chosen for analysis purposes: root
mean square height of the surface Sq, maximum height of peaks Sp, maximum height
of valleys Sv, maximum surface height Sz and core roughness depth Sk. The averaged
roughness measurement results are presented in Table 3. The mean value was calcu-
lated from 6 separate measurement results. Standard deviation of results has not
exceeded ±6%.
A graphical representation of roughness measurement results is shown in Figs. 2, 3
and 4.
Basing on the analysis of surface roughness measurement results presented
graphically in Figs. 2, 3 and 4, it can be seen that both pulse current and pulse voltage
336 K. Jarosz et al.
Fig. 2. Root mean square height of the surface Sq vs. pulse current for different pulse voltage.
Investigation of the Effect of Process Parameters on Surface Roughness 337
Fig. 3. Maximum surface height Sz and maximum height of valleys Sv vs. pulse current for
different pulse voltage.
Fig. 4. Core roughness depth Sk vs. pulse current for different pulse voltage.
338 K. Jarosz et al.
4 Conclusions
The following conclusions were drawn on the basis of obtained experimental results:
• Differences in surface roughness between assumed pulse currents grow greater with
an increase in pulse current. Therefore it can be inferred that this is the machining
parameter which affects surface roughness the most;
Investigation of the Effect of Process Parameters on Surface Roughness 339
References
1. Kiyak, M., Cakir, O.: Examination of machining parameters on surface roughness in EDM
of tool steel. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 191(1–3), 141–144 (2007)
2. Keskin, Y., Selcuk, H., Mevlüt, K.: An experimental study for determination of the effects of
machining parameters on surface roughness in electrical discharge machining (EDM). Int.
J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 28(11–12), 1118–1121 (2006)
3. Halkaci, H.S., Abdülkadir, E.: Experimental investigation of surface roughness in electric
discharge machining (EDM). In: 6th Biennial Conference (ESDA 2002), Instanbul, Turkey
(2002)
4. Lee, S.H., Li, X.P.: Study of the effect of machining parameters on the machining
characteristics in electrical discharge machining of tungsten carbide. J. Mater. Process.
Technol. 115(3), 344–358 (2001)
5. Habib, S.S.: Study of the parameters in electrical discharge machining through response
surface methodology approach. Appl. Math. Model. 33(12), 4397–4407 (2009)
6. Rahman, M.M., Khan, M.A.R., Kadirgama, K., Noor, M.M., Bakar, R.A.: Experimental
investigation into electrical discharge machining of stainless steel 304. J. Appl. Sci. 11(3),
549–554 (2011)
7. Pellicer, N., Ciurana, J., Ozel, T.: Influence of process parameters and electrode geometry on
feature micro-accuracy in electro discharge machining of tool steel. Mater. Manuf. Process.
24(12), 1282–1289 (2009)
8. Gostimirovic, M., Kovac, P., Skoric, B., Sekulic, M.: Effect of electrical pulse parameters on
the machining performance in EDM. Indian J. Eng. Mater. Sci. 18, 411–415 (2012)
9. Kuruvila, N.: Parametric influence and optimization of wire EDM of hot die steel. Mach. Sci.
Technol. 15(1), 47–75 (2011)
10. Kanlayasiri, K., Boonmung, S.: An investigation on effects of wire-EDM machining
parameters on surface roughness of newly developed DC53 die steel. J. Mater. Process.
Technol. 187, 26–29 (2007)
340 K. Jarosz et al.
11. Choi, K.K., Nam, W.J., Lee, Y.S.: Effects of heat treatment on the surface of a die steel
STD11 machined by W-EDM. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 201(1–3), 580–584 (2008)
12. Singh, S., Maheshwari, S., Pandey, P.C.: Some investigations into the electric discharge
machining of hardened tool steel using different electrode materials. J. Mater. Process.
Technol. 149(1–3), 272–277 (2004)
13. http://www.bucorp.com/orvar_supreme_h.htm
The Influence of EP/AW Addition in the MQL
Method on the Parameters of Surface
Geometrical Structure in the Process
of Turning 316L Steel
Abstract. The methods of cooling with minimum lubrication, MQL, and with
minimum cooling and lubrication, MQCL, are often applied in machining
nowadays due to their ecological and environmental advantages. The MQL and
MQCL methods are a good alternative to dry cutting, especially during
machining of hard-to machine steels, where high temperature occurs in the
cutting zone and process engineers want high quality of the machined surface.
The paper compares four methods of cooling when turning austenitic steel,
316L: dry cutting, MQCL method, MQL method and MQL + EP/AW method.
During the experiment, 2D height parameters were monitored, as well as Abbott
Firestone curve with the spatial parameters and profiles of selected surfaces have
been presented. Due to the large number of variables in the tests, the planning
method of Parameter Space Investigation has been used. When applying the
MQL cooling method with the addition of EP/AW, the smallest values of Ra and
Rz parameters have been obtained in the whole range of the variable parameters
of machining. The Abbott Firestone curve, together with the spatial parameters,
has proved that a surface manufactured after the process of turning in the
MQL + EP/AW conditions shows better exploitation properties.
1 Introduction
Fluids used for cooling and lubrication of the cutting zone contain chemical substances
which are detrimental to health and environment. CCS are applied many times in the
process of manufacturing and, consequently, the quantity of bacteria grows as result of
their ageing [1]. Long lasting exposure of an employee to the vapors resulting from the
use of such coolant can cause pneumonia, irritation of the upper respiratory tract and
generates an additional problem of utilization of the used substances. Incorrect storing
and utilization of such substances results in: contamination of underground waters,
surface waters, soil and air [2]. On the one hand, ecological trends in the cutting zone
cooling solve the problems of environment contaminations and hazards; on the other
hand, they reduce costs related to the use of CCS in industry. Among these trends, the
dry cutting [3–5], cryogenic method [6, 7], MQL and MQCL method [8–12] can be
found.
Many scientific works concerning machining under the MQL and MQCL condi-
tions have been devoted to the surface irregularity [8, 10, 12–15]. The surface quality
of a machined part has a decisive influence on: thermal and electrical conduction,
tightness, esthetical features (appearance), rigidity of joints, deformation, fatigue
strength and, first of all, on the basic tribological properties of the surface [16–20]. In
machining, surface roughness can be influenced by plastic deformations of the
machined material (internal stresses), by generation of high temperatures, changes in
the cutting tool geometry (cracks, deformations, roughness) and by chemical reactions
between the cutting edge and the material under machining [11, 17].
Application of an adequate cooling-lubricating agent can reduce friction during
machining and increase heat dissipation from the machined surface, which reduces
mechanical interaction and increases compressive internal stress [19]. That is why the
MQL method finds wide application for the sake of the quality of the machined surface,
also when machining hard steels. Rabiei et al. [21] have subjected hard steels (HSS and
100Cr6) and soft ones (CK45 and S305) to the process of grinding with the three
methods of cooling: dry cutting, wet machining and MQL. In grinding of hard steels
under MQL conditions, lower values of the friction coefficient and larger cutting forces
have been obtained as compared to other cooling conditions. Those effects cause
increase of the grinding wheel sharpness, which increases the depth of cutting with a
single grain and results in obtaining chips with smaller coefficient of chip thickening
and in improvement of the machined surface quality.
Krolczyk et al. [15] have proposed an approach to the surface quality analysis based
on quality assessment of it. They have analyzed the conditions of turning duplex steel,
dry and with MQL method of cooling. In the paper, the authors have proved that,
applying spectral density of power (SDP), it is possible to assess the surface quality
after turning depending on the applied methods of cooling the cutting zone, so as to
compare the checked surfaces in the qualitative and quantitative way. Analysis of the
SDP signal has shown higher values of the wave lengths and amplitudes in dry cutting
than in the conditions of MQCL cooling. The differences were up to 52% for lower
cutting speeds and 55% for higher cutting speeds. The authors have drawn special
attention to the assessment of the surface quality results which, based mostly on the
The Influence of EP/AW Addition in the MQL Method 343
identification of surface damages, will have particular importance for many scientists,
both in the field of surface metrology and in the field of machining.
Investigations show that, in addition to the lubricating substances contained in
vegetable, mineral oils, water based emulsions and synthetic fluids, improvement of
lubricating properties of the individual machining fluids can be obtained by the
application of additives. That is why solid particles of MoS2, WS2, CaF2, graphite, TiN,
TiC, TiB2, etc. [22–24], as well as extreme pressure additives, EP, and anti wear
additives, AW [8, 13], which allow for minimization of the friction effect and for
control of the temperature between the friction surfaces in contact are being employed.
The kind and concentration of the solid lubricant in the machining fluid can be
important factors for the optimum utilization of CCS in the machining processes [25].
Many scientists have investigated the effects of applying various cooling methods
with the use of conventional machining liquids depending on the process of machining.
However, there are no detailed data concerning the application of conventional
machining fluids improved by the additions of EP/AW in the MQL method. The
purpose of the present work is to determine the influence of the EP/AW addition in the
MQL method on the surface roughness and the Abbott Firestone curve, together with
spatial parameters in the process of turning the 316L steel.
2 Experimental Procedure
The tests have been performed on cylindrical samples with the diameter of 45 mm and
width of 16 mm made of 316 austenitic steel. Prior to testing, the samples have been
initially subjected to turning with the depth of 1 mm to eliminate any casting inac-
curacies in the form of surface irregularities and to ensure similar properties. The
turning process has been performed on an lathe, CU502. The tool kind and geometry,
chemical composition of the machined material, parameters of cutting and supply of the
active medium in the MQL and MQCL methods have been shown in Table 1.
In order to minimize the influence of the tool wear on the surface roughness, each
sample has been turned with the use of a new edge of the cutting plate.
In the experiment, four cooling methods have been applied: dry cutting, minimum
quantity cooling lubrication (MQCL), minimum quantity lubrication (MQL), minimum
quantity lubrication with the addition of EP/AW (MQCL + EP/AW. In the MQL and
MQCL methods, the active medium has been made with the use of the device,
Micronizer Lenox 1 LN. The compressor working pressure was 0.48 MPa.
In the MQCL method the active medium was a mixture of water and a concentrate
with trade name Wedolit K-910 made by Lubricant Poland Ltd in the concentration of
7%. WedolitK-910 is a semi-synthetic high-quality machining fluid containing 20% of
mineral oil. Wedolit K-910 does not possess in its composition additives type EP
containing compounds of chlorine. phosphor or sulfur. For correct preparation of the
active medium, electromagnetic mixer type ES21H has been used. In the MQL method,
the active medium was oil with the trade name UltraLube which is recommended for
the processes of turning, milling, threading, drilling and reaming. It does not contain
chlorine. In the MQL +EP/AW method, the product available in the marked with the
trade name ECOCUT MIKRO 20 E based on mineral oil has been used.
The surface of the samples after the turning process has been analysed on a focal
differentiation microscope, InfiniteFocus 4G. The system of the InfiniteFocus 4G.
microscope makes a series of images on various heights of the examined samples. Each
image has pixels which are sharp depending on the difference of height on which they
have been recorded. The software processes a set of over a dozen images to determine
the highest sharpness for each pixel. The work presents the results of parameters Ra,
Rz, surface profiles, Abbott Firestone curve with the Sk, Spk, Svk parameters and two
values of material contribution, Sr1 and Sr2.
Due to the high number of variables, the planning method of Parameter Space
Investigation (PSI) has been used in the tests; the method is widely applied in solving
problems concerning, among others, designing of machines and mechanisms and
manufacturing engineering [26]. Basing on the values from the individual items of the
PSI method from the computer program, regression equations have been obtained; the
equations can be found in Table 2.Checking the relationships between the variables,
the multiple correlation, coefficient, Ri.1….k has been taken into consideration (the
coefficient informs about the strength of the relationship between a variable and the set
of the other variables from 1 to k), as well as Cochran coefficient, G which checks the
relationship between the nominal variables in case of checking another variable [26].
Table 2. Multiple regression equations for the selected parameters of roughness depending on
the method of cooling.
Dry cutting MQL MQL + EP/AW MQCL
Ra Ra = 42.3v−0.175
c Ra = 43,6v−0.235
c Ra = 31v−0.309
c Ra = 36.2v−0.256
c
f 0.945 f 0.827E0.054P −0.095 f 0.924E0.16P−0.091 f 0.956E0.103P−0.126
G = 0.54 R = 0.81 G = 0.68 R = 0.77 G = 0.51 R = 0.81 G = 0.49 R = 0.82
Rz Rz = 68.4v−0.209
c f0.564 Rz = 129v−0.209
c f Rz = 142v−0.3c f 0.849 E Rz = 72.7v−0.214
c
0.823
E 0.042P0.006 0.043
P −0.105 f 0.68E 0.056P −0.186
G = 0.38 R = 0.79 G = 0.34 R = 0.79 G = 0.43 R = 0.89 G = 0.36 R = 0.74
The Influence of EP/AW Addition in the MQL Method 345
3 Experimental Procedure
Fig. 1. The influence of feed and cutting speed on the surface roughness parameters for the
investigated cooling/lubricating methods.
For the height parameters, Ra and Rz, the smallest values in the whole range of the
variable cutting speed were observed in the case of cooling by the MQL method with
the addition of EP/AW. The MQL + EP/AW method reduces the considered param-
eters by about 35–49% as compared to dry cutting, by about 23–30% as compared to
the MQCL method and by about 17–28% as compared to the MQL method. The
reduction of the Ra and Rz values can be due to the fact that, when cooling with oil mist
with EP/AW addition, more intensive lubrication of the contact zone takes place,
particularly between the flank face and the newly formed top layer [11], which also
causes temperature drop in the cutting zone [27]. The lowest values of Ra and Rz
parameters in the whole range of variable feeds have been observed in the case of
cooling with oil mist with the addition of EP/AW. On the other hand, cooling with oil
346 R. W. Maruda et al.
mist alone has resulted in that the highest values of the Ra parameter have been
obtained. The Rz parameter after dry turning and turning with oil mist has reached
comparable values for the feeds of 0.25 to 0.35 mm/rev; with the feed below
0.25 mm/rev, one could see that the surface quality, in respect of roughness was better
with the application of the MQL method.
The percentage differences between the Ra values for the selected cooling methods
according to the seven items of the PSI method can be seen in Fig. 2. The diagrams have
been shown, depending on the variable cutting parameters, i.e. variables X1 and X2.
Fig. 2. Percentage changes of the Ra parameter after turning of 316L steel - dry cutting
compared to other methods of cooling (sign “−” means drop of a value; sign “+” means increase
of a value).
Analysing the percentage changes (Fig. 2), it has been found tat the largest dif-
ferences, as compared to dry cutting, were those of the method of cooling by oil mist
with the addition of EP/AW. The application of the MQL method has caused reduction
of the Ra parameter by 17% to 33% (an exception was only the 7th point of the PSI
method where the value was only 6.4%) The seventh point of the PSI method
The Influence of EP/AW Addition in the MQL Method 347
corresponds to the highest value of the feed (f = 0.35 mm/rev) and the lowest cutting
speed (vc = 70 m/min). With the use of the MQCL method, the direction of the per-
centage changes has been noticed, which has been marked in the diagram. Emulsion
mist cooling brings the largest differences as compared to dry cutting for smaller feeds
and higher cutting speeds, I e. for parameters which correspond to finish machining. In
tho0se conditions, emulsion droplets better penetrate the zone between the chip and the
rake face and, consequently, reduce the cutting force, which could influence reduction
of roughness [28]. Applying cooling and lubrication by oil mist alone, it has been
noticed that, for all the items of the PSI method, the value of the Ra parameter is
reduced as compared to dry cutting and in oscillates from 2% to 19%. In the MQL
method the influence of the cutting parameters like in the case of the MQL +EP/AW
and MQCL methods has not been found. Elimination of the cooling and lubricating
liquid has resulted in a slight increase of surface roughness with larger feeds and lower
cutting speeds.
The load capacity of the surface geometrical structure has been defined by the ratio
of the total surface to the bearing surface. The graphic presentation of the relationship is
the Abbott Firestone curve. The curve informs the process engineer about the shape of
surface irregularities and that is why it is mainly used to check the surfaces generated
by multioperational forming of surfaces. Figure 3 shows spatial Abbott Firestone
curves of 316L steel after the process of turning with the four methods of cooling
according to the fifth point of the PSI method.
Additionally, a linearising line has been determined for the middle area of that
curve comprising 40% of all the defined items of the profiles. The curve divides into
parts related to pits, core and upgrades. This, in turn, allows the surface roughness to be
assessed with the use of the spatial parameters: core height, Sk, reduced height of
vertices, Spk, two values of the Abbott Firestone curve, Sr1 and Sr2, and reduced depth
of valleys, Svk. Furthermore, determination of those parameters has allowed for the
calculation of the area of pit free from material, Sa, and the area of upgrades filled with
material, Sa1.
In an analysis of the shapes of the Abbott Firestone curve (Fig. 3), it has been
found that the shape of the curve is very similar in the cases of dry cutting, MQL and
MQCL methods. However, for the MQL +EP/AW method (Fig. 3d), the curve is
clearly moved upward (the curve bending point moves in the degressive direction).
From the exploitation point of view, such a surface has many advantages. Then the
vertices of the irregularities will be most probably removed during running-in and the
manufactured part will work with the whole surface of it.
Considering the roughness parameters of group Sk of the analysed surfaces, it has
been found that the highest values of the core height, Spk, can be observed for dry
cutting (7.63 µm), the lowest for MQL +EP/AW method of cooling (2.72 µm). Higher
values of the Spk parameter generally designate a surface built of high vertices. In
practice, high vertices result in that the contact area between the matching surfaces
decreases, which leads to an increase of pressures between those surfaces. On the other
hand, the biggest depth of valleys, Svk, has been found for surfaces after turning in the
conditions of cooling by the MQL +EP/AW method. The higher value of that
parameter results in s arresting of oil or grease in those places, which is very advan-
tageous in respect of further exploitation of the manufactured part. The results of spatial
348 R. W. Maruda et al.
Fig. 3. Abbott Firestone curves for the 5th item according to the PSI method after turning of
31 l steel in the case of: (a) dry cutting; (b) MQL method; (c) MQCL method;
(d) MQL + EP/AW method.
roughness parameters reflect the values for areas Sa1 and Sa2. The biggest area of
upgrades filled with material has been obtained in the case of MQL method; the
smallest in the case of the MQL +EP/AW method. As regards the area of pits free from
material, the biggest one has been found in the case of a surface after turning in the
conditions of cooling with oil mist with the addition of EP/AW.
4 Conclusion
Applying four methods of cooling based on ecological trends in machining, the fol-
lowing conclusions have been formulated in respect of the parameters of the geo-
metrical structure of 316L steel surface after turning:
1. The lowest values of the roughness height parameters, Ra and Rz, have been
obtained in a surface machined in the conditions of cooling by the MQL + EP/AW
The Influence of EP/AW Addition in the MQL Method 349
method in the whole range of the variable parameters of machining and parameters
of generating the active medium.
2. The biggest percentage changes, as compared to dry cutting, have been observed
with the application of MQL +EP/AW method for smaller feeds and higher cutting
speeds, i.e. for conditions corresponding to finish machining
3. The Abbott Firestone curve combined with the linearization line have proved that
the surface generated in the process of turning under MQL +EP/AW conditions has
better properties for further exploitation. For the MQL +EP/AW method, the lowest
values of the Spk parameter have been recorded and the highest ones of the Svk
parameter. The Svk parameter, which is a measure of the valley depths, causes then
oil and grease arresting on the surface. In dry cutting, higher values of the Spk
parameter have been found, which means a surface consisting of high peaks. In
practice, high peaks result in smaller area of contact between two matching parts,
which causes higher pressure on the contact surfaces.
References
1. Shokoohi, Y., Khosrojerdi, E., Rassolian Shiadhi, B.H.: Machining and ecological effects of
a new developed cutting fluid in combination with different cooling techniques on turning
operation. J. Clean. Prod. 94, 330–339 (2015)
2. Barth, M.: Belastung und Beanspruchung durch biologische Arbeitsstoffe bei Kühlschmier-
mittel-Exponierten in der Metallbearbeitung. University of Duüsseldorf, Düsseldorf. (Dr. -
Ing. Dissertation), Elsevier B.V. (2003)
3. Twardowski, P., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Hloch, S.: Investigation of wear and tool life
of coated carbide and cubic boron nitride cutting tools in high speed milling. Adv. Mech.
Eng. 7(6), 1–9 (2015)
4. Niemczewska-Wójcik, M.: Multi-sensor measurements of titanium alloy surface texture
formed at subsequent operations of precision machining process. Measurement 96, 8–17
(2016)
5. Kaplonek, W., Nadolny, K., Królczyk, G.M.: The use of focus-variation microscopy for the
assessment of active surfaces of a new generation of coated abrasive tools. Meas. Sci. Rev.
16(2), 42–53 (2016)
6. Aramcharoen, A.: Influence of cryogenic cooling on tool wear and chip formation in turning
of titanium alloy. Procedia CIRP 46, 83–86 (2016)
7. Pušavec, F., Kopač, J.: Sustainability assessment: cryogenic machining of inconel 718. Stroj.
Vestnik/J. Mech. Eng. 57(9), 637–647 (2011)
8. Maruda, R.W., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Lukianowicz, C., Stoic, A.: Effect of anti-wear
additive on cutting tool and surface layer of workpiece state under MQCL conditions. Teh.
Vjesn. - Tech. Gaz. 22(5), 1219–1223 (2015)
9. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Analysis of contact phenomena
and heat exchange in the cutting zone under minimum quantity cooling lubrication
conditions. Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 41(2), 661–668 (2016)
10. Dhar, N.R., Kamruzzaman, M., Ahmed, M.: Effect of minimum quantity lubrication
(MQL) on tool wear and surface roughness in turning AISI-4340 steel. J. Mater. Process.
Technol. 172(2), 299–304 (2006)
350 R. W. Maruda et al.
11. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Michalski, M., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S.: Structural
and microhardness changes after turning of the AISI 1045 steel for minimum quantity
cooling lubrication. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 26(1), 431–438 (2017)
12. Tawakoli, T., Hadad, M.J., Sadeghi, M.H., Daneshi, A., Stöckert, S., Rasifard, A.: An
experimental investigation of the effects of workpiece and grinding parameters on minimum
quantity lubrication-MQL grinding. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 49(12–13), 924–932 (2009)
13. Maruda, R.W., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Hloch, S., Michalski, M.: An influence of
active additives on the formation of selected indicators of the condition of the X10CrNi18-8
stainless steel surface layer in MQCL conditions. Int. J. Surf. Sci. Eng. 9(5), 452–465 (2015)
14. Emami, M., Sadeghi, M.H., Sarhan, A.A.D., Hasani, F.: Investigating the Minimum quantity
lubrication in grinding of Al 2O3 engineering ceramic. J. Clean. Prod. 66, 632–643 (2014)
15. Krolczyk, G.M., Maruda, R.W., Nieslony, P., Wieczorowski, M.: Surface morphology
analysis of Duplex Stainless Steel (DSS) in clean production using the power spectral
density. Measurement 94, 464–470 (2016)
16. Jaber, S.A., Ruggiero, A., Battaglia, S., Affatato, S.: On the roughness measurement on knee
prostheses. Int. J. Artif. Organs 38(1), 39–44 (2015)
17. Liao, Y.S., Lin, H.M.Ã.: Mechanism of minimum quantity lubrication in high-speed milling
of hardened steel. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 47, 1660–1666 (2007)
18. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E.: Experimental analysis of tribological behavior of
UHMWPE against AISI420C and against TiAl6V4 alloy under dry and lubricated
conditions. Tribol. Int. 92, 154–161 (2015)
19. Arunachalam, R.M., Mannan, M.A., Spowage, A.C.: Residual stress and surface roughness
when facing age hardened Inconel 718 with CBN and ceramic cutting tools. Int. J. Mach.
Tools Manuf. 44(9), 879–887 (2004)
20. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E., Merola, M.: Experimental comparison on
tribological pairs UHMWPE/TIAL6V4 alloy, UHMWPE/AISI316L austenitic stainless
and UHMWPE/AL2O3ceramic, under dry and lubricated conditions. Tribol. Int. 96, 349–
360 (2016)
21. Rabiei, F., Rahimi, A.R., Hadad, M.J., Ashrafijou, M.: Performance improvement of
minimum quantity lubrication (MQL) technique in surface grinding by modeling and
optimization. J. Clean. Prod. 86, 447–460 (2015)
22. Krajnik, P., Rashid, A., Pušavec, F., Remškar, M., Yui, A., Nikkam, N., Toprak, M.S.:
Transitioning to sustainable production - part III: developments and possibilities for
integration of nanotechnology into material processing technologies. J. Clean. Prod. 112,
1156–1164 (2015)
23. Su, Y., Gong, L., Li, B., Liu, Z., Chen, D.: Performance evaluation of nanofluid MQL with
vegetable-based oil and ester oil as base fluids in turning. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 83(9–
12), 2083–2089 (2016)
24. Hdz-García, H.M., Pech-Canul, M.I., Muñoz-Arroyo, R., Mtz-Enriquez, A.I., Acevedo-
Dávila, J.L., Castro-Román, M.J., Reyes-Valdés, F.A.: 304 stainless steel brazing
incorporating tungsten nanoparticles. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 215, 1–5 (2015)
25. Vamsi Krishna, P., Nageswara Rao, D.: Performance evaluation of solid lubricants in terms
of machining parameters in turning. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 48(10), 1131–1137 (2008)
26. Statnikov, R.B., Matusov, J.B.: Multicriteria Analysis in Engineering. Springer (2002)
27. Dhar, N.R., Islam, M.W., Islam, S., Mithu, M.A.H.: The influence of minimum quantity of
lubrication (MQL) on cutting temperature, chip and dimensional accuracy in turning AISI-
1040 steel. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 171(1), 93–99 (2006)
28. Machado, A.R., Wallbank, J.: The effect of extremely low lubricant volumes in machining.
Wear 210(1–2), 76–82 (1997)
Change of the Substrate Surface After Removal
Multiple Plasma Spraying Layers
Abstract. The paper deals with the change of the surface properties of the
substrate after the application of multiple plasma spraying NiCr. The influence
of selected technological factors (substrate material, surface angle of the sub-
strate and degreasing of the surface) on topography and surface quality of the
substrates. Presented procedures and experimental results demonstrate surface
resistance of individual materials from effect multiple plasma coatings. The best
results of surface resistance have samples from chromium steel. In addition, the
results of these experiments indicate which parameters are key in selecting the
substrate material for the masking process in serial production of coatings by
plasma spraying.
Nomenclature
Ra Mean arithmetic deviation of roughness
Rz Maximum height of the roughness profile
HVm max Maximum value of microhardness according to Vickers
HVm min Minimum value of microhardness according to Vickers
HVm avg Average value of microhardness according to Vickers
CTE Coefficient of thermal expansion
Rm Ultimate tensile strength
1 Introduction
Plasma spraying emerged as a surface finishing technology after the Second World
War. Currently, plasma spray technology brings new possibilities to manufacturing
technology. In the field of engineering, energy, aerospace, automotive, chemistry and
electrical engineering, these technologies are widely used. It is one of the leading
technologies for applying a relatively thick coating (a few hundred of micrometers up
to a few millimeters thick) on a substrate to protect its surface or improve its function.
Their extensive use in industrial practice is a driving force for studying their own
application process, developing of new coatings and rationalizing processes. Of the
45° angle and also with degrease and grease surface. To create a grease surface on
samples was used a thin vaseline film. It was used vaseline Shell Gadus S2 V220AC.
All measurement machines which were used and experimental set up are shown in
Figs. 1.
The results show that the grease surface on the substrate on AlCu4 Mga and chromium
steel had a negative influence on roughness compared to degreased surface. Samples
with grease surface of substrate 90° and 45° had similar parameters. This did not
confirm the hypothesis that the grease surface on the substrate will have a protective
effect before the plasma spraying. Comparison of surface roughness Ra, Rz and
evaluation of microhardness based on HVm min, HVm max and HVm avg are shown
in Table 3. The experiment was performed at the same plasma spraying parameters and
the same distance from the plasma nozzle to the samples.
3.1 Duralumin
Comparisons of parameters are shown in Figs. 2 and 3. Measurements Hvm and
surfaces of samples are shown in Figs. 4, 5, 6 and 7. Evaluation of experimental
samples AlCu4 Mg number 2–5 did not indicate a change microhardness material
because of influence plasma coatings. Between samples with 90° and 45° angle of
surface, and between degrease and grease samples were measured only small devia-
tions. The least increased of roughness compared to the roughness of material before to
plasma spraying was measured on sample No. 2 (90° + degrease). The highest
roughness was measured on sample No. 5 (45° + no degrease). Surface with no
degrease have negative influence on the surface roughness of the sample after the
plasma spraying.
3.2 Nickel
Evaluation of experimental samples coated Ni-Cu-Ni No. 6–10 indicate the big dif-
ferences microhardness of the material because of influence plasma coatings. On
samples 7, 8 (90°) the hardness was reduced by 48% and on samples 9, 10 (45°) the
hardness was reduced by 44%. The surface cleanliness did not affect the hardness of the
358 J. Kužma et al.
samples. The surface roughness was doubled on samples 7, 8 (90°) because of influ-
ence plasma coatings. On samples 9, 10 (45°) the roughness did not change. The
surface cleanliness did not affect the roughness of the samples.
Fig. 6. Measurement Hvm and surface of Chromium steel (samples No. 11–15).
Fig. 7. Measurement Hvm and surface of Hard chrome (samples No. 16, 18).
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgments. Research knowledge can be used in the engineering industry, where plasma
coating is used. Primary, the research results can also be used to rationalization the plasma
coating process for serial production and next research and development of material resistance to
the plasma coating.
Next recommended research should be to compare the HVm and surface roughness after
double removal plasma coatings (24 times coating). Also, more detailed research of multiple
plasma coating on material Chromium Steel because, material Chromium steel had the best
resistance from negative effects of multiple plasma spraying, but there was a big deviation of
HVm on the sample No. 14 (degrease + 45°).
Change of the Substrate Surface 361
References
1. Aubrecht, V.: Technické aplikace plazmatu. Vutium, Brno (2003)
2. Ambrož, O., Kašpar, J.: Žárové nástřiky a jejich průmyslové využití. 1. vyd. Praha: SNTL,
320 p. (1990)
3. Tucker R.C. (ed.): ASM Handbook, vol. 5A, Thermal Spray Technology. ASM International
(2013)
4. Steffens, H.D., Nassenstein, K.: Thermal spraying: a review of 1993. Powder Metall. Int. 25
(6), 280–284 (1993)
5. Suryanarayanan, R.: Plasma Spraying: Theory and Applications. CNRS, London (1993)
6. Westergard, R., Axen, N., Wiklund, U., Hogmark, S.: An evaluation of plasma sprayed
ceramic coatings by erosion, abrasion and bend testing. Wear 246, 12–19 (2000)
7. Jankura, D., Papcun, P.: Evaluation of structure of ceramics and composite coatings prepared
by heating sprying. Mechanika 270(78), 25–29 (2009)
8. Houdková Šimůnková, Š., Enžl, R., Bláhova, O.: Žárové nástřiky: moderní technologie
povrchových úprav Plzeň (2003)
9. Gardon, M., Guilemany, J.M.: Therm. Spray Technol. 23, 577 (2014)
10. Fauchais, P., Heberlein, J., Boulos, M.: Thermal Spray Fundamentals. Springer, New York
(2014)
11. Skočovský, P., Konečná, R.: Nové konštrukčné materiály – Vybrané kapitoly II, ŽU (1996)
12. Svenson, E.: Plating Resources, Inc. Cocoa, Florida, USA (2006)
Tool Wear Measurement in Single Point
Incremental Forming
1 Introduction
Single-point incremental forming (SPIF) of sheets metal is comes into the picture in last
two decade. The transformation of a plane sheet (limited thickness) into a finished part
by is made by localized deformation where forming tool moves in a prescribed tool
path. There is no need of die and punch, Of course, the deformation is incremental,
local in nature and gradual. These enhance the limiting strain during SPIF. It is
a growing process; therefore, a wide analysis is required to develop the theory of
incremental forming [1]. The review of SPIF is carried out with its practical application
in different sectors is presented [2]. The finite element (FE) based analysis is investi-
gated for shape distortions and spring back effects in SPIF. They suggested that, spring
back effect can be reduced by optimized tool path [3]. In SPIF, a simple circular rod is
used as tool whose one face is shaped. The shaped end rod moves over the clamped
metal sheet in a predefined path in computer numerical control (CNC) machine [4]. The
ball end tool and conical end tool is used in SPIF and compared the effective based on
induced deformation force. It is found that the ball end tool will be providing the more
accurate shape than the conical end tool [5]. SPIF has a great potential to respond the
2 Experimental Instigation
In SPIF, tool wear is a progressive damage to a tool end caused by relative motion with
respect to a blank surface. Measurement of tool wear is time-consuming and costly to
predict the tool worn location as well as relationships between tool wear distribution
and processing control parameters by means of try-out techniques based on conven-
tional trial. Measurement of tool wear is difficult in SPIF due to many control
parameters involvement such as step depth, lubrication, spindle speed, feed rate, wall
angle, type of metal, contact pressure at the tool-work piece interface etc. The SPIF of
AA3003-O is done on CNC vertical milling centre MIKROTOOLS DT-110 at
department of production engineering, Birla institute of technology, Mesra, India. The
machine having specifications such as Travel: x-axis: 200 mm, y-axis: 100 mm and z-
axis: 100 mm, Spindle speed: 0–3000, Feed rate: 1–2000 mm/min. A single tool is
used during the entire experiments. The end of tool is measured every time before and
after conducting individual experiment. The differences in the tool end height are
assumed as the wear of tool. In the present study, only aluminum AA3003-O alloy is
taken for experiment and small pyramid frustum is formed during SPIF. The experi-
mental setup on the table of machine DT100 and tool wear zone is presented in Fig. 1.
2.2 Experiment
There are various input parameter involved in SIPF and it is very difficult to consider
the whole input parameters at the same time for investigation of tool wear. The
selection of inputs for the present study is done with the help of literatures in which the
influences of inputs on output are discussed followed by preliminary experiments. The
influences of input variables such as step depth (Dz), feed rate (f ), spindle speed (R),
sheet thickness (T), wall angle (h) and lubricant (L) is considered for the analysis. The
two levels (low and high) of parameters are shown in Table 1.
Six input parameters are considered for SPIF of AA3003-O alloy. The combination
of these input are decided by suitable orthogonal array (OA). Since, the tool wear
measurement is limited in literatures; a minimum number of experiments are conducted
in the present study. The L8 orthogonal array and only two levels (low and high) is
used in the present investigation.
quantity of tool worn out after each experiment. The image of tool is captured before
experiment and after experiment. The captured images are then imported in compatible
image analysis software for measuring the tool wear. MATLAB version R2010a is
used for image analysis in the present study. The image of tool end before conducting
experiment and after experiment is shown in Fig. 4a and b respectively. The exact tool
wear measurement is not possible in these images.
Fig. 4. Forming tool during image analysis: (a) before experiment; (b) after experiment.
Further, the images are converted into the histogram plot for the calculation of exact
amount of tool wear. The histogram plot for initial shape (before experiment) and final
shape (after experiment) is shown in Fig. 5. The tool wear zone is shown in Fig. 5b.
For each experiment, the difference in the height of individual bar is calculated and
taken the average of these differences as mean tool wear. The measured tools wear
along with the coded input variables shown in Table 2.
Tool Wear Measurement in Single Point Incremental Forming 367
Fig. 5. Wear measurement: (a) Tool end profile before experiment; (b) Wear zone.
The effect of SPIF in tool end is observed. For the purpose, the scanning electron
microscope (SEM) is used. Figure 6a is the SEM image of tool end before SPIF
whereas Fig. 6b is the image of tool end at minimum tool wear (Experiment 1) and
Fig. 6c is the image of tool end at maximum tool wear (experiment 4).
Fig. 6. SEM images of tool end (a) before SPIF, (b) at low Tw , (c) at high Tw .
368 M. Oraon and V. Sharma
3 Statistical Analysis
The statistical analysis is carried out in Minitab 17.0.1 version with 95% confidence
level. The minimum tool wear increased the life of tool. For the purpose, smaller is
better approach is taken for the statistical analysis for finding the significance of input
variables. The effect of individual input parameters for tool wear Tw is shown in Fig. 7.
Figure 7 represents the slop of curve for individual input parameters. Higher slop of
individual input parameter indicated more significance on output.
According to Fig. 7, the feed rate of tool, spindle speed and step depth are the
controlling input parameters for the lowering the tool wear. Other input parameters are
not shown their significance on output. The rank of input parameters is presented in
Table 3. According to Table 3, the higher priority for low tool wear is feed rate of tool
followed by spindle speed/RPM, step depth, thickness of metal, lubricant and wall
angle respectively.
Table 3 indicated that the suitable combination of input parameters for low tool
wear is as Dz = 0.7 mm, f = 20 mm/min, R = 500, T = 0.2 mm, h = 150, and L =
MoS2 grease. The wall angle is found as neutral input parameter for the low tool wear.
It means tool wear does not controlled by the wall angle during SPIF. Further, Analysis
of variance (ANOVA) is carried out for finding the significance of input parameter for
low tool wear (Table 4).
Table 4 shows that the significance of input parameter for low tool wears Tw . The
step depth Dz (P = 0.022), feed rate of tool f (P = 0.014) and spindle speed R
(P = 0.015) are found as the significant input variables which directly affect the tool
wear Tw . The other input parameters viz thickness T, wall angle h and lubricant L are
not significant for tool wear.
The life of forming tool is main consideration for manufacturing industries. The pre-
cision of tool profile takes a vital role in SPIF. If the tool end worn out rapidly and
needed to be replaced, it will be a costlier affair for manufacturing industries. The tool
wear is measured through image analysis by using MATLAB version R2010a by
means of histogram plots. The decrement in bar height (Fig. 5b) indicated as the wear
of tool end. In this continuation, the significant input parameters i.e. Dz, f and R is
found as significant input parameters for low tool wear. The interactions of these input
parameters are not discussed in the present study. These interactions may show the
significance of metal thickness T, wall angle h and lubricant L.
5 Conclusion
The forming tool in SPIF is important parameter in SPIF. The life of tool may be
increased by controlling the input parameters. The present study is concentrated on the
reduction of tool end wear and following points is found as,
370 M. Oraon and V. Sharma
• The exact tool wear in SPIF can be measured through image analysis. The differ-
ences in bar height can easily by measure.
• The suitable combination of input parameters for low tool wear is Dz ¼ 0:7mm,
f ¼ 20 mm=min, R ¼ 500, T ¼ 0:2 mm and L = MoS2 grease.
• Wall angle h is not significant for tool wear.
• Statistically, it is observed that the tool wear is influenced by step depth
DzðP ¼ 0:022Þ, feed rate of tool f ðP ¼ 0:014Þ and spindle speed RðP ¼ 0:015Þ.
• The main controlling parameter for low tool wear is feed rate of tool with respect to
step depth and spindle speed.
• The input parameters metal thickness T, wall angle h and lubricant L are not
significant for tool wear.
• The tool wear may vary in SPIF of hard metals.
• The other hardening such as isothermal hardening, nitriding etc. may improve the
life of tool.
References
1. Pohlak, M., Majak, J., Kuttner, R.: Manufacturability and limitations in incremental sheet
forming. Proc. Estonian acad. Sci. Engg 13(2), 129–139 (2007)
2. Oraon, M., Sharma, V.: Sheet metal micro forming: future research potentials. Int. J. Prod.
Ind. Eng. 1, 31–35 (2010)
3. Dejardin, S., Gelin, J.C., Thibaud, S.: Experimental investigations and numerical analysis for
improving knowledge of incremental sheet forming process for sheet metal parts. J. Mater.
Process. Technol. 201(2), 363–369 (2010)
4. Oraon, M., Sharma, V., Kumar, S.: Effect of tool geometry in sheet metal Incremental
forming. In: 27th National Convention of Production Engineers: National Seminar on
Advancements in Manufacturing Vision-2020, pp. 1–6. Ranchi, India (2012)
5. Oraon, M., Sharma, V.: Effectiveness of tool profile in sheet metal incremental forming. In:
5th International Scientific and Expert Conference of the International TEAM Society, vol.
1, pp. 55–59. Presov, Slovakia (2013)
6. Kroplin, B., Luckey, E.: Metal forming process simulation in industry. In: International
Conference and Workshop, pp. 28–30. Baden-Baden, Germany (1994)
7. Lee, J.K., Kinzel, G.L., Wagoner, R.: Numerical simulation of 3D sheet metal forming
processes, verification of simulations with experiments. In: 3rd International Conference on
NUMISHEET 96, pp. 128–135. The Ohio State University, Dearborn (1996)
8. Guo, Y.Q., Batoz, J.L., Naceur, H., Bouabdallah, S., Mercier, F., Barlet, O.: Recent
developments on the analysis and optimum design of sheet metal forming parts using a
simplified inverse approach. Comput. Struct. 78, 133–148 (2000)
9. Ham, M., Jeswiet, J.: Dimensional accuracy of single point incremental forming. Int.
J. Mater. Form. 1(1), 1171–1174 (2008)
10. Hamilton, K., Jeswiet, J.: Single point incremental forming at high feed rates and rotational
speeds: surface and structural consequences. CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol. 59(1), 311–314
(2010)
11. Sarraji, W.K.H., Hussain, J., Ren, W.X.: Experimental investigations on forming time in
negative incremental sheet metal forming process. Mater. Manuf. Process. 27(5), 499–506
(2012)
Tool Wear Measurement in Single Point Incremental Forming 371
12. Kadhum, A., Zghair, H., Mohammed, Z.: Estimation the influence of tool geometry on the
surface quality and tool wear. Iraqi J. Mech. Mater. Eng. 10(3), 417–430 (2010)
13. Radu, M.C., Cristea, I.: Processing metal sheets by SPIF and analysis of parts quality. Mater.
Manuf. Process. 28, 287–293 (2013)
14. Podgornik, B., Leskovsek, V.: Wear mechanisms and surface engineering of forming tools.
Mater. Technol. 49(3), 313–324 (2015)
15. Jarfors, A.E.W., Castagne, S.J., Danno, A., Zhang, X.: Tool wear and life span variations in
cold forming operations and their implications in microforming. Technologies 5(3), 1–29
(2017)
16. Diabb, J., Rodriguez, C.A., Mamidi, N., Sandoval, J.A., Tijerina, J.T., Romero, O.M.,
Zuniga, A.E.: Study of lubrication and wear in single point incremental sheet forming (SPIF)
process using vegetable oil nano lubricants. Wear 376-377, 777–785 (2017)
17. Lu, B., Fang, Y., Xu, D.K., Chen, J., Ou, H., Moser, N.H., Cao, J.: Mechanism investigation
of friction-related effects in single point incremental forming using a developed oblique
roller-ball tool. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 85, 14–29 (2014)
18. Grimm, T.J., Ragai, I., Roth, J.T.: A novel modification to the incremental forming process,
part 2: validation of the multi-directional tooling method. Procedia Manuf. 10, 520–530
(2017)
Materials
Increasing Compressor Wheel Fatigue Life
Through Residual Stress Generation
1 Introduction
One of the common modes of failure for an automotive turbocharger compressor wheel
is low cycle fatigue (LCF), which is the fatigue of the material due to a cyclic load at a
low frequency. Engels [1] highlights that the fatigue behaviour of metallic materials is
closely connected with local plastic deformation and an accumulation of cyclic plastic
deformation that leads to micro fatigue cracks. The initial micro cracks are the starting
point for macro cracks and then after a certain time the macro crack growth will lead to
component failure. In the case of the example automotive compressor wheel used in
this paper, the material is a cast aluminium alloy and the load is being applied by the
application duty cycle.
During operation the compressor wheel can be subjected to high stresses due to
speed, temperature and pressure. Ohri and Shoghi [2] have shown that the principal
stress is only minimally affected by pressure, while Christmann et al. [3] demonstrated
that the influence of temperature on the principal stress is also minimal. Hence, the duty
cycles used for LCF analyses are typically presented as speed vs time. Engels [1] states
that the load cycle is mainly determined by the application topography but operating
altitude and driving style can also have an influence.
Residual stresses may be generated within a component during the manufacturing
processes. In the case of cast aluminium compressor wheels initial casting of the wheel
and subsequent machining of the bore, nose, blade profile and back disc may all
generate residual stresses. Wyatt et al. [4] note that casting may generate residual
stresses at any point within the section whereas machining will only impact up to
depths of approximately 0.1 mm. Webster and Ezeilo [5] note that residual stresses can
either be beneficial or detrimental and can have a significant influence on the fatigue
life of the component. They point out that, “near surface tensile residual stresses tend to
accelerate the initiation and growth phases of the fatigue process while compressive
residual stresses close to a surface may prolong fatigue life”. To accurately determine
the fatigue life of a component the residual stress profile within the component is
required and then needs to be incorporated in to the life time calculation process.
Within the pressure vessel industry, it is common practice to autofrettage cylin-
drical vessels [6]. In this process the vessel is subjected to a single pressure load cycle
where the maximum pressure drives the stresses at the inner surface of the wall beyond
the material yield point. However, the bulk material remains elastic so when the
autofrettage pressure is removed, compressive residual stresses are present at the inner
surface. These residual stresses then reduce the level of stress at that surface when
cyclic working pressures are applied and hence increase fatigue life.
Within the turbocharger industry, it appears that only the detrimental effects of
residual stress have been studied. There appears to have been no attempt to study the
potential benefits of residual stress. In particular, residual stresses may be beneficial in
the bore of the wheel.
The objective of the work described here is to generate a design tool which will
allow a process similar to autofrettage to be defined to generate beneficial residual
stresses within compressor wheels.
The equivalent elastic stresses are determined by ignoring material yielding and
assuming elastic behaviour up to infinite stress levels. For rotating cylinders
Increasing Compressor Wheel Fatigue Life 377
Where a and b are the inner and outer radii of the cylinder respectively, q and t are
the material density and Poisson’s ratio and x is the angular velocity.
Gamer and Lance [7] have previously presented an elastic-plastic analysis of a
rotating cylinder with fixed ends assuming linear work hardening and applying the
Tresca yield criterion. The yield stress, rY , can be defined as:
rY ¼ r0 þ gepEQ ð4Þ
Where r0 is the initial yield stress, g is the hardening factor and epEQ is the
equivalent plastic strain.
As the speed of rotation is increased, the cylinder first yields at the inner radius, a.
Further increasing the angular velocity produces a cylinder with an inner portion which
is deforming plastically and an outer portion which is still deforming elastically. In the
plastic region, up to an interface radius, c, the stresses are given by:
1 D
rr ¼ 16rY lnr f8 þ ð3 2tÞH gqx r 4ð1 2tÞH 2 þ C ð5Þ
2 2
8½2 þ ð1 tÞH r
1 D
rh ¼ 16r Y ð1 þ lnr Þ f8 þ ð1 þ 2tÞH gqx r þ 4ð1 2tÞH 2 þ C
2 2
8½2 þ ð1 tÞH r
ð6Þ
Where:
" 2
#
1 16rY lna þ 4ð1 tÞHrY ac2
C¼
8½2 þ ð1 tÞH þ f8 þ ð3 2tÞH gqx2 a2 ð1 2tÞHqx2 ac2
4
1t 1
D¼ rY c2 qx2 c4
1 2t 4
Between the interface radius and the outer radius, b, of the cylinder the elastic
stresses are given by:
A 2G 3 2t
rr ¼ 2G þ B qx2 r 2 ð8Þ
r 2 1 2t 8ð 1 t Þ
A 2G 1 þ 2t
rh ¼ 2G þ B qx2 r 2 ð9Þ
r 2 1 2t 8ð 1 t Þ
Where:
1 1 2t
2GA ¼ rY c2 qx2 c4
2 8ð1 tÞ
2G 1 c2 1 c4
B ¼ rY 2 þ qx2 b2 3 2t ð1 2tÞ 4
1 2t 2 b 8ð 1 t Þ b
The following equation can be used to determine either the elastic-plastic interface
radius for a given angular velocity or the location of the elastic plastic interface for
a given angular velocity.
ð3 2Þ½2 þ ð1 tÞH ð1 tÞ½8 þ ð3 2tÞH Q2 þ 4ð1 2tÞf2 ð1 2tÞ½2 þ ð1 tÞH f4
f4
þ ð1 tÞð1 2tÞH 2 gX2 ¼ 4ð1 tÞ½2 þ ð1 tÞH 1 f2
Q 2
f f
þ 4ð1 tÞ2 H 1 þ 16ð1 tÞln ð10Þ
Q2 Q
To determine the number of elements required through the cylinder wall to accu-
rately predict the stresses, a mesh convergence study was carried out. This study
indicated that using more than 26 elements through the cylinder wall made minimal
difference to the stress magnitude and distribution.
Figure 1 compares the finite element and theoretical results with a hardening
parameter, H ¼ 0 (i.e. a perfectly plastic material model). These show good correlation
although the FEA predicts a smaller plastic region and consequently, less residual
stress. This is due to the theoretical calculations using the Tresca yield criterion, while
the FEA uses the Von-Mises. The Von-Mises criterion, unlike the Tresca criterion,
accounts for the fact that hydrostatic stress does not cause yielding.
Fig. 2. (a) Comparison of hardening parameters and (b) impact on circumferential stress.
The FEA described in Sect. 3.3 was repeated with the four linear work hardening
material models shown in Fig. 2(a) and the non-linear material model. The partially
plastic circumferential stresses generated are shown in Fig. 2(b). The linear work
hardening material model with a hardening parameter of 0.71 gives the closest result to
the non-linear material model. This is due to the constraining, elastic outer portion of
the cylinder preventing substantial plastic deformation.
3 Wheel Analysis
Fig. 4. (a) and (b) Maximum principal stress (MPa) at 150 krpm. (c) and (d) subsequent
minimum principal stress (MPa).
minimum principal residual stress vector were running around the surface of the fillet
radius, in an approximately circumferential direction. For both the main blade and the
splitter blade the residual stress was –20 MPa.
Looking at the position of the maximum principal stress at 150 krpm in Fig. 4a and
then the minimal principal stress (or largest magnitude compressive stress) at 0 rpm in
Fig. 4c it can be seen that the position is not identical as may be expected. A similar
situation exists for the blade root area shown in Fig. 4b and d. In both cases the largest
magnitude principal residual stress is in the same location as the maximum equivalent
stress during the over-speed load step. This is due to residual stress generation being a
function of plastic deformation which in turn is governed by the equivalent stress.
A consequence of this is that the maximum benefit from the compressive residual
stresses cannot be utilised.
Increasing Compressor Wheel Fatigue Life 383
Fig. 5. Key maximum principal stresses at working speed following residual stress generation.
However, the closed form theoretical model presented in Sect. 3 is for a plain cylinder,
not a wheel. A method of approximating a wheel as a thick walled cylinder is therefore
required. The length of the wheel can be disregarded in the theoretical model and the
bore is clearly defined. A cylinder outer diameter which will represent the hub sub-
jected to blade loading, is then required.
Fig. 6. Theoretical and FEA circumferential stresses at the bore at maximum working speed.
by 2 mm, required the over-speed to be increased by 1000 rpm. In other words, the
technique is relatively insensitive to the initial yield speed predicted by the simple FEA
model.
5 Conclusions
References
1. Engels, B.: Lifetime prediction for Turbocharger Compressor Wheels - Why Use Titanium-?
BorgWarner internal company presentation (2002)
2. Ohri, K., Shoghi, K.: Compressor wheel low cycle fatigue calculations for off highway
applications an approach to accurately calculate application duty cycle. In: IMechE 10th
International Conference on Turbocharging, London, pp. 97–107 (2012)
3. Christmann, R., Langler, F., Habermehl, M., Fonts, P.-M., Fontvielle, L., Moulin, P.: Low –
cycle fatigue of turbocharger compressor wheels. In: IMechE 9th International Conference on
Turbocharging, London, pp. 251–262 (2010)
4. Wyatt, J.E., Berry, J.T., Williams, A.R.: Residual stresses in aluminum castings. J. Mater.
Process. Technol. 191(1), 170–173 (2007)
5. Webster, G.A., Ezeilo, A.N.: Residual stress distributions and their influence on fatigue
lifetimes. Int. J. Fatigue 23, 375–383 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0142-1123(01)00133-5
6. Zhu, R., Yang, J.: Autofrettage of thick cylinders. Int. J. Press. Vessel. Pip. 75(6), 443–446
(1998)
7. Gamer, U., Lance, R.H.: Stress distribution in a rotating elastic-plastic tube. Acta Mech. 50(1–
2), 1–8 (1983)
8. Barrans, S., Tabriz, M., Ellis, C.: Determining stress in turbocharger impellers due to
component machining. In: ASME Turbo Expo: Turbomachinery Technical Conference &
Exposition, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA, 26–30 June 2017
Preliminary Study of Residual
Stress Measurement Using Eddy Currents
Phasor Angle
Abstract. Residual stress detection and evaluation has been of crucial impor-
tance, and also problematic for many years. There are many methods of residual
stresses determination based on destructive and non-destructive way of
approach. Nowadays there are still undiscovered possibilities to determine these
internal stresses. Opportunity to detect residual stress on line directly, without
using big and expensive devices is motivation for presented work. Presented
article is focused on possibility to determine the residual stresses induced in
conductive materials using eddy currents phasor angle. Using eddy currents
method gives opportunity for quick on line measurement of residual stresses.
Induced stress causes in base material slight deviation in permeability and
conductivity, which can be detected using standard eddy currents flaw detector.
Experimental procedure included annealing for stress relief, manufacturing by
face milling and measurement of residual stresses using x-ray diffraction and
eddy currents. Results of experimental research lead to extension of knowledge
in the field of residual stresses. Presented method is applicable for assessment of
residual stresses in many components.
1 Introduction
Residual stresses (RS) are tensions in object, which are not necessarily in balance
between object and environment. Residual stresses can be categorized according to
cause of origin and based on dimension (distance) in which they acquire balance [1]
(Fig. 1).
Categorization of residual stresses according to area of influence [23]:
I. Order – Macroscopic stress is created during machining process, forming pro-
cess, welding, and heat treatment. They act in deep volumetric layers of material.
II. Order – Second order RS act in grains and crystals in small volumes.
III. Order – Third order RS act in the level of crystalline lattice atoms.
Nowadays, the detection, evaluation and elimination of residual stresses are very
actual issues. Authors Winiarski et al. [3] described detection of residual stresses after
shot peening using drilling method, cutting method and x-ray diffraction on aluminum
alloy Al-7075-T651. Authors Sun et al. [4] deals with detection of residual stresses
after friction stir welding of high strength aluminum alloy AW 7010 on notched
samples after shot peening. Coules et al. [5] used neutron diffraction on samples after
three-point bend test. Smith [6] deals with effect of RS no cracks creation in creep
resistant stainless steel AISI 316 Effect of RS on fracture behavior on different plas-
ticity levels was aim of research of Ainswort et al. [7]. Detection of RS after electron
beam welding of austenitic stainless steel AISI 316LN and ferritic-martensitic P91 steel
using neutron diffraction described Venkata et al. [8]. Wang et al. [9] observed residual
stresses induced in various materials using neutron diffraction. Publication [9] deals
with stress induced phase transformation of CuZr alloy. Wang et al. [10] evaluate effect
of compressive RS on crack growth on aluminum alloy 6061-T6. Yang et al. [11] deals
388 F. Botko et al.
2 Experimental Methods
Face mill used in experimental machining was FMACM 4063HR with effective
diameter Def = 63 mm with carbide inserts SEET 14M4AGSN – MM from company
KORLOY (Fig. 4).
Machining operation was carried out with constant depth of cut ap = 2 mm with
single pass. After each pass were cutting inserts turned to unused cutting edge and after
fourth turn were changed for new insert. Cutting conditions used in experimental
procedure are listed in following table (Table 3).
Measurement of residual stress was provided in NDT laboratory of Faculty of
Mechanical Engineering - University of Zilina using x-ray diffraction instrument
Proto XRD. For all samples was detected significant values of normal residual stress,
tangential residual stresses were detected in the range from −35 to +35 MPa and thus
were not taken in to account. All measured residual stresses for each sample were in
normal direction in the range from 362–593 MPa (Fig. 5).
390 F. Botko et al.
Eddy current measurement was performed using EC flaw detector Olympus Nortec
600 D with absolute probe INDETEC ndt. MTW100.S3.A1N 10–100 kHz. Taking into
account XRD measurement of residual stress in the depth 12 lm was calculated eddy
currents depth of penetration for construction steel. Depth of penetration was calculated
using skin effect formula (1).
503:3
s ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð1Þ
f :lr :ro
Where:
S [mm] – eddy current’s depth of penetration
f [Hz] – probe frequency
µir – permeability of material
rO [S.m−1] – electrical conductivity
In the fact, that measurement is carried out in near surface layer was selected probe
frequency 100 kHz with depth of penetration 60 µm. Selected frequency was subse-
quently preliminary tested for measurement resolution. Figure 6 shows signals from all
experimental samples. Curve heading to center of axes comes from “zero” sample,
Preliminary Study of Residual Stress Measurement Using Eddy Currents Phasor Angle 391
signals in the right upper quadrant comes from machined samples. Measurements were
carried out in laboratory conditions with stable temperature 22 °C.
Measured values Hmax [V] and Vmax [V] were subsequently used for calculation
of phasor size and phasor angle. Hmax [V] represents horizontal part of voltage and
392 F. Botko et al.
Vmax [V] vertical part of voltage. Phasor size and phasor angle were calculated using
Eqs. (2) and (3) and graphical representation is shown in Fig. 7.
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
j zj ¼ Hmax2 þ Vmax2 ð2Þ
Hmax
cosu ¼ ð3Þ
j zj
Where:
Hmax [V] – horizontal shift of voltage (real part)
Vmax [V] – vertical shift of voltage (imaginary part)
3 Results
Mentioned formula (4) then allows calculations of phasor size and phasor angle. For
each measured sample were subsequently calculated phasor angles and their average
values. Following figure (Fig. 8) shows graphical dependence of XRD measured
residual stress on eddy current’s average phasor size. From figure is evident that in the
range of measured residual stresses acquire linear trend. For simplification of prelim-
inary experiment was calculated linear formula used for calculation of residual stress
size based on phasor angle size.
Following graphical dependence shows courses of XRD measured residual stresses
and calculated residual stresses based on EC phasor size. For better illustration were
added curves which characterize courses of residual stresses calculated using minimal
and maximal phasors angle. Minimal and maximal phasors angle were obtained by
calculation of minimal respectively maximal values of Hmax [V] and Vmax [V] for
each sample separately (Fig. 9).
394 F. Botko et al.
4 Conclusions
Acknowledgement. This work was supported by the Slovak Research and Development
Agency under the contract No. APVV-15-0696 and by project 039-TUKE-4/2017 - Transfer of
Knowledge from Research of Welding the Creep Resistant Steel into the Study Branch
Progressive Technologies.
References
1. Kloos, K.H., Kaiser, B.: Residual stresses induced by manufacturing, residual stresses
measurement, calculation, evaluation. In: Hauk, V., Hougardy, H., Macherauch, E. (eds.)
Proceedings of the Conference on Residual Stresses, Darmstadt, Deutsche Gesellschaft für
Metallkunde, Oberursel, pp. 205–226 (1991)
2. Davim, P.J.: Residual stresses and microstructural modifications. In: Surface Integrity in
Machining, pp. 67–126. Springer, London (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-84882-874-2
3. Winiarski, B., Benedetti, M., Fontanari, V., et al.: High spatial resolution evaluation of
residual stresses in shot peened specimens containing sharp and blunt notches by micro-hole
drilling, micro-slot cutting and micro-x-ray diffraction methods. Exp. Mech. 56, 1449–1463
(2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11340-016-0182-x
4. Sun, T.Z., Roy, M.J., Strong, D., et al.: Comparison of residual stress distributions in
conventional and stationary shoulder high-strength aluminum alloy friction stir welds.
J. Mater. Process. Technol. 242, 91–100 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2016.
11.015
5. Coules, H.E., Smith, D.J., Orrock, P.J., et al.: A combined experimental and modelling
approach to elastic-plastic crack driving force calculation in the presence of residual stresses.
Exp. Mech. 56, 1313–1325 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11340-016-0171-0
396 F. Botko et al.
6. Smith, D.J.: Creep stress relaxation and crack incubation in the presence of structural elastic
follow-up. Trans. Indian Inst. Metals 69, 483–488 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12666-
015-0819-y
7. Ainsworth, R.A., Sharples, J.K., Smith, S.D.: Effects of residual stresses on fracture
behaviour-experimental results and assessment methods. J. Strain Anal. Eng. Des. 35, 307–
316 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1243/0309324001514431
8. Venkata, K.A., Truman, C.E., Smith, D.J., et al.: Characterising electron beam welded
dissimilar metal joints to study residual stress relaxation from specimen extraction. Int.
J. Press. Vessel. Pip. 139, 237–249 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpvp.2016.02.025
9. Wang, D.M., Mu, J., Chen, Y., et al.: A study of stress-induced phase transformation and
micromechanical behavior of CuZr-based alloy by in-situ neutron diffraction. J. Alloys
Compd. 696, 1096–1104 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.12.020
10. Wang, Y.L., Zhu, Y.L., Hou, S., et al.: Investigation on fatigue performance of cold
expansion holes of 6061-T6 aluminum alloy. Int. J. Fatigue 95, 216–228 (2017). https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2016.10.030
11. Yang, H., Yo, D., Chen, Y., et al.: In-situ TOF neutron diffraction studies of cyclic softening
in superelasticity of a NiFeGaCo shape memory alloy. Mater. Sci. Eng. A Struct. Mater.
Prop. Microstruct. Process. 680, 324–328 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2016.10.078
12. Aba-Perea, P.E., Pilling, T., Withers, P.J., et al.: Determination of the high temperature
elastic properties and diffraction elastic constants of Ni-base superalloys. Mater. Des. 89,
856–863 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.09.152
13. Aba-Perea, P.E., Pilling, T., Preuss, M.: In-situ residual stress analysis during annealing
treatments using neutron diffraction in combination with a novel furnace design. Mater. Des.
110, 925–931 (2016)
14. Krejci, L., Hlavaty, I., Sevcikova, X.: Transition zones study of the heterogenous welded
joints. In: 22nd International Conference on Metallurgy and Materials, Metal 2013,
pp. 785–789 (2013)
15. Wang, Q., Liu, X.S., Yan, Z.J., et al.: On the mechanism of residual stresses relaxation in
welded joints under cyclic loading. Int. J. Fatigue 105, 43–59 (2017). https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.ijfatigue.2017.08.016
16. Mohyla, P., Tomcik, P., Benes, L., et al.: Effect of post-welding heat treatment on secondary
hardening of welded joints Cr-Mo-V Steel. Metal Sci. Heat Treat. 53, 374–378 (2011).
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11041-011-9401-3
17. Cozzolino, L.D., Coules, H.E., Colegrove, P.A., et al.: Investigation of post-weld rolling
methods to reduce residual stress and distortion. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 247, 243–256
(2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2017.04.018
18. Shen, Y., Lo, C.C.H., Nakagawa, N., Frishman, A.M.: Residual stress profile assessment by
eddy current for shot peened nickel superalloy. J. Nondestruct. Eval. 29(1), 1–13 (2010)
19. Abu-Nabah, B.A., Hassan, W.T., Ryan, D., Blodgett, M.P., Nagy, P.B.: The effect of
hardness on eddy current residual stress profiling in shot-peened nickel alloys. J. Nonde-
struct. Eval. 29(3), 143–153 (2010)
20. Habibalahi, A., Safizadeh, M.S.: Forward to residual stress measurement by using pulsed
eddy current technique. Insight Non Destruct. Test. Cond. Monit. 55(9), 492–497 (2013)
21. Abu-Nabah, M.B.B., Hassan, W., Nagy, P.B.: On the limitations of eddy current residual
stress profiling in precipitation-hardened nickel-base superalloys. In: Electromagnetic
Nondestructive Evaluation (XIII), vol. 13, p. 95 (2010)
22. Boone, T.A.P.S., Raoa, S.I., Wang, P., Nagy, P., Blodgett, M.: Investigation of
microstructural effects on electrical resistivity and their implications for eddy current
methods in measuring residual stresses in IN718. In: Electromagnetic Nondestructive
Evaluation (XIII), vol. 13, p. 165 (2010)
Preliminary Study of Residual Stress Measurement Using Eddy Currents Phasor Angle 397
23. Withers, P.J., Bhadeshia, H.K.D.H.: Residual stress. Part 1–measurement techniques. Mater.
Sci. Technol. 17(4), 355–365 (2001)
24. Kumar, A.: Synthesis and Characterization of TiO2-GeO2-Azobenzene nanocomposite as
Photoanode for Dye Sensitized Solar Cells and other Optoelectronic devices Applications.
Doctoral dissertation, Pondicherry University (2016)
25. García-Martín, J., Gómez-Gil, J., Vázquez-Sánchez, E.: Non-destructive techniques based on
eddy current testing. Sensors 11(3), 2525–2565 (2011)
Forces and Process Dynamics in Profiling
of AlCu4MgSi Aluminium Alloy
1 Introduction
The change in cutting force significantly affects – directly or indirectly – basically every
indicator of the machining process, such as chatter intensity, heat exchange in the
machining zone, character of tool wear, tool life and strength, surface layer hardening etc.
The effects of research on the subject of machining force are very broad and shown
in scientific publications, both domestic and foreign. The research regards all types of
construction materials- steel, cast iron, non-ferrous alloys, polymer composites and
many others. Aluminum alloys are nowadays widely used in many branches of
industry. Therefore, expanding the knowledge regarding forces and dynamic phe-
nomena in machining of aluminum alloys is an important issue.
The main factors affecting cutting force are material properties, machining param-
eters, cooling and lubricating conditions, and finally cutting tool geometry and condition
[1, 2]. In regards to tool geometry, the rake angle has the most effect on cutting force, as
the cutting force decreases with and increase in it. On the other hand, an increase in rake
angle decreases tool life. A preparation of cutting edge and overall tool condition also
have a substantial effect on cutting force. For example, the use of polished cutting edges
and the used of tool coatings extends tool life and facilitates chip removal, causing a
decrease in cutting force [3, 4]. The use of TiN coated indexable inserts has allowed to
lower the cutting force in turning of Al 2219 aluminum alloy and composites based on it
when turning with cutting speeds of 75–175 m/min, 0.3 mm/rev feed rate and constant
depth of cut 0.5 mm [5]. It was found that in turning of 7050-T7451 aluminum alloy,
lowering the rake angle and depth of cut resulted in increased cutting energy con-
sumption in the range of 1000–4500 m/min cutting speeds [6]. In [7], the effect of
cutting speed on thrust force when turning different aluminum alloys was shown. For
each of those alloys, a border value of cutting force at a certain cutting speed (600–
750 m/min depending on the alloy) was determined, marking the transition between
conventional and high speed cutting (HSC) at that “critical cutting speed”. Similar data
was shown in [8] when researching the effect of tool coating type (or lack thereof) on
thrust force depending on the cutting speed in machining of AlSilMgMn alloy. The use
of an approx. 1 lm thick TiB2 layer causes a decrease in cutting force in comparison to
a non-coated tool in a wide range of cutting speeds. A thicker TiAlCN coating lowers
the cutting force for cutting speeds under 450 m/min. For the higher cutting speeds the
cutting force is higher or comparable to values obtained when machining with a non-
coated tool. The effect of cutting liquids on cutting force was analyzed in [3, 4, 9]. It was
ascertained that turning with the use of cutting liquid or in MQL conditions significantly
lowers the cutting force value in comparison to dry cutting.
Minimum Quantity Lubrication (MQL) [3, 4, 9, 11–13] and Minimum Quantity
Cooling Lubrication (MQCL) [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20] based strategies are nowadays
widely used in machining due to environmental aspects associated with the use of those
methods. MQL and MQCL fit into sustainable development thanks to reduction in
environmental effects of machining, reduction in energy consumption, cutting liquid
costs, improvement of machine tool operator health and safety and a positive effect on
waste management. Authors of many scientific papers have proven positive effects of
MQL and MQCL methods in comparison to traditional flood cooling and dry machining.
Currently, it has been proven that the use MQL and MQCL strategies results in decreases
in surface roughness [11, 12, 15, 16, 20], tool wear [11–14, 16], plastic deformation in
near-surface layer [19], cutting force [11, 13], cutting zone temperature [11] and
improvement in tribological properties of the surface layer [17].
Results of research regarding cutting force and process dynamics in turning of
AlCu4MgSi aluminum alloy for different cooling and lubricating conditions are shown
below.
2 Experimental Procedure
AlCu4MgSi aluminum alloy was used for research purposes. It is commonly known as
duralumin and is characterized as having high strength and good machinability. It is
used for production of parts and components, particularly in automotive and aerospace
industries.
A CSDCN 20 20 H 12 tool holder with SNMN 12 04 08 cutting tool was used for
machining. Tool geometry characteristics are as follows: jr = 45°; a = 7°; c = −7°;
re = 0.8 mm. Non-coated P25 grade sintered carbide inserts were used.
400 E. Feldshtein and P. Nieslony
A 23-1 type fractional factorial design was used to conduct the research [10]. Range
of research parameters and their codes are given in Table 1.
Turning was performed both in dry conditions and with the use of various cooling
strategies, i.e. flood cooling (7% water-based cutting fluid on the base of Emulgol-S
concentrate), MQCL (minimum quantity cooling lubrication) with the same fluid as
used for flood cooling, and finally MQL (minimum quantity lubrication) with the use of
ECOCUT MIKRO PLUS 20 oil. The following conditions for creation of coolant mist
were used: air flow 5.8 l/min, fluid/oil flow 0.44 g/min, nozzle standoff from the
machining zone 0.3 m.
Cutting force components were measured with the used of Kistler 9129A
dynamometer equipped with piezoelectric sensors. Sampling frequency was 1000 Hz.
Values of three main cutting force components in cartesian coordinate system were
registered during machining: Fc – main cutting force, Fp – thrust force, Ff – feed force.
Statistical processing of obtained results was done with the use of Statistica 13.1
software.
3 Research Results
Examples of registered Fc, Fp and Ff cutting force components are shown in Fig. 1. The
effect of machining conditions on cutting force components is shown in Fig. 2. It can
be easily seen that cooling conditions have a negligible effect on cutting force com-
ponents values. Even in the most favorable conditions, changes do not exceed 5%
(MQCL). Therefore, the solution to use dry cutting in machining of aluminum with
high cutting speeds presents itself as economically viable, allowing for reduction in
production costs.
Changes in cutting force components can be characterized by the following rela-
tion: Fc Fp > Ff. Intensity of the effect of machining parameters on cutting force
drops in the direction of f ! ap ! vc. A substantial effect of feed rate can be attributed
to low depths of cut, at which cutting force values are mostly affected by cutting edge
radius.
Forces and Process Dynamics in Profiling of AlCu4MgSi Aluminium Alloy 401
Fig. 1. Examples of registered cutting force component signals (positive and negative force
values are in accordance to dynamometer software measurement coordinates).
Fig. 2. The effect of cutting conditions on cutting force components (numbers 1–4 designate
machining parameter values in accordance with Table 1).
Forces and Process Dynamics in Profiling of AlCu4MgSi Aluminium Alloy 403
Fig. 5. The effect of cutting conditions on chatter frequency in Fc (a), Fp (b) and Ff (c) directions
(numbers 1–4 designate machining parameter values in accordance with Table 1).
4 Conclusion
Basing on the analysis of cutting force components and machining dynamics in turning
of AlCu4MgSi aluminum alloy in different cutting conditions (dry cutting, flood
cooling, MQL, MQCL) it was observed that lubricating and cooling conditions in the
assumed machining parameter range (cutting speed 300–600 m/min, depth of cut 1–
2 mm and feed rate 0.1–0.5 mm/rev) have a minimal effect on cutting force. Therefore,
a conclusion to use dry cutting to cut down production costs presents itself. Changes in
cutting force components can be characterized by the following relation: Fc Fp > Ff.
Intensity of the effect of machining parameters on cutting force drops in the direction of
f ! ap ! vc. It was established that details of chatter formation in different cutting
conditions can be evaluated on the basis of changes in cutting force components vs.
machining time. Basing on the analysis of chatter frequency and amplitude it can be
inferred that self-induced chatter does not occur in the assumed range of parameters
Forces and Process Dynamics in Profiling of AlCu4MgSi Aluminium Alloy 405
and cutting conditions- only parametric chatter is present due to constant changes in the
stiffness of machine-tool-workpiece system during machining.
References
1. Oczoś, K.E., Kawalec, A.: Kształtowanie metali lekkich. PWN, Warszawa (2012)
2. Songmene, V., Khettabi, R., Zaghbani, I., Kouam, J.A.D.: Machining and machinability of
aluminum alloys. In: Tibor, K. (ed.) Aluminium Alloys, Theory and Applications, Canada
(2011)
3. Fukui, H., Okida, J., Omori, N., Moriguchi, H., Tsuda, K.: Cutting performance of DLC
coated tools in dry machining aluminum alloys. Surf. Coat. Technol. 187(1), 70–76 (2004)
4. Sreejith, P.S.: Machining of 6061 aluminium alloy with MQL, dry and flooded lubricant
conditions. Mater. Lett. 62(2), 276–278 (2008)
5. Siddesh Kumar, N.G., Shiva Shankar, G.S., Ganesh, M.N., Vibudha, L.K.: Experimental
investigations to study the cutting force and surface roughness during turning of aluminium
metal matrix hybrid composites. Mater. Today: Proc. 4, 9371–9374 (2017)
6. Wang, B., Liu, Z., Song, Q., Wan, Y., Shi, Z.: Proper selection of cutting parameters and
cutting tool angle to lower the specific cutting energy during high speed machining of 7050-
T7451 aluminum alloy. J. Clean. Prod. 129, 292–304 (2016)
7. Adamski, W.: Wybrane kierunki zwiększania wydajności procesów skrawania. Mechanik 5–
6, 540–546 (2009)
8. Obróbka skrawaniem stopów aluminium i magnezu. Praca zbiorowa. In: Kuczmaszewski, J.,
Zaleski, K. (eds.) Politechnika Lubelska, Lublin (2015)
9. Kishawy, H.A., Dumitrescu, M., Ng, E.G., Elbestawi, M.A.: Effect of coolant strategy on
tool performance, chip morphology and surface quality during high-speed machining of
A356 aluminum alloy. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf 45(2), 219–227 (2005)
10. Taavitsainen, V.M.T.: Experimental optimization and response surfaces. In: Varmuza, K.
(ed.) Chemometrics in Practical Applications, pp. 91–138. In Tech, Rijeka (2012)
11. Sharma, A.K., Tiwari, A.K., Dixit, A.R.: Effects of minimum quantity lubrication (MQL) in
machining processes using conventional and nanofluid based cutting fluids: a comprehensive
review. J. Clean. Prod. 127, 1–18 (2016)
12. Stachurski, W., Sawicki, J., Wójcik, R., Nadolny, K.: Influence of application of hybrid
MQL-CCA method of applying coolant during hob cutter sharpening on cutting blade
surface condition. J. Clean. Prod. 171, 892–910 (2018)
13. Chetan, B.C., Ghosh, S., Rao, P.V.: Wear behavior of PVD TiN coated carbide inserts
during machining of Nimonic 90 and Ti6Al4 V superalloys under dry and MQL conditions.
Ceram. Int. 42(13), 14873–14885 (2016)
14. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Analysis of contact phenomena
and heat exchange in the cutting zone under minimum quantity cooling lubrication
conditions. Arab. J. Sci. Eng. 41(2), 661–668 (2016)
15. Maruda, R.W., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M., Lukianowicz, C., Stoic, A.: Effect of anti-wear
additive on cutting tool and surface layer of workpiece state under MQCL conditions. Teh.
Vjesn. - Tech. Gaz. 22(5), 1219–1223 (2015)
16. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Wojciechowski, S., Zak, K., Habrat, W., Nieslony, P.:
Effects of extreme pressure and anti-wear additives on surface topography and tool wear
during MQCL turning of AISI 1045 steel. J. Mech. Sci. Technol. 32(4), 1585–1591 (2018)
17. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Improving the efficiency of
running – in for a bronze – stainless steel friction pair. J. Frict. Wear 36(6), 548–553 (2015)
406 E. Feldshtein and P. Nieslony
18. Maruda, R.W., Feldshtein, E., Legutko, S., Krolczyk, G.M.: Research emulsion mist
generation in the conditions of minimum quantity cooling lubrication (MQCL). Teh. Vjesn. -
Tech. Gaz. 22(5), 1213–1218 (2015)
19. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Michalski, M., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S.: Structural
and microhardness changes after turning of the AISI 1045 steel for minimum quantity
cooling lubrication. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 26(1), 431–438 (2017)
20. Krolczyk, G.M., Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, J.B., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S., Legutko,
S.: Parametric and nonparametric description of the surface topography in the dry and
MQCL cutting conditions. Measurement 121, 225–239 (2018)
A Polyurethane/Carbon Black Composite
Absorber for Low Frequency Waves
1 Introduction
Polymer composites (PC); specially electrically conductive polymeric types are widely
using in different industries due to their plastic nature. With conducting fillers such
carbon fibers and carbon black (CB), PCs can be used as electrical conductors or for
medium for heat transfer. Their plastic nature gives the advantage of easy preparations
in various forms and low cost for the manufacturing process. to create different forms
of products by using institutional techniques hereby decreases costs [1].
Electrostatic coating materials are often used in the coating of metal and non-metal
surfaces as well as thermosetting materials. They become more preferred than wet-
liquid coating materials because they do not contain solvent chemicals in their struc-
ture. In addition to being environmentally friendly due to their solvent content, they
have the ability to form a film layer with the desired fineness on the surface of the
material to be coated. According to the type of resin and hardener used, those coating
materials can be named such as epoxy-polyester and polyurethane (PU) [2].
Usage of organic composites for coating of various material is not new, but we have
studies about the low frequency wave absorbance of Polyurethane/Carbon Black
(PU/CB) composites are rare in literature. This study proposes a PU/CB coating and
measures the absorbance of the PU/CB coated surface using a practical system consist
of a square wave generator, light source (laser) and a photodetector. For performance
analyses of the material, amplitude-modulated signals from the generator are super-
imposed on laser beams and reflections are measured.
The following sections of the paper are organized as follow. In Sect. 2, charac-
teristics of PU/CB coating (including the contact angle measurement) are presented
with the experimental setup (measurement system). In Sect. 3, results from the
experimental application are illustrated. And finally, in Sect. 4 conclusions of the study
are presented briefly.
All reagents in the current experiments were of technical grade and were used as
received without further treatment.
Fig. 1. Images of water, glycerol and paraffin oil droplet for 0.3 wt.
A Polyurethane/Carbon Black Composite Absorber for Low Frequency Waves 409
The angle between the optical system axis and the direction perpendicular to the
sample surface was fixed at 45°. This angle; while remaining close to normal, will
avoid measuring a reflected modulated flux from the optical system, which is not
perfectly transparent.
The square wave with 1 kHz shown in Fig. 3 is used when the laser light is mod-
ulated. The value of the alternative signal equal to the direct signal is called the effective
(root mean square-rms) value and calculated as follow for both laser beams [5];
410 M. Yagimli et al.
sffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
Z
1 T 2
Urms ¼ U dt ð1Þ
T 0
The amount of conductivity is measured by the four-point probe technique. The four-
point probe technique has been a widespread method for electrical characterization of
thin films for many years [6]. A thin film sheet resistivity measurement with a collinear
symmetry was performed [7]. Figure 4 illustrates schematic of collinear four-point
probe set-up for measurement. In the figure S is the probe spacing, V is the voltage
across the sample, I is current in the sample and t is the film thickness. The amount of
conductivity by the four-point probe technique was measured as 5.10−4 Siemens (S) on
the aluminum surface and 4.76.10−5 S on the 0.1 wt% surface. Conductivity is written
as resistance in Tables 2 and 3.
Table 2. Voltage of the input and reflected wave from the noncoated surface.
Materials Input wave (mV) Output (Reflected) Surface resistance (kX)
wave (mV)
Red laser Green laser Red laser Green laser
Aluminum surface 2536 3360 164.20 349 2
Table 3. Voltage of the input and reflected wave from the coated surface.
Coated Input wave (mV) Output Surface Surface energy
surface (Reflected) wave resistance (kX) (mJ/m2)
(mV)
Red Green Red Green
laser laser laser laser
0.1 wt% 2445 11800 46.26 15 21 26.67
0.2 wt% 2445 11800 50 18.5 18 24
0.3 wt% 2445 11800 54.32 20 17 20.94
0.4 wt% 2445 11800 62.74 23 16 20.64
3 Results
Table 2 illustrates voltage values of the input and reflected wave and surface resistance
in the aluminum surface without coating. 2536 mV square wave transmitted to the
aluminum surface with a red laser has been measured as 164 mV reflected wave.
Similarly, 3360 mV square wave transmitted with green laser has been measured as
349 mV reflected wave. In this process the aluminum surface resistance was measured
as 2 kX.
Table 3 illustrates voltage values of the input and reflected wave and surface
resistance of the coated surfaces. The surface with 0.1 wt% transmitted with 2445 mV
square wave with red laser has been obtained 46.26 mV reflected wave. In the same
way, a green laser sent with a square wave of 11800 mV has been measured as 15 mV
reflected wave. The surface resistance was measured as 21 kX.
4 Conclusion
This study examines the low frequency wave absorbance of a proposed PU/CB
composite coating with different pigment levels. Experiments using amplitude-
modulated signals (which were superimposed separately on red and green laser
beams) showed that CB pigments dramatically increased the amount of low frequency
wave absorbance of the coated surface (see Tables 2 and 3). Table 3 also illustrated
that the surface resistance is proportional to surface energy (when conductivity
increases, the surface energy decreases). Further researches can be made by changing
pigment levels in the mixture and the heat drying process.
412 M. Yagimli et al.
References
1. Appaji, V.: Preparation and properties of polyurethane-carbon black-graphite hybrid
composites for electrically conductive applications. M.S. Thesis, University of Massachusetts
Lowell, MA, USA (2008)
2. Kısmet, Y.: Effects of Hydrolyzed electrostatic powder coating wastes on fluidity and density
of polyolefins. Sigma J. Eng. Natl. Sci. 33, 377–383 (2015)
3. Laser Diode Datasheet. http://www.alldatasheet.com/datasheet-pdf/pdf/536908/ROITHNER/
ADL-65075TA2.html. Accessed 25 Apr 2018
4. BPW20RFPhotodiode Datasheet. http://www.vishay.com/docs/81570/bpw20rf.pdf. Accessed
25 Apr 2018
5. Yağımlı, M., Akar, F.: Alternatif Akım Devreleri & Problem Çözümleri, 6. Edt., BETA
(2015). ISBN 978-605-377-998-8
6. Agumbo, O.J.: Design and Fabrication of a Simple Four Point Probe System for Electrical
Characterization of a Thin Films, Thesis MS, Kenyatta University (2010)
7. Bautista, K.: Thin Film Deposition, 2nd edn., pp. 67–120. University of Texas at Dallas, Erik
Jonsson School of Engineering, Richardson (2004)
The Effect of Additional Shielding Gas
on Properties and Erosion Resistance of High
Chromium Hardfacing
Abstract. The wear-resistant layers of the chromium cast iron structure can be
made by traditional casting methods as well as by the use of welding methods.
The use of hardfacing allows for the creation of a protective layer on existing
elements, often in the place of their use. Especially the use of hardfacing using
self-shielding core wires allows obtaining layers with the desired properties. The
paper presents the results of research on high-chromium hardfacings made in
self-protective technology as well as using shielding gas. It was noted that the
addition of shielding gas has a positive effect on the stability of the surfacing
process and on the appearance of hardfaced surfaces. The hardness tests and
erosive wear tests carried out also indicate a positive effect of shielding gas on
the properties of hardfacings.
1 Introduction
The materials with structure of cast chromium iron are widely used in different man-
ufacturing processes, in which high wear resistance and low manufacturing cost are
required. The foundry technologies give a good possibility to produce cast chromium
irons massive elements with modification of their properties by heat treatment and
changes in chemical composition, especially chromium to carbon ratio [1] but with
limitation of this ratio to the 10:1 [2] and addition of titanium [3] and boron [4].
Advancement in welding technologies allows to deposit the surface with similar
structure and chemical composition as well known foundry technologies. One of the
interesting welding technology for hardfacing is using self shielded cored wires that
can be used for obtaining much proper structures of the joints [5]. This technology
gives chance to create surface with desirable structures with implementation of different
welding technologies [6, 7], in which the determination of the most important
parameters is the crucial point of efficiency in processing [8] and quality and quantity
of carbides in the structure [9]. This kind of hardfacing presents greater productivity
than coated electrodes and greater flexibility than with a submerged arc and in addition
to this, lower thermal input, less distortions, and less thermally affected zone. The self-
shielded flux cored arc welding process aggregates the main advantages of the GMAW
such as high values of deposition rate, yield, and the work factor of the welder,
enabling high productivity and high quality weld to be obtained [10, 11]. It is possible
to achieve the better erosion rate [12] and corrosion resistance [13] by using cored
wires with nano-additives. This seems to be better solution than implementation the
elements as the boron which increases carbide volume fraction but decreases corrosion
resistance [4].
The method of self-shielded flux-cored wire welding involves melting flux-cored
wire and metal substrates from the heat of an electric arc burning between the metal
wire tube, comprising a core powder, and the weld object. The components of the core
wire provide gas and metal vapour deposition insulating zone than atmosphere. During
the melting of the core is also generated slag. It covers a thin layer of liquid metal
droplets transferred from the wire to the molten weld pool. The slag that is formed
during the melting process is primarily responsible for protecting the welding arc and
molten weld pool from the atmosphere. The problem is that during self-shielding
process the flow of gas is not stable and in some cases produce a lot of spatter and
porosity. Determination of the gas flow rate, as well as changes in the nozzle settings
are considered in work [14] in which it was shown that good quality of the welds can
be achieved in proper conditions of the gas flow rate.
The main objective of the study was to investigate the effect of addition shielding
gases on the properties of the obtained wear resistant plates.
2 Experimental Procedure
Steel grade S355JR for general purpose was selected as parent material for hardfacing
layers. The thickens of deposited steel plate was 30 mm. Self shielded cored wire with
a diameter of 1.2 mm and the chemical composition specified by the manufacturer in
Table 1 was selected for hardfacing. The deposition process was carried out on using a
Cloos Quinto Profi welding source.
The process of deposition was carried out in two variations, using the same base
process parameters given in Table 2, but in one case using external shielding gas. The
mixture of gases was 82% of argon and 18% of carbon dioxide.
The process of hardfacing was performed using device for automatic welding
PRO-DC 25. In both cases of hardfacing the 4 weave beads were applied with linear
speed 130 mm/min. Made in this way, the deposit has been subsequently tested with
metallographic optical microscope Olympus GX51 and hardness tests with Vickers
The Effect of Additional Shielding Gas 415
Welds made without additional shielding gas were marked with a rectangle and with
the letter A (Fig. 1). The remaining paddles marked with the letter B were made with
an additional shielding gas. The use of an additional shielding gas has allowed to
stability of welding arc and almost eliminate of spatter and porosity in the hardfacing.
The analyzed samples show significant differences in the structure of the obtained
deposits. In the case of the hardfacing sample marked as A (Figs. 2 and 3), there are
numerous needle-shaped primaryM7C3 carbides in the matrix comprised of eutectic
mixture of austenite (dark phase) and fine eutectic M7C3 carbides (white phase) [15].
The primary M7C3 needles grow predominantly along the heat flow direction in layer
deposits to depth about 500 lm. In the deepest part of the deposit it is observed mostly
hexagonal carbides. For the sample marked as B the structure close to surface is
dominated by eutectic mixture of carbides (Figs. 4 and 5). It is observed a few large
needle-shaped primary carbides compared to sample A. In both samples the structure of
deposits, close to the fusion line and base material is similar and consist mainly of
hexagonal carbides and numerous of fine eutectic particles. The hardness test shows
416 M. Gucwa et al.
that the differences in shape and type of carbides do not have significant impact on
obtained values. The average hardness of specimen A is 850 HV10 and specimen B is
882HV10. The maximum hardness 933 HV10 was measured for the sample B close to
the surface. In both investigated deposits the hardness close to the fusion line is on the
same level about 810820 HV10. The decreasing of hardness along the cross-section
of hardfacing is due to the dilution of base mild steel and weld metal. It is noted that
cold cracks occur in the deposits, which are stopped on the fusion line between deposit
and base material (Fig. 6). These cracks exist independently of the setted welding
parameters. Additional shielding gas has positive influence on the absence of spatter
and porosity in the deposit material. The additional gas made better stabilization of the
burning welding arc and increased temperature that gives better possibility to relief
gases of the welding pool. The second positive results of the additional shielding is the
lack of porosity on the surface. The transport of the molten material from the tip of the
wire is in the axis in the opposition to the process without it in which the droplet is
detached from the surface of the electrode in the random direction.
The results of erosive tests are shown in Table 3. The highest wear was measured
for sample A, made without the use of an additional shielding gas tested at an erosive
angle of 30°. The lowest measured wear was also observed for a sample made in the
same way, but tested at an angle of 45°. The weight loss at 45° erosive angle is 4 times
smaller than at 30°. The opposite situation was observed for samples made with
additional shielding gas. In this case, the lowest wear was measured at an erosive
impingement angle of 30°. However, the difference in wear resistance in this case does
The Effect of Additional Shielding Gas 417
Fig. 2. Structure of specimen A near surface, made without additional shielding gases.
Fig. 3. Structure of specimen A in the middle, made without additional shielding gases.
418 M. Gucwa et al.
Fig. 4. Structure of specimen B near surface, made with additional shielding gases.
Fig. 5. Structure of specimen B in the middle, made with additional shielding gases.
The Effect of Additional Shielding Gas 419
Fig. 6. Crack and porosity in specimen A, made without additional shielding gases.
not exceed 15%. This is due to the more homogeneous structure in the padding
obtained in the hardfacing process with an additional shielding gas. In addition, pads
made in this way are free from pores and gas bubbles, the presence of which can affect
the resistance to wear as was probably the case with the sample marked as A1.
4 Conclusions
References
1. Pokusová, M., Brúsilová, A., Šooš, Ľ., Berta, I.: Abrasion wear behavior of high-chromium
cast iron. Arch. Foundry Eng. 16, 69–74 (2016)
2. Tanga, X.H., Chunga, R., Panga, C.J., Li, D.Y., Hinckleyb, B., Dolmanb, K.: Microstructure
of high (45 wt.%) chromium cast irons and their resistances to wear and corrosion. Wear
271, 1426–1431 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2010.11.047
3. Kopyciński, D., Piasny, S., Kawalec, M., Madizhanova, A.: The Abrasive wear resistance of
chromium cast iron. Arch. Foundry Eng. 14, 63–66 (2014)
4. Lu, H., Li, T., Cui, J., Li, Q., Li, D.Y.: Improvement in erosion-corrosion resistance of high-
chromium cast irons by trace boron. Wear 376–377, 578–586 (2017). https://doi.org/10.
1016/j.wear.2017.02.014
5. Dumovic, M., Dunne, D.: Prediction of weld metal microstructure of self-shielded arc
hardfacing welds resistant to metal-to-metal wear. Weld. World 5, 831–837 (2014). https://
doi.org/10.1007/s40194-014-0162-7
6. Gucwa, M., Winczek, J.: The properties of high chromium hardfacings made with using
pulsed arc. Arch. Foundry Eng. 15, 37–40 (2015)
7. Gucwa, M., Winczek, J., Bęczkowski, R., Dośpiał, M.: Structure and properties of coatings
made with self shielded cored wire. Arch. Foundry Eng. 16, 39–42 (2016)
8. Bęczkowski, R.: Effect of cladding parameters on the hardness of bimetal plates. Metalurgija
56, 59–62 (2016)
9. Günther, K., Liefeith, J., Henckell, P., Ali, Y., Bergmann, J.P.: Influence of processing
conditions on the degradation kinetics of fused tungsten carbides in hardfacing. Int.
J. Refract Metal Hard Mater. 70, 224–231 (2018)
10. Liu, D., Liu, R., Wei, Y.: Effects of titanium additive on microstructure and wear
performance of iron-based slag-free self-shielded flux-cored wire. Surf. Coat. Technol. 207,
579–586 (2012)
11. Liu, D., Liu, R., Wei, Y., Ma, Y., Zhu, K.: Microstructure and wear properties of Fe–15Cr–
2.5Ti–2C–xB wt.% hardfacing alloys. Appl. Surf. Sci. 271, 253–259 (2013)
12. Gou, J., Wang, Y., Wang, Ch., Chu, R., Liu, S.: Effect of rare earth oxide nano-additives on
micro-mechanical properties and erosion behavior of Fe-Cr-C-B hardfacing alloys. J. Alloy.
Compd. 691, 800–810 (2017)
13. Gou, J., Wang, Y., Li, X., Zhou, F.: Effect of rare earth oxide nano-additives on the
corrosion behavior of Fe-based hardfacing alloys in acid, near-neutral and alkaline 3.5 wt.%
NaCl solutions. Appl. Surf. Sci. 431, 143–151 (2018)
14. Bitharasa, I., McPhersonb, N.A., McGhiec, W., Royc, D., Moorea, A.J.: Visualisation and
optimisation of shielding gas coverage during gas metal arc welding. J. Mater. Process.
Tech. 255, 451–462 (2018)
15. Correa, E.O., Alcântara, N.G., Valeriano, L.C., Barbedo, N.D., Chaves, R.R.: The effect of
microstructure on abrasive wear of a Fe–Cr–C–Nb hardfacing alloy deposited by the open
arc welding process. Surf. Coat. Technol. 276, 479–484 (2015)
Analysis of the Legal Risk
in the Scientific Experiment of the Machining
of Magnesium Alloys
Abstract. In the article, the legal risk of the researcher in the case of a scientific
experiment in the machining of magnesium alloys was determined. The use of
magnesium alloys in industry and identification of the problems associated with
machining were presented. The issues concerning legal liability in the experiment
and provisions ensuring a greater scope of legal protection for the researcher were
indicated and challenges in the machining of magnesium alloys were analyzed.
Moreover, the method to assess legal risk in experiments was proposed and its
application in the experiments was presented. The analysis confirmed the
applicability of the proposed method to the analysis of the legal risk.
1 Introduction
Magnesium alloys are widely used, among others, in the automotive [1] and aviation
industry [2]. One of the ways to reduce the fuel consumption of aircraft is an appli-
cation of lighter materials in aircraft construction. Magnesium, next to fiber compos-
ites, is seen as the primary candidate for substantial weight reduction [3]. Therefore,
there is a need to manufacture parts from magnesium alloys. One of the most com-
monly used manufacturing methods is machining. Increasing the efficiency of
machining is associated with scientific research and a need to conduct experiments.
The high strength-to-weight ratio, along with other unique properties, offered by
magnesium alloys, are overshadowed by their high surface reactivity. A lack of sta-
bility at increased temperatures is often associated with magnesium ignition and
burning when in contact with an open flame or another source of heat [3]. One result of
cutting is heat and its generation is associated with the risk of ignition. In particular, it
is dangerous to conduct experimental research due to the fact that the researcher
operates in uncharted areas of knowledge.
The risk of a fire during an experiment, depending on its effects, is associated with
the risk of legal liability. The aim of the research was to determine the legal risk to the
The rapid progress of modern technology determines the need to conduct research,
make experiments related to the unavoidable risk of negative effects not only in the
sense of failure of the attempt, but also specific material damage, and even dangers to
human life or health. This risk is sometimes huge. However, this is the price of
technical progress that cannot be avoided. The collision between the necessity of
conducting research experiments and the element of danger that is inevitably associated
with it is one of those situations which require new solutions outside of the framework
of traditional statutory structures under criminal law.
In the face of dynamic scientific development in the world, criminal law empha-
sizes the need to include the risk element in human activities, mainly in the scientific
and technical sphere. Development in various areas of life, in particular in the economy
and industry, requires conducting experiments and scientific research, and thus it is
necessary to clearly indicate that the persons carrying them will not be prosecuted [4].
Technical development carries both, a risk in the form of innovative risk, without
which there is no progress, as well as a form of risk associated with the operation of
new machines, the use of innovative technologies and any inventions and improve-
ments. The problem is not easy, on the one hand, it is necessary to protect human life,
health, social and private property, and on the other - you must constantly expose these
goods to danger if you want to keep up with the progress of technology. In this
situation, any innovative activity that creates new social values can lead to a point of
risk of criminal responsibility.
An act taken as part of the risk of innovation, which under the conditions of normal
production activities could be subject to legal liability, may be subject to the exclusion
of unlawfulness. Such a justification concerns the taking of risky activities that are a
threat to legal goods [5]. The diagram, shown in Fig. 1, presents the rules for exclusion
of legal liability in the case of experiments. Although the presented principals are based
on the Polish criminal code, they may also be applied to other legal systems, even if the
specific legal provisions do not regulate these issues. Among the examples of the legal
responsibility of workers for production activities, the responsibility of the manager for
the occupational health and safety (OHS) system and the responsibility of workers for
unintentional human exposure to injury or loss of life can be distinguished. Moreover,
it can be the responsibility for unintentional exposure to a fire risk or the causing of a
fire that threatens many people.
Analysis of the Legal Risk in the Scientific Experiment 423
The application of the exclusion of legal liability in accordance with the principle of
permitted risk may be related to the unpredictable course of the experimental work that
was not planned. In other words, it includes events resulting from failure to experiment,
despite the preservation of careful experimentation. There is no legal responsibility for
experimental activities if the expected benefit is cognitive, the goal of the experiment is
expected due to the current state of knowledge and the conditions of the experiment are
justified due to the current state of knowledge [6].
To show the practical effect of regulations to protect the researchers, a case study of
the experiment of magnesium alloy machining with the legal risk analysis will be
presented. Analysis of the legal risk is one of the most important points of risk
management [7].
424 D. Habrat et al.
In industry, magnesium alloy machining can be both efficient and safe but it is nec-
essary to know the ranges of acceptable parameters. This is currently possible because
scientific research also takes into account factors related to tests into the time to ignition
of chips from magnesium alloys [8]. There are industry guidelines for activities with
magnesium and its alloys taking into account, among others, analysis of the sources of
ignition and the procedure in case of fire [9].
Magnesium alloys ignite at temperatures even below the melting point. This is
especially dangerous if the material’s volume is small like for chips after finish
machining. Friemuth et al. [10] analysed chip temperature and the danger of chip
ignition. These studies have shown that cutting tools coated with polycrystalline dia-
mond presented a superior behavior in dry machining of magnesium alloys compared
to uncoated or TiN-coated cemented tools. Low machining forces reduce the chip
temperature and thus the danger of chip ignition. Carou et al. [11] evaluated the
likelihood of risk ignition due to the size of the chips, finding no relation with the type
of workpieces machined. For the machining process, continuous and long chips should
be avoided, obtaining segmented chips is preferred. On the contrary, short chips can be
a cause of ignition if their size is small and the temperature reached is high. In addition,
it should be considered that the higher part of the heat generated is evacuated by the
chips. Therefore, chip morphology is of great importance in magnesium machining.
Zhao et al. investigated the ignition conditions of magnesium alloy chips during
high-speed dry machining. Based on this research, it could be concluded that the macro
morphologies of chips can be characterized into a powdered chip, tubular helical chip,
acicular helical chip, and long belt chip, which correspond to the different ignition
conditions. The powdered chips and acicular spiral chips are easily ignited. These
results may be used to analyze the cutting process and prevent the chip ignition in dry
machining of magnesium alloys. Hou et al. [12] investigated the relationship between
the cutting parameters and the ignition conditions of chips during milling of selected
magnesium alloys. The probability of ignition of magnesium alloy chips first increases
and then decreases with the increase in cutting speed. Therefore, the fire hazard can be
avoided by selecting suitable cutting parameters and the depth of cut should be greater
than the critical value.
Kuczmaszewski et al. [13] investigated the ignition temperature after high-speed
dry milling of magnesium alloys. It was concluded, that the main parameter deter-
mining safety of magnesium alloy machining is time to ignition. Moreover, Zagórski
and Kuczmaszewski [14] showed that the ignition of magnesium alloy chips is pre-
ceded by strong thermal deformation of the chip.
This analysis shows that the problem of risk in machining magnesium alloys is
significant and connects with important research in this field.
Analysis of the Legal Risk in the Scientific Experiment 425
Conducting scientific experiments is associated with the risk of their failure due to the
failure to achieve the assumed research goals. In addition, because the experiments
involve the study of new materials, testing of new technologies, etc., various types of
hazards may affect the experimentalists. Therefore, proper preparation of tests is nec-
essary to ensure the safety of conducting experiments. To protect people and equip-
ment, appropriate safety measures should be implemented based on the requirements of
legal regulations and the available knowledge. If the experiment is not properly pre-
pared and the experimenters are not properly protected, there may appear an occupa-
tional risk as well as a legal risk.
In literature, different methods which can be used to assess the occupational risk
such as HAZOP [15, 16], PHA [17], MORT [18], FMEA [19], ISRS [20], Event tree
analysis [21, 22] and many others [23] are presented. With the methods for occupa-
tional risk analysis, what is the source of the hazard, what can happen, what is the
probability of the certain event, how sever might be the consequences, how many
people are at risk, how effective are the protections applied etc., is analyzed. Addi-
tionally, in many publications it is explained how to perform such analysis. Such
analyzes are applied at every new workplace and when an important change is intro-
duced in an existing workstation which may result in new risks.
At the same time, in the literature there are no methods presented which were
applied to assess the risk of legal responsibility concerning threats, which may appear
during the work, although the law regulations present clearly define what the
responsibilities of employers and employees are concerning safety protection.
However, if we are talking about conducting scientific experiments, the legal
provisions are slightly different, as it was presented in the earlier part of this work.
Nevertheless, also in relation to scientific experiments the risk of legal liability has not
been analyzed before. Therefore, in this work, a proposal of a method which can be
used to assess risk of legal liability is presented and then applied for experiments in
which magnesium alloys are treated.
The proposed method doesn’t analyze the probability of legal liability but identifies
situations in which legal liability will arise.
In magnesium alloys machining, the most serious threat is self-ignition. Therefore,
an experiment in which magnesium alloys are used should be adequately prepared and
then monitored to ensure that: (1) no self-ignition will occur, (2) if self-ignition occurs
the fire will burn out within a short time, (3) devices and people will be protected from
the fire, (4) the fire does not spread. To ensure the above mentioned, adequate actions
should be undertaken at different steps of experiment planning and realization.
Therefore, in the proposed method the following steps of the analyses are
recommended:
1. Identification of activities necessary to prepare and carry out the experiment.
2. Identification of potential mistakes which can be made.
3. Identification of causes of the mistakes.
4. Identification of levels of the legal responsibility risk.
5. Identification of a responsible person.
426 D. Habrat et al.
Table 1. Risk of legal liability in scientific experiments concerning planning and realization of
magnesium alloys machining - Stage 1: Experiment definition; Legal responsibility: R2;
Responsible: RR.
No Step of the process Potential mistake Cause
1. Problem definition Adoption of the problem to be analyzed, Lack of
which should be solved in specific knowledge
conditions that the laboratory cannot
provide
2. Development of The choice of the machine on which
machining technology machining should not be carried out
3. Choosing the tools The choice of the tools which should not
be applied
4. Choosing the machining The parameters should not be applied due
parameters to the risk of ignition
5. Determining the Wrong selection of the experiment
conditions for conducting conditions
the experiment
Table 2. Risk of legal liability in scientific experiments concerning planning and realization of
magnesium alloys machining - Stage 2: Experiment preparation; Legal responsibility: R1;
Responsible: ER.
No Step of the process Potential mistake Cause
1. Development of instructions for Lack of instructions or Negligence or
conducting the experiment incorrectly prepared insufficient
instructions analysis of state of
2. Development of safety Lack of instructions or knowledge
instructions incorrectly prepared
instructions
3. Development of methods for Lack of methods for
monitoring the experiment monitoring the experiment
parameters parameters
4. Determination of actions to be Lack of established actions
taken in case of a fire hazard or incorrectly determined
actions
5. Operator training Lack of training or Negligence
improper training
6. Medical examination of the Lack of current medical
operator examination
7. Providing measures in the event Lack of measures or Negligence or
of fire insufficient measures insufficient
8. Work stand organization Improper organization of analysis of state of
work stand (e.g. not knowledge
removing flammable
materials)
9. Organization of a workstation Failure to provide Negligence
with increased risk resulting substitute protection
from the conditions of measures
conducting the experiment (e.g.
no safety covers, no safety
switches)
• Large fire due to self-ignition of a magnesium alloy and leaving a large amount of
chips in the machine-tool space.
The first stage is very important because at this stage the current state of knowledge
is analyzed. In case of the experiment, unintentional human exposure to injury or loss
of life will not apply if the available knowledge did not allow to ensure safer working
conditions. The legal responsibility will be if the lack of safe conditions results from
negligence in the analysis of the current state of knowledge, which indicate how to
ensure safe conditions in similar experiments.
The second stage concerns the experiment preparation. In many cases, the exper-
iment requires special preparation of the workstation, which results from the accepted
conditions for conducting the experiment. This may be, for example, the need to
remove covers from machines or standard safety switches. However, in this situation,
428 D. Habrat et al.
Table 3. Risk of legal liability in scientific experiments concerning planning and realization of
magnesium alloys machining - Stage 3: Experiment realization.
No Step of the Potential Cause Legal Responsible
process mistake responsibility
1. Start the Failure to apply Failure to R1–R5 RR
experiment appropriate follow the
safeguards (e.g. instructions or
safety covers) safeguards
were
inadequate due
to lack of
knowledge
2. Monitoring No reaction to Negligence or R2–R5 RR
the process the improper insufficient
situation knowledge
initially due to wrong
identified (e.g. training or
wrong chip general lack of
size) or knowledge
unidentified
3. Taking Not taking Negligence or R1 ER
planned planned actions insufficient
actions knowledge
according to due to wrong
the training
experiment
instructions
(e.g.
removing
chips)
4. Taking Not taking Negligence, R1 ER
determined determined insufficient
actions in case actions knowledge,
of self- lack of
ignition measures or
insufficient
measures
other security measures should be provided to protect people and equipment. The
analysis of the state of knowledge can facilitate the preparation of research, but one
cannot neglect to ensure safety in the design of the experiment. Occupational health
and safety system should ensure safety. The system should be prepared for known
treats. If not, the employer will take the legal responsibility in case of an accident. The
employer will not take the responsibility only in cases of arising of unknown treats or
situations.
Analysis of the Legal Risk in the Scientific Experiment 429
Experiment realization depends on the researcher and on how well the experiment
and the experimenter have been prepared. He or she should follow the rules and
instructions. If the rules and instructions are inadequate because of lack of knowledge
we will deal with lack of legal liability. For example, the legal responsibility for
unintentional exposure or causing risk or injury will apply if the rules are not respected
due to wrong training or negligence.
5 Conclusions
The paper presents a method which can be used in legal risk analysis of experiments.
The law provides for special treatment of participants of experiments who have limited
knowledge because they are investigating the unknown. However, on the other hand, it
places special demands on ensuring occupational safety. If the potential negative effects
of the conducted experiments are not known, better protection is required. Only in a
situation where the consequences of the conducted experiment were unpredictable, we
will speak of unintentional action. However, when the adopted rules or developed
instructions of an experiment are not applied, then we already deal with negligence.
In future work, we would like to apply the proposed methodology to other kinds of
experiments to find weaknesses and strengths of the method and to propose
improvements if it will be necessary. Additionally, a study concerning Directives of the
European Union can be interesting in context of requirements concerning risk
assessment of conducting scientific experiments.
References
1. Kainer, K.U. (ed.): Magnesium Alloys and Their Applications. Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH &
Co. KGaA, Weinheim (2000)
2. Ostrovsky, L., Henn, Y.: Present state and future of magnesium application in aerospace
industry. In: International Conference “New Challenges Aeronautics”. In: ASTEC 2007,
pp. 1–5 (2007)
3. Czerwinski, F.: Controlling the ignition and flammability of magnesium for aerospace
applications. Corros. Sci. 86, 1–16 (2014)
4. Mozgawa, M. (ed.): Criminal law. The general part (In Polish: Prawo karne. Część ogólna),
Warszawa (2009)
5. Kubiak, R.: Justification of the allowed experiment in the light of collision theory of goods
and social profitability (In Polish: Kontratyp dozwolonego eksperymentu w świetle teorii
kolizji dóbr i opłacalności społecznej), Państwo i Prawo (2005)
6. Gałuszka, A.: The risk of innovation in the new penal code (In Polish: Ryzyko nowatorstwa
w nowym kodeksie karnym), Prokur. i Prawo, no. 2 (1998)
7. Sadgrove, K.: The Complete Guide to Business Risk Management. Routledge, London
(2016)
8. Zagórski, I., Kuczmaszewski, J.: Efektywność i bezpieczeństwo frezowania stopów
magnezu Effectiveness and safety during milling magnesium alloys. Politechnika Lubelska,
Lublin (2017)
9. BG-Regel: BGR 204 Umgang mit Magnesium (2005)
430 D. Habrat et al.
10. Friemuth, T., Winkler, J.: Machining of magnesium workpieces. Adv. Eng. Mater. 1, 183–
186 (1999)
11. Carou, D., Rubio, E.M., Lauro, C.H., Davim, J.P.: Experimental investigation on finish
intermittent turning of UNS M11917 magnesium alloy under dry machining. Int. J. Adv.
Manuf. Technol. 75, 1417–1429 (2014)
12. Hou, J.Z., Zhou, W., Zhao, N.: Methods for prevention of ignition during machining of
magnesium alloys. Key Eng. Mater. 447–448, 150–154 (2010)
13. Kuczmaszewski, J., Zagórski, I., Dziubinska, A.: Investigation of ignition temperature, time
to ignition and chip morphology after the high-speed dry milling of magnesium alloys. Aircr.
Eng. Aerosp. Technol. 88, 389–396 (2016)
14. Zagórski, I., Kuczmaszewski, J.: Study of chip ignition and chip morphology after milling of
magnesium alloys. Adv. Sci. Technol. Res. J. 10, 101–108 (2016)
15. Khan, F.I., Abassi, S.A.: TOPHAZOP: a knowledge-based software tool for conducting
HAZOP in a rapid, efficient yet inexpensive manner. J. Loss Prev. Process Ind. 10(5–6),
333–343 (1997)
16. Venkatasubramanian, V., et al.: Intelligent systems for HAZOP analysis of complex process
plants. Comput. Chem. Eng. 24, 2291–2302 (2000)
17. Brereton, S., McLouth, L., Odell, B., Singh, M., Tobin, M., Trent, M., Yatabe, J.: Overview
of the preliminary safety analysis of the national ignition facilitiy. J. Fusion Energy 16(1/2),
85–94 (1997)
18. Hammer, W., Price, D.: Occupational Safety Management and Engineering, 5th edn.
Prentice Hall, New Jersey (2001)
19. Sevcik, F.: Current and future concepts in FMEA. In: Proceedings – Annual Reliability and
Maintainability Symposium, Philadelphia, PA, USA, pp. 414–421 (1981)
20. Kjellen, U.: Prevention of Accidents through Experience Feedback. CRC Press, London and
New York (2000)
21. Aven, T.: Foundations of Risk Analysis. Wiley, Chichester (2003)
22. Cooper, D.F., Grey, S., Raymond, G., Walker, P.: Project Risk Management Guidelines:
Managing Risk in Large Projects and Complex Procurements. Wiley, Chichester (2004)
23. Lawley, H.G.: Operability studies and hazard analysis. Chem. Eng. Prog. Am. Inst. Chem.
Eng. 4, 45–56 (1974)
Prediction of Tensile Failure Load
for Maraging Steel Weldment by Acoustic
Emission Technique
List of Abbreviations
AE - Acoustic Emission
UT - Ultrasonic Testing
AET - Acoustic Emission Testing
LEFM - Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics
EDM - Electric Discharge Machining
GTAW - Gas Tungsten Arc Welding
FOS - Factor of Safety
NDE - Non Destructive Engineering
NDT - Non Destructive Testing
SAE - Society for Automobile Engineers
AMS - Aerospace Material Specifications
PAC - Physical Acoustics Corporation
TIG - Tungsten Inert Gas (welding)
HAZ - Heat Affected Zone
HRC - Rockwell Hardness
PZT - Lead-Zirconate Titanate
FL - Failure Load
1 Introduction
Maraging steel has increasingly found its place in manufacturing of the pressurised
chambers of launch vehicles and missiles as it exhibits good weldablity and strength
thereby offering high payload and range capabilities [1]. Predominantly the fabrication
of rocket motor casings is achieved by GTAW welding process and hence becomes the
obvious weak link during failure. Moreover, the presence of defects induced by
welding process catalyzes failure. In-spite of the most stringent Non-Destructive
Testing and inspection in place, aerospace industry has envisaged catastrophic failures
and breakdowns [2]. Nevertheless, optimization of welding parameters leads to higher
weld efficiency. Similarly usage of advaced welding methods viz. laser welding have
yeilded in better weldments [3]. Any manufacturing or production process induces
defects and a 100% defect free component is near uneconomical. Hence an under-
standing of the potential of the available flaws to cause a failure is to be ascertained.
Many of these flaws cannot often be detected with traditional NDT techniques. Non
destructive techniques in weld joint area are commonly used to control and diagnostic
of welding process. Non destructive techniques try to ensure that the welds are free of
unaccetable defects [4].
Prediction of Tensile Failure Load 433
Acoustic emission (AE) technique is a fast maturing NDT tool ideally suited for
real time monitoring of active defects [5]. The AE technique identifies defects and
discontinuities in terms of AE parameters. Most of the Acoustic emission sources can
be distinguished by their acoustic emission signature [6]. The structural Integrity of any
component can be quantified by way of its residual/safe life which in-turn demands the
estimation/prediction of the component’s failure/rupture load. The application of AE
testing as an effective tool for the evaluation of structural integrity assessment needs a
lot of acoustic data generation for various materials in different failure modes [7, 8].
Acoustic emission signal analysis quantifies flaw growth activity in a structure as it
is loaded through descriptive signal parameters such as amplitude, energy and duration,
provide a measure of the active failure mechanism present during loading [9]. The
presence of various failure initiating mechanisms as recorded by the AE signal dis-
tributions, have been shown to persist throughout final phase of loading, making it
possible to predict the subsequent failure load from a lower level (less than 85% of the
expected ultimate load) proof test. The only limitation on the level of the proof loads is
that sufficient AE must be collected to statistically establish failure mechanism per-
centages. As a precursor for burst pressure prediction of rocket motor pressure
chambers, failure loads of maraging steel tensile specimens with various induced
defects are predicted using Acoustic Emission data [10].
Ultrasonic inspection process is being used typically for locating and defining
internal defects such as cracks, voids, laminations and other structural discontinuities
which may or may not be exposed to the surface. These inspections are usually carried
out according established standards. For weld inspection of Aerospace Grade systems,
ultrasonic Inspection Standard, SAE AMS 2632A is being followed [13]. For angle
beam inspection, E, F and G Notches are specified with E being most critical of these.
Specimens have been prepared with all possible notches using EDM technique. Notch
dimensions are as given below.
G Notch: 2.54 mm 1.27 mm with 0.25 mm width
F Notch: 1.27 mm 0.76 mm with 0.25 mm width
E Notch: 1.02 mm 0.51 mm with 0.25 mm width
Ultrasonic NDT evaluation of the defects were carried out using
Krautkramer® USN 45 UT system with 4 MHz, 45o, 60o and 70o angle beam probes.
By referring to the density function, it can be seen that the skewness of the dis-
tribution is controlled by the shape parameter, “b”. For example if b = 1;
1
expð hAo Þ
AAo
f ðxÞ ¼ ð2Þ
ðh Ao Þ
1.8
b=5
No. Of Hits / Frequency of Events – f(x)
1.6
b=0.5
1.4
1.2
0.8
b=1.5
0.6
0.4 b=1
0.2
0
30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Ao
Amplitude
Fig. 4. Plot indicating Weibull parameters and their effect on the shape of the distribution.
The ultimate stress prediction equation can be determined using multivariate sta-
tistical strength equation and is represented as follows:
FL ¼ C0 þ C1 Ao þ C2 b þ C3 h þ C4 Ao b þ C5 b h þ C6 Ao h ð3Þ
where Ci R:
It should be noted that by fixing Ao to a constant value, the three terms involving
this parameter will vanish and hence effect of this variable on prediction process will
almost become negligible. Hence the Failure load depends on either b, h or b * h.
Therefore the above equation can be conveniently re-written as
FL ¼ X0 þ X1 b þ X2 h þ X3 b h ð4Þ
where Xi R.
The specimen-wise details giving UT echo, type of failure and failure load is presented
in Table 1 for correlation. The UT Reference value is set as SAE AMS G-Notch
showing up with 100% value on CRT screen.
It can be seen that the notch with the highest UT echo (i.e. 125% G Notch) has
failed at the lowest load. But interestingly, Specimen 17 in-spite of having a 30% G
438 G. S. Wuriti et al.
Notch (i.e. equivalent to F Notch) has not shown substantial reduction in failure load,
there by indicating that the failure is not by fracture but by yielding. The specimens that
failed from Heat Affected Zone have exhibited the maximum failure load. There has
also been failure in the weldment indicating presence of micro defects in the
weldments.
The Weibull parameters arrived from the AE amplitude distributions for all the
specimens are tabulated in Table 2. The data used in the analysis were collected at a
stress state which corresponded to 85% of the expected tensile failure load. The
threshold value, “Ao”, was set to 40 dB.
Tensile Failure load versus Weibull parameters b and h are given in Figs. 5 and 6.
Additionally the failure load is also plotted against the value “b * h” for extended
interpretation (see Fig. 7).
It can be seen that the parameter “b” and the cross product term “b * h” appear to be
linearly correlated with the tensile failure load, while “h” shows no correlation with the
tensile failure load. This is because “h” is a measure of the mean amplitude of the AE
signal and is related to variations in the brittleness or ductility of material which is
attributed to changes in metallurgical behaviour.
Table 3 provides a comparison of the predicted and actual values of failure loads.
The results indicate that there is better correlation between the Weibull parameters and
the failure load. The average prediction capability of the proposed model is well within
5–6% in most of the cases excepting Specimen 10 (Notch Failure) and Specimen 01
(Weldment Failure) where the % error has been close to 9%. By and large, the
Prediction of Tensile Failure Load 439
Fig. 5. “b” Value vs failure load Fig. 6. “h” Value vs failure load
prediction error pertaining to HAZ failure has been over and above 15% thereby
rendering this model in-effective for HAZ type failure. Nevertheless, HAZ failures are
encountered when the weldments are of superior quality and hence HAZ type data
needs a different approach.
440 G. S. Wuriti et al.
4 Conclusions
• Failure load was predicted with the Acoustic Emission Data acquired till a stress
state which corresponded to 85% of the expected tensile failure load individual
specimens.
• The average prediction capability of the proposed model is well within 5–6% in
most of the cases.
• The capability of the model to predict failure load improved with number of
samples tested.
• The probabilistic approach of correlating acoustic emission data has yielded a
quantitative measure by way of failure load prediction. The same shall be highly
useful in structural integrity assessment of larger structures viz. rocket motor
casings.
Acknowledgements. Authors are thankful to the Director General, Missiles and Strategic
Systems Defence Research & Development Organization (DRDO), New Delhi and Director,
Indian Institute of Technology (ISM) Dhanbad for extending full support in carrying out the
above research and for giving permission to publish the work.
References
1. Yamamoti, S., Tsupikawa, T., Nakaro, M., Veyana, H.: Acoustic emission testing of
pressure vessels made of 2¼ Cr – 1 Mo steel, Non-Destructive Examination in Relation to
Structural Integrity, pp. 19–39 (1980)
2. Chelladurai, T., et al.: Acoustic emission technique – an effective tool for the integrity
evaluation of M250 maraging steel aerospace pressure chambers. In: Trends in NDE Science
and Technology: Proceedings of the 14th WCNDT, 8–13 December 1996, vol. 4,
pp. 2409–2412 (1996)
3. Kumar, P., Saw, K., Kumar, U., et al.: Effect of laser power and welding speed on
microstructure and mechanical properties of fibre laser welded Inconel 617 thin sheet.
J. Braz. Soc. Mech. Sci. Eng. 39, 4579–4588 (2017)
4. Krolczyk, J.B., et al.: Topographic inspection as a method of weld joint diagnostic. Teh.
Vjesn. 23(1), 301–306 (2016)
5. Miller, R.K., McIntire, P. (eds.): Nondestructive Testing Handbook: Acoustic Emission
Testing, vol. 5, 2nd edn. American Society for Nondestructive Testing, Columbus (1987)
6. Hay, D.R., Chan, R.W.Y., Sharp, D., Siddiqui, K.J.: Classification of acoustic emission
signals from deformation mechanisms in aluminum alloys. J. Acoust. Emiss. 3(3), 118–129
(1984)
7. Pollock, A.A.: Acoustic emission amplitude distributions. Int. Adv. Nondestr. Test. 7,
215–239 (1981)
8. Gross, N.O., Loushin, L.L., Thompson, J.L.: Acoustic emission testing of pressure vessels
for petroleum refiners and chemical plants. In: ASTM STP, vol. 505, pp. 270–296 (1972)
9. Subba Rao, V. et al.: Analysis of acoustic emission data obtained during pressure testing of
M250 maraging steel rocket motor cases. In: Trends in NDE Science and Technology:
Proceeding of the 14th World Conference on NDT, vol. 4, pp. 2427–2450 (1996)
10. Chelladurai, T., et al.: Acoustic emission response of 18% Ni maraging steel weldment with
inserted cracks of varying depth to thickness ratio. J. Mater. Eval. 53, 742–746 (1995)
442 G. S. Wuriti et al.
11. Krolczyk, G.M., Nieslony, P., Krolczyk, J.B., Samardzic, I., Legutko, S., Hloch, S.:
Influence of argon pollution on the weld surface morphology. Measurement 70, 203–213
(2015)
12. Properties and Selection: Irons, Steels and High performance Alloys. ASM Handbook,
vol. 1 (1990)
13. Inspection, Ultrasonic, of thin Materials 12.7 mm and under in cross-sectional thickness,
AMS 2632A, Aerospace Material Specification, SAE
14. Chelladurai, T., et al.: Micro structure studies on M 250 maraging steel weldment in relation
to acoustic emission. In: Trends in NDE Science and Technology: Proceedings of the 14th
WCNDT, vol. 4, pp. 2399–2403 (1996)
15. Walker, J. II.: Ultimate strength prediction of ASTM tensile specimens from acoustic
emission amplitude data. In: AIAA-92-0258, Proceedings of 30th Aerospace Sciences
Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV (1992)
16. Scheaffer, R.L., McClave, J.T.: Probability and Statistics -for Engineers, 2nd edn. Duxbury
Press, Boston (1986)
Measurements of the Friction Coefficient:
Discussion on the Results in the Framework
of the Time Series Analysis
1 Introduction
It is well known that dry friction represents the surface resistance to relative motion
between to body in contact. Frictional resistance force is proportional to the friction
coefficient and to the force perpendicular to the surface:
Ff ¼ lN ð1Þ
These factors are source of fluctuations of measured COF and they are difficult to
control and to eliminate.
The main novelty of this investigation is to consider the measured COF as time
series of data in order to achieve detailed information on the frictional force transitions
during its characteristic behavior [11].
2 Experimental Setup
3 Methods
Stationary residuals are obtained by removing the trend and the seasonal compo-
nent. As a stationary process this component has the property that the mean, variance
and autocorrelation do not change over time.
The analysis of time series, in this study, is carried out by using the software R, that
is a language and environment for statistical computing and graphics. This software
provides a wide variety of statistical and graphical techniques, and it is highly exten-
sible; it was used for investigating COF variation during a reciprocating test as sum of
trend s(t), seasonality S(t) and irregularity r(t) components. The presence of a peri-
odicity in the time series was confirmed by means of the autocorrelation coefficient
evaluation [20]:
Pnk
t¼1 ðxt xs1 Þðxt þ k xs2 Þ
qðk Þ ¼ qffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
Pnk qP ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi ð6Þ
t¼1 ð x t
x s1 Þ 2 nk
t¼1 ðxt þ k xs2 Þ2
Where xt is the measurement value in t, n is the number of periods, k is the lag and
Pnk Pnk
xt xt þ k
xs1 ¼ ; xs2 ¼
1 1
ð7Þ
nk nk
These two means were calculated by excluding the first and the last k periods,
respectively. The lag value is evaluated by using the maximum of the autocorrelation.
While the trend of the data was studied by using the regressive tools (i.e. moving
average data set).
The application of Ljung-Box (LB) and Box-Pierce (BP) tests allowed to verify if
the data have an autocorrelation. Both tests adopt the autocorrelation coefficient,
showed in Eq. (8), in order to evaluate the presence and the value of the periodicity:
Pnk
ðxt xÞðxt þ k xÞ
r ðk Þ ¼ t¼1
Pn ð8Þ
t¼1 ðxt xÞ 2
Measurements of the Friction Coefficient 447
Once the autocorrelation coefficient has been introduced the LB test can be per-
formed as follow:
Xh r 2 ðk Þ
v2LB ðhÞ ¼ nðn þ 2Þ k¼1 n k
ð9Þ
Where h varies according to the assumed lag and it is integer related to the number
of autocorrelation coefficients under test. If there is the absence of autocorrelation, the
LB statistics is distributed according to a random variable v2, with h degree of freedom.
As for the LB test, the BP test can be performed as follow:
Xh
v2BP ðhÞ ¼ n k¼1
r 2 ðk Þ ð10Þ
The two test differ only in the different weighting system adopted, but asymptot-
ically converge to the same distribution.
A measurement of model performance can be obtained by “coefficient of variation
of the error” (CVE). This model considers the variation from the reality in absolute
value. The mathematical expression is:
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
P ffi
n
ðet Þ2
t¼1
n1
CVE ¼ ð11Þ
A
where A is the mean value of the actual data in the considered range [19].
It is necessary to verify that the mean of the residual is not different from zero. In
this case the t-test was used:
e
t¼ pffiffiffi ð12Þ
s= n
where e is the mean of the error, s is the standard deviation and n is the amount of data.
It is important to check if the random errors have a normal distribution. The analysis
of QQ-normality and quantitative indices such skewness and kurtosis was carried out in
order to assess the normality of the distribution of the random errors. In particular, the
normal density plot was used as a graphical technique to assess if the random errors are
normally distributed. The data are plotted against a theoretical normal distribution in
such a way that the point should form an approximate straight line. Deviations from this
straight line indicate the deviation from normality. In addition, the statistical tests of
normality from Shapiro-Wilk and Jarque-Bera could be used.
The Shapiro-Wilk test (SW) is able to check the normality of a set of data even with
a small number of observations. The formula is:
Pn 2
ai x i
SW ¼ Pn i¼1
ð13Þ
i¼1 ðxi xÞ2
448 A. Ruggiero et al.
The Jarque-Bera test (JB) is often used for verify the hypothesis of normality in
econometric area. It is based on the measurements of the asymmetry and kurtosis of a
distribution. The null hypothesis of the test includes two conditions: the skewness and
the excess kurtosis should be zero. If this hypothesis is verified, the data can be con-
sidered as derived from a normal distribution, and the JB statistics tends to a chi-squared
distribution with two degrees of freedom. The test is based on the following expression:
" #
c23 ðc4 3Þ2
JB ¼ T þ ’ v22 ð14Þ
6 24
Four tests by using a sphere in steel AISI 52100 with diameter of 10 mm (Fig. 3) and a
circular flat made of steel X210 Cr12 with a diameter of 25 mm (Fig. 4) have been
carried out. The duration, the length of stroke and slip frequency were maintained
constant, while the closure loads were set equal to %N, 10 N, 17 N, 20 N. The tem-
perature and the humidity were controlled and set to environmental conditions
(20 ± 2 °C and 50 ± 5% RH) (Table 2).
Fig. 3. The ball using for the tests, assemble in the holder.
The Ljung-Box and Box-Pierce tests highlight the presence of autocorrelation in the
data. The test has been implemented in the “R” software framework and the results are
given in Table 3.
The small p-value in both tests indicates that the hypothesis of absence of auto-
correlation in the data must be rejected. The correlogram is reported in Fig. 5. The
highest autocorrelation value is obtained for a lag of 50 (Fig. 5). This value coincides
whit the “seasonality” and is fully in agreement with the consideration that the
reciprocating tribometer carries out a continuous alternative motion across the stroke
with a complete cycle (two strokes) of 100 points.
Measurements of the Friction Coefficient 449
Fig. 4. The circular flat before (left) and after (right) the test.
In the second time, the time series was divided in two parts: transient and steady
state (Fig. 6).
First the transient is analyzed. In Fig. 7 the time plot for different test cases with
different loads are reported. This time plot is obtained using the software Matlab®. It is
evident that increasing the load the transient ends earlier. A summary of the extension
time is reported in Table 4.
The new Time Series is stationary because we proved that the mean does not
depend on time and the auto-covariance function is independent on time for each lag.
Then, the residual was analyzed in order to verifying the normality of these data.
As example we considered two extreme conditions with reference to the tests with
load of 5 N and 20 N.
The Q-Q plots (Figs. 9 and 10) show in abscissa the theoretical quantiles and
ordered the same quantiles obtained from the sample data distribution. More the
quantiles are equal more the data are conforming to the Gaussian’s hypothesis; in this
case the Q-Q plot present a set of data with quite different behavior.
Observing Fig. 9 (test with 20 N load) and Fig. 10 (test with 5 N load) is possible
to underline that for the high load there is a normal distribution of the errors, but for a
little load this is not true. This is due to the fact that the fluctuations of friction
coefficients during tests with low load are more influenced from the coupled surfaces
metrology.
452 A. Ruggiero et al.
5 Conclusion
The analysis of the fluctuations of the friction coefficients (specially in dry conditions)
during tribological tests are strictly connected with changes which occur in the con-
ditions of the coupled surfaces. Generally, the evolution of the friction coefficient
during a reciprocating test (but also other tests) is characterized by an initial phase
(running-in) in which the change of the shape and surface morphology of the couple
under investigation change and causes the changing of the friction coefficient. After
that, the friction coefficient reaches a steady state, interesting for the tribological
characterization of the investigated system, but with the elapsing of the time tribody-
namic aging could occur [11] and the friction coefficient express high variations. At
moment in the scientific literature few attempts were made for the systematic analysis
of the variation of COF values during the tribological tests in order to describe exactly
running-in phase and steady state phase. This manuscript represents a first attempt for a
deep examination of the friction coefficient behavior obtained from tribological tests
and the main novelty is connected with the use of time series as investigation tool.
In this paper, by using a reciprocating tribometer, several tests were carry out in
dry-friction and some results of time series theory were applied to measured data set, in
order to gain detailed information on the tribological state of the investigated couple.
The analyzed contact was sphere-on-flat with constant duration tests, length of stroke
and alternative motion frequency, but changing the imposed normal load.
In this paper the authors studied the “story” of friction coefficient during tests using
a statistical methodology based on time series analysis which allowed to decompose the
measured data set in three main components: trend, seasonality and residual data set.
The trend give detailed information on the COF run-in conditions and the results of
the tests are in agreement with general theory on friction phenomena [11].
The presence of expected periodicity (due to reciprocating motion of the sphere) in
the time series was confirmed by means of autocorrelation coefficient evaluation of the
seasonality component. The small calculated p-value indicates that the hypothesis of
absence of autocorrelation in the data must be rejected and with the autocorrelogram it
is possible to evidence the presence of periodicity.
Finally, the analysis of the residual component, obtained by subtracting from the
original time series both the trend and the seasonal components, allows to individuate
the time interval in which is reasonable to attribute to the COF variation the steady state
conditions.
Finally, the Authors highlight that the proposed tool is extendible to other kind of
tribological tests in which a time history of friction coefficient is measured and rep-
resents a powerful methodology toward both the determination of accurate value of
friction coefficient characterizing the investigated tribo-system both the systematic
determination of the friction coefficient measurements uncertainty with reference to the
variation of the measurand component.
454 A. Ruggiero et al.
References
1. Ungureanu, M., Nasui, V.: Considerations on Certain Tribological Aspects of the System
Brake Shoe–Drum (2013)
2. Ungureanu, M., Ungureanu, N.S., Crăciun, I.: Study on friction behaviour of brake shoe
materials for mining hoist. IOP Conf. Ser. Mater. Sci. Eng. 174(1), 12016 (2017)
3. Jaber, S.A., Ruggiero, A., Battaglia, S., Affatato, S.: On the roughness measurement on knee
prostheses. Int. J. Artif. Organs 38(1), 39–44 (2015)
4. Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, G.M., Michalski, M., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S.: Structural
and microhardness changes after turning of the AISI 1045 steel for minimum quantity
cooling lubrication. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 26(1), 431–438 (2017)
5. Nieslony, P., Krolczyk, G.M., Wojciechowski, S., Chudy, R., Zak, K., Maruda, R.W.:
Surface quality and topographic inspection of variable compliance part after precise turning.
Appl. Surf. Sci. 434, 91–101 (2018)
6. Krolczyk, G.M., Maruda, R.W., Krolczyk, J.B., Nieslony, P., Wojciechowski, S., Legutko,
S.: Parametric and nonparametric description of the surface topography in the dry and
MQCL cutting conditions. Measurement 121, 225–239 (2018)
7. Affatato, S., Ruggiero, A., De Mattia, J.S., Taddei, P.: Does metal transfer affect the
tribological behaviour of femoral heads? Roughness and phase transformation analyses on
retrieved zirconia and Biolox® Delta composites. Compos. Part B Eng. 92, 290–298 (2016)
8. Ruggiero, A., Merola, M., Affatato, S.: On the biotribology of total knee replacement: a new
roughness measurements protocol on in vivo condyles considering the dynamic loading from
musculoskeletal multibody model. Measurement 112, 22–28 (2017)
9. Krolczyk, G.M., Nieslony, P., Maruda, R.W., Wojciechowski, S.: Dry cutting effect in
turning of a duplex stainless steel as a key factor in clean production. J. Clean. Prod. 142,
3343–3354 (2017)
10. Valášek, P., Ruggiero, A., Müller, M.: Experimental description of strength and tribological
characteristic of EFB oil palm fibres/epoxy composites with technologically undemanding
preparation. Compos. Part B Eng. 122, 79–88 (2017)
11. Blau, P.J.: Friction Science and Technology: From Concepts to Applications. CRC Press,
Boca Raton (2009)
12. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Merola, M., Valašek, P., Müller, M.: Tribological character-
ization of vegetal lubricants: Comparative experimental investigation on Jatropha curcas L.
oil, Rapeseed Methyl Ester oil, Hydrotreated Rapeseed oil. Tribol. Int. 109, 529–540 (2017)
13. Schmitz, T.L., Action, J.E., Ziegert, J.C., Sawyer, W.G.: The difficulty of measuring low
friction: uncertainty analysis for friction coefficient measurements. J. Tribol. 127(3), 673
(2005)
14. Ruggiero, A., Mindas, M., Knapcíková, L.: Tribodiagnostic investigation on oil filtration:
results from a novel apparatus. Ind. Lubr. Tribol. 68(6), 689–695 (2016)
15. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Merola, M., Valášek, P., Müller, M.: On the tribological
performance of vegetal lubricants: experimental investigation on Jatropha Curcas L. oil.
Procedia Eng. 149, 431–437 (2016)
16. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E.: Experimental analysis of tribological behavior of
UHMWPE against AISI420C and against TiAl6V4 alloy under dry and lubricated
conditions. Tribol. Int. 92, 154–161 (2015)
17. Ruggiero, A., Merola, M., Carlone, P., Archodoulaki, V.M.: Tribo-mechanical character-
ization of reinforced epoxy resin under dry and lubricated contact conditions. Compos.
Part B 79, 595–603 (2015)
Measurements of the Friction Coefficient 455
18. Ruggiero, A., D׳Amato, R., Gómez, E., Merola, M.: Experimental comparison on
tribological pairs UHMWPE/TIAL6V4 alloy, UHMWPE/AISI316L austenitic stainless
and UHMWPE/AL2O3 ceramic, under dry and lubricated conditions. Tribol. Int. 96,
349–360 (2016)
19. Tepedino, C., Guarnaccia, C., Iliev, S., Popova, S., Quartieri, J.: A forecasting model based
on time series analysis applied to electrical energy consumption. Int. J. Math. Model.
Methods Appl. Sci. 9, 432–445 (2015)
20. Guarnaccia, C., Quartieri, J., Rodrigues, E.R., Tepedino, C.: Acoustical noise analysis and
prediction by means of multiple seasonality time series model. Int. J. Math. Model. Methods
Appl. Sci. 8, 384–393 (2014)
Experimental Description of the Aging
of the Coconut Shell Powder/Epoxy Composite
1 Introduction
Composite materials are materials that combine the properties of their sub-components
and offer a wide use not only in engineering [1]. Important properties of materials
include their strength but also tribological characteristics [2]. In the field of processing
of biological commodities, a number of secondary materials are produced, the mean-
ingful use of which is desirable and can increase the profitability of this agricultural
process. An example of this is the use of EFF (empty fruit bunch) as a secondary
commodity that occurs during the processing/pressing of palm oil from the fruit of
Elaeis Guineensis [3]. A similar case is the processing of the fruits of the coconut.
During the processing of nuts, coir - cellulosic fibers and shell nuts are obtained as
secondary raw materials. Both of these secondary products can be used in the field of
material engineering [4–6].
Powders prepared by grinding shell nuts (CSP) can be a very interesting filler for
material engineering, where they can, for example, substitute powdered wood-based
powders [7]. Leman et al. [8] states that coconut shells are a type of agricultural waste,
which can be converted into useful material. Teipel et al. [9] consider the CSP filler as a
renewable source of filler that is suitable for filling polymeric materials, in particular, a
unique combination of mechanical and physical properties - describes the filling of
polypropylene with corresponding increases in sustainability and performance in price
reduction, adding CSP has increased the stiffness by 137%. Singh et al. [10] state that
the coconut shell powder in conjunction with the epoxy polymer is suitable for use as
low-weight composite materials in engineering. Salmah et al. [11] demonstrated that
adding CSP to PLA biocomposites reduced tensile strength and elongation at break, but
the modulus of elasticity increased. Leman et al. [8] mention the use of coconut shell
powder as a concrete filler for the benefit of a more sustainable and greener material.
The degradation behaviour of natural filler materials is key to describing possible
application areas. Sreejith et al. [12] describe the degradation behaviour of styrene-
butadiene rubber reinforced with coconut powder - the extent of biodegradation of
composites was assessed by measuring weight loss, tensile strength and hardness, it
was found that the stability of the composites was remarkably dependent on filler
treatment, filler particle size, and filler content.
It is clear from the research that the issue of the use of secondary bio-residues,
including CSP, is a current topic, and the description of the degradation materials with
the phase in form of CSP will help to describe the possibilities of application of these
biocomposites.
The paper focuses on the description of the aging of CSP/epoxy composite through
a degradation chamber where the positive and negative temperatures (−40 to +70 °C)
were alternated along with the change in humidity. An experimental description of the
effect of this aging focuses primarily on shear strength on conventional carbon
adherents and the change in tensile strength of body test specimens, cut by water jet
from plates prepared with vacuum infusion. The paper describes a simple composite
system where CSPs were sized with sieves, but there was not a surface treatment
applied (for example, chemical).
Fig. 1. Vacuum infusion: a-vacuum closed form, b-vacuum pump (left), plate from which the
test body was cut (right).
2.4 Degradation
To assess the aging of testing specimens the degradation chamber was used according
to the standard CSN EN ISO 9142 - temperature (70 °C and – 40 °C) and humidity
(90% and 50%) were regulated during the degradation process. The test specimens
were removed from the chamber after each end of the 7 cycles (1 cycle - 24 h). Overall,
it was repeated 5 7 cycles (35 cycles - 840 h) - see Fig. 2. After removal from the
degradation chamber, the test specimens were for 24 h under laboratory conditions, and
Experimental Description of the Aging of the CSP/Epoxy Composite 459
Fig. 2. Description of the degradation cycle (CSN EN ISO 9142 - left), space of degradation
chamber with test specimens (right).
Size, morphology, and particle concentration in the epoxy matrix are factors that
greatly affect the mechanical characteristics of the composite system. The morphology
of coconut-based particles (CSP) was evaluated by electron microscopy (see Figs. 3
and 4). The particles were first gold-plated to prevent their charging. Particle shape
analysis confirmed the predicted irregular shape of the particles. The irregular shape of
the particles promotes mechanical bonding - the wedging of the particle in the matrix,
of course, the good wetting (interaction) between the matrix and filler used is a
prerequisite.
460 K. Habrová et al.
Fig. 3. Electron microscopy - the morphology of CSP microparticles: Mag. 4.80 kx (left), Mag.
3.47 kx (right).
Fig. 4. Surface detail of CSP microparticles Mag. 7.96 kx (left), Mag. 10.2 kx (right).
To describe the particle size, laser diffraction was used by a dry way - a specific
surface area of 180.5 m2 kg−1, the particle distribution is evident from Fig. 5. More
than 84% were smaller than 98.11 lm. The average particle size was below 100 lm.
The cohesion and adhesion characteristics of the composite systems were assessed
through tensile strength and shear strength. Shear strength was performed on con-
ventional carbon steel, the area of application of the composite system was blasted and
degreased, the roughness parameter detected by the touch grinder corresponded to
Ra = 2.3 ± 0.3 lm and Rz = 10.7 ± 2.3 lm. The epoxy resin is commonly used for
conventional bonding of material in engineering. The shear strength of the non-filled
resin was 12.38 ± 0.38 MPa. Inclusion of the coconut powder filler in the 2.5%
inclusion range did not significantly affect the shear strength increase (p = 0.16), and in
the case of inclusion of 5.0% of the filler there was a statistically significant increase in
shear strength of 12% (1.5 MPa, p = 0.01), in the case of 10.0% inclusion there was no
Experimental Description of the Aging of the CSP/Epoxy Composite 461
statistically significant change (p = 0.28). For non-filled resin, the shear strength
decreased to 8.11 ± 0.85 MPa throughout the cycle due to degradation throughout the
cycle. For filled resin with coconut microparticles, the shear strength dropped to
8.81 ± 0.98 MPa (2.5%), 8.68 ± 0.74 MPa (5.0%) and 9.02 ± 0.48 MPa (10.0%),
see Fig. 6.
Fig. 6. Influence of inclusion of CSP microparticles on the matrix: Shear Strength of epoxy used
for conventional bonding of material in engineering.
The dominant type of failure of the test specimens was the adhesive failure. During
the degradation, this type of violation did not change significantly. On degraded sheets,
however, the phenomenon of corrosion was observable with the increasing number of
degradation cycles, see Fig. 7 - Bonding area (25 12.5 mm) and detail of bonding
area (captured by stereoscopic microscope).
The tensile strength of the non-filled resin, which is used in the mechanical engi-
neering area for vacuum infusion, reached 44.00 ± 2.68 MPa. Due to the inclusion of
particles, the shear strength was reduced by 2.33 MPa to 41.67 ± 1.70 MPa, but
p = 0.13 (see Fig. 8).
The tensile strength of the resin for the vacuum infusion dropped to
26.08 ± 2.62 MPa after 5 weeks of degradation and to the CSP/epoxy composite to
462 K. Habrová et al.
Fig. 7. Comparison of adhesive type of disruption for test specimens - shear strength, given
number is the number of weeks of degradation.
Fig. 8. Effect of inclusion of CSP microparticles on the matrix: tensile strength of epoxy used
for vacuum infusion.
24.07 ± 2.53 MPa. The interfacial interactions between the particles and the epoxy
matrix were evaluated by electron microscopy (see Fig. 9).
The results confirm that organic particulate fillers can form appropriate interactions
with polymer matrices. In accordance with the conclusions of Renner et al. [13] and
Shivamurthy et al. [14] the organic fillers can reduce the resulting cost of material, as
demonstrated by the description of the interfacial interface by electron microscopy. The
experiments did not show a significant dependence of the aging of CSP composites
(shear strength) on the filler content described by Sreejith et al. [12]. The presence of
CSP microparticles did not significantly affect the change of the observed character-
istics during the degradation of CSP composites compared to the non-filled epoxies.
Experimental Description of the Aging of the CSP/Epoxy Composite 463
Fig. 9. CSP particles in the composite system Mag. 2.47 kx (left), detail of the interfacial
interaction Mag. 2.57 kx (right).
4 Conclusions
The experiment describes the aging of a biocomposite with a synthetic matrix and a
biological filler made from secondary materials that occurs during coconut processing -
shells. Conclusions resulting from the experiment can be summarised as follows:
• 5% inclusion of organic microparticles prepared from coconut resulted in an
increase in shear strength of 12%.
• Comparison of non-filled and filled resin for a vacuum infusion, a 5.3% decrease in
tensile strength occurred.
• Due to the change of temperature and humidity, the shear strength and tensile
strength of both non-filled resins (on average 34%) and filled resins decreased (by
35% - 2.5%, 37% - 5.0%, 29% - 10.0%).
• Due to changes in temperature and humidity, the tensile strength of the resin for the
vacuum infusion decreased by 40.7% and for the CSP/epoxy composite by 42.2%.
Acknowledgements. This paper has been made with the assistance of the grant CULS - IGA TF
2018.
References
1. Ruggiero, A., Merola, M., Carlone, P., Archodoulaki, V.M.: Tribo-mechanical characteri-
zation of reinforced epoxy resin under dry and lubricated contact conditions. Compos. Part B:
Eng. 79, 595–603 (2015)
2. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E., Merola, M.: Experimental comparison on
tribological pairs UHMWPE/TIAL6V4 alloy, UHMWPE/AISI316L austenitic stainless
and UHMWPE/AL2O3 ceramic, under dry and lubricated conditions. Tribol. Int. 96, 349–
360 (2016)
3. Valášek, P., Ruggiero, A., Müller, M.: Experimental description of strength and tribological
characteristic of EFB oil palm fibres/epoxy composites with technologically undjm-
00emanding preparation. Compos. Part B: Eng. 122, 79–88 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
compositesb.2017.04.014
464 K. Habrová et al.
4. Jia, Y., Yingchang, H., Wen, L.: Performance research on coir fiber and wood debris hybrid
boards. BioRes. 7(3), 4262–4272 (2012)
5. Keerthika, B., Umayavalli, M., Jeyalalitha, T., Krishnaveni, N.: Coconut shell powder as
cost effective filler in copolymer of acrylonitrile and butadiene rubber. Ecotoxicol. Environ.
Saf. 130, 1–3 (2016)
6. Easwara Prasad, G.L., Keerthi Gowda, B.S., Velmurugan, R.A.: Study on impact strength
characteristics of coir polyester composites. Procedia Eng. 173, 771–777 (2017)
7. Kirby, M. Optimization of natural functional fillers created from bio-waste in polymeric
composites using coconut shell powder and MAPP SCONA®. In: Society of Plastics
Engineers - 2013 SPE International Polyolefins Conference (2013)
8. Leman, A.S., Shahidan, S., Nasir, A.J., Senin, M.S., Mohd Zuki, S.S., Wan Ibrahim, M.H.,
Deraman, R., Khalid, F.S., Azhar, A.T.S.: Properties of concrete containing coconut shell
powder (CSP) as a filler. In: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering.
Global Congress on Construction, Material and Structural Engineering 2017, vol. 271(1),
7 December 2017
9. Teipel, E.G., Conroy, S., Kirby, M., Bradley, W.: Natural functional fillers from agricultural
waste to reinforce polymeric composites: coconut shell powder technology. In: Society of
Plastics Engineers - SPE International Polyolefins Conference 2014, pp. 53–60 (2014)
10. Singh, S., Singh, A., Sharma, S.K.: Analytical modeling for mechanical strength prediction
with raman spectroscopy and fractured surface morphology of novel coconut shell powder
reinforced: epoxy composites. J. Inst. Eng. (India) Ser. C 98(3), 235–240 (2017)
11. Salmah, H., Koay, S.C., Hakimah, O.: Surface modification of coconut shell powder filled
polylactic acid biocomposites. J. Thermoplas. Compos. Mater. 26(6), 809–819 (2013)
12. Sreejith, M.P., Balan, A.K., et al.: Biodegradation behavior of styrene butadiene rubber
(SBR) reinforced with modified coconut shell powder. In: AIP Conference Proceedings, vol.
1849, p. 020047 (2017)
13. Renner, K., Kenyó, C., et al.: Micromechanical deformation processes in PP/wood
composites: particle characteristics, adhesion, mechanisms. Compos. Part A: Appl. Sci.
Manuf. 41(11), 1653–1661 (2010)
14. Shivamurthy, B., Murthy, K., et al. Mechanical properties and sliding wear behavior of
Jatropha seed cake waste/epoxy composites. J. Mater. Cycles Waste Manag. 1–13 (2014)
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite
Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings
by Using the Warner’s Theory
Abstract. The purpose of this paper is to propose a method for the analytical
description of the non-steady fluid film for the liquid-lubricated finite journal
bearings operating in a fully developed turbulent regime. The analytical
description takes in account a symmetrical rigid rotor supported on two lubri-
cated journal bearings under the classical assumptions of the Reynolds theory.
The proposed methodology represents an extension of the Warner’s approach
and allows to solve analytically in approximate way the equation governing the
distribution of pressure in the bearing oil gap and then to obtain the analytical
expressions for the unsteady fluid film forces giving particular attention to their
continuity in the entire definition domain, introducing original analytical func-
tions called “jump function”. The proposed model allows not only to minimize
the computation time without any significant loss of accuracy in the nonlinear
dynamic analysis of rotors on turbulent journal bearings but also permits a better
readability of the parameter effects on the system unsteady behavior.
1 Introduction
analytical calculation of the fluid film force in the case of short bearing with a fully
developed turbulent flow [3]. Childs has presented the modeling and analysis for the
turbomachinery rotordynamics phenomena [4] for Constantinescu in his book on the
sliding bearings [5]. In fact, it is well known that when turbo-machines work with high
shaft rotational speeds or with lubricants having low viscosity [6] (water, refrigerants,
liquid metals or liquefied gases, vegetal lubricants [7]) the action of fluid dynamic
forces produces a self-excited orbital motion. Furthermore, these phenomena are linked
to a series of parameters related to the tribo-system under study (relative velocity
between the two surfaces in contact [8], surface roughness, applied load and viscosity
of lubricant [9]). In their works several Authors, by using the classical theory of
lubrication, have neglected the inertia force with respect to the pressure forces and
viscous stresses [5]. However, in some journal bearings, like, for example, pumps
operating in atomic power plant, when the diameters are very large or when the rotating
bearings operate in high speed regime, the inertia force might become preponderant
due to large operating clearance, low kinematical viscosity of lubricants and high linear
speeds. In this case, when in lubricant films are present the inertia forces, the rigorous
use of the Reynolds equation is not allowed [10]. In fact, due to the change of the flow
structure produced by the inertia force, that reaches a certain value in the journal
bearing, progressively, appear turbulence phenomena. These turbulence phenomena
produce an increase of the load carrying capacity and simultaneously a sensible
increase of the friction. The occurrence of turbulence is due to the increase of the
journal bearing characteristic Reynolds number. When those occurs the Taylor’s vortex
pattern flow and the turbulent regime may occur [11]. In journal bearings, turbulence
makes its first appearance at Re = 2000 [12]. For this reason, several theoretical [1, 10]
and experimental studies [13] focused its attention to the study of dynamic charac-
teristic problems of journal bearings [14]. In fact, many authors have presented a
theoretical study on the vibration of a rigid shaft on short sleeve bearings [15] and a
numerical method for the calculation method of the dynamic coefficients of oil-
lubricated journal bearings [16].
Large part of these investigations has presented different methods in order to solve
the Reynolds’ equation and all were based on numerical methods, like the finite dif-
ference or the finite element technique, and all limited to the calculation of the bearing
linearized dynamic coefficients. The laminar lubrication conditions were the only
object under study of these investigations and, in the scientific literature, only few
papers have attempted to treat the turbulent lubrication conditions [16, 17].
Indeed, no Authors have tried to describe in a fully analytical way the fluid film
pressure and the fluid film forces acting in the lubricated gap in non-stationary con-
dition of the shaft in the case of finite length journal bearing. In fact, under these
conditions the unsteady and two-dimensional Reynold’s equation does not present a
closed analytical solution [18]. For this reason, the aim of this paper is to propose an
approximate analytical method in order to obtain the hydrodynamic pressure field in the
case of finite journal bearing in a fully developed turbulent flow regime.
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings 467
2 Theoretical Analysis
The analyzed system consists into a rigid, symmetric balanced rotor supported in two
equal plain cylindrical journal bearings. The rotor possesses perfect axial symmetry; it
allows limit the analysis to one of the parts into which the system is subdivided.
Figure 1 shows the model and the coordinates x, y used.
It is assumed that the system is loaded in the y direction in the plane of symmetry
by a load W. With reference to the journal bearing [1] in Fig. 1, under the hypothesis of
hydrodynamic lubrication [19], the equation which governs the pressure in the lubri-
cant film is in dimensional form [20]:
1 @ h3 @p @ h3 @p 1 @
h @ h
þ ¼ x þ ð1Þ
R @h lkx @h
2 @z lkz @z 2 @h @t
Where R is the journal radius, x represents the angular speed, h is the film
thickness, e the eccentricity, t the time and l the viscosity of the lubricant. The weight
of the rotor imposes a load W on the bearing; and in order to taking in account the
turbulence effects the equations derived from the Constantinescu’s turbulent theory [5]
and based on the Prandtl’s mixing length hypothesis.
The coefficients kx and kz are known function depending, in a first an approxima-
tion, only on the local flow Reynolds number Re = qVh/µ and can be used in the
interval of 103 Re 5 104, i.e. for most self-acting bearing applications [5, 11].
468 A. Ruggiero et al.
kx ¼ 12 þ ax Rbe x ð2Þ
kz ¼ 12 þ az Rbe z ð3Þ
In the above expressions the values of the variables are: ax ¼ 0:0136, bx ¼ 0:9,
az ¼ 0:0043 and bz ¼ 0:96. In the laminar case kx ¼ kz ¼ 12.
Introducing the dimensionless quantities:
p
p¼ 2 ; ð4Þ
6lx CR
h
h¼ ; ð5Þ
C
s ¼ xt; ð6Þ
z
f¼ ; ð7Þ
R
e
e¼ ð8Þ
C
With:
The analytical approximate solution, in the case of finite journal bearing, was found
by a novel model proposed by authors based on the Warners’ approach used in the
laminar case for partial arc journal bearings [21]. Thus, assuming a solution of the
Eq. (10) in the form:
Where f(h), g(h) and k(z) are calculated from the ordinary differential equations:
d h3 df @h
¼ ð1 2u_ Þ þ 2_e cos h ð12Þ
dh kxa dh @h
3
kza d h @g d @k
h3 dh kxa @h df df
þ ¼0 ð13Þ
g k
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings 469
Whence:
d2 k
k2 k ¼ 0 ð14Þ
df2
d h3 dg h3
þ k2 g ¼ 0 ð15Þ
dh kxa dh kza
The analytical expression for the f(h) function was obtained by integrating the
Eq. (12) with the continuity condition of the solution. A qualitative plot of f(h) is
reported in Fig. 2 for a typical set of parameters.
1.2
1
0.8
f(θ)
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
f(θ)
aR
þp
h3 dg1 2
kxa dh dh
a
k2 ¼ aR
þp
ð19Þ
2
h3 g1
kza 2 dh
a
where a is calculated in approximate way by using the relations obtained in the case of
laminar infinitely long bearing [5]:
Further, assuming g1(h) f*(h), where f*(h) is the solution of the differential
equation:
d h3 df
¼ ð2u_ 1Þe sinðhÞ þ 2_e cosðhÞ ð21Þ
dh kxa dh
h3 g21 e þ 2e 1 þ ax ð2 þ e ÞRe cos hÞ sin h
ð4 þ ax ð4 þ 3e2 ÞRbx 2 bx
¼ ð1 2u_ Þ
kxa 2 2ð4 þ e2 Þð1 þ e cos hÞ
ð23Þ
The analytical solution of the integrals in Eq. (19) was performed by using
Mathematica (Wolfram) software. The obtained expressions however for brevity are
not reported in this paper.
In order to evaluate the characteristic value k as defined in Eq. (19) it has been
necessary to calculate the definite integrals in the numerator and denominator of the
equation. Due to a discontinuity point in p it was necessary to define two new novel
functions called “JUMP functions”. The JUMP functions were calculated analytically
and represent the difference between the right-hand limit and left-hand limit in the p
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings 471
point. Then the new functions were defined by adding the JUMP functions at the
original functions in the domain [p, 2 p].
3 Results
The knowledge of the analytical expressions of the functions introduced in the theo-
retical analysis, make possible to obtain, even if not reported, the analytical expression
of the fluid film pressure in turbulent flow and in unsteady journal conditions. As
example of the results obtainable, by using the numerical values shown in Table 1 it is
possible to plot the hydrodynamic pressure in a fully developed turbulent flow regime.
Figures 3 and 4 show the evolution of the hydrodynamic pressure with respect to h
and to f by imposing generic kinematical values to the shaft motion.
Fig. 3. Evolution of the non-dimensional hydrodynamic pressure for finite journal bearing vs h
and to f using e = 10−6, u = 10−6 and Re number equal to 2000.
472 A. Ruggiero et al.
Fig. 4. Evolution of the non-dimensional hydrodynamic pressure for finite journal bearing vs h
and to f using e = 2, u = 1 and Re number equal to 2000.
The Figs. 5 and 6 show the evolution of the hydrodynamic pressure with respect to
h and to f by using the parameters values shown in Table 1, but with the Reynolds
number equal to 5000.
Fig. 5. Evolution of the hydrodynamic pressure for finite journal bearing with respect to h and
to f using e = 10−6, u = 10−6 and Re number equal to 5000.
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings 473
Fig. 6. Evolution of the hydrodynamic for finite journal bearing pressure with respect to h and
to f using e = 2, u = 1 and Re number equal to 5000.
4 Conclusions
With the method shown in this paper it is possible to determine an analytical model for
describing the fluid film pressure field in turbulent conditions with reference to finite
length lubricated journal bearings. The closed form solution makes it possible the
analytical calculation of the unsteady fluid film force acting on the journal in unsteady
state and thus the rapid determination of the stiffness and damping coefficients which
allow the knowledge of the bearing response for any dynamic calculations. The use of
proposed method is recommended in all types of bearing analysis that favor an ana-
lytical approach, i.e., in all cases in which the aim is to obtain a better trade of between
accuracy and computational expense. Moreover, in the analysis of flexible rotors
supported by several bearings, it is possible to take in account the fluid film force
exerted from bearings by introducing opportunely the stiffness and damping expres-
sions in the structural stiffness and damping matrices of the entire system. The lin-
earized stability analysis can be seen as an effortless application of the present work
outcomes: in fact, the derivatives of the unsteady expressions of the oil film forces lead
to the stable/unstable onset values and stability map for each aspect ratio.
474 A. Ruggiero et al.
References
1. Lund, J.W.: Ph.d. thesis: Self-Excited, Stationary Whirl Orbits of a Journal in a sleeve
bearing. Inst. Dept. of mechanics, N.Y. Rensselaer Polytechnic institute (1966)
2. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Magliano, E., Kozak, D.: Dynamical simulations of a flexible
rotor in cylindrical uncavitated and cavitated lubricated journal bearings. Lubricants 6(2),
40–69 (2018)
3. Ruggiero, A., Hloch, S., Kozak, D., Velasek, P.: Analytical fluid film force calculation in the
case of short bearing with a fully developed turbulent flow. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part J
J. Eng. Tribol. 230(4), 395–401 (2016)
4. Childs, D.: Turbomachinery Rotordynamics Phenomena, Modeling, and Analysis. Wiley,
New York (1993)
5. Constantinescu, V.N.: Sliding Bearings. Allerton Press (1985)
6. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Merola, M., Valášek, P., Müller, M.: Tribological character-
ization of vegetal lubricants: comparative experimental investigation on Jatropha curcas L.
oil, Rapeseed Methyl Ester oil, Hydrotreated Rapeseed oil. Tribol. Int. 109, 529–540 (2017)
7. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Merola, M., Valášek, P., Müller, M.: On the tribological
performance of vegetal lubricants: experimental investigation on Jatropha curcas L. oil.
Procedia Eng. 149, 431–437 (2016)
8. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E.: Experimental analysis of tribological behavior of
UHMWPE against AISI420C and against TiAl6V4 alloy under dry and lubricated
conditions. Tribol. Int. 92, 154–161 (2015)
9. Ruggiero, A., D’Amato, R., Gómez, E., Merola, M.: Experimental comparison on
tribological pairs UHMWPE/TIAL6V4 alloy, UHMWPE/AISI316L austenitic stainless
and UHMWPE/AL2O3 ceramic, under dry and lubricated conditions. Tribol. Int. 96, 349–
360 (2016)
10. Lahmar, M., Haddad, A., Nicolas, D.: An optimised short bearing theory for nonlinear
dynamic analysis of turbulent journal bearings. Eur. J. Mech. A/Solids 19(1), 151–177
(2000)
11. Frene, J., et al.: Hydrodynamic lubrication: bearings and thrust bearings, vol. 33. Elsevier
(1997)
12. D’Agostino, V., Ruggiero, A., Senatore, A.: Unsteady oil film forces in porous bearings:
analysis of permeability effect on the rotor linear stability. Meccanica 44(2), 207–214 (2009)
13. Kirk, R.G., Gunter, E.J.: Short bearing analysis applied to rotor dynamics-Part 2: results of
journal bearing response. J. Tribol. 98(2), 319–329 (1976)
14. Kirk, R.G., Gunter, E.J.: Short bearing analysis applied to rotor dynamics-Part I: theory.
J. Tribol. 98(1), 47–56 (1976)
15. D’Agostino, V., Ruggiero, A., Senatore, A.: Approximate model for unsteady finite porous
journal bearings fluid film force calculation. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. Part J J. Eng. Tribol. 220
(3), 227–234 (2006)
16. Lund, J.W., Thomsen, K.K.: A calculation method and data for the dynamic coefficients of
oil-lubricated journal bearings. Topics in fluid film bearing and rotor bearing system design
and optimization 1000118 (1978)
17. Hashimoto, H., Wada, S.: Dynamic behavior of unbalanced rigid shaft supported on
turbulent journal bearings-theory and experiment. J. Tribol. 112(2), 404–408 (1990)
18. DuBois, G.B., Ocvirk, W.: Analytical derivation and experimental evaluation of short-
bearing approximation for full journal bearing. Naca-report-1157 (1953)
Fluid Film Pressure Description in Finite Turbulent Lubricated Journal Bearings 475
19. Ruggiero, A., Gòmez, E., D’Amato, R.: Approximate closed-form solution of the synovial
fluid film force in the human ankle joint with non-Newtonian lubricant. Tribol. Int. 157,
157–161 (2012)
20. Ruggiero, A., Gòmez, E., D’Amato, R.: Approximate analytical model for the squeeze-film
lubrication of the human ankle joint with synovial fluid filtrated by articular cartilage. Tribol.
Lett. 41(2), 337–343 (2011)
21. Warner, P.C.: Static and dynamic properties of partial journal bearings. J. Basic Eng. 85, 247
(1963)
Influence of Processing Parameters
on Residual Stress in Injection Molded Parts
Abstract. Residual stresses are the source of shrinkage and warpage of the
parts manufactured with injection molding technology and strongly influences
its final dimensions. In complicated parts residual stresses are very difficult to
predict without numerical tools, along with the warpage, what leads to problems
with manufacturing parts that meet the expected tolerances. Residual stresses
have also strong influence on mechanical performance of the part, where its high
value can results with self-cracking during ejection from the mold. In this work
numerical simulations injection molding process were performed to analyze the
presence of residual stresses in manufactured plastic parts by this technology.
Numerical simulations were used to find the relations between the processing
parameters and the distribution and magnitude of residual stresses. Occurrence
of residual stresses were analyzed with new 3D residual stress model imple-
mented in Autodesk Moldflow® software. Qualitative strain-optics observations
were performed to verify the differences between different sets of processing
parameters. From investigated parameters the strongest influence on residual
stresses was observed with packing time, while the weakest influence was
observed with injection time.
1 Introduction
Injection molding is one of the most popular plastics processing method because of its
high versatility and quality of manufactured parts. It is a cyclical process, where first
step is injection of the plastic to the cavities of the mold. Afterwards the packing phase
has its place where empty spaces in the cavities that appears during the solidification of
polymers are filled with polymer to obtain good quality parts. Then during the cooling
phase the rest of heat is removed from the part and the mold and then part is ejected
from the mold.
Residual stresses are stresses that are frozen in molded parts, which were developed
during processing. They lead to warpage (or even buckling with very high residual
stresses) and even self-cracking of the part during ejection from the mold [1]. With very
high residual stresses that overcome structural integrity the void can be formed, what is
unacceptable defect in the manufactured part. Residual stresses can be divided in two
types of residual stresses: thermal-induced and flow-induced.
Flow-induced residual stresses come out when long-chain polymers molecules aim
to conform to state equilibrium. This state is achieved at temperatures higher than the
melt temperature of used polymers (this state is called as molten state). During the
process all molecules take orientation in accordance with direction of the flow. This
phenomenon occurs because polymer is shared and elongated. What is important, the
molecular orientation of polymers chain is locked within the molded part, when melted
material solidifies before the molecules of the polymer are fully relaxed to their state of
equilibrium. This type of frozen-in stressed state introduces anisotropic, non-uniform
shrinkage and mechanical properties in parallel and perpendicular directions to the
direction of the flow. It is caused by molecular orientation of the polymer, which is
stretched exactly in line with the flow direction [3].
The process conditions and design elements that reduce shear stress during cavity
filling will help to reduce flow-induced residual stress. Likewise, those that promote
sufficient packing and uniform mold cooling will reduce thermal-induced residual
stress. For fiber-filled materials, those process conditions that promote uniform
mechanical properties will reduce thermal-induced residual stresses. During the cooling
process different residual stress are formed and named as thermal-induced residual
stress. At the beginning the basis for this process should be mentioned, namely that
polymers are susceptible for contraction. The fact is that during the cooling stage
polymers cools at different rates from the cavity wall to the center. Hence, at first the
external surface layer is getting colder and starts to shrink, while the core of polymer is
still hot and free to contract. Next, after some time, the internal core cools and it’s
contraction is limited by external surfaces, which are already stiff. So unbalanced
cooling, non-uniform part thickness or improper packing pressure could be phenomena
which leads to the formation of the thermal-induced residual stress [2]. However, in
absolute values, the flow-induced stresses are usually one order of magnitude smaller
than the thermal-induced stresses [4]. To decrease the thermal-induced residual stress
some conditions which lead to sufficient packing and more uniform mold temperature
should be keep. For example these are: proper packing pressure and duration, uniform
and balanced cooling stage for all surfaces of the part, uniform heat removal from
mold, proper (well designed) wall-section thickness [5].
2 Simulation Research
In this paper new method was used to investigate residual stresses in injection molded
parts. Numerical simulations were performed with Autodesk Moldflow® software,
where its new 3D thermo-viscous-elastic residual stress has been implemented (3D
uncorrected residual stress model). It was introduced to Autodesk Moldflow software
for more precise evaluation of 3D shrinkage and warpage. In this model linear elastic
behavior was assumed in the solidified part and purely viscous behavior was assumed
in the melt. Autodesk Moldflow® software can also evaluate the residual stresses in
fiber-filled polymer composites. It delivers Young Modulus, Poisson’s ratio, thermal
expansion coefficients of material using previously obtained fiber orientation and
mechanical properties of composite [6–8]. Results are used to evaluate 3D orthotropic
stress-strain relation. Governing equations of this problem are presented below (1, 2).
478 P. Poszwa et al.
2 3
2 3 1myz mzy myz þ mzx myz mzx þ myz mzy 2 3
rxx 6 Ey Ez D Ey Ez D Ey Ez D 0 0 0 7 exx
6 ryy 7 6 mxy þ mxz mzx 1mzx mxz mzy þ mzx mxy
0 0 0 76 eyy 7
6 7 6 Ez Ex D Ez Ex D Ez Ex D 76 7
6 rzz 7 6 mxz þ mxy myz mzy þ mxz myz 1mxy myx 0 0 0 76 ezz 7
6 7 6 76 7
6 sxy 7 ¼ 6 Ex Ey D Ex Ey D Ex Ey D
Gxy 0 0 76 cxy 7 ð1Þ
6 7 6 0 0 0 76 7
4 syz 5 6 0 Gyz 0 74 cyz 5
4 0 0 0 5
szx 0 0 Gzx czx
0 0 0
To solve the problem of warpage, the equilibrium Eq. (3) is solved iteratively (at
time t + Dt, for iteration k = 1, 2, 3,…):
Z ðkÞ ðk1Þ R t þ Dt ðk1Þ ðkÞ
Cijrs Ders dDeij dV þ m Sij dDgij dV ¼
R t þ Dt ðk1Þ ðk1Þ iniðkÞ ðk1Þ ð3Þ
m m Sij dDeij dV þ Cijrs Ders dDeij dV
ðkÞ ðkÞ
where Cijrs – the stress-strain tensor, ers and gij – the linear and non-linear incre-
ðk1Þ ðkÞ
mental strain tensors for iteration k, eij and dDgij – the linear and non-linear
iniðkÞ
incremental strain tensors corresponding to virtual incremental displacement, ers –
ðk1Þ
the incremental initial strain tensor for iteration k, Sij – the second Piola-Kirchoff
stress tensor after iteration (k − 1) at time t þ Dt.
Mathematical model was used to estimate the values of residual stresses and to
provide the validation of results obtained from Autodesk Moldflow®. The model was
developed by Osswald and was used to evaluate the thermal-induced residual stresses
[9]. No residual stress build-up that occurs during phase change is assumed.
2
2 3z 1
rðzÞ ¼ aEðTs Tf Þ ð4Þ
3 8b2 2
The equation presented at (4) can be applied for thin section, where: a – thermal
expansion coefficient, E – Young modulus, Ts – solidification temperature, Tf – final
part temperature, b – thickness, z – distance from the centerline of the cross section.
Stresses introduced to polymer parts have strong influence on optical properties of
transparent polymers. They can change its refractive index n in different directions
what lead to birefringence according to the stress-optic law equation [10]:
2pt
D¼ Cðr1 r2 Þ ð5Þ
k
where D – induced retardation, t – specimen thickness, k – vacuum wavelength, C –
stress-optics coefficient, r1 and r2 are the first and second principal stresses.
Relative phase retardation between the two components is observed due to the
difference in the refractive indices. Retardation leads to change of the polarization of
Influence of Processing Parameters on Residual Stress 479
transmitted light. It can be observed with polariscope which uses optical interference of
light waves that have different polarization before/after passing through the part.
In this work transparent styrene-acrylonitrile resin (SAN) Lustran 31 produced by
Ineos was used to manufacture parts. Simulations were performed with general SAN
material, which has averaged material parameters. The geometry of runner system and
cavities used for simulations and photoelastic measurements is presented at Fig. 1.
Specimens were examined with polariscope and the different patterns were observed
for different sets of parameters. Slight difference in pattern was observed at the ends of
the bars and no difference was observed in the middle of the parts. In the middle of the
parts the difference in colors was observed, what means that the processing parameters
have slight influence at stress distribution but have also influence on stress values.
Examples of the difference in patterns and colors are presented at Fig. 2.
the stress in the region close to the surface (almost 3.5 MPa) and to significant increase
of the stress in the middle of the cross section (almost 3.5 MPa). Further increase of
packing time led to slight fall of the stress in the region close to the surface and in the
middle of the cross section. According to the governing equations the source of this
change is the packing pressure, that were frozen during cooling stage. Increase of the
packing time lead to more uniform Hencky-Mises stress distribution.
Fig. 4. Hencky-Mises stress across the cross Fig. 5. Hencky-Mises stress across the cross
section of the specimen at different packing section of the specimen at melt temperatures Tp
times tp (ti = 1 s, Tm = 20 °C, Tp = 240 °C). and mold temperatures Tm (ti = 1 s, tp = 1 s).
Last two processing parameters that were investigated simultaneously were melt
temperature Tp and mold temperature Tm. Hencky-Mises stress distribution for different
sets of Tp and Tm are presented at Figs. 5, 6 and 7. In the beginning the influence of
previously mentioned parameters were verified for tp = 1 s. In this situation the
increase of the mold temperature led to slight decrease of the stress (around 1 MPa) in
the middle of the cross section. Insignificant influence of melt temperature was
observed for this packing time. Increase of packing time to 3 s resulted with higher
influence of mold and melt temperature. After increase of packing time the increase of
the temperature led to the significant decrease of the stress (around 3.5 MPa) in the
middle of the cross section. Increase of the melt temperature resulted with significant
482 P. Poszwa et al.
rise of the stress at the region close to the surface of the part and slight increase of the
stress in the middle of the cross section. Further increase of the packing time to 5 s
resulted with more significant influence of mold and melt temperature on residual
stresses. In comparison to the previous packing time the rise of the mold temperature
lead to slight decrease of the Hencky-Mises stress in the middle of the cross section and
significant decrease (around 3.5 MPa) in the region close to the surface of the speci-
men. With longer packing time and higher mold temperature no stress increase at the
region close to the surface was observed, only small decrease of the residual stress in
the middle of the cross section was observed.
Fig. 6. Hencky-Mises stress across the cross Fig. 7. Hencky-Mises stress across the cross
section of the specimen at melt temperatures Tp section of the specimen at melt temperatures
and mold temperatures Tm (ti = 1 s, tp = 3 s). Tp and mold temperatures Tm (ti = 1 s,
tp = 5 s).
The cause of the residual stress decrease with the increase of the mold temperature
is the reduction of heat transfer from the part, which leads to slower solidification of the
layers of polymer. For short packing time high shrinkage occurs (no material is added
in packing phase), that is why the increase of packing time has crucial role in the
increase of the influence of mold temperature. The cause of the residual stress increase
with the increase of the mold is longer cooling phase (longer time needed to cool the
temperature below melting temperature or glass transition temperature) and smaller
viscosity of the polymer. Longer cooling phase leads to higher shrinkage of the part
and smaller viscosity leads to stronger orientation (flow-induced residual stress is
higher). The lowest and the most uniform Hencky-Mises stress was obtained with the
highest packing time, higher mold temperature and lower melt temperature.
Validation of the results with analytical models could be done by comparison with
the part of the tensor that is parallel to the flow (in this case Txx part). According to
Fig. 8 analytical model is a good approximation of the real residual stresses. In the
region closer to the skin small differences are observed, especially for short packing
time, so the source of the difference can be the limitation of the analytical model (it
does not take into account the residual stress from pressure). Consideration of packing
Influence of Processing Parameters on Residual Stress 483
pressure leads to the decrease of the compression stresses near surface (negative) of the
specimen and tensile stresses (positive) in the internal part of the specimen.
Fig. 8. Values of Txx tensor across the cross section of the specimen at different packing times tp
and mold temperatures Tm (ti = 1 s, Tp = 240 °C).
4 Conclusions
In this work numerical simulations of injection molding process were performed with
Autodesk Moldflow® software to obtain information about residual stresses. Delivered
results were qualitatively compared with strain-optics observations and quantitatively
validated with analytical model. According to the results good agreement of results
were obtained, where the source of the difference was the limitations of analytical
model. The strongest influence on residual stresses had packing time, which was
strongly nonlinear and connected with melt and mold temperature. Besides, for the
specific packing time the increase of mold temperature led to the decrease of the
Hencky-Mises stresses, while the increase of melt temperature led to the increase of
stresses. For above presented specimen, investigated injection time range had negli-
gible influence on residual stresses. It is worth to mention that analytical model used in
this work can be only applied for simple parts, whereas plastic parts are often very
complicated (especially in automotive industry). That is why the application of
numerical simulations are the only option for investigation of the residual stresses that
are always present in plastic parts.
References
1. Postawa, P., Kwiatkowski, D.: Residual stress distribution in injection, molded parts.
J. Achiev. Mater. Manuf. Eng. 18(1–2), 171–174 (2006)
2. Zhang, X., Cheng, X., Stelson, K.A., Bhattacahry, M., Sen, A., Voller, V.R.: Approximate
model of thermal residual stress in an injection molded part. J. Therm. Stress. 25(6), 523–
538 (2002)
484 P. Poszwa et al.
3. Pak, S.Y., Kim, S.Y., Kim, S.H., Youn, J.R.: Measurement of residual stresses in polymeric
parts by indentation method. Polym. Test. 32(5), 946–952 (2013)
4. Azdast, T., Behravesh, A.H., Mazaheri, K., Darvishi, M.M.: Numerical simulation and
experimental validation of residual stress induced constrained shrinkage of injection molded
parts. Polimery 53(4), 304–310 (2008)
5. http://www.dc.engr.scu.edu. 15.03.2017
6. Advani, S.G., Tucker III, C.L.: The use of tensors to describe and predict fiber orientation in
short fiber composites. J. Rheol. 31(8), 751–784 (1987)
7. Tandon, G.P., Weng, G.J.: The effect of aspect ratio of inclusions on the elastic properties of
unidirectional aligned composites. Polym. Compos. 5(4), 327–333 (1984)
8. Schapery, R.A.: Thermal expansion coefficients of composite materials based on energy
principles. J. Compos. Mater. 2(3), 380–404 (1968)
9. Osswald, T.A.: Polymer Processing Fundamentals. Hanser Publishers, Cincinnati,
Hanser/Gardner (1998)
10. Dally, J.W., Riley, W.F.: Experimental Stress Analysis, 3rd edn. McGraw-Hill Inc., New
York (1991)
Shape Memory Alloy (SMA) as a Potential
Damper in Structural Vibration Control
1 Introduction
Plastic deformation of Gold-Cadmium (Au-Cd) alloys take place when it becomes cold
and recovers its original shape upon heating. This phenomenon of solid phase trans-
formation was first observed by Olander [1] in SMA (1932). Vernon was the first to use
the term “shape memory” in 1941 [2]. Till date, various categories of SMAs have been
invented. But Nitinol (NiTi) is the most widely used SMA amongst all because of its
high thermo-mechanical and electrical properties. Some other examples of SMAs are
Cu-Al-Be and Cu-Al-Mn. Research on ferrous based SMA is also in progress. Greninger
and Mooradian [3] were the first to observe the phenomenon of SME for copper-zinc
(Cu-Zn) alloys and copper-tin (Cu-Sn) alloys in 1938. Kurdjumov and Khandros [4]
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 485–492, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_51
486 S. C. Dutta and R. Majumder
(1949) and Chang and Read [5] (1951), reported the shape memory effect on a large
scale after a long span of time. After 1962, SME in nickel-titanium was discovered by
Buehler and other co-researchers [6, 7]. The material was named as Nitinol after their
workplace. Similar effects were also discovered in other alloys as well. SMAs drew the
attention of many researchers and inventors but owing to its high material cost and
complexity in manufacturing its industrial and commercial applications could not be
enhanced. Graesser and Cozzarelli in 1991 were the first to present new results in the
field of hysteretic modelling and explained the characterization of Shape Memory
Alloys through experimental investigations [8] (Fig. 1).
SMAs exist in two crystalline forms - austenite and martensite. The martensite is stable
at low temperature and high stresses whereas the austenite is stable at high temperature
and low stresses. Apart from Shape Memory Effect (SME) and pseudo or super-
elasticity, which occurs due to the reversible phase transformation between the
martensite and austenite phases, an outstanding re-centering capability is exhibited by
SMA owing to its hysteretic behavior. SMAs possess other properties which include
high strength, excellent resistance to fatigue and corrosion and also exhibits tremen-
dous damping capacity. A large number of investigations have been carried out to find
out the suitable utilization of SMAs in civil engineering structures over the last few
years. Although the use of SMAs is still in its initial phase in the field of civil
engineering, but it has shown tremendous potential in controlling structural vibrations
when subjected to seismic excitation as well as blast load. The response and the
subsequent plastic deformation in structures due to extreme loadings can be mitigated
SMA as a Potential Damper in Structural Vibration Control 487
in the passive structural control technique using SMA since it possess excellent
damping property. Ground isolation system and energy dissipation system are the two
mechanisms by which SMAs could be utilized in an effective manner for the purpose of
passive control technique. Super-elastic SMAs are the most suitable for isolators and on
the other hand both the martensite and super-elastic SMAs may be utilized as energy
dissipators (Figs. 2 and 3).
Fig. 2. SMA wire as re-centering device. Fig. 3. SMA as spring isolation system.
The SMA energy dissipaters are used in the form of bracings in framed structures
and also in bridges as dampers. They find applications as connecting elements in
columns and also as devices for retrofitting in old historic buildings.
A time domain based blast input model is presented in brief. An empirical formulae
given by Wu and Hao [10] is used to compute the ground motion generated from
underground blast. The average empirical attenuation relation for peak particle velocity
PPVs along the ground is given below:
1:3375
R
PPV s ¼ 2:981 f1s ð1Þ
Q0:33
and,
where
f1s = Factor of decoupling for PPV s ,
R = distance (meters) taken from the charge center,
488 S. C. Dutta and R. Majumder
Here, td ¼ R=Cp = time for arrival and Cp = Propagation velocity of wave in the
rock.
A two-story steel frame installed with Nitinol SMA wire is considered for the
study. SMA wire bracing of / = 1 mm is taken. The frame is 2 m high, 1 m in length,
0.25 m wide and incorporated with SMA dampers as diagonal and X-bracings as
shown in Figs. 4 and 5 respectively. Circular columns and floor beams of diameter
8 mm and 10 mm are used at the upper and lower storey respectively.
Fig. 4. Frame with diagonal bracing (unit: m). Fig. 5. Frame with X-bracing (unit: m).
The non-linear hysteretic behavior of the Nitinol damper is taken into account as
shown in Fig. 6.
SMA as a Potential Damper in Structural Vibration Control 489
Fig. 6. Stress-strain curves of SMAs showing non-linear hysteretic behavior: (a) at low
temperature and (b) at high temperature [12].
The results indicate that the SMA braced frame performs much better than the
traditional steel braced frame when subjected to the same acceleration due to under-
ground Blast Induced Ground Motion (BIGM) (Table 1).
Majumder et al. (2015) also studied the performance of SMA wire braces in another
three-storey steel frame subjected to underground blast [13].
4 Conclusions
The results have revealed the suitability of SMA as a device to mitigate the vibration of
framed structure when subjected to ground acceleration due to BIGM. The performance
of SMA as a damper has been evaluated by modeling the framed structure in standard
finite element software.
SMA as a Potential Damper in Structural Vibration Control 491
SMA Nitinol dampers have reduced the response to about 90% over the steel
bracings which have reduced the response to about 75% of that of the uncontrolled
structural response. The structural response time histories also show an excellent re-
centering capability of SMA as the response dies down only in a fraction of a second.
As a result, the structure regains its original configuration after the blasting effect in
almost no time.
If the Nitinol-based SMAs are used as small devices or if they are applied judi-
ciously over certain selected portions of a structure economically feasible solutions can
be obtained. Also extra fabrication costs can be avoided as SMA device has a very
straight and simple method of design. So the SMAs have huge potential in reducing the
structural response due to underground blast induced support motions of structures.
Future Scope. For further accurate evaluation of the effectiveness of the damper, the
research may be extended through a large number of case studies to see the extent of
similar effects on space frame under unidirectional and bidirectional ground motions.
The number of storeys and number of bays may be varied further to have an idea about
the variation of the effect in general multi-storied structures.
Acknowledgement. The authors acknowledge a part of the idea generated during the second
author’s (Rohan Majumder) Masters thesis carried out under the guidance of Dr. Aparna
(Dey) Ghosh at Department of Civil Engineering, IIEST Shibpur, Howrah- 711103, India.
References
1. Olander, A.: An electrochemical investigation of solid Cadmium-gold alloys. Am. Chem.
Soc. 54, 3819–3833 (1932)
2. Vernon, L.B., Vernon H.M.: Process of manufacturing articles of thermoplastic synthetic
resins. US Patent 2234993 (1941)
3. Greninger, A.B., Mooradian, V.G.: Strain transformation in metastable beta copper-zinc and
beta copper-Ti alloys. AIMETRANS 128, 337–369 (1938)
4. Kurdjumov, G.V., Khandros, L.G.: First reports of the thermoelastic behavior of the
martensitic phase of Au-Cd alloys. Doklady Akademii Nauk SSR 66, 211–213 (1949)
5. Chang, L.C., Read, T.A.: Behavior of the elastic properties of AuCd. Trans Met Soc. AIME
191, 47–52 (1951)
6. Buehler, W.J., Gilfrich, J.V., Wiley, R.C.: Effect of low-temperature phase changes on the
mechanical properties of alloys near composition TiNi. Appl. Phys. 34, 1475–1477 (1963)
7. Kauffman, G., Mayo, I.: The story of Nitinol: the serendipitous discovery of the memory
metal and its applications. Chem. Educ. 2, 1–21 (1997)
8. Graesser, E.J., Cozzarelli, F.A.: Shape-memory alloys as new materials for aseismic
isolation. J. Eng. Mech. (ASCE) 117(11), 2590–2608 (1991)
9. Parulekar, Y.M., Reddy, G.R.: Nonlinear model of pseudoelastic shape memory alloy
damper considering residual martensite strain effect. Adv. Acoust. Vib. (2012). https://doi.
org/10.1155/2012/261896
10. Wu, C., Hao, H., Lu, Y., Sun, S.: Numerical simulation of structural response on a sand layer
to blast induced ground excitations. J. Comput. Struct. 82, 799–814 (2004)
492 S. C. Dutta and R. Majumder
11. Carvalho, E.M.L., Battista, R.C.: Response characteristics of structures subjected to blasting-
induced ground motion. Int. J. Impact Eng. 28, 813–828 (2003)
12. Corbi, O.: Shape memory alloys and their application in structural oscillations attenuation.
Simul. Model. Pract. Theor. 11(5–6), 387–402 (2003)
13. Majumder, R., Ghosh, A.: Performance study of a SMA bracing system for control of
vibration due to underground blast induced ground motion. structural engineering
convention (SEC 2014), IIT Delhi, India. Advances in Structural Engineering: Mechanics,
vol. 1, pp. 393–404. Springer (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/9798-81-322-2190-6_34
Study of Cutting Tool Durability
at a Short-Term Discontinuous Turning Test
Abstract. The article deals with study of cutting performance and its impact on
durability of cutting tool in a short-term alternate turning test. The short-time test
was carried out at discontinuous machining to increase an intensity of tool wear
and to reduce the time of the test. Two types of workpieces in shape of circular
segments with angles of 45° and 180° were prepared from material DIN 17200
that correspond to the STN 41 1373 (11 373) steel. Cutting plates, type of SPUN
120504, from the 19 830 steels with the tool holder type of CSSPR 2525
M12 KT 716 were used at the machining. The tests were realized based on the
standard ISO 3685 without cutting fluid. The process of machining and tool
wear was evaluated from the energy point of view. The machine input power
was measured by means of measuring equipment UNI-T UT232. The results
were statistically processed. Based on the results it can be said that the durability
of tools at the machining the 45° segment was higher. Also, the hypothesis
considering that the work of cutting wedge is constant during machining up to
the achievement of critical tool has not been confirmed.
1 Introduction
Despite the emergence of new technologies in recent decades, the machining tech-
nology is still actual and widely used in technical practice. Progress in the development
of new materials has also contributed to the intensive development of chip machining.
Basic principles and physical phenomena (plastic deformation, friction, heat transfer,
etc.) occurring in a cutting zone have been studied by many researchers for a long time.
Many experiments have been done to analyze relations and interactions between cut-
ting tool and a workpiece. It has been found that surface quality after machining and
tool durability are very important indicators of machining efficiency and they depends
on technological conditions [1, 2].
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 493–501, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_52
494 P. Pastucha et al.
There are several variables in the cutting process, which need to be in balance to be
the best durability of tool achieved. They are normal and shear stresses along with
material, tool geometry, technological and thermal conditions, etc. [3]. The researchers
have found out that the minimal tool wear occurs at the lowest friction coefficient using
optimal cutting speed, taking into account the fact that the values of normal and shear
stresses, which appear in a contact area, change during the machining [4, 5]. The tool
wear can be defined as a loss of its cutting ability that is usually connected with the loss
of material at the cutting edge of tool, with formation built-up edge or with change in
geometry of tool. It is also related to tribological processes occurring in the cutting area
as an outcome of chemical and thermal impacts [6–8]. The material of a tool needs to
have a specific set of attributes such as temperature ability, strength, hardness and
thermal conductivity, but one of the most important properties of tool life is its wear
resistance. The selection of material for a suitable tool is dependent on the method of its
wear or destruction. This selection is given by the tool material and work conditions,
which affect the method of the tool wear [9].
Researcher Wagner with his colleagues [10] studied conditions of the tool wear.
They have found out that the process of tool wear is divided in several phases, which
are related not only to the cutting process, but also to the chip formation. Heat transfer
and temperature in the cutting zone along with attrition between the cutting tool and
removed material affect the built-up emergence and its growth rate, what has a great
impact on the tool wear and subsequently also on the quality of machined surface [11].
The relation for durability according to EN ISO 3685 is defined as follows: [12]
Durability tests are usually divided into two categories: short-term and long-term
tests. In practice, short-term durability tests are used more frequently due to the time
saving and economy. They are often used for input checks of workpiece materials,
respectively for fast comparing durability of tested cutting tool with an etalon [16].
Base on the theory mentioned above, the objective of this paper was specified. It is
focused on determination of the cutting performance and its impact on the durability of
the cutting tool in a short-term alternate turning test.
2 Conditions of Experiments
The short-term test, at which the material is removed by facing, appears as one of the
effective method to find out the durability of the cutting tool. It is based on the
machining a disk with larger diameter (Dmax is about 300 mm). Cutting is carried out in
radial direction, from the pre-drilled coaxial hole in centre of the disc, towards the
periphery of the disk. It means that the cutting speed gradually increases and at a
specific diameter Dn the cutting speed reaches a maximum value vn, at which the
cutting ability of the tool material is lost. The basic necessities for the procedure of
cutting life testing by facing are: [17]
– every experimental tool has to be designed with the same cutting wedge geometry,
– new cutting wedge is used at every test,
– cutting depth ap and feed per revolution f are constant,
– it is needed to specify correctly number of tools to be a relevant statistical signif-
icance has been reached.
The short-term tests are characterized by high efficiency, short time needed for
experiments, by material saving, sufficient accuracy and undemanding request for
measuring facilities. The principle of short-term durability test by facing is shown in
Fig. 1.
A possible alternative of the short-term test by facing described above is the method
of discontinuous cut (Fig. 2) that lead to the higher intensity of tool wear. The
workpiece (3) is radially positioned on a disc with large diameter (1). The cutting tool
(5) cuts off the material from the workpiece in circular sections [12].
Two workpieces prepared in shapes of circular segments with angles of 45° and
180° were clamped on the disc by means of dovetail groove and secured by bolts. They
are shown in Fig. 3. The disc was clamped into the lathe spindle.
The lathe SV 18 RA was used during the experiments, because it was able to
ensure: adequate rigidity of technological set, stability of operating speed frequency,
sufficient power output, sufficient rigidity and clamping range of jaw and sufficient
maximal diameter of the workpiece.
Machined material was DIN 17200 that correspond to the STN 41 1373 (11 373)
steel. Tools from High Speed Steels were used during the experiments. More specif-
ically, they are five cutting plates (marked P1–P5), type of SPUN 120504 made from
Study of Cutting Tool Durability at a Short-Term Discontinuous Turning Test 497
the 19 830 steels, geometry and dimensions of which are determined by standard ISO.
Gradually all four corners of cutting plate (labelled A, B, C and D) were used at the
machining. The shape and labelling of cutting plate is shown in Fig. 4 [18].
The tool holder type of CSSPR 2525 M12 KT 716 was selected for these cutting
plates. The tests were realized based on the standard ISO 3685 at the following cutting
conditions: feed rate: 0.2 mm per revolution, depth of cut: 1 mm, frequency of spindle
speed for a short-term test: 180, 224 and 280 min−1.
Tests have been carried out without using cutting fluid what caused a faster wear of
cutting edges of the tool. The process of machining and tool wear was also evaluated
from the energy point of view. Due to this reason, the machine input power was
measured within the research and it was done by means of measuring equipment UNI-
T UT232. The results were statistically processed, while the data were evaluated by
means of the Grubs´ tests and the statistical significance along with quality of
regression function were evaluated by Fisher - Snedecor testing criterion.
The criterion for the cutting tool wear at the short-term durability test realized through
discontinuous machining was a reduction of the cut depth by more than 20%,
respectively complete destruction of the cutting edge. Measured diameters, at which the
critical wear has been occurred, are arranged in Table 1. Cutting feed 0.2 mm/rev was
the same at all tests.
Table 1. (continued)
Cutting Corner N0 Angle of The diameter at which the critical
plate [min−1] machined wear is achieved Dn [mm]
segment [°]
P3 A 180 45 / 443
B 224 45 / 352
C 280 45 / 278
D 180 180 / 410
P4 A 224 180 / 206
B 280 180 / 198
C 180 180 / 398
D 224 180 / 168
P5 A 280 180 / 157
B 180 180 / 374
C 224 180 / 356
D 280 180 / 168
The dependencies of radius Dn and cutting speed vC on the spindle speed for both
segments are presented in Figs. 5 and 6. The radius and cutting speed vC represent the
values, at which the critical wear has been occurred. It is clear from the graphs in
Figs. 5 and 6 that the dependencies of critical radius on spindle speed have decreasing
tendencies, similarly as it is at the dependency of critical cutting speed on spindle
speed, but the trend at 45° segment is very weak. The graphs also show that the cutting
tools´ wears have occurred at higher values of critical diameter Dn (or at critical cutting
speed vn respectively) during machining of 45° segment, so it can be said that the
durability of tools at the machining of material segment with angle 45° was higher.
Fig. 5. The dependency of critical radius Rn= Dn/2 and cutting speed vC on the spindle speed.
The measured input power of the turning machine was multiplied by its efficiency
to obtain the dependency of cutting performance on time. The example of one of these
dependencies, plotted for the cutting plate P4 at the machining with corner “C”, is
shown in Fig. 7. It can be said (based on dependency plotted in Fig. 7) that cutting
performance linearly increasing with time increasing.
Study of Cutting Tool Durability at a Short-Term Discontinuous Turning Test 499
The area bounded by the curve in the graph above specifies the work (energy) that
the tool has performed until complete losing of its cutting ability. The work was
calculated for all cutting plates in dependency on spindle revolution and it was done
during “effective cutting time”. The effective cutting time is the time, during which the
tool was in contact with the workpiece. The results are presented in Fig. 8.
4 Conclusion
The experiments presented in the article were carried out at discontinuous machining,
what is a special type of short-term test of tool durability. During the research, the
hypothesis considering that the work of cutting wedge is constant during machining up
to the achievement of critical tool, has been verified wear. This hypothesis has not been
confirmed, because the amount of work has increased with the cutting speed up to tool
wear.
Based on the results it can be said that less energy was spent at the machining of the
45° segment than at machining of 180° segment, what resulted in higher durability of
cutting tool at machining of 45° segment. The important effect on tool durability
probably had a temperature. At machining of 45° segment, the cutting tool was
engaged in machining process only the 1/8 of spindle revolution, so the tool could be
cooled more intensively during the rest of spindle revolution than it was at machining
of 180° segment. Due to these reasons, the objective of authors´ research in a close
future is to realize new short-term tests of tool durability, at which the temperature in
cutting area will be observed.
Acknowledgement. The paper originates with the direct support of Ministry of Education of
Slovak republic by grants VEGA 1/0795/19, KEGA 001TUZ-4/2017 and APVV-17-0380.
References
1. Petru, J., et al.: Influence of cutting parameters on heat-affected zone after laser cutting.
Techn. Gaz. 20(2), 225230 (2013)
2. Monka, P., et al.: Multivariant process plans design in relation to the European market. In:
DAAAM Symposium, Trnava, Slovakia, pp. 901–902 (2008)
3. Baksa, T., et al.: Durability of cutting tools during machining of very hard and solid
materials. In: 25th DAAAM International Symposium, Vienna, vol. 100, pp. 1405–1413
(2015)
4. Smeringiova, A., et al.: Experimental analysis of the dynamics of gear boxes - Part 1. Tech.
Mess. 82(2), 57–64 (2015)
5. Zetek, M., Zetkova, I.: Increasing of the cutting tool efficiency from tool steel by using
fluidization method. In: 25th DAAAM International Symposium, Vienna, vol. 100,
pp. 912–917 (2015)
6. Monka, P., et al.: Design and experimental study of turning tools with linear cutting edges
and comparison to commercial tools. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 85(9–12), 2325–2343
(2016)
7. Malotova, S., et al.: Roughness evaluation of the machined surface at interrupted cutting
process. Manuf. Technol. 16(1), 168–173 (2016)
8. Misik, L., et al.: Side milling factors analysis affecting the surface irregularities of high-grade
steel E295. Techn. Gaz. 15(2), 19–23 (2008)
9. Jurko, J., et al.: Verification of cutting zone machinability during the turning of a new
austenitic stainless steel. Adv. Comp. Sci. Edu. Appl. 202(2), 338–345 (2011)
10. Wagner V., et al.: The relationship between the cutting speed, tool wear, and chip formation
during Ti-5553 dry cutting. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 76(5–8), 893–912 (2015)
Study of Cutting Tool Durability at a Short-Term Discontinuous Turning Test 501
11. Monkova, K., et al.: Inverse processing of undefined complex shape parts from structural
high alloyed tool steel. Advances in Mechanical Engineering, art. num. 478748 (2014)
12. Vasilko, K.: Theory and practice of machining, FMT TU Kosice, p. 532 (2009). ISBN 978-
80-553-0152-5
13. Twardowski, P., et al.: Investigation of wear and tool life of coated carbide and cubic boron
nitride cutting tools in high speed milling. Advances in Mechanical Engineering 7(6), 1–9
(2015)
14. Monkova, K., et al.: Newly developed software application for multiple access process
planning. Advances in Mechanical Engineering, pp. 39071–39071 (2014)
15. Kazimir, I., Paulikova, A.: Cutting tools durability and reliability of their evaluation, Cutting
tools – internal documents, Computer Technology Company, Bratislava, division Presov,
Slovakia, pp. 35–37 (2010)
16. Cep, R., et al.: Surface roughness after machining and influence of feed rate on process. Key
Eng. Mater. 581, 341–347 (2014)
17. Monkova, K., et al.: The research of the high speed steels produced by powder and casting
metallurgy from the view of tool cutting life. Appl. Mech. Mater. 302, 269–274 (2013)
18. Somsak, M.: Results correlation of short-term and long-term test characteristics of cutting
tools durability, Diploma thesis, p. 72 (2011)
Behavior of the Beam with a Lightweight
Porous Structure in Its Core
1 Introduction
New, more lightweight materials with better mechanical properties have started to be
used in practice with an effort to reduce costs and make production more effective. In
terms of their use in technical practice, the most important property is their correct rate
of compressive strength to weight [1]. At the same time, the component has to meet
specific criteria to avoid premature damage and thus the failure of the whole device.
The properties of these materials offer a wide range of porous structures applications, at
which the classical materials would be difficult to use [2].
Low density and a weight allow the creation of light and rigid components such are
filled profiles and large portable structures in the automotive, aviation and construction
industries [3]. Production of such structures is allowed by the current development of
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2019
S. Hloch et al. (Eds.): ICMEM 2018, LNME, pp. 502–510, 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-99353-9_53
Behavior of the Beam with a Lightweight Porous Structure in Its Core 503
the 3D printing technology of metallic and non-metallic materials, while the per-
spective of their use in the aerospace, automotive or engineering industries as well as in
other sectors of the economy is indisputable [4]. The rocket engine with porous
structures designed by Mr. Jurg and manufactured by the AMAERO Company is
presented in Fig. 1. Structural optimization has ensured weight savings while main-
taining the desired stiffness. This lattice structure also promotes an even cooling of the
engine and its contents, typically fueled by liquid hydrogen that must be stored at
−252.882 °C [5].
Fig. 1. Application of a fine lattice into the wall of an engine’s shell [5].
Regarding the facts mentioned above, the research within the presented article was
aimed to determine the influence of the volume ratio of the solid phase on the behavior
of the simple beam with the lightweight porous structure. This is so-called lattice
structure that is defined by a set of struts oriented in different directions with a different
cross-section. The struts with a circular cross-section have been selected within the
research. The shape, size, and density of the grid structure are important parameters that
have to be kept so the component handles load [6].
Currently, there are many articles dealing with the topic of porous structures.
Researchers in these articles investigate not only mechanical but also physical prop-
erties of different types of porous structures, which are made from various materials.
Porous structures are divided into several groups. They can be geometrically
defined or undefined with random geometry. The second type are usually called foams.
Another parameter is a topology of the structures, which can be open or close. Closed
structures are characterized by completely impassable cavities [7]. Contrary, open
structures have cavities which are interconnected and therefore allow a flow of liquids
through their volume. Geometrically defined porous structure is a structure that is
504 J. Tkáč and M. Pollák
geometrically or mathematically definable and due to this property, they are repro-
ducible in one, two or three non-collinear directions [8]. This group of porous materials
can also be distinguished according to the type of a matrix which indicates the location
of series of basic units (cells) in space. The most common matrix form is cubic, but
there are also circular, polygonal, cylindrical and other matrixes [9]. One of the
advantages of the geometrically defined structures is a fact that their mechanical
properties can be influenced not only by the appropriate choice of material, but also by
the topology of the structure and volume ratio, which can be advantageously used in
designing the component for a specific application [10].
In 2013 Mr. Hussein has investigated the manufacturability and mechanical
behavior of advanced lightweight cellular structures in metal AM processes. The cel-
lular structures used in his research were based on Triple Periodic Minimal Surface
(TPMS) cell topologies. Comprehensive experimental tests were conducted at different
cell topologies using commercially available 316L stainless steel, Titanium alloy (Ti-
6Al-4V), and Aluminum alloy (AlSi10Mg) metal powders. Research has revealed that
the use of graded cellular support structures has improved the manufacturability of the
supported part. The potential material saving combined with multi-functionalities make
the structures suitable for internal lightweight and external support structure applica-
tions at metal additive manufacturing [11].
In 2016, Mr. Hanzl dealt with the influence of volume ratio of special type of the
porous structure, made from tool steel by DMLS technology, on its loading capacity. In
the final measures, he found out that there is a dependence between the volume ratio of
solid phase and the bearing capacity of this special structure [12].
In 2018 Koehnen and others dealt with mechanical properties and deformation
behavior of additively manufactured lattice structures of stainless steel. They used the
powder bed fusion selective laser melting (SLM) technique to build two different lattice
structures showed comparable specific energy absorption with respect to volume ref-
erence samples. The plastic deformation behavior of various lattice structures was
assessed by considering the geometric and microstructural aspects [13].
Regarding the fact that majority of the papers presented so far have dealt with the
properties of the porous structures under pressure load or tension load, the originality of
this research lies in investigation of the behavior of the porous structure at the bending.
3 Research Conditions
The static stress analysis and the modal analysis using the finite element method
(FEM) were selected as a preliminary study of the dynamic analysis to determine the
behavior of the selected porous structure. Static analysis is usually used for specifi-
cation of model stresses and deformations of in response to loads and subject to
specified constraints [14].
A static analysis can provide to the researcher following information [15]:
• whether the material in the model will handle stress,
• whether the part might break (stress analysis),
• at which place the component might break (strain analysis),
Behavior of the Beam with a Lightweight Porous Structure in Its Core 505
The thickness of the beam shell was constant with the value of 2.5 mm and its core
was filled with the porous structure. Since it is a basic research, the simple lattice
structure (Fig. 1) was chosen with a cell size of 25 25 25 mm. The change of the
volume ratio was controlled by the change of the circular cross-section size of the
struts, which were in the range from / 3 mm to / 8 mm.
The beam was designed in accordance with the requirements of the DMLS tech-
nology so that the residual metal powder from inside of the beam could be removed
after the completion of the production. One end of the beam was built-in and the other
was loaded with the static force of 1500 N. The size of the elements at the network
creation within the FEM analysis has been modified in regard to the cross-section of the
struts (the size of the elements has reduced with the reduction of the cross-section). At
the full-volume solid beam, the maximum element size was 5 mm. Usually about
218 000 finite elements have been created and the analysis takes about 4 h. The
boundary conditions of the analysis are shown in Fig. 3.
506 J. Tkáč and M. Pollák
All the beams that differ only in volume ratios were analyzed in the same conditions.
The volume ratio of the beam is given by the equation [18]
Vcss
V¼ 100 ½% ð1Þ
VFull
where V is a value of the volume ratio in [%]; VCSS is a volume of solid phase in a beam
with a porous structure; VFULL is a volume of a beam that did not contain porous
structure. The example of static analysis result of the beam with the cross-section size
of 3 mm is shown in Fig. 4.
The final values of stresses and displacements after static analyses of beams with
different volume ratios are recorded in Table 1.
The processed results of the static analysis are plotted in Fig. 5. It is clear from the
graph that with volume ratio increasing, the stress value drops more significantly than
the displacement.
Behavior of the Beam with a Lightweight Porous Structure in Its Core 507
The dependency of stress per the unit of solid phase is plotted in Fig. 6. It is clear
from the graph that the volume unit of solid phase with lower volume ratio is able to
handle a greater load than volume unit with higher volume ratio. With increasing
volume fraction, the value of stress per unit volume of solid material decreases
exponentially. This finding is similar to the result of Mr. Hanzl [12].
Modal properties of two beams were analyzed within the research. The first one
was the beam with volume ratio of the 44.53% at the cross-section size of strut 6 mm
and the second one was the full-volume beam. The first 6 modes with their natural
frequencies are shown in Table 2.
508 J. Tkáč and M. Pollák
22.72 Hz 20.59 Hz
72.51 Hz 81.59 Hz
141.67 Hz 128.69 Hz
372.53 Hz 360.56 Hz
432.92 Hz 489.52 Hz
Behavior of the Beam with a Lightweight Porous Structure in Its Core 509
5 Conclusion
Acknowledgment. The present contribution has been prepared with direct support of Ministry
of Education of Slovak Republic by the projects KEGA 007TUKE-4/2018, VEGA 1/0795/19
and APVV-17-0380.
References
1. Misik, L., et al.: Side milling factors analysis affecting the surface irregularities of high-grade
steel E295. Tech. Gaz. 15(2), 19–23 (2008)
2. POSTERUS Homepage. http://www.posterus.sk/?p=7861. Accessed 15 May 2018
3. Monkova, K., et al.: Inverse processing of undefined complex shape parts from structural
high alloyed tool steel. Adv. Mech. Eng. 6, 478748 (2014)
4. Petru, J., et al.: Influence of cutting parameters on heat-affected zone after laser cutting.
Tech. Gaz. 20(2), 225–230 (2013)
5. 3D Printing Industry Homepage. https://3dprintingindustry.com/news/monash-additive-
manufacturing-postdoc-reimagines-rocket-engine-design-betatype-118049/. Accessed 15
May 2018
6. SCULPTEO Homepage. https://www.sculpteo.com/blog/2017/05/24/optimize-your-3d-
printed-parts-with-lattice-structures. Accessed 15 May 2018
7. Monkova, K., Monka, P.: Qualitative parameters of complex part produced by additive
approach. In: ICMAE 2017, Prague, Czech Republic, pp. 130–134 (2017)
8. Challis, V.J., et al.: High specific strength and stiffness structures produced using selective
laser melting. Mater. Des. 63, 783–788 (2014)
510 J. Tkáč and M. Pollák
9. Saranathan, V., et al.: Structure, function, and self-assembly of single network gyroid
(I4132) photonic crystals in butterfly wing scales. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 107(26),
11676–11681 (2010)
10. Monkova, K., et al.: Study of 3D printing direction and effects of heat treatment on
mechanical properties of MS1 maraging steel. Arch. Appl. Mech., 1–14 (2018, in press)
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00419-018-1389-3
11. Hussein, A.Y.: The development of lightweight cellular structures for metal additive
manufacturing, Ph.D. thesis, 228 p. (2013)
12. Hanzl, P., et al.: Cellular lattice structure produced by selective laser melting and its
mechanical properties. In: Proceedings of the 26th DAAAM International Symposium,
Vienna, Austria, pp. 748–752 (2016)
13. Kohnen, P., et al.: Mechanical properties and deformation behavior of additively
manufactured lattice structures of stainless steel. Mater. Des. 145, 205–217 (2018)
14. Cizikova, A., et al.: Numerical and experimental modal analysis of gear wheel. MM Sci. J.,
1232–1236 (2016). https://doi.org/10.17973/mmsj.2016_11_201654
15. Beards, C.: Structural Vibration: Analysis and Damping, 286 p. Arnold, London (1996).
ISBN 340-64580-6
16. Valicek, J., et al.: Analysis of signals obtained from surfaces created by abrasive waterjet by
means of amplitude-frequency spectra and autocorrelation function. Tech. Gaz. 15(1), 25–31
(2008)
17. Make it from Homepage. https://www.makeitfrom.com/material-properties/AISI-415-1.
4313-X3CrNiMo13-4-S41500-Stainless-Steel. Accessed 15 May 2018
18. Monkova, K., et al.: Three approaches to the gyroid structure modelling as a base of
lightweight component produced by additive technology. In: CMSAM 2017, pp. 124–129.
DEStech Publications, Lancaster (2017)
19. Dobransky, J., et al.: Monitoring diagnostic indicators during operation of a print machine.
Adv. Sci. Tech. Res. J. 9(28), 34–39 (2015)
Advanced Preparation of the NC Programs
with Usage of Strategy Manager
1 Introduction
workpieces to control the immediate cross-section of the removed layer and apply
the optimal feedrate within the specified feed rate range. They can also optimize
spindle speed or cutting velocity [7].
3. Optimization programs integrated into CAM systems - optimization program
resp. the module is directly integrated into the CAD/CAM system. Their main
functions include motion detection and movement of tool movements, machining
analysis, optimization of cutting conditions. It also allows user to reduce machine
time, wear machines and tools, and improve the quality of machined surfaces [1].
These optimization programs and modules are at the most of times designated
exclusively to optimizing of NC programs. However, there is also other group of
applications which allow to optimize process of NC program preparation. Those
programs are described in following chapter.
The features are standardized shapes, that can be used for analysis, assembly, function,
design and manufacturing. From a machining point of view, the features are generally
defined as a set of related geometric elements that correspond to certain production
process or which may be used to select suitable manufacturing procedures for creating
this geometry. Essentially, the process of recognition is done by comparing information
with a database containing the conditions for the definition of the features. The Features
for manufacturing can be divided into several basic groups: surfaces, steps, pockets,
Advanced Preparation of the NC Programs with Usage of Strategy Manager 513
Fig. 1. Strategy manager (Edegcam2017 R2) with roughing NC strategy for pockets.
Fig. 3. Basic NC strategies for A-drilling holes, B-drilling and countersinking holes, C-drilling,
counterboring and countersinking holes.
Advanced Preparation of the NC Programs with Usage of Strategy Manager 515
4 Application
For experiments were chosen six different models of components. These parts share
several similar features that differs by dimensions. First four components contain only
2D features (on Fig. 5), last two components contain complex 3D surfaces (on Fig. 6)
(Figs. 7 and 8).
Fig. 7. Time required to create complete machining sequence with and without the strategies
use for components 1–4.
Fig. 8. Time required to create complete machining sequence with and without the strategies
use for components 5 and 6.
Advanced Preparation of the NC Programs with Usage of Strategy Manager 517
5 Conclusion
References
1. Císar, M., Kuric, I., Čuboňová, N., Kandera, M.: Design of the clamping system for the CNC
machine tool. In: MATEC Web of Conferences, vol. 137, p. 01003. EDP Sciences (2017)
2. Čuboňová, N.: Genetic algorithms implemented for optimization of technological processes.
In: Chosen Applications of Computer Modelling in Mechanical Engineering, pp. 157–181.
Pearson Education Limited, London (2015)
3. Dodok, T., Čuboňová, N., Rudawska, A.: Creation of strategies by use of edgecam strategy
manager. In: Strojírenská technologie: časopis pro vědu, výzkum a výrobu. Roč. 21, č.
1 (2016)
4. Kuric, I.: Dynamic classification system. In: Chosen Applications of Computer Modelling in
Mechanical Engineering, pp. 135–154. Pearson Education Limited, London (2015)
5. Dodok, T., Čuboňová, N., Rudawska, A.: Analysis of shapes for the development of
algorithms for strategies of machining process in the CAM system. In: Computing and
Solutions in Manufacturing Engineering, Braşov, Romania (2016)
6. Dodok, T., Čuboňová, N., Kuric, I.: Workshop programming as a part of technological
preparation of production. Adv. Sci. Technol. Res. J. 11(1), 111–116 (2017)
7. Kuric, I., Zajačko, I., Císar, M.: Analytical intelligence tools for multicriterial diagnostics of
CNC machines. Adv. Sci. Technol. Res. J. 10(32), 59–64 (2016)
Modeling and Validation of Spindle Shaft
Followed by Goal Driven Optimization
1 Introduction
The spindle bearing system is one of the most critical mechanical components in
machining center. The machine tool spindle not only supports the work piece and
cutting tool but also rotates at very high speed. Therefore, the spindle design has a
direct impact on material removal rate and the accuracy of the finished part. The
structural properties of the spindle directly affect the machining productivity and finish
quality of the work pieces. The spindle structural properties depend on parameters of
the shaft, bearings, drive, tool holder, and the design configuration of the overall
spindle assembly. The effects of variations of structural parameters on static and
dynamic properties of spindle is well studied [1]. Study by Vadgeri et al. [2] shows that
static and fatigue analysis should take into account different cutting forces and belt
tensions in the drive for safer spindle design. Today’s modern machine tool demands
the capabilities to produce parts of high accuracy and precision. Therefore, researchers
have studied the concept of intelligent spindle to investigate monitoring and control of
tool condition, spindle balance, spindle collision, temperature/thermal error, chatter,
and spindle health [3]. Thermal distortion of spindle is another factor leading to con-
siderable dimensional errors on machined components. Experiments are conducted to
study the effect of spindle rotational speed and corresponding thermal distortion of the
tool center point [4]. In past, thermal errors in spindle have been investigated by
developing analytical models and it is observed that thermal loads have significant
effect on spindle design. Moreover, these analytical models have been used for spindle
design optimization subjected to thermal loads [5]. Researchers not only used exper-
imental and analytical methods but also used numerical methods to perform spindle
design calculations due to increased complexity of the system. Altintas and Cao pre-
dicted the static and dynamic deflections of spindle shaft including contact forces on
the bearings using numerical simulations before physical building and testing of the
spindles [6]. Numerical optimization studies for spindle design are used to obtain a
smooth cutting operation at the desired speed and depth of cut for a given cutter [7].
Over the years, spindle system has evolved and it is one of the complex and critical
system. Moreover, there is thrust on making light weight machine tools. Traditional
approach of fail-safe design for machine centers leads to over-sized machine tool
design including spindle bearing system. Over-sized spindle design affects the per-
formance characteristics of the machine center and should be optimized. Therefore, this
work presents a methodology for design optimization of spindle shaft that is subjected
to uniformly distributed load. In this work analytical as well as numerical methodology
is presented for a goal driven optimization of spindle shaft design. The approach is
called goal driven because analytically calculated bearing span is used as a design
variable with specific range to minimize mass within permissible deflection limits.
Bosch India Ltd., is designing and developing a new grinding machine (see Fig. 1a)
to use for surface finishing of plunger body (one of the Bosch Company’s product)
as a preparatory procedure for C-coating. This new machine is expected to reduce
cycle time as well as space occupied, by providing multi stations for plunger body
using indexer unit. The indexer unit has four stations to reduce cycle time. While
grinding operation is in progress, loading of plunger body is performed at two other
stations using indexer plate. One of the critical aspects in this machine tool design is to
maintain the deflection of spindle shaft within permissible limit at plunger body.
Moreover, another objective is to reduce mass of spindle bearing system as much as
possible to readily mount four such systems on indexer plate.
For predicting the performance characteristics of the spindles accurately requires
integrated modeling of all spindle elements and mounting on the machine tool [8].
Initially, analytical model for spindle design subjected to uniformly distributed pressure
on work piece (or plunger body) has been developed based on conventional beam
theory to predict the deflection distribution of the shaft as it controls the stability of
spindle. In this work, the stepped spindle is transformed into uniform spindle with
cross-section of the largest value of stepped spindle as proposed by Ai-Shareef and
Brandon [9]. This analytical model is validated by performing structural analysis using
BEAM188 element in ANSYS. Thereafter, analytical model is used to calculate
520 K. Roshan et al.
optimum bearing spacing for minimum deflection. Further, optimization studies are
performed using several spindle design parameters as variables in order to obtain
a chatter/vibration-free cutting operation at the desired speed and depth of cut for
a given cutter. The GDO model uses mass reduction as an objective function and
deflection as design constraint within ANSYS.
The spindle bearing system consists of spindle shaft bolted with spindle nose, gear
drive, bearing support and spindle housing. Cylindrical plunger body is subjected
to uniformly distributed load for finishing purpose and held rigidly in position between
collet and dead center. Figure 1b shows the spindle shaft system used in present study.
Table 1 lists geometrical parameters and dimensional values used in this study.
The free body diagram (FBD) of spindle system is shown in Fig. 2 along with
plunger body for the given loading condition. The shaft is subjected to radial load (wg )
due to gear drive system and uniformly distributed pressure (w=l) on plunger body and
Modeling and Validation of Spindle Shaft 521
Rr & Rf are reactions at bearings R & F respectively. The shaft is considered as simply
supported and reaction Rh is due to dead center as hinge point at H i.e. end of the
plunger. The spindle system is in static indeterminate form as there are three unknown
reactions. Therefore, superposition principle must be used to find the reactions Rr ; Rf
and reaction Rh .
The spindle design should be checked for lateral deflection considering it as a beam
where the resultant/total defection d of the spindle system comprises the deflection
of the spindle due to bending moment db , and the yield of the bearing due to elastic
deformation dy . These deflections are superimposed to calculate the overall deflection
of the spindle (d) [10].
522 K. Roshan et al.
The process of mathematical modeling for spindle shaft involves three stages [10, 11]:
1. Calculation of deflection distribution of spindle axis due to bending (see Fig. 3),
2. Calculation of deflection due to compliance of spindle supports (See Fig. 4), and
3. Superposition of the spindle deflections to calculate total deflection.
Where, Vind,, Mind are induced shear force and moment at each step of the shaft
Vr, Mr are actual shear force and moment acting upto each step of the shaft
In is the moment of inertia of largest diameter of stepped shaft
I1, I2 are the two succeeding moment of inertia at each step of the shaft
This analysis is repeated to find an induced shear and bending moment at each step
in the shaft. The induced force and moment becomes applied forces to a uniform shaft
with a moment of inertia I n . The loading and reaction forces from the stepped spindle
shaft must be scaled to provide equivalent applied forces on the uniform shaft.
The calculated equivalent applied forces Wge and We are given by Eqs. 3–4. Similarly,
the calculated equivalent reactions Rre ; Rfe and Rhe are given by Eqs. 5–7:
I3
Wge ¼ Wg ð3Þ
I1
I3
Rre ¼ Rr ð5Þ
I2
I3
Rfe ¼ Rf ð6Þ
I2
I3
Rhe ¼ Rh ð7Þ
I4
The uniform beam shown in Fig. 5 can be easily analyzed to find deflection dis-
tribution using conventional beam theory and singularity functions. The singularity
functions are represented by expressions in < >. If the value of the expression within
these brackets is less than zero the function becomes zero (i.e. <2–4> 2 = 0).
524 K. Roshan et al.
The integration constants C1 & C2 are obtained by applying the following boundary
conditions dy ¼ 0 at x ¼ B þ C and dy ¼ 0 at x ¼ L þ B þ C:
h i h i
W
C1 ¼ 6Lge ðB þ LÞ3 B3 V 6L
1
ðB þ L þ C l1 Þ3 ðB þ C l1 Þ3 M
2L
1
½ðB þ L
i 2 ð10Þ
þ C l1 Þ2 ðB þ C l1 Þ2 Rre6L
Wge 3 V1 M1
C2 ¼ B ðB þ C l1 Þ3 C1 ðB þ CÞ ðB þ C l 1 Þ2 ð11Þ
6 6 2
ðdf þ dr Þ ðx B CÞ ðdr LÞ
db ¼ ð12Þ
L
The values of elastic deformation at bearings due to loading given by df & dr are
calculated using formulations as given in handbook [11].
After individual contribution of deflections i.e. elastic spindle deflection dy (Eq. 9)
and deflection due to bearing compliance db (Eq. 12), total deflection is calculated
using method of superposition and given by Eq. 13.
dT ¼ dy þ db ð13Þ
h
Wge 3 Rre 3 Rfe 3
dT ¼ EI1 6 hx Ci þ C1 x þ C2 þ 6 hx B Ci þ 6 hx L B Ci
D3 E4 P
W l
24 x 2 A L B C
e
þ R6he hx l A L B Ci3 þ nk¼1 V6 k hx lk i3 ð14Þ
P i ðd þ d Þ xBC d L
ð Þ ðr Þ
þ nk¼1 M2 k hlk i2 þ
f r
L
The FEA model is developed to validate the mathematical model derived in earlier
section for calculating the lateral deformation of the spindle. The model of spindle is
created using BEAM188 element in ANSYS. There are 80 beam elements in the
meshed model which are good enough to obtain accurate solution for deflection of
spindle. The dimensions of model are given in Table 1. Hinge supports are created at
bearing and dead center locations. The plunger body is considered as integral part of
spindle and applied with line pressure as w=l and point load at gear position as wg .
Figure 7 shows detailed FEA model used in the present study. The deflection of beam
obtained by FEA solution at any particular section is compared with calculated values
obtained by mathematical model at same location (see Table 2) and percentage error
doesn’t exceed 8%. Therefore, it can be concluded that the FEA approach used in this
section is reasonably accurate and can be further used for FEA based goal driven
optimization of spindle shaft.
526 K. Roshan et al.
This section presents a Goal Driven Optimization (GDO) of spindle shaft design.
The objective of study is to minimize the spindle mass. GDO is carried out using
Design Exploration module within ANSYS [13]. Table 3 shows design variables and
constraints used in the present work. Among several design variables, the spacing
of the bearings (L) is one of the important parameter. Either it minimizes deflection
or maximizes chatter free machining at the desired speed region for a given geometry
and work piece material [4]. In the present work, range of L is obtained by differen-
tiating dT with respect to L and equated to zero.
ddT
¼0 ð15Þ
dL
h 3
We V2 V3
0¼ 6 x 2l A L B C þ 2 hx b=2 L B C i2 þ 2 hx A L
2 2 2
B Ci þ M2 hx b=2 L B C i þ M3 hx A L B Ci ð16Þ
ðdf þ dr ÞðxBCÞÞ
L2
bound of L. Moreover, spindle should have stiffness (SL ) greater than 35 kgf/micron
[11]. This can be ensured by satisfying the following condition.
D1:33
L 2
ð17Þ
k0:33
Where,
D2 diameter of the spindle between bearing
k = 0.05 for average accuracy
k = 0.1 for high precision machines
After creating parametric model of spindle in ANSYS using parameters shown
in Table 3, a GDO is initiated. The first step towards GDO is to create a DOE followed
by response surface and optimization [13]. The final results obtained by optimizing
parametric values are candidate points which fulfill the objective function. Figure 8
shows sensitivity bar chart obtained from ANSYS. From sensitivity chart, it is con-
cluded that spindle nose diameter affects geometrical mass of system and spindle nose
length affects total deflection. In the bar chart negative values of sensitivities indicates
inverse relation for corresponding parameters.
Figure 9 shows response surfaces representing variation of geometric mass as a
function of two most sensitive parameters i.e. spindle shaft inner diameter (P5) and
spindle nose diameter (P6). It shows P5 should be increased and P6 should be
decreased to minimize the mass.
Figure 10 shows the trade-off chart between geometric mass and total deflection
which both of them are contradictory to each other. The feasible points are shown as
green points which give minimum mass range with permissible deformation.
528 K. Roshan et al.
Table 4 shows the three candidate points as optimum solution and their mutual
variation with design parameters. The objective function of mass reduction is suc-
cessfully achieved with deformation less than the permissible values. The initial mass
of the spindle was 2.3 kg which is reduced to 1.4 kg and by mounting such four
spindles gives mass reduction of 39.1%.
Modeling and Validation of Spindle Shaft 529
6 Conclusions
This work presents methodology for design optimization of spindle shaft that is sub-
jected to uniformly distributed load. In this work analytical as well as numerical
methodology is presented for a goal driven optimization (GDO) of spindle shaft design.
Some of the main conclusions of this study are:
• The analytical model for deflection distribution of spindle shaft gives a generalized
equation. This model is verified successfully by performing FEA using ANSYS.
Percentage error between analytical model and FEA model doesn’t exceed 8%.
• Further MATLAB based technique is used to obtain minimum value of bearing
spacing (L) which is one of the critical design variables.
• A Goal Driven Optimization (GDO) is proposed as an optimization method with
spindle mass as an objective function and total deflection as a design constraint.
• GDO yields three optimum solutions which reduces spindle mass by 39.1%.
This compact design has helped to select smaller size of indexing unit which leads
to cost benefits to the company.
530 K. Roshan et al.
• GDO technique also allows designer to know the critical design parameters
affecting mass and total deflection. In the present study spindle nose diameter affects
geometrical mass of and spindle nose length affects total deflection
• The proposed method allows the designers to virtually test the spindle model
and improve design parameters to cope with targeted machining applications.
• This technique would be much helpful for designing of high speed spindles required
in most of advanced manufacturing operations.
References
1. Reddy, V.R., Sharan, A.M.: The finite element modelled design of lathe spindles. Static
Dyn. Anal. 109, 407–415 (1987)
2. Vadgeri, S.S., Patil, S.R., Chavan, S.T.: Static and fatigue analysis of lathe spindle for
maximum cutting force. Mater. Today Proc. 5, 4438–4444 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
matpr.2017.12.012
3. Cao, H., Zhang, X., Chen, X.: The concept and progress of intelligent spindles: a review.
Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 112, 21–52 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2016.
10.005
4. Grama, S.N., Mathur, A., Aralaguppi, R., Subramanian, T.: Optimization of high speed
machine tool spindle to minimize thermal distortion. Procedia CIRP 58, 457–462 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2017.03.253
5. Liu, T., Gao, W., Zhang, D., Zhang, Y., Chang, W., Liang, C., Tian, Y.: Analytical modeling
for thermal errors of motorized spindle unit. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 112, 53–70 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2016.09.008
6. Altintas, Y., Cao, Y.: Virtual design and optimization of machine tool spindles. CIRP Ann.
Manuf. Technol. 54, 379–382 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/S0007-8506(07)60127-9
7. Gagnol, V., Bouzgarrou, B.C., Ray, P., Barra, C.: Stability-based spindle design, vol. 129,
pp. 407–415 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1115/1.2673400
8. Cao, Y., Altintas, Y.: Modeling of spindle-bearing and machine tool systems for virtual
simulation of milling operations. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf. 47, 1342–1350 (2007). https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2006.08.006
9. Brandon, J.A.: On the quasi-static design of machine tool spindles, 204 (1990)
10. T.I. Central Machine, CMTI.pdf, 1st Editio, Mcgraw Higher Ed. (2001)
11. Joshi, P.H.: Machine Tools Handbook - Design and Operation (2007). https://doi.org/10.
1036/0071494359
12. Maeda, O., Cao, Y., Altintas, Y.: Expert spindle design system. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf
45, 537–548 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmachtools.2004.08.021
13. Canonsburg, T.D.: ANSYS Mechanical User’s Guide, 15317, pp .724–746 (2013)
Modeling and Simulation of Technological
Factors in Bakery Industry
1 Introduction
profound and aggregate analysis could lead to vital measures and possibilities for
optimization targeting the performance of the bakery industry in Romania.
It is very appropriate for Romanian entrepreneurs in the field to quickly change
their philosophy if they want to adapt to the managerial “war” that moves from the
traditional industry into the distribution and service industry, from west to east, and
from north to south. It is vital for businesses to associate in networks capable of
meeting the interests and expectations of consumers [1]. There are mutations of phi-
losophy, from information sharing and added value, to trust in a partnership by power
transfer to retailers. The transfer does not stop here. It is an evolution towards the full
power of the consumer, awaiting permanent satisfaction - enthusiasm - by the
location/entity that gives him/her the maximum of functional and especially emotional
characteristics.
World experience shows that the strategic solution is the partnership on the logistics
distribution/supply chain. The shift of power to retailers forces manufacturers to change
their strategy, starting from the technological and communications revolution that has
brought greater informational advantages to EPOS holders (Electronic Point of Sale –
electronic registers), which, based on ultra-fast and detailed processing, through the bar
code and soon with the radio frequency label (RFID), can show the brand of products,
orders, create customer segments, can automate the shop, with great customer benefits
through prices and food safety, but also for the organization, through costs, inventory,
business security.
Purchasing management plays an important role in creating value, ensuring con-
tinuity of supply, efficient and economical purchasing, inventory management, in order
to deliver high customer service and low storage costs [2].
Order management includes cargo inventory verification activities and determining
the quantities to be ordered in response to customer needs or strategy policies [1].
However, from the point of view of the bakery products market, this is currently the
most used distribution model for finished products and, at the same time, it is the model
that allows use without negative consequences on other distribution models, in its own
shops or through distributors on certain routes on which the manufacturer does not
activate.
The power of retailers is not only due to their association or growth through
investments, mergers or acquisitions. When we talk about the new power of retailers as
a new strategic direction in business, we start from the very low profitability they have,
namely 1–2% on turnover (with a few exceptions, like WallMart, with a return of 3–
4%), which, on the reverse side, forces partners (wholesalers, manufacturers or sup-
pliers) to dramatically reduce their costs, working together to meet any buyer/consumer
requirement as quickly as possible and at a very low price. At this time, the power of
bargaining of retailers, which are comprised in different competing logistics chains, has
increased and is increasing considerably. Retail has become an industry in most
developed countries [8]. Big transnational firms that have also entered the Romanian
market have had a delicate start in the past 1–2 years.
Modeling and Simulation of Technological Factors in Bakery Industry 533
In order to analyze all the factors influencing the production and distribution of fresh
baked products in the bakery industry, aimed at improving physical production, we
chose to group the factors with significant impact in the following categories: supply,
storage, production, consumers, marketing, maintenance, transport and human
resources.
The dominant feature of all identified factors is the competitiveness and the added
value to the company in the market.
All given data, monetary sums, percentages and analyses are done in close col-
laboration with a local manufacturer from bakery industry. Analyzed company is
operating a distribution channel as presented in the Variant 4, with predetermined
routes. All the results are subject of further research on industry level both locally and
nationally.
Supply
Depending on the financial situation of the company, suppliers are willing to collab-
orate and offer different offers both in terms of freight transport and sufficiently large
payment terms. However, there must be a set of conditions to be able to benefit from
these offers: accessibility with large scale means of transport up to the factory, avail-
ability to purchase larger quantities and a lower frequency, which also means more
storage space [10]. These factors are met only by large factories, located predominantly
in the city outskirts.
Storage of Raw Materials and Materials
All factors that influence the storage of raw materials such as warehouse capacity,
receipt of goods, handling of raw materials, except for a low number of raw materials
requiring special storage conditions and direct consumption of electricity for storage at
the recommended temperature, the other inventories do not generate direct costs and,
having the necessary storage space at hand, we can assume that they are insignificant or
are found in the costs of the TESA (technical, economical, social and administrative)
staff of the receiving company and the directly productive personnel who handles them
from the warehouses to production.
Production
Production volume is a factor that directly influences unit cost per product but also has
a chain-reaction effect in terms of impact on transport costs.
A diversified assortment reduces productivity due to the operations before pro-
duction, but increases the management costs related to supply and storage, inventory,
etc.
The company’s flexibility to adapt to market requirements is very low and the time
needed for compliance is long, generating additional costs and investment [9]. In terms
of product range, it takes weeks or even months for a new product to be prepared and
marketed, compared to the direct sale that allows the factory to put the new product on
the shelf and available to consumers on the same day.
Machinery currently used in bakeries are powered by gas or electricity, so in total
production costs we can identify significant expenses with gas and electricity.
Modeling and Simulation of Technological Factors in Bakery Industry 535
According to the information from the analyzed unit, they amount to a total of about 5–
7% of the price of the finished product.
Marketing
The long payment terms used by the increased competition in this field lead to situa-
tions that affect the conduct of the company’s business. Basically, if a factory credits its
customers for more than 7–10 days, talking about products that cannot be stored and
which have been sold from the shelf, and the stores must be constantly supplied, then it
needs to borrow money from suppliers and from banks in order to carry on its business.
Thus, we can consider that a percentage of the product’s price is represented by this
cost generated by the need for money, both through long payment terms, low cash
flow, or inefficient stock management.
Large firms are exposed to a real danger, i.e. that of focusing on large customers,
which also account for a large share in total sales. This can cause sudden and drastic
changes in production [5].
For companies that opt for their own distribution system, the real advantage is
accessing a large market and supplying all communities in a particular area, even if
they are not merged into one place [7]. Also, by working with a large number of
customers, identifying and replacing one does not cause problems for production and
does not jeopardize the profitability of the distribution route. However, there is a
continuing need for promotion and investment in a brand that is recognized and
appreciated by consumers and customers, ensuring its presence on store shelves.
The costs of promoting and investing in one’s own brand can reach up to 10% of
the income, but in Romania, small and medium bakery resort to the minimum nec-
essary to carry out their business, preferring to offer a price that is as small as possible.
Thus, we shall consider a marketing cost with the promotion of the company, the
products and the brand of 1% of the total price of the product.
Maintenance
The total costs of maintaining the storage and production areas, maintenance of the
fleet and the IT equipment within the company at optimal parameters at represent 2.5%
of the factory’s monthly turnover. This is average, and it can be reflected over time in
various forms, by replacing equipment and making new acquisitions, general renova-
tions or leasing of new vans when maintenance costs are unjustified, given the situation
in which operating the machines in an emergency state or stopping production or
distribution causes considerably greater losses than replacing these machines.
Starting from the necessity to renew the car fleet with a frequency of 10 years/car,
we can determine a cost that will be reflected in the price of the products. Thus, a van
that transports daily products worth a total of 1600 lei, has a value of about 150 000 lei
which, distributed over the entire 10-year life span, represents a daily cost of 50 lei. As
a percentage, the cost of amortization of the transport vans is 3%.
Transport of Bakery Products
According to the information provided by a local manufacturer using the preset dis-
tribution channel, transport costs for bakery/pastry products are significant.
In relative terms, the percentage may vary between 4 and 5% (the cost of fuel
consumption in the price of the finished product).
536 A. D. Pop et al.
Human Resources
In a bakery production unit, 3 large categories of employees can be identified: auxiliary
staff, represented by administrators, accountants, management and directly productive
staff: production and packaging, distribution drivers.
In the analyzed unit, TESA staff is represented by 8 people with a cost of about
10% of the finished product price.
Also, the personnel carrying out the production and packaging activities is repre-
sented by 26 persons, the cost of which represents 25% of the final product price.
Drivers distributing finished products contribute 5% of the total cost of finished
products.
From this analysis we can see that a bakery unit has very high staff costs, which
account for over 40% of the total cost of the finished product.
A visual presentation of all identified factors can be seen below in the form of
an Ishikawa fish bone chart
See Fig. 2.
3 Conclusions
4 Research Directions
Once we identify the factors that influence the entire distribution process, based on the
analysis presented, we can also identify the existing algorithms and write the algo-
rithms that can be used to improve the production and physical distribution in the
bakery field, to be tested in practice on companies operating in production and dis-
tribution of bakery products.
Our immediate steps in the current research is to test the identified factors and
determine the relevance of their influence on a larger scale among the bakeries that use
their own distribution system based on predefined routes.
The factors that most influence the entire production and distribution process
specific to the bakery industry must be found in a mathematical algorithm designed to
identify deficiencies in a production unit, based on the input given by its management.
The validation of the proposed algorithm and formalizing the entire experiment in a
software program accessible to bakeries.
Factors with the highest competitiveness level will play a key role in the final
algorithm that enable managers in bakery industry to track and improve much faster the
gaps in the distribution chain.
References
1. Acu, D., Acu, M., Dicu, P., Dicu, A.M.: Matematici Aplicate in Economie (Mathematics
Applied in the Economy). Universitatea Lucian Blaga, Sibiu (2015)
2. Bayles, D.: E-commerce Logistics and Fulfillment: Delivering the Goods. Prentice Hall,
New York (2001)
538 A. D. Pop et al.
3. Baramel, J., Simchi-Levi, D.: The Logistic of Logistics. Theory, Algorithms, and
Applications for Logistics Management. Springer, New York (1997)
4. Breuer, R., Winter, K.H.: Marketing Management. Editura Gabler, Wiesbaden (2000)
5. Benoun, M., Héliès Hassid, M.L.: Category mangement: mythes et réatités, art. Revue
Française du Marketing. nr. 198 (2004)
6. Oliver, R.K., Webber, M.D.: Supply Chain Management: Logistics Catches Up with
Strategy. Logistics, London (1992)
7. Stern, L.W.: Marketing Channels, 7th edn. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs (2006)
8. Ţole, A., Zirra, D.: Analiza Economico – Financiară. Editura ProUniversitaria, Bucureşti
(2006)
9. Ungureanu, M., Pop, N., Ungureanu, N.: Innovation and technology transfer for business
development. Procedia Eng. 149, 495–500 (2016)
10. Ungureanu, M.: A model for product innovation project. In: International Conference on
Production Research - Regional Conference Africa, Europe and the Middle East and 3rd
International Conference on Quality and Innovation in Engineering and Management (ICPR-
AEM 2014), pp. 489–492. (2014). http://apps.webofknowledge.com/full_record.do?product=
UA&search_mode=CitationReport&qid=24&SID=N243zW8iJdxxZfytkRA&page=1&
doc=2. (ISI Proceedings)
11. Ungureanu, N., Duval, P., Mocan, M.L., Tăucean, I.M.: Logistica Activităților de
Mentenanță. Editura Universității de Nord, Baia Mare (2010)
12. Vişean, M.O.: Tehnologii comerciale. Editura ASE, București (2004)
Numerical Study of Rapid Cooling
of Injection Molds
1 Introduction
of the entire cycle time [2, 3]. For this reason there has been a growing tendency to
minimize the cooling time by lowering the mold temperature. This approach would
allow reducing the cooling time and in consequence, an increase the production effi-
ciency [2]. On the other hand too low temperature of forming walls is the main cause of
molding’s defects, including short shots, visible joining lines and sink marks, defor-
mations, excessive internal stresses, diesel effect, warp and others [4].
Mentioned factors has a huge impact on necessity of looking for new methods of
molds cooling systems with possibility of its rapid temperature control. For this reason
engineers invented technology called Rapid heat cycle molding (RHCM), that has been
dynamically developing around the world for over a dozen years [5, 6]. In the RHCM
the forming surfaces are rapidly heated to a high temperature (even melt filling tem-
perature) in key places and next quickly cooled after melt filling [7]. Increasing the
temperature of forming surfaces can be achieved by applying various methods such as
induction heating, infrared heating, resistance heating, hot – gas heating or steam
heating [8]. In the case of such a process control, contact of the hot, liquid plastic with
the cold forming wall is avoided, what limits or even eliminates the molding’s defects
[8]. High temperature of forming walls makes it possible to accurately replicate the
surface topography of the mold cavity through the melted polymer [9]. Described
activities allow to avoid previously presented problems, however they negatively
influence the cycle time. This is why the development of an effective cooling system
that will overcome the additional time for heating is so important aspect.
Modern development trends in the field of plastic industry, like RHCM technology,
result from a desire to improve the quality of manufactured parts with simultaneous
minimizing costs and production time. In consequence, the factors that play essential
role in the abovementioned process are the proper selection of cooling method and
designing the cooling system, which provides effective heat transfer.
2 Simulation Research
Within this paper, there are undertaken the simulation research under the problem of
efficiency of the cooling channels with various geometry, to test their applicability in
the RHCM technology. The main aim of this study is to present the investigation
process and obtained results, that allow comparing the effectiveness of cooling process
with commonly used drilled channels. Simulation research are performed by using the
Finite element method (FEM) in the commercial software environment ANSYS Fluent.
The analysis establish the Transient State and the turbulent models (k-e).
Fig. 2. Geometries of considered cooling channels: (a) smooth drilled Ø8, (b) ellipse, (c) square,
(d) finned M4H08, (e) finned M8H08.
It is assumed that the diameter of smooth channel equals Ø8 mm (rn = 4 mm), the
angle b of the fin is 3°, the cross-sectional area of fluid flow A is constant for each
shape and equals 50.264 mm2 and cavity insert is made of steel 1.2311. The ther-
mophysical properties of steel and water (chosen coolant), are shown in Table 1.
@q
þ r ðquÞ ¼ 0 ð1Þ
@t
where q-density of the fluid; u-axial velocity.
@u
q þ u r ðquÞ ¼ rp þ lr2
uþF ð2Þ
@t
where µ-fluid dynamic-viscosity; F-body forces; p-pressure.
@
ðqEÞ þ r ðuðqE þ pÞ ¼ r ½keff rT h þ ðseff
uÞ ð3Þ
@t
where keff-effective conductivity; h-sensible enthalpy; T-temperature; seff-stress tensor;
E-total energy.
qw D h
Nu ¼ ð4Þ
kðTw Tb Þ
where Dh-hydraulic diameter; qw-the average heat flux at outer tube wall; k-thermal
conductivity of the fluid; Tw-tube-wall temperature; Tb-bulk temperature.
qum Dh
Re ¼ ð5Þ
l
2ss
f ¼ ð6Þ
qu2m
Like was said before the numerical transient state simulation of the flow through
various cooling channels is considered to investigate and solve the fluid flow and the
heat transfer in injection mold. The commercial available CFD software, Fluent is used
to solve the governing equations of continuity, momentum and energy. The standard
k-e turbulence model is selected. Further, a Second Order Upwind scheme is assumed
to discretize momentum, Turbulent Kinetic Energy, Turbulent Dissipation Rate and
Energy equation. The flow distribution is solved by using the Semi-Implicit Method for
Pressure-Linked Equations iterative algorithm.
The temperature responses of the point ‘B’ on mold cavity Surface (Fig. 1) for
various geometries of cooling channels are shown in Fig. 3. However, Fig. 4 presents
the cooling profile of average temperature of the entire insert. It can be observed that in
both cases the lowest temperature is noted for channel with 8 fins. By contrasting
cooling process for smooth channel and for channel with eight fins, it can be find that
the difference of the temperature is around 6 °C/20 s, that gives approximately 2.7 °C/s
for finned and 2.3 °C/s for smooth channel. Slightly higher temperatures are seen for
channel with four fins, which lead to conclude that the configuration of eight fins
ensures higher efficiency of the heat transfer. Moreover, it can be stated that the cooling
dynamics decline with the passage of time. After analyzing results received for
channels Ø8, ellipse and square (Fig. 4) it is clearly seen that differences of the tem-
perature are insignificant.
Like was said before, temperature uniformity of the cavity insert surface during and
at the end of the cooling phase is desired factor. The temperature distribution along the
cavity surface for all considered cases is shown in Fig. 5. As was mentioned earlier, the
minimal temperature for smooth channel achieved a value of 103.58 °C, while for the
544 P. Muszynski et al.
Fig. 3. Results of cooling process obtained Fig. 4. Average temperature of cooling inserts
at the measuring point (B). with different channels.
finned channel M8H08 is 97.33 °C. Furthermore, a thermal distribution on the surface
of the cooling insert with the finned channel is characterized by higher uniformity and
lower temperature gradients in selected zones. However, the results are not spectacular
because the model of simulation insert is equipped with only two channels due to limits
the number of numerical calculations. In general, more cooling channels are used to
ensure high uniformity and balanced heat removal.
To more clearly show the correlation between the geometry of the cooling chan-
nels, flow state of working fluid and the heat transfer, the dependencies of the Nusselt
number (Nu) on the Reynolds number are plotted in Fig. 6. It can be observed that as
the Reynolds number increase from 2000 to 24000, the Nu rises for each cases. The
maximum Nu is reached in case of using finned channels (M8H08) and it increases
from 14.9 to 182.3. In contrast, the maximum Nu for smooth channel reaches 93.30
which is two times smaller than in the channel with fins. These are quite high results of
Nu but some other researchers proved, that it can reach very high level, before the flow
of the fluid reaches a fully developed state in a short inlet range [11, 12]. It shows that
fins, which are used in channels, are good solution to enhance the convective heat
transfer in injection molds working in the RHCM.
Numerical Study of Rapid Cooling of Injection Molds 545
Fig. 6. The Nu number on the Re number. Fig. 7. The friction factor (f) on the Re number.
Figure 7 presents the correlation of the friction factor on the Reynolds number.
It can be observed that the value of f decreases with the rise of Re for all examined
channels, which is consistent with the moody diagram. On this basis, it can be con-
cluded, that the fins cause the increase of friction factor, what can lead to increase of
flow resistance and thus adversely affects the pressure loss in the cooling system.
4 Conclusions
The simulation research of the cooling channels of various geometry, which can be
implemented in injection molds working in Rapid Heat Cycle Molding technology,
was showed and discussed in this paper. For this purpose, a series of simulation studies
on the efficiency of the heat transfer exchange process were made. Based on obtained
results, the following conclusions were made.
The most effective cooling process was noted in case of using channels with eight
fins. Comparing the obtained results of the temperature for insert M8H08 with insert
with conventional channel a difference of approximately 6 °C/20 s was recorded (about
2.7 °C/s for finned channel and 2.3 °C/s for drilled channel). The above dependence
allows to conclude, that the use of finned channels increases the efficiency of the
cooling process in the injections molds working in RHCM technology, and thus it will
enable the reduction of the production cycle time. This treatment will significantly
improve the economics of entire injection process and thus allows the increase of
profits of companies, which deal in plastic injection industry. In the cases of channels
of elliptical and square cross-section, the obtained results were similar to the results of
the conventional cooling channel.
The maximum Nusselt number was reached in case of using finned channels
(M8H08) and equals 182.3. In contrast, the maximum Nusselt number for smooth
channel reached 93.30. It shows the advantage of using finned channels over the
smooth ones.
546 P. Muszynski et al.
The implementation of finned cooling channels in cavity inserts requires the use of
WEDM (Wire Discharge Electric Machining) technology, which may increase the cost
of the cooling system. On the other hand the application of WEDM technology allows
to control the surface texture, what may have an impact on increasing the efficiency of
the heat transfer.
In order to verify the results of the simulation research, the injection mold with
cavity inserts equipped with the finned cooling channels should be designed and built.
It is necessary to carry out the injection molding process in a mold equipped with the
proposed cooling system in order to perform a series of tests of the manufactured
plastic moldings. First of all, the analysis of the influence of rapid cooling on the
mechanical properties of the moldings should be done. Furthermore, an analysis of the
impact of improving the efficiency and uniformity of cooling on the aesthetic properties
of the moldings will be also performed. Particular attention should be paid to the
stresses and deformations of the injected parts after it has been completely cooled.
References
1. Kurt, M., Kamber, S., Kaynak, Y., Atakok, G., Girit, O.: Experimental investigation of
plastic injection molding: Assessment of the effects of cavity pressure and mold temperature
on the quality of the final products. Mater. Des. 30(8), 3217–3224 (2009)
2. Chen, S.C., Jong, W.R., Chang, J.A.: Dynamic mold surface temperature control using
induction heating and its effects on the surface appearance of weld line. J. Appl. Polym. Sci.
101(2), 1174–1180 (2006)
3. Hassan, H., Regnier, N., Le Bot, C., Defaye, G.: 3D study of cooling system effect on the
heat transfer during polymer injection molding. Int. J. Therm. Sci. 49(1), 161–169 (2010)
4. Dawkins, E., Engelmann, P., Horton, K.: Color and gloss – the connection to process
conditions. J. Injection Molding Technol. 2(1), 1–7 (1998)
5. Guilong, W., Guoqun, Z., Huiping, L., Yanjin, G.: Analysis of thermal cycling efficiency
and optimal design of heating/cooling systems for rapid heat cycle injection molding
process. Mater. Des. 31(7), 3426–3441 (2010)
6. Lucchetta, G., Fiorotto, M.: Influence of rapid mould temperature variation on the
appearance of injection moulded parts. Strojniski Vestnik J. Mech. Eng. 59(11), 683–688
(2013)
7. Mrozek, K., Chen, S.C.: Selective induction heating to eliminate the fundamental defects of
thin – walled moldings used in electrical industry. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 134(26), 44992
(2017)
8. Guilong, W., Yang, H., Lei, Z., Guoqun, Z.: Research on temperature and pressure responses
in the rapid mold heating and cooling method based on annular cooling channels and electric
heating. Int. J. Heat Mass Transf. 116, 1192–1203 (2018)
9. Chen, S., Chang, Y., Chang, T., Chien, R.: Influence of using pulsed cooling for mold
temperature control on microgroove duplication accuracy and warpage of the Blu-ray Disc.
Int. Commun. Heat Mass Transf. 35, 130–138 (2008)
10. Vanaki, Sh.M., Mohammed, H.A.: Numerical study of nanofluid forced convection flow in
channels using different shaped traverse ribs. Int. Commun. Heat Mass Transf. 67, 176–188
(2015)
Numerical Study of Rapid Cooling of Injection Molds 547
11. Dirker, J., Meyer, J., Kohlmeyer, B.: Local heat transfer coefficients at the inlet of an annular
flow passage. Int. J. Heat Mass Transf. 113, 268–280 (2017)
12. Fenot, M., Dorignac, E., Giret, A., Lalizel, G.: Convective heat transfer in the entry region of
an annular channel with slotted rotating inner cylinder. Appl. Therm. Eng. 54, 345–358
(2013)
Influence of Fill Imbalance on Pressure Drop
in Injection Molding
1 Introduction
the part, air traps and extra weld lines [2]. Hence, the molding engineers attaches great
importance to establishing proper process of filling and packing phases and the
switchover point between them. The switchover filling-to-packing point problem was
presented by Huang et al. [3], Kazmer et al. [4] and Wang et al. [5].
In recent years, many engineers have been considering the imbalance flow in
injection molds, like in [6] or [7], wherein the most comprehensive studies have been
made by Beaumont [8]. Geometrically imbalance can occurs in the cavity or the entire
injection mold. In the case of cavity, the reason is the wrong choice of gate position,
what results that all the extremities of the cavity are not fill at the same time. However,
in the case of mold filling imbalances (in multi-cavity injection molds) the main cause
lies with the erroneously designed runner system, which does not ensure uniform filling
of all cavities. Furthermore, the flow of melted plastic in the runner system is quite
complex, because of its Non-Newtonian characteristic. The viscosity decreases with an
increase of the shear rate and temperature, what causes the second type of imbalance
fill, shear-induced [9].
The imbalance filling also results from the cavity pressure drops and the wrong
selection of filling-to-packing switchover moment. Like was said before, injection
molding is a cyclic process, which can be shown in the form of cavity pressure profile
(Fig. 1). The filling process starts at point 1 and is completed at point 3 – the moment
the cavity is volumetrically filled by the melted plastic without being compressed. At
point 3 there is a switchover from the filling phase to compression phase, what causes a
rapid pressure increase to peak value at point 4. Then the holding phase occurs, in
which an additional melted plastic can be pressed into the cavity to compensate for
material shrinkage during the cooling phase. The holding phase lasts until the moment
when the gate is frozen, as showed at point 5. The process ends with the cooling phase
during which in the heat is removed from the manufactured part [3]. To ensure the
550 P. Poszwa et al.
quality of the molded parts the crucial role during this process plays the switchover
from filling to packing point (point 3, Fig. 1). The significance of the switchover point
can be best presented by considering of switching too early or too late. Switching to
early can lead to the formations of burn marks as the plastic traps into the extremities of
the cavity wall, the opening of the mold, damage to the molding machine and mold as
well [10]. On the other side switching to early can lead to short shots due to insufficient
ram displacement and extends the entire injection process [10].
Considering above, mold filling imbalances and improper cavity pressure control
might be the most costly and misunderstood sources of problems in injection molding
industry today. Despite the fact that these phenomena are well known and undesirable,
they have not been examined in the proposed way yet, where pressure drop was
precisely estimated for different cases of fill imbalance.
2 Simulation Research
In this paper the relation between fill imbalance and injection pressure needed for
cavity filling were investigated with Autodesk Moldflow Insight software. In this
research several different shapes with thickness equal to 3 mm were analyzed: square
(100 100 mm), rectangle (50 200 mm), circle (100 mm) and modified square with
additional 25 25 mm square region located near one of the corners. Analyzed
geometries are presented at Fig. 2. Simulations were performed with Moplen HP500U,
where melt temperature was set to 240 °C, mold temperature was set to 30 °C and
injection time was set to 1 s. In case of square-shaped part two different thicknesses
were studied (1 mm and 5 mm). To analyze the effect of fill imbalance different
moments of V/P switch-over point were used (90%, 95% and 100% for different
thicknesses, 90%, 92%, 94%, 96%, 98% and 100% for different shapes).
In this study gates were singly placed at locations presented at Fig. 2 and were
marked in (X,Y) system with unitary increment: from the center of the part (0,0) to the
midpoint of the edge (5,0), from the midpoint of the edge to the corner (5,5).
Influence of Fill Imbalance on Pressure Drop in Injection Molding 551
Fig. 3. Relation between pressure drop and gate location for different V/P switchover for circle
geometry (left), relation between pressure drop and V/P switchover for different injection
locations for circle geometry (right).
The analysis was started from circle-shaped part, because it is possible to reach every
edge of the part in the same time. The lowest pressure drop was observed for gate
location at the center of the part. Move of the gate location led to almost 100% increase
of pressure drop. Significant rise of pressure drop was observed when gate was moved
to the edge (from point 4 to point 5). V/P switch-over point has insignificant influence
for gate localized in the center of the part. Fill imbalance led to significant increase of
pressure drop for V/P switch-over point above 98% of cavity fill (Fig. 3).
Fig. 4. Pressure drop for different gate locations of square geometry (thickness equal to 3 mm).
Each bar presents different V/P switchover (the thickest bar – 90%, the thinnest bar – 100%).
Next investigated geometry was square-shaped part. In this case only quarter of the
part were analyzed (Fig. 4) because of its symmetry. This part was investigated for 3
different thicknesses. For gate located in the center of the part and the lowest V/P
switch-over point pressure drop had almost the same value as for circle geometry.
552 P. Poszwa et al.
When V/P switchover was equal to 100% pressure drop for square part was higher by
15% in comparison to circle geometry. With shift of the gate location to the edge of the
part pressure drop rose linearly by almost 100% to 4,9 MPa. Shifting of the gate to the
corner of the part led to increase of pressure drop to 6,7 MPa. It means that the
strongest increase of the pressure drop is along the line from the center of the part to its
corner. The most significant influence of V/P switchover was observed along the line
from the center of the part to its corner and from the middle of the edge to the corner of
the part. The strongest increase of the pressure drop was observed when V/P switch-
over point was increased from 98% to 100%, especially at point (4,4) and (5,5). V/P
switchover has slight influence between 90 and 98%.
For the thinnest variant (Fig. 5) the insignificant increase of pressure drop was
observed along the line from the center of the part to its edge. For thin parts late V/P
switchover can drastically increase the pressure drop when fill imbalance is present.
Fig. 5. Pressure drop for different gate locations of square geometry (thickness equal to 1 mm).
Each bar presents different V/P switchover (the thickest bar – 90%, the thinnest bar – 100%).
Fig. 6. Pressure drop for different gate locations of square geometry (thickness equal to 5 mm).
Each bar presents different V/P switchover (the thickest bar – 90%, the thinnest bar – 100%).
Influence of Fill Imbalance on Pressure Drop in Injection Molding 553
For the thickest version (5 mm) the slight increase of pressure drop was observed
along the line from the center of the part to its edge and from the center to the corner of
the part. Huge increase was observed when gate was placed at the edge of part. It
means that the source of the pressure drop was not the flow length but fill instability
when the gate was at the edge (Fig. 6).
Next investigated part was the rectangle-shaped part. In this case the rise of
pressure drop was almost equal when the gate was moved to the shorter edge and when
the gate was moved to the corner. Shift of the gate along the shorter edge will not have
any significant impact on pressure drop of the part. In this case small influence is
observed when V/P switchover is moved from 90% to 100%.
The last analyzed part is modified square-shaped part ith natural fill imbalance
when gate is located at the center of base square. Addition of small square region has
significant impact at maximum pressure drop – the lowest observed value rose by
Fig. 7. Pressure drop for different gate locations of rectangle geometry. Each bar presents
different V/P switchover (the thickest bar – 90%, the thinnest bar – 100%).
Fig. 8. Pressure drop (MPa) for different gate locations of modified square geometry for V/P
switchover equal to 90%.
554 P. Poszwa et al.
around 30%. The regions where the lowest pressure drop occurred are placed around
(Figs. 7, 8, 9 and 10).
Points (0,1), (−1,1), (−1,0) instead of point (0,0) – what depended on V/P switch-
over point. Highest pressure drop was obtained when gate was located at (5, −5)
because of fill imbalance and the longest flow length. For this gate location V/P switch-
over point should be moved even to 96%. There are insignificant differences in pressure
drops along the edges and in the internal region of the part when mirrored regions are
considered.
Fig. 9. Pressure drop (MPa) for different gate locations of modified square geometry for V/P
switchover equal to 98%.
Fig. 10. Pressure drop (MPa) for different gate locations of modified square geometry for V/P
switchover equal to 100%.
Influence of Fill Imbalance on Pressure Drop in Injection Molding 555
4 Conclusions
In this paper the influence of geometry and gate location (as the source of fill imbal-
ance) on pressure drop was investigated. According to obtained results even for simple
parts (square in comparison to circle) fill imbalance can lead to significant increase of
pressure drop during filling of the cavity. This effect is visible when V/P switch-over
point is higher than 98%. For long parts insignificant difference was observed when
gate was moved along the shorter edge of the part. Addition of small regions can lead
to significant increase of needed injection pressure, especially for thin parts. For thick
parts the influence of gate location on pressure drop is visible, but its values are very
low and the effect can be neglected.
It was found that even slight imbalance can lead to the increase of pressure drop by
at least 20% and can be increased even to 100% if gate is placed in “unfavourable”
location (sometimes gate must be located in “unfavourable” region because of mold
limitations or optimal warpage by such operation). In such case more powerful
injection molding machine (with higher clamp force) becomes necessity, what
increases cost of the production. Additionally, higher injection pressure results with
higher power consumption during injection molding.
In many cases application of lower V/P switch-over point can be used to reduce
pressure drop. As presented in this paper, small shift of V/P switch-over point below
98% can reduce the pressure drop even by 25%, what is significant benefit for bigger
parts, especially when clamp forces are measured in hundreds of tonnes.
Future research will be concentrated on parts with additional features (ribs, bosses,
holes), more complex shapes and nonuniform part thickness. Further investigation of
fill imbalance phenomenon can provide the guidelines for injection pressure reduction
what will improve cost-efficiency of part manufacturing.
References
1. Mrozek, K., Chen, S.C.: Selective induction heating to eliminate the fundamental defects of
thin-walled moldings used in electrical industry. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 134(26), 44992 (2017)
2. Baesso, R., Salvador, M., Lucchetta, G.: Filling balance optimization for plastics injection
molding. In: Advanced Manufacturing Systems and Technology, AMST 2005, pp. 617–624
(2005)
3. Huang, M.S.: Cavity pressure based grey prediction of the filling-to-packing switchover
point for injection molding. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 183(2–3), 419–424 (2007)
4. Kazmer, D.O., Velusamy, S., Westerdale, S., Johnston, S., Gao, R.X.: A comparison of
seven filling to packing switchover methods for injection molding. Polym. Eng. Sci. 50(10),
2031–2043 (2010)
5. Chen, Z., Turng, L.H., Wang, K.K.: Adaptive online quality control for injection-molding by
monitoring and controlling mold separation. Polym. Eng. Sci. 46(5), 569–580 (2006)
6. Kim, J., Ahn, S., Atre, S.V., Park, S.J., Kang, T.G., German, R.M.: Imbalance filling of
multi-cavity tooling during powder injection molding. Powder Technol. 257, 124–131
(2014)
7. Kazmer, O.D.: Injection Mold Desing Engineering. Hanser, Munich (2007)
556 P. Poszwa et al.
8. Beamont, J.P.: Runner and Gating Design Handbook – Tool for Successful Injection
Molding, 2nd edn. Hanser, Munich (2007)
9. Poszwa, P., Brzek, P., Szostak, M.: Influence of proces parameters and runner geometry on
shear heating effect. Mechanik 1, 36–38 (2018)
10. Autodesk Inc. Moldflow Insight – Process Simulation Software. https://knowledge.autodesk.
com. Accessed 17 Mar 2018
Assessment of the Production Reducer
for Clamping the Drilling Tools
Abstract. The article deals with the evaluation of the production of the
reduction clamping mandrel on the milling machine. The reducer is designed to
clamp the drill tool with a 16 mm diameter cylindrical shank so that it can be
clamped into the clamping head of the drill with a maximum diameter of
13 mm. The clamping tool itself is secured with two screws. The billets of the
reducer are selected from the available manufactured steel parts, allowing it to
be maximally fast and meet the production criteria. The material of the joined
parts guarantees guaranteed weldability. The technological process, the method
of clamping and setting of the tooling was chosen so as to achieve the desired
deviations of co-ordination of the two coupled cylindrical components. Mea-
surement of the produced diameter of the reducer and evaluation of co-
ordination was done on the THOME 3D measuring instrument. It has been
measured the diameter and the deviation of the co-ordinates of the produced
cylindrical surfaces with a maximum value of 0.0053 mm, with a maximum
quadratic error of 0.003543 mm. The produced reducer clamp was tested for the
production of cylindrical holes by a 25 mm diameter drill. By measuring,
stamping and practical application of the clamping mandrel, the possibility of
replacing turning operations at the CNC milling center was confirmed.
1 Introduction
The cutting tool was generally perceived as a body whose surface is identical to the
machined surface and which has cutting edges on the surface to be able to cut off the
layers of material in the form of chips during the working movement. The functional
principle of all cutting tools consists in removing the layer of cutting material.
Wedge-shaped wedge. The work with chase removal is different in particular by the
kinematics of the machining process and the way the tool is used. He work with chase
removal is different in particular by the kinematics of the machining process and the
way the tool is used [1]. There are a variety of machining methods that was used to
remove chippings (drilling, milling, turning, drilling, etc.) [2]. Clamping tools were
used to clamp the tools. The most common method of clamping is by means of conical
and cylindrical stems [3]. Depending on the type of the spindle, the metric [4] and
Morse cones are used [5]. Important feature of the fasteners is their self-confident. This
is achieved either by shape surface [6], which is conical or coupling [8] is achieved by
means of a coupling [9].
Tangential water jet abrasion of the hybrid alumina matrix composite made by
electromagnetic blending technology from A359 aluminum alloy with a final work-
piece diameter of 14.5 mm was evaluated. The lowest average roughness value of
6.64 lm was obtained using olivine grains at an abrasive mass flow rate of 400 g/min.
The topographical detail of the machined surface revealed several cutting traces,
grooves and furrows which show the ploughing nature [10].
The untraditional construction of the turning tool has been carried out [11], com-
pared with the construction of commercial lathe tools to find new non-traditional tools.
Turning the metal matrix composites and surface quality evaluation has also been
dealt with [12] where they evaluated the impact of the feed rate, the depth of cut and the
surface roughness, which reached max. a value of 1.544 lm.
The thin-walled reducing clamping mandrel was did not made from full circular cross-
sectional material and was did not produced by turning technology. Reasons are the
subject of other chapters.
After alignment of the M16 threaded rod to 50 mm, and after the two ends were
bridged at 2 45°, the two components were screwed together, centered and welded
by an arc welding machine GAMA 166 OMICRON with an electrode EB 121 with
a diameter of 2.5 mm. After the weld was welded to the desired shape Fig. 3.
The last operation on the milling CNC machining center was the setting, clamping
of the reamer D16H8 Fig. 9 and reaming of the D16H8 hole Fig. 10.
562 P. Michalik et al.
Fig. 9. Adjusting and clamping reamer. Fig. 10. Reaming of diameter D16H8.
Assessment of the Production Reducer for Clamping the Drilling Tools 563
The measured values of the diameters D12f8 and D16H8 are shown in Table 1.
Table 1.
1 2 3 4 5
D12f8 11.934 11.945 11.947 11.948 11.946
D16H8 16.015 16.016 16.0168 16.0148 16.0155
6 7 8 9 10
D12f8 11.985 11.938 11.939 11.974 11.944
D16H8 16.0149 16.0163 16.01585 16.0168 16.0153
The co-axial alignment was evaluated based on the measured D12 and D16
diameters using the Thome Fig. 13 3D measuring device.
Fig. 14. The assembled thin wall reducing the arbor of a drilling tool with diameter 25 mm.
Assessment of the Production Reducer for Clamping the Drilling Tools 565
3 Discussion
The article deals with the design and assessment of nuclear production using milling
technology. Machining technology has been replaced by milling technology as a result
of a general overhaul of the lathe. The clamping mandrel of the reducer allows drilling
of a 16 mm drill bit with a diameter of 12 mm. The technological process, setting and
clamping of tools in the production of the reducer has been selected and executed in
order to achieve a tolerance for IT 8 accuracy.
4 Conclusion
For the production of a reduction mandrel, an unusual method of clamping the tools
and choosing a blank for the welding was used. The design of the reduction mandrel
was supplemented with M8 bore holes and then with a clamping tool with a diameter D
25 mm Fig. 14. Derived values of the measured values of the diameters for D12f8
where the left lower deviation is −34 lm the minimum difference of the deviation is
1.2 lm, a maximum difference of 6.6 lm. D16H8 where the upper deviation is
+28 lm, the minimum variation difference is 11.2 lm, the maximum difference is
13.2 lm. The maximum deviation of alignment 5.5 lm with quadratic error of
3.54 lm corresponds to the functionality of this production run. Practical use has
confirmed the correctness of production and the of measurement a reducer.
References
1. Murčinková, Z., et al.: Research and analysis of stress distribution in multilayers of coated
tools. Int. J. Mater. Res. 108, 495–506 (2017)
2. Fedorko, G., et al.: Failure analysis of textile rubber conveyor belt damaged by dynamic
wear. Eng. Fail. Anal. 28, 103–114 (2013)
3. Hosovsky, A., et al.: Preliminary investigation of static and dynamic hysteresis of DMSP-5
fluidic muscle. MM Sci. J. (2018)
4. Miko, E., Nowakowski, L.: Analysis and verification of surface roughness constitution
model after machining process. Procedia Eng. 39, 395–404 (2012)
5. Mantic, M., et al.: Influence of selected digitization methods on final accuracy of 3D model,
pp. 475–480 (2016)
6. Straka, Ľ., et al.: Properties evaluation of thin microhardened surface layer of tool steel after
wire EDM. Metals (Basel) 6, 95 (2016)
7. Liptai, P., et al.: Check measurements of magnetic flux density: equipment design and the
determination of the confidence interval for EFA 300 measuring devices. Meas. J. Int. Meas.
Confed. 111, 51–59 (2017)
8. Baron, P., et al.: Research and application of methods of technical diagnostics for the
verification of the design node. Measurement 94, 245–253 (2016)
566 P. Michalik et al.
9. Lehocka, D., et al.: Comparison of the influence of acoustically enhanced pulsating water jet
on selected surface integrity characteristics of CW004A copper and CW614N brass.
Measurement 110, 230–238 (2017)
10. Nag, A., et al.: Hybrid aluminium matrix composite AWJ turning using olivine and Barton
garnet. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 94, 293–2300 (2018)
11. Monka, P., et al.: Design and experimental study of turning tools with linear cutting edges
and comparison to commercial tools. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 85, 2325–2343 (2016)
12. Srivastava, V.S., et al.: Surface roughness a measurement of in-situ metal matrix composite
Al7075/B4C, vol. 6, pp. 358–362 (2017)
Evaluation of Damage of Almandine Garnet
Grains by N2 Adsorption Method
1 Introduction
Natural origin of almandine garnets and their properties are associated with the genesis
of these minerals, e.g. occurrence of primary cracks of natural origin, mineral inclu-
sions and others [1]. These properties influence the use of garnets in the AWJ tech-
nology, e.g. it influences the intensity of abrasive disintegration after passing through
the mixing chamber as described previously [2]. Further disintegration follows after the
interaction of garnet grains with a cutting material. This interaction has influence on the
cutting performance [2].
From the eco-technological and economical point of view, AWJ technologists are
interested in recycling of garnet of suitable grain shape and granularity. Therefore, the
sedimented disintegration slurry is removed after the AWJ cutting process and used for
recycling. Resulting recyclates that are reused during the AWJ cutting can have new
defects in the garnet structure either of the natural or technological origin [1]. These can
be cracks or inclusions which can have influence on the cutting performance [2].
In our previous studies, the evaluation of sustainability and damage of grains was
performed by classical methods - optical microscopy [3], density [2, 3], morphology
[2], grain size [3], shape etc. [3] However, these methods are not entirely sufficient for
quantitative evaluation of these damages.
The method we used allows quick quantitative measurement of some surface
parameters and obtained results provide better information about the damage of
material than some traditionally used methods.
The aim of this study was to investigate the possibility of application of a simple N2
adsorption method for determination of the type and intensity of internal grain damage
of industrial garnet abrasives. Specific surface area, pore volume and pore distribution
can be used as potential parameters for this determination.
2 Experimental Method
Table 1. Summary of values of the specific surface area of garnet grains (SBET), total pore
volume (VTPV) and classification of materials.
Sample SBET VTPV total Average grain Type of Classification of Type of pores
m2/g pore volume size and S.D. isotherm hysteresis loop
cm3/g µm
Input 0.03 0.000149 263 (64) II. nonporous or
almadine macroporous
garnet AG80 material
AGR1 0.21 0.000705 177 (50) IV. mesoporous ink-bottle-shaped pore
Recyclate 1 material, H2
AGR2 3.27 0.009628 22 (17) IV. mesoporous slit-shaped pore;
Recyclate 2 material, H3 lamelar, disordered
structure
and separation processes. In the figure, the cracks and inclusions are evident [1]. These
cracks have influence on the shape, size and resulting pore structure of grains in the
original garnet product [3]. After the use of the AWJ, all parameters were changed and
became worse detectable by the optical method.
Fig. 1. Thin section of muskovite-garnet schist with an almandine garnet grain [3]. There is
an illustration of the inner structure of the grain with dark fine mineral inclusion and natural cracks
of tectonic origin. Polarized-light optical microscopy, subparallel Nichols. Scale in slide. [3]
Fig. 2. N2 adsorption isotherms of the AG80 (a) almandine garnet and AGR1 Recyclate 1 (b),
AGR2 Recyclate 2 (c).
Evaluation of Damage of Almandine Garnet Grains 571
Fig. 3. Types of hysteresis loops and their corresponding pore shape [11].
Fig. 4. Cumulative (red) and differential (green) curves calculated from the adsorption branch of
isotherm using the BJH model for the input almandine garnet AG80 (a) and its recyclates AGR2
Recyclate 2 (b), AGR1 Recyclate 1 (c).
Evaluation of Damage of Almandine Garnet Grains 573
4 Summary
According to the results obtained, the almandine garnet grains can be divided into three
groups using the N2 adsorption method, specifying the nature or degrees of the grain
damage:
1. Nonporous or macroporous materials with minimum damage of grains - the input
almandine garnet grains (type AG80).
2. Mesoporous materials with the ink-bottle-shaped pores - garnet grains after the
AWJ cutting and recycling (AGR1). This type of almandine garnets contains some
inclusions which can be released from the garnet surface.
3. Mesoporous materials with the slit-shaped pores or disordered structures, probably
created due to the breakdown of the almandine garnet (e.g. recyclate AGR2).
Results obtained from the N2 adsorption method show that the use of garnet grains
for the AWJ technology causes changes in their pore structure. Comparing them to the
original garnet grains, degree of the grain damage is determined.
The main result of the testing is that this method can be applied in the quantitative
characterization of technological properties of abrasives and can save the time.
Obtained results can be used for overall assessment of the usability of garnet recyclates
in the AWJ technology, avoiding constant mining of new materials, which negatively
affects our environment. In this regard, the issue of recycled abrasives creates space for
the development of effective separation processes and equipment.
Currently, the experiments on determination of abrasive parameters still continue
and the cutting performance of recyclates is investigated on various types of materials.
After realization of these experiments, the used garnets and their recyclates will be
classified according the cutting efficiency.
In these experiments, one genetic type of garnet is used [3], i.e. the commercial
almandine garnet and its recyclates. Next research will be focused on the second type
of garnets [3]. The study will be extended to the testing of new sources of abrasives, not
only garnets. The parameters will be further used as the input information on garnets in
computational models which can predict the interaction of the water jet with abrasives.
These issues are solved in the cooperation with the colleagues from the Institute of
Geonics of the CAS [12]. The results can be interesting for the prediction of abrasive
cutting performances.
Acknowledgement. This article was written within the scope of a project of the Institute of
Clean Technologies for Mining and Utilization of Raw Materials for Energy Use – Sustainability
Program, (Reg. No. LO1406) and project LM201584 Research Infrastructure for Geothermal
Energy, financed by MEYS Czech Republic.
574 L. Ruppenthalova et al.
References
1. Martinec, P.: Granáty pro technologie vysokotlakého vodního paprsku (Garnets for AWJT).
VŠB-Technical University, Ostrava, MS (1994). (in Czech)
2. Martinec, P., Foldyna, J., Sitek, L., Ščučka, J., Vašek, J.: Abrasives for AWJ cutting.
Institute of Geonics AS CR, INCO-COPERNICUS no. IC 15-CT98-0821, Ostrava (2002).
ISBN 80-86407-02-0
3. Martinec, P., Hlaváček, P., Ruppenthalova, L., Sitek, L.: Properties and characteristics of
recycled garnet abrasives for AWJ. In: Klichová, D., Sitek, L. (eds.) VODNÍ PAPRSEK
2017 -VÝZKUM, VÝVOJ, APLIKACE, pp. 101–125. Institute of Geonics of the CAS,
Ostrava (2017)
4. Rouquerol, J., Avnir, D., Fairbridge, C.W., Everett, D.H., Haynes, J.H., Pernicone, N.,
Ramsay, J.D.F., Sing, K.S.W., Unger, K.K.: Recommendations for the characterization of
porous solids. Pure Appl. Chem. 66(8), 1739–1758 (1994)
5. Brunauer, S., Emmett, P.H., Teller, E.: Adsorption of gases in multi-molecular layers. J. Am.
Chem. Soc. 60(2), 309–319 (1938)
6. ISO 9277:2010. Determination of the specific surface area of solids by gas adsorption – BET
method (2010)
7. Barrett, E.P., Joyner, L.G., Halenda, P.P.: The determination of pore volume and area
distributions in porous substances. I. Computations from nitrogen isotherms. J. Manag. Eng.
24(4), 207–216 (2014)
8. Sing, K.S., Everett, D.H., Haul, R.A.W., Moscou, L., Pierotti, R.A., Rouquerol, J.,
Siemieniewsha, T.: Reporting physisorption data for gas/solid systems with special reference
to the determination of surface area and porosity. Pure Appl. Chem. 57(4), 603–619 (1985)
9. Thommes, M., Kaneko, K., Neimark, A.V., Olivier, J.P., Rodriguez-Reinoso, F., Rouquerol,
J., Sing., K.S.W.: Physisorption of gases, with special reference to the evaluation of surface
area and pore size distribution (IUPAC Technical Report). Pure Appl. Chem. 87(9–10),
1051–1069 (2015)
10. Kuila, U., Mccarty, D.K., Derkowski, A., Fischer, T.B., Prasad, M.: Nanoscale texture and
porosity of organic matter and clay minerals in organic-rich mudrocks. Fuel 136(6), 359–373
(2014)
11. Tingwei, L., Jiang, Z., Chenlu, X., Liu, B., Liu, G., Wang, P., Li, X., Chen, W., Ning, Ch.,
Wang, Z.: Effect of pore structure on shale oil accumulation in the lower third member of the
Shahejie formation, Zhanhua Sag, eastern China: Evidence from gas adsorption and nuclear
magnetic resonance. Mar. Pet. Geol. 88, 932–949 (2017)
12. Říha, Z., Zeleňák, M.: Flow field analysis in abrasive head as tool for high-speed abrasive jet
cutting. In: Klichová, D., Sitek, L. (eds.) VODNÍ PAPRSEK 2017 - VÝZKUM, VÝVOJ,
APLIKACE, pp. 153–163. Institute of Geonics of the CAS, Ostrava (2017)
Author Index
J Müller, Niklas, 18
Jan, Novotný, 45 Muszynski, Pawel, 476, 539, 548
Jarosz, Krzysztof, 315, 333
Jerman, Marko, 229 N
Nag, Akash, 63, 72
K Nieslony, Piotr, 333, 398
Kargl, Rupert, 220
Karkalos, Nikolaos E., 205 O
Karolína, Habrová, 45 Olaf, Jan M., 11
Kartal, Fuat, 173 Oraon, Manish, 362
Kaufeld, Michael, 264
Kepič, Ján, 163 P
Klich, Jiří, 36, 85, 114, 163 Pagac, Marek, 290
Klichová, Dagmar, 36, 114 Palatinuš, Tomislav, 29
Kot, Wlodzimierz, 254 Panc, Nicolae, 324
Kováčik, Jaroslav, 97 Parle, Dattatraya, 518
Kozak, Dražan, 3 Pastucha, Peter, 493
Krejčí, Lucie, 163 Perec, Andrzej, 124
Krescanko, Michal, 351 Petr, Valášek, 45
Krile, Srecko, 493 Petrovan, Adrian, 299
Krolczyk, Grzegorz M., 341 Petru, Jana, 290
Krolczyk, Jolanta B., 254 Petruš, Michal, 557
Krupa, Krzystof, 205 Pimenov, Danil Yu, 341
Krupa, Krzysztof, 237 Piteľ, Jan, 281
Kučera, Marián, 493 Poklemba, Robert, 183
Kuric, Ivan, 511 Pollák, Martin, 502
Kužma, Jozef, 351 Pop, Adrian Dan, 531
Popan, Alina Ioan, 105
L Popan, Ioan Alexandru, 105
Laskowski, Piotr, 237 Poszwa, Przemyslaw, 476, 539, 548
Lebar, Andrej, 229 Prijatelj, Miha, 229
Legutko, Stanislaw, 254, 341 Puchý, Viktor, 97
Lehocká, Dominika, 163 Pude, Frank, 144
Lissek, Fabian, 264
Löschner, Piotr, 315, 333 R
Radchenko, Svetlana, 386
M Radic, Pavol, 386
Majstorovic, Vidosav, 493 Riha, Zdenek, 144
Majumder, Rohan, 485 Roberto, D’Amato, 45
Makles, Krzysztof, 307, 413 Roshan, Kahane, 518
Marić, Dejan, 29 Rudolf, Rebeka, 220
Martinec, Petr, 567 Ruggiero, Alessandro, 443, 456, 465
Maruda, Radoslaw W., 254, 341 Ruppenthalova, Lucie, 567
Merola, Massimiliano, 195 Rus, Gabriel, 531
Mesicek, Jakub, 290
Michalik, Peter, 557 S
Mičian, Milos, 413 Sabotin, Izidor, 229
Miroslav, Müller, 45 Samardžić, Ivan, 29
Modrak, Vladimir, 183 Schlatter, Manfred, 18
Molnár, Vieroslav, 557 Sedivy, Jiri, 290
Mrozek, Krzysztof, 476 Sedlák, Richard, 97
Müller, Miroslav, 195, 456 Shariq, Mohammed, 220
Muller, Miroslav, 85 Sharma, Anuj Kumar, 213
Author Index 577